RES 1973-01 - 00008006RESOLUTION NO. 1 -1973
A RESOLUTION APPROVING AND AUTHORIZING THE SIGNING
OF AN AGREEMENT ESTABLISHING WORKING CONDITIONS,
WAGES AND HOURS OF EMPLOYEES OF THE CITY OF FRIDLEY
POLICE DEPARTMENT (DISPATCHERS AND PATROLMEN)
- WHEREAS, Mail Order Department Store and Warehouse Employees Local Union
No. 149, as bargaining representative of the Patrolmen and Dispatchers of the
City of Fridley Police Department, has presented to the Council of the City of
Fridley various requests relating to the working conditions, wages and hours
of employees of the Police Department of the City of Fridley, and
WHEREAS, the City of Fridley has presented various requests to the Union
and to the employees relating to working conditions, wages and hours of
employees of the Police Department of the City of Fridley, and
WHEREAS, Representatives of the Union and the City have met and negotiated
regarding the requests of the Union and the City, and
WHEREAS, Agreement has now been reached between representatives of the
two parties on the proposed changes in the existing contract between the City
and the Union,
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the City Council that the Mayor and
the City Manager are hereby authorized to execute the attached Agreement
(Exhibit "A ") relating to working conditions, wages and hours of employees of
the City of Fridley Police Department (Dispatchers and Patrolmen).
PASSED AND ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF FRIDLEY
THIS 8TH DAY OF JANUARY, 1973.
ATTEST:
CITY CLERK - MARVIN C. BR LL
1�1
T�Qt�
MAYOR - F A e L
1
2
RESOLUTION NO. 1 -1973 Continued
EXHIBIT "A" AGREEMENT
AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY OF FRIDLEY AND MAIL
ORDER DEPARTMENT STORE AND WAREHOUSE EMPLOYEES
LOCAL UNION NO. 149 ESTABLISHING WORKING CONDITIONS,
WAGES AND HOURS OF EMPLOYEES OF THE FRIDLEY POLICE
DEPARTMENT (DISPATCHERS AND PATROLMEN)
ARTICLE I
PURPOSE OF AGREEMENT
This Agreement is entered into between the City of Fridley, hereinafter called
the Employer, and Local No. 149, Mail Order Department Store and Warehouse
Employees Union, hereinafter called the Union. The intent and purpose of this
Agreement is to:
a. Establish certain hours, wages and conditions of employment;
and
b. Establish procedures for the resolution of disputes concerning
this Agreement's interpretation and /or application; and
c. Place in written form the parties Agreement upon terms and
conditions of employment for the duration of the Agreement.
ARTICLE II
RECOGNITION
Section 1. The Employer recognizes the Union as the exclusive representative
under Minnesota Statutes, Section 179.71, Subd. 3 for the following
job classificiations:
1. Dispatchers
2. Patrolmen
ARTICLE III
UNION SECURITY
Section 2. In recognition of the Union as the exclusive representative, the
Employer shall:
a. Deduct each payroll period an amount-sufficient to provide the
payment of dues established by the Union from the wages of all
employees authorizing in writing such deduction, and
b. Remit such deduction to the appropriate designated officer of
the Union.
RESOLUTION NO. 1 -1973
EXHIBIT "A" (CONTINUED)
c. The Union may designate certain employees from the bargaining
unit to act as stewards and shall inform the Employer in
writing of such choice.
d. The Union agrees to indemnify and hold the Employer harmless
against any and all claims, suits, orders, or judgements
brought or issued against the City as a result of any action
taken or not taken by the City under the provisions of this
article.
ARTICLE IV
EMPLOYER AUTHORITY
Section 1. The Union recognizes the prerogative of the Employer to operate
and manage its affairs in all respects in accordance with existing
and future laws and regulations of appropriate authorities, including municipal
personnel policies and work rules. The prerogatives and authority which the Employer
has not officially abridged, delegated or modified by this Agreement and retained
by the Employer; such as, but not limited to:
a. Direct employees;
b. Hire, promote, transfer, assign, retain employees in positions
and suspend, demote, discharge or take disciplinary action
against employees. Civil Service Commission Regulations to be
followed wherever applicable;
c. Relieve employees from duties because of lack of work or other
legitimate reasons consistent with Civil Service Commission
Regulations;
d. Maintain the efficiency of the government operations;
e. Determine the methods, means, job classifications and personnel
by which such operations are to be conducted consistent with
Civil Service Commission Regulations.
f. Take whatever actions may be necessary to carry out the missions
of the agency in situations of emergency;
g. Determine reasonable scheduled of work and establish the methods
and processes by which such work is performed.
ARTICLE V
EMPLOYEE RIGHTS AND GRIEVANCE PROCEDURE
Section 1. Definition of Grievance: A grievance is defined as a dispute or
disagreement as to the interpretation or application of the specific
3
RESOLUTION NO. 1 -1973
EXHIBIT "A" (Continued)
terms and conditions of this Agreement. It is
matters governed by civil service rules, merit
shall not be considered grievances and subject
after set forth. No disciplinary action which
or merit system authority will be considered a
procedure herein.
specifically understood that any
system rules or statutory provisions
to the grievance orocedure herein-
may be appealed to a civil service
grievance and subject to the grievance
Section 2. Organization Representatives: The Employer will recognize Employee
Representatives designated by the Employee Organization as the
grievance representatives of the bargaining unit having the duties and responsibilities
established by this article. The Employee Organization shall notify the Employer'
in writing of the names of such Employee Representative and of their successors when
so designated.
Section 3. Processing of Grievance: It is recognized and accepted by the Employee
Organization and the Employer that the processing of grievances as
hereinafter provided is limited by the job duties and responsibilities of the employees
and shall therefore be accomplished during normal working hours only when consistent
with such employee duties and responsibilities. The aggrieved employee and the
Employee Representative shall be allowed a reasonable amount of time without loss
in pay when a grievance is investigated and presented to the Employer during normal
working hours provided the employee and the Employee Representative have notified
and received the approval of the designated supervisor who has determined that such
absence is reasonable and would not be detrimental to the work programs of the
Employer.
Section 4. Procedure: Grievances, as defined by Section 1, shall be resolved in
conformance with the following procedure:
Step 1. An employee claiming a violation concerning the interpretation or
application of this agreement shall within twenty -one (21) calendar days
after such alleged violation present such grievance to the employee's
supervisor as designated by the Employer. The Employer- designated representa-
tive will discuss and give an answer to such Step 1 grievance within ten (10)
caleddar days after receipt. A grievance not resolved in Step 1 and appealed
to Step 2 shall be placed in writing setting forth the nature of the grievance,
the facts on which it is based, the provision or provisions of the Agreement
allegedly violated, the remedy requested, and shall be referred to Sten 2
within ten (10) calendar days after the Employer - designated representative's
final answer in Step 1. Any grievance not referred in writing to Step 2 by the
employee within ten (10) calendar days shall be considered waived.
Step 2. The written grievance shall be presented to and discussed with the
employer- designated Step 2 representative. The Employer- designated representa-
tive shall give the employee the Employer's Step 2 answer in writing within
ten (10) calendar days afterreceipt of such Step 2 grievance. A grievance not
resolved in Step 2 may be appealed to Steo 3 within ten (10) calendar days ,
following the Employer- designated representative's final Step 2 answer. Any
grievance not referred in writing to Step 3 by the employee within ten (10)
calendar days shall be considered waived.
RESOLUTION NO. 1 -1973
EXHIBIT "A" (Continued)
Step 3. The written grievance shall be presented to and discussed with
the Employer- designated Step 3 representative. The Employer - designated
representative shall give the employee the employer's answer in writing
within ten (10) calendar days after receipt of such Step 3 grievance.
A grievance not resolved in Step 3 may be appealed to Step 4 within
ten (10) calendar days following the Employer- designated representative's
final answer in Step 3. Any grievance not referred in writing to Step 4
by the employee within ten (10) calendar days shall be considered waived.
Step 4. A grievance unresolved in Step 3 and appealed to Step 4 shall
be submitted to arbitration subject to the provisions of the Public
Employment Labor Relations Act of 1971. The selection of an arbitrator
shall be made in accordance with the "Rules Governing the Arbitration of
Grievances" as established by the Public Employment Relations Board.
Section 5. Arbitrator's Authority:
a. The arbitrator shall have no right to amend, modify, nullify, ignore, add
to, or subtract from the terms and conditions of the Agreement. The arbi-
trator shall consider and decide only the specific issue(s) submitted in
writing by the employer and the employee, and shall have no authority to
make a decision on any other issue not so submitted.
b. The arbitrator shall be without power to make decisions contrary to or
inconsistent with or modifying or varying in any way the application of
laws, rules, or regulations having the force and effect of law. The arbi-
trator's decision shall be submitted in writing within thirty (30) days
following close of the hearing or the submission of briefs by the parties,
whichever be later, unless the parties agree to an extension. The decision
shall be based soley on the arbitrator's interpretation or application of
the express terms of this Agreement and to the facts of the grievance
presented.
c. The fees and expenses for the arbitrator's services and proceedings shall
be borne equally by the employer and the employee organization, provided
that each party shall be responsible for compensating its own representa-
tives and witnesses. If either party desires a verbatim record of the
proceedings, it may cause such a record to be made, providing it pays for
the record. If both parties desire a verbatim record of the proceedings,
the cost shall be shared equally.
Section 7. Grievance Representative: Employees presenting grievances may choose to
be represented by the grievance representative of the employee organization.
Section 6.
Waiver: If a grievance is not
presented within the time limits set forth
above, it shall be considered "waived
". If a grievance is not appealed
to the next
step within the specified time
limit or any agreed extension thereof, it
shall be considered
settled on the basis of
the employer's last answer. If the
employer does not answer a grievance or an
appeal thereof within the specified time
limits, the
immediately
employee may elect to treat the
appeal the grievance to the next
grievance as denied at that step and
step. The time limit in each step may
be extended
by mutual written agreement of
the employer and the employee in each step.
Section 7. Grievance Representative: Employees presenting grievances may choose to
be represented by the grievance representative of the employee organization.
RESOLUTION NO. 1 -1973
EXHIBIT "A" (Continued)
L
Section 8. Records: All documents, communications and records dealing with a
grievance shall be filed separately from the personnel files of the
involved employee(s). All employee personnel records are open to the employee.
ARTICLE VI
nPPTNTTTnNC
Section 1. Union: Mail Order Department Store and Warehouse Employees Local
Union No. 149.
Section 2. Employer: The City of Fridley.
Section 3. Union Member: A member of the Mail Order Department Store and Warehouse
Employees Local Union No. 149.
Section 4. Employee: A member of the formally recognized bargaining unit (Dis-
patchers and Patrolmen).
Section 5. Base Pay Rate: The employee's monthly pay rate exclusive of longevity
or any other special allowances.
Section 6. Seniority: Length of continuous service with Police Department.
Seniority rosters may be maintained by the Public Safety Director
on the basis of time in grade and within specific classifications.
Section 7. Compensatory Time: Time off during the employee's regularly scheduled
work schedule equal in time to overtime worked. One (1) hour worked
beyond regular schedule equals one and one -half (12) hours compensatory
time.)
Section 8. Severance Pay: Payment made to an employee upon honorable separation
of employment.
Section 9. Grievance: A dispute over the interpretation or applicaton of this
Agreement.
ARTICLE VII
SAVINGS CLAUSE
Section 1. This agreement is subject to the laws of the United States, the State
of Minnesota, and the signed municipality. In the vent any provision
Of this Agreement shall be held to be contrary to law by a court of competent
jurisdiction from whose final judgement or decree no appeal has been taken within
the time provided, such provision shall be voided. All other provisions shall
continue in full force and effect. The voided provision may be renegotiated at I
the request of either party.
r,
0
7
RESOLUTION NO. 1 -1973
IEXHIBIT "A" (Continued)
ARTICLE VIII
WORK SCHEDULES
Section 1. The work week schedule for all sworn officers and patrolmen, shall
constitute four (4) days on duty and two (2) days off duty for a total
of thirty -seven and one -half (372) hours per week. The Public Safety Director is
responsible for scheduling and assigning the weekly work schedule.
Section 2. No officer or patrolman will be required to work two shifts during a
twenty -four (24) hour period, except during an emergency, or for
assigned shift change.
Section 3. The work week for civilian dispatchers shall be forty (40) hours per
week, or thirty -seven and one half (372) hours per week as determined
by the employer.
ARTICLE IX
OVERTIME PAY
Section I. Hours worked in excess of eight (8) hours within a twenty -four (24)
hour period (except for shift changes) or more than forty (40) hours
within a seven (7) day period will be compensated for at one and one -half (12)
times the employee's regular base pay rate.
Section 2. Overtime will be distributed as equally as practicable.
Section 3. For the purpose of computing overtime compensation, overtime hours
worked shall not be pyramided, compounded, or paid twice for the
same hours worked.
Section 4. Management reserves the right to approve compensatory time in lieu
of overtime pay. Compensatory time shall not be accumulated in excess
of twenty -four (24) hours.
ARTICLE X
CALL BACK
Section 1. If an employee is called back to work and more than one (1) hour has
elapsed since his work period ended, he will receive a minimum of two
hours overtime. If the employee is called to work early with no break in service
before his regularly scheduled work period starts, the work performed is considered
normal overtime for the period of time acutally worked. When the assigned scheduled
work day falls or are on Saturday or Sunday, no overtime will be paid.
ARTICLE XI
LEGAL DEFENSE
Section 1. Employees involved in litigation because of proven negligence, or non-
observance of laws, or of a personal nature, may not receive legal
defense by the municipality.
RESOLUTION NO. 1 -1973
EXHIBIT "A" (Continued)
M
Section 2. Any employee who is charged with a traffic violation, ordinance
violation or criminal offense arising from acts performed within the
scope of his employment, when such act is performed in good faith and under direct
order of his supervisor, shall be reimbursed for attorney's fees and court costs
actually incurred by such employee in defending against such charge.
Section 3. The City of Fridley will provide protection for all officers and
patrolmen against false arrest charges.
ARTICLE XII
RIGHT OF SUBCONTRACT
Section 1. In an emergency declared by the City Council, nothing in this Agreement
shall prohibit or restrict the right of the Employer from subcontracting
work performed by employees covered by this Agreement.
Section 2. The City reserves the right to use supportive forces as needed.
ARTICLE XIII
AkTOI]i Ink 19
Section 1. The employer will discipline employees only for just cause.
ARTICLE XIV
SENIORITY
Section 1. Seniority will be the determining criterion for promotions, lay -offs,
and shift assignments when all other qualification factors are equal.
Section 2. Seniority will apply on vacations up to May 1st of each year. After
May 1st, vacations will be on a first come, first served basis.
Section 3. Seniority will apply on shift positions except that the Department Head
shall have the right to schedule employees pursuant to Section I of this
article if it is necessary to insure a. balance of experienced personnel on any shift.
A patrolman with three and one -half (32) years experience as a patrolman on the
Fridley Police Department under normal circumstances is considered experienced. The
City has the right to utilize special skills of employees as needed.
ARTICLE XV
LOSS OF SENIORITY
Section 1. Employees shall lose their seniority for the following reaons:
a. Discharge, if not reversed.
b. Resignation.
c. Unexcused failure to return to work after expiration of a vacation
or formal leave of absence. Events beyond the control of the
employee which prevent the employee from returning to work will
not cause loss of seniority.
d. Retirement.
RESOLUTION NO. 1 -1973
M
EXHIBIT "A" (Continued)
ARTICLE XVI
PROBATIONARY PERIODS
Section 1. All newly hired or rehired employees will serve a twelve (12) months
probationary period.
Section 2. All employees will serve a six (6) months probationary period in any
job classification in which the employee has not served a probationary
period.
ARTICLE XVII
VACATIONS
Section 1. Each employee of the City who has worked regularly for the City for a
period of not less than twelve (12) successive months is entitled to a
vacation away from employment with pay. Vacation pay shall be computed at the
regular rate of pay to which such employee is entitled. An employee who has
worked a minimum of twelve (12) months is entitled to one (1) workday of vacation
for each month so worked. An employee who has worked eighty-four (84) consecutive
months is entitled to one and one -half (12) workdays of vacation for each month
worked beginning with the eighty -fifth (85th) month of consecutive employment.
An employee who has worked one hundred eighty (180) successive months is entitled
to one and two - thirds (1 -2/3) workdays of vacation for each month worked beginning
' with the one hundred eighty -first (181st) month of consecutive employment.
ARTICLE XVIII
REQUESTS FOR CHANGE OF POSITION
Section 1. With regard to investigator's request to revert to patrolman status,
management agrees with the right of an employee to have a hearing
before the Department Head on the matter. If the question is not settled, the
employee has the right to a hearing before the City Manager. The City Manager's
decision will be final.
ARTICLE XIX
EMPLOYEE EDUCATION PROGRAM
Section 1. The education Program in effect is as adopted by the City of Fridley.
ARTICLE XX
Nrn rnnvc
Section 1. There is no holiday pay as such for police officers, or dispatchers if
the employees work a four (4) day on, two (2) days off schedule
(372 hours per week).
Section 2. If employees are required to work a regular forty (40) hour work week,
their holidays shall be as set for other civilian employees as follows:
Holidays include New Year's Day, January 1; Washington's and Lincoln's Birthday,
the third Monday in February; Memorial Day, the last Monday in May; Independence
Day, July 4; Labor Day, the first Monday in September; Christopher Columbus Day,
the second Monday in October; Veterans Day, the fourth Monday in October; Thanks-
giving Day, the fourth Thursday in November; and Christmas Day, December 25; provided
10
RESOLUTION NO. 1 -1973
EXHIBIT "A" (Continued)
when New Year's Day, January 1; or Independence Day, July 4; or Christmas Day,
December 25, falls on Sunday, the following day shall be a holiday, and provided,
when New Year's Day, January 1; or Independence Day, July 4; or Christmas Day,
December 25, falls on Saturday, the preceding day shall be a holiday. if additional
holidays are granted by the City Council by ordinance, the employee covered by this
Agreement will receive the benefit of such additional holiday.
ARTICLE XXI
SICK LEAVE
Section 1. Any employee who is unable to work because of sickness or injury may
obtain a leave of absence upon notice to the City. Written verification
of his condition by a competent medical authority may be required. Where the condi-
tion of the employee is such that he is unable to act for himself, the Union may
apply for such leave of absence in his behalf. Failure to notify the City subjects
the employee to appropriate discipline by the City.
Section 2. Each employee of the City who has worked regularly for the City for
a period of not less than twelve (12) successive months is entitled
to sick leave away from employment with pay. Sick leave pay shall be computed at the
regular rate of pay to which such employee is entitled. An employee who has worked
a minimum of twelve (12)months is entitled to one (1) day of sick leave for each
month worked, cumulative to one hundred twenty (120) days of sick leave. After one
hundred twenty (120) earned and unused days of sick leave have accumulated, one (1)
day additional vacation shall be granted to an employee for every three (3) sick
leave days earned and unused. The employee may elect, after ninety (90)earned
and unused days of sick leave have accumulated, to receive one (1) day additional
vacation for every three (3) sick days earned and unused. Sick leave days shall
not accumulte beyond one hundred twenty (120). Before any sick leave compensation
is paid, the City may request and is entitled to receive from any employee who has
been absent more than three (3) days in succession, a certificate signed by a
competent physician or other medical attendant certifying to the fact that the
absence was in fact due to sickness and not otherwise. The Citv also reserves
the right to have an examination made at any time of any person claiming absense
by reason of sickness; such examination may be made when the City deems the same
reasonably necessary to verify the sickness claimed and may be made in behalf of
the City by any competent person designated by the City.
ARTICLE XXII
INJURY ON JOB
Section 1. Any full time City employee who has been employed by the City at least
six (6) months, injured on hisregular job, shall be entitled to full
pay up to a period of ninety (90) days while he is absent from work by reason of
such injury and his accrued sick leave will not be charged until after and
beginning with the ninety -first (91st) day of absence from work by reason of such
injury, provided however, the amount of any compensation shall be reduced by any
payment received by the injured employee from workmen's compensation insurance.
An employee who claims an absence from work due to an injury sustained on his
regular job is subject to an examination to be made in behalf of the City by a
person competent to perform the same and as is designated by the City.
RESOLUTION NO. 1 -1973
EXHIBIT "A" (Continued)
ARTICLE XXIII
UNIFORM ALLOWANCE
Section 1. The City shall provide a uniform clothing allowance for police officers
of $150 (One Hundred and Fifty Dollars) per year as needed.
Section 2. The City shall provide civilian Dispatchers a uniform clothing allowance
of $100 (One Hundred Dollars) per year for clothing as needed.
Section 3. All money for uniforms to be paid only as clothing is purchased. This
includes uniformed and non - uniformed personnel. Non - uniformed personnel
shall not draw more than one - quarter (',) of their uniform allowance in any quarter
of the year.
Section 4. Clothing or uniforms damaged in the line of duty through no fault of
the employee shall be replaced or repaired by the employer.
ARTICLE XXIV
FUNERAL PAY
Section 1. Funeral leave will be granted to full time employees up to a maximum of
three days. Funeral leave is granted in case of deaths occuring in the
immediate family. For this purpose immediate family is considered to be a spouse,
child, parent, grandparent, brother or sister, mother -in -law and father -in -law.
ARTICLE XXV
,7NRY PAY
Section 1. It shall be understood and agreed that the City shall pay all regular
full time employees serving on any jury the differences in salary
between jury pay and his regular salary or pay while in such service.
ARTICLE XXVI
HEALTH AND WELFARE BENEFITS
Section 1. Regular full time employees shall receive the same as other City
employees, which policy at the present time provides that the City
pays for the employee's Health and Hospital Insurance and the employee pays for
dependent coverage. The City also provides life insurance equal to annual salary,
with a maximum of $10,000. The City also provides additional AD &D Insurance
equal to salary, with a maximum of $10,000.
Section 2. A representative from the employee group shall be included on a committee
which makes recommendations on the content of specifications for any new
policy. Such recommendations are subject to Council approval.
11
12
RESOLUTION NO. 1- 1973
EXHIBIT "A" (Continued)
ARTICLE XXVII
,
RATES OF PAY 1973
Section 1. Patrolmen's-,Salaries:
Starting Salary
$ 828.00
Per
Month
After One (1) Year
872.00
Per
Month
After One & One -Half (12) Years
918.00
Per
Month
After Two & One -Half (22) Years
966.00
Per
Month
After Three & One -Half (32) Years
1,017.00
Per
Month
Dispatchers' Salaries:
First six (6) Months
$ 698.00
Per
Month
After six (6) Months
733.00
Per
Month
One and One -Half (12) Years
772.00
Per
Month
Two and One -Half (22) Years
813.00
Per
Month
Three and One -Half (32) Years
856.00
Per
Month
ARTICLE XXVIII
ADDITIONAL INCENTIVE PAY 1973
Section 1. Incentive pay will be paid over and above the standard base rate or
going rate for employees hired before July 1, 1973 according to the
following schedule: Time in other classifications will not count towards incentive
pay for a sworn officer.
Patrolman After 5 years $25.00 Per Month
Patrolman After 10 Years 50.00 Per Month
Patrolman After 15 Years 75.00 Per Month
Dispatchers After 5 Years 21.00 Per Month
Dispatchers After 10 Years 42.00 Per Month
Dispatchers After 15 Years 63.00 Per Month
ARTICLE XXIX
COLLEGE CREDITS
Section 1. For officers hired prior to July 1, 1972, the City will pay for education
credits at the rate of $.40 per quarter credit, up to a maximum of
$72.00 per month. Credits must be in police related work. The courses taken
must be part of a curriculum approved by the City. No officer hired after
July 1, 1972 will be eligible for longevity. No officer will draw both longevity
i�
I
13
RESOLUTION NO. 1 -1973
EXHIBIT "A" (Continued)
and pay for education credits. Present officers will have a choice of drawing
education credits or longevity. A determination of the number of credits an
employee is eligible for will be made on December 1, of the previous year. Credits
earned during the year will not be counted until the succeeding year. The City
will not pay tuition for courses that employee will later be Paid for as noted
above.
Section 2. For officers hired after July 1, 1972, the City will pay for education
credits at the rate of $.40 per quarter credit beginning with the
ninety -first (91st) credit earned up to a maximum of $36.00 Per month. The admin-
stration of the payment of credits will be as outlined in Section I above.
ARTICLE XXX
This Agreement shall be effective as of January 1, 1973, and shall remain in full
force and effect until December 31, 1973.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this Agreement this 29th day
of December, 1972.
In the presence of: Mail Order Department Store and Warehouse
Local No. 149
S/ Neil Duncan
S/ Arthur R. Groinus
S/ Marvin C. Brunsell
S/ Joseph Prifrel
City of Fridley
I hereby recommend to the City Council
approval of this agreement
S/ Gerald R. Davis