The URL can be used to link to this page

AF-V - 45015_� � CITY OF FRIDLEY 6431 UNIVERSITY AVENUE FRIDLEY, MN 55432 • (612) 571-3450 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT VARIANCE APPLICATION FOR: x Residential Commercial/Industrial Siqns PROPERTY INFORMATION: - site plan required for submittal, see attached Address: '7�18 yldel� �vay ��? �J. , Fridley, T�l'�� 5�32 Property Identification Number: ��3 3� 2� 3� ��5� Legal Description: Lot �_ Block �_ Tract/Addition pearsoyl' s��r� l�U�dy .,�states 2�:�� y�aditior7, Ario'_�a County � . � Current Zoning: t3es . Square footage/acreage: 21, ��0 Sq . ft . Reason for Variance:To �er�:�it co�istructiori of sunroom to replace exis deteriorated deck. ��;eed is due to unic�ue lot contour �,nd re uirem or se ac rom o ropo es a is��e since ouse was u Have � ou o erated a business in a cit which re uired a business license? t i ons in YPs X P!Vo � If Yes, whi h city? 4 Fridley If Yes, what type of business? iy?ar_ufacturir�=� Was that license ever denied or revoked? Yes No X ��_��_��_��_��.�.�.��.�.�.�� FEE OWNER INFORMATION (as it appears on the property title) (Contract purchasers: Fee owners must sign this form prior to processing) NAME: Karl & Margaret A. Schurr , _ ADDRESS: 7a1� Alden ��Jay iv L, FridlEy, i�ii�i 55'�3� �'��<�:��z.� r".��'��, DAYTIME PHONE: 5`�1-3121 SIGNATURE/DATE: �� -� �'.-1.��-� •�; 3�/,> �V�V�r�V�V N�V�VNN�V�V/V N�V�VnrArti�V�VN�V NN/V�V�VAr�V/V�V/VNN/V�VNN�VNN�VArN�VA/AI�V/V�V1V�VA/�VN�V/�/�VA/�VNN/VN�V�V PETITIONER INFORMATION NAME: �S�.rI Scti��urr ADDRF�S: 7018 Alderi WaY _v_� ;:,riuley, `�i`�' S5�32 DAYTIME PHONE: 5%�-31�1 SIGNATURE/DATE: �,�� E: 1.,.�•-� .�%�;L� �� Section of City Code: FEES Fee: $100.00 for commercial, industrial, or signs: Fee: $60.00 for residential properties: Receipt #: �-' � � Received By: Application Number. V�t,� ��i`I - �iz, Scheduled Appeals Commis i�on Date: ti�ve� �-� 2� I`i�i' Scheduled City Council Date: ix�� L� �' 10 Day Application Complete Notification Date: ,� `w ��<<i�. - �� `%'� ` - 60 Day Date: 1;� � �� .�� x �`i`i�1 ing nt t). ny way. - �l : h ' ' �� t.� • m � �,;� • !';'- �� '�~:� :• T . .� •� • �,. Zi'.�i. � � + • .� . -. . �. �+ L• . ' .-- �► ' . `T� . Y j . ' . a� . ` �� 4�� "�e �A � . _ �� ' . / N �/ �.. • � O�y � `� � • ♦ i� " - _ __. . , -�^ �,'"��i � ��'� ` � " ' � ��w '�' , �.3- �t�,:.. _ . � ,� .� _ . , , , �- , ; s Y,, �,-' � �, • ' - ;�� r� < �.� . . ,,.._.- --� ��'' .-�.., � u.x��: �� . ��i. 1...�� . . t� `� od. t'�.,n ��: ?,5 � . . . . . :�. ' 3o-$ ,ld - . � • � � �` :�� t-.x�.Eer' � .. ,�� • �,..+^'" . �-�>,4 . �.y� c' * • ' ��,, �t - � `..�'#° � , . f ,i* y � / 1 :� " . �`2 � i�lt� � �� $ � � `"`f i�'�' �,;�` . � � I '�� .; �'��.6,�'�+� �+. �4�� -�'-- _ `'F � �,�� .}1E�x 14a'y"ii�' � ''1i:'- �� .g� :'4.. y r.,.i �� : � �+ I � F4i R.� ' � - � • 'A Y � ` F . _, �-i .. t � �.� � ",-'� : � -� ' ttiw � 'i � " � �� .-� ��` � ' .. , . .�, � �.t ` ." ' v 1 s -; i . . ,y,�"�,. � . � - .ry.: .' .w��, _� . . _ i �I I 1 4 .. . i - . � ''� ;� � -= z : � :.�` �: s.-.� �� ' �` �' !�' �i�t t , � a+��,+ �r. 9 ,,,�,f�- ° z f. ��i� .� �a ' .'TA �i�'F i # 3. . ,�?�` s J��.�'�` F d � � .t i ' - �� „ f' �Q �i�r..� r,� y� � •.'.�� '::a � �- �. �.. � 1.� . 3...� . . ,� 1 �"�? �� '�`S °- � gR �y, � � �� T /:� , �S :_a - r"' "� i.�, � ��r�� ' � -� ..S , . . t +afi _ + ` +�a � . �iv • ^� ` , - ' � �, ��. •�� r��f .,��,� � . � . � , } ��?'�.��' �,�� ^ 1 � f '� `ys u � ,� ° �C , � ,��; ., ti ` it� �i ; i � � �A x� � : w,. .,a.'",��` BR��.�:�,lt_. ' : � - � c , � �' i�� ic .��3 � .. ��v' e ,yr '�i -'9,:�h t'��-5 °�O �,,, . ' � � .- �' � .� ' '� � 1� � '- � �`�.> �.� i^d`�'i .:,e,- th� : . �c- �r � . .. i � t � I�� r,�-' a -#�� a i... y .y�rl � �- a�*n�•i t s.� �C •-" � �'� ` �t �4 � � V. +Sti� �{�� } � ;`� �'�t�z�.� � ; is �t ' `' �} - .i -��a� �F'�'� � Y�'' 4 � .x ��s.'�.'fi � �'� � . � 1 � t i. a a � 9� �� t °'� *• ,¢,,� �• �9�,i e: � �. �" � ' �x � i�w �rv:Y ,y Ss.%�' 1 i .yll "� '.. 3 � A ' P.. p'1`y `'`} �5{ ! £ � �t : y.Z 4 d ! k'... � M� . -. T $�..� 1 � .➢ � -'_,� 3 . .i . . #a� � s �-yrt �.�. I. �.t �...-s$• . � :°� � i i, �. t .ww+W"`+"` '�A.r i �t 4 Y ,�_ } i.. 1 ,�aii� � :+l :� a. -.�, �'..d,. i 1 i '� . i � � :� � p �� . . �.J �. ,; ;� �� } , -� � ,� z � �; � . :. � � � ; � � � I . � �3 _ ��'�TM�z� � _ i n +� g^ s' � '� a a `� �"� � 1 � .` ' ;: c; a �' *F? �� _ � - .. � V� � � ; .- � s� � � � � li� �'t " � �"� � `� . " ,, t . �a [a y ! .� �� w . � �. � F g F ! l` p 3 1 . � { .+ . t � � '. �+� � ;; x � �"^" � }+ � �f, €s-� 2 „� _ � �;� ( r � AS° L�� -1 . i..`^F `,,- f ; .� . ' f�y � : '-{ y� �'� �� ,$- � _� . �' �� . � �� .c, � .m 3� �- � � �. � � � � �;t ��'�*�� `i k'� iz. �� ; �. � - ° '.�� .- � P�� • - . � .. �.t � .. � °.� � q � �'+�"�.�, � . i-. � / - 3� � i S� �� .. „_._ . . . � � i _ � : � . 7, - ; . �� - . _ ,, _ �, -�.---�t-- i _ ; �� i. �i�� ~'`'�`~ �'—=� � ' . . ,� � j r � � ` \ _ �; 4��' . , \ � �- �<- : �; �. ;u � �. • � � _ � � ;� f . w � '` �� .. _ - t � � __ ,� g i �• ."€�: t 1 � � � . y '/ `"r�`' �.�� 1- � � -.t, � . �; - . A r, � � r, — ��. � � � ` - : t � ::.� � �: '.,:' .; �' :�. � � � ,: , `� : � � � �..'' , ; f, ,, + ..'-: c�� ,�, , � �. . �,.; �' �� ` �� . � a �. ��;,� � ,� t j; , �� - _ .. ?y � i ��e�. ." . ' , � :: r . . . y� . �' . �� f ' >� ` t � 4. � � �`a� F' � � 1 �i ��t 1 � � i� . a�' _ �\�.:��,� ,1�. 4 /' '� � a � - - - � ^.� _.� �'� ;� ' . , p' � �, � - ( 1 ¢�\ -..a-^°.m'ary"f ,._, }a�. ... if� ;� �, +� ��f,, 1 "°�,<._ � ' 1 Y� � �� --- 4 � �.---� ,� `� �� p y�, ,,� . J'i � '. ; � l , , ,� .� �.r , '��,m, ; � , `e � + � _ �' �; �� f�`Y �r � pyy' �,+y�. � ��.��y��r��' `� ��1�� ,i{ � 1y � ` t� �.6fJ.i- ,T�J � ' .��y�� r��1 'W �� J+ . 3� � Y ..1.�r+r �� } '� ��,�°��.l,T �, . % 7` � ��'�� ''.��i� 4R� . a�~ �- � �"� � _ ,� -, y�-a p � �i, , : J✓i < ` ¢` c� } �)�: �� , `�`� �`�� o� �� +� �� .,.. 8...�.-... -- - - . 1 � i � �e.- �.� 1 � ��'S. �?�' 1 { .�t.T.--� - � �S � , a i�� -. s � i' � w � �ti ` � ,�' � � '�,'-�, ,> _ �.-- r m.vw-,:..�= ^^��I �� ' `.t � 1/ � � l (�� r. t. ' � .-.. �, . '.. . ( :� � �'.. !' � /y -�It� : F��L �I � �. l. t \ . _ � - .. '!f 3 '�'�. .i�' ,y � s�.��,'" ��.+.' �/1�A�:��.� ✓' t �`�(p� -� �,--.��.�..--`; _ �- � ; "l - �l ', �, � ' �`' ^i � i `� , � � �4 � .._.�.,.. - - � . " , . _ . - i 1p„>L::jl' -t�� sJ �� " .. . . ' . . � . '� .. � � �: � . : � ' .. . ,; �,�I� P�#..� . _,.._ � : �� t; . . . . . • .. -�"»" 'r�w,s", ��, � . � . � � , , i —.-----_".: _ `} +� ��r,�^'. ; , .,,.. , . .�U�(P .'��- . ':r '� �.��s_:) f� - .�� .�, \ � ,.._.. .._. . � ' n � » .; , . . . /. 't " ' � i . + �1,�'�"� �• � ! �` . �` "u� C,..,._.:'.._._�.. ?t.. t J-__ . �� —"�...�' " .... � ,' , � : it .. � L��wI'a . . _ . — � , . � . Froposed surroom elevation side v;_ec,�, Door & Window Placement Key A= Awning Win �awlin��'ft�1`'t�'1��i2 Ritati s�'�� - - L-3 L-6 _-- -- -- �=z - ;� o m D 5 � - G � o 9 _ g o0 o m ' -- a - — ' _ — :o A A A ��n��r��e ��) � l��' C-3 i � � m = — b � A SK-3 �� C '� i q----'�I � i � � `---- ; c � a «�� :�� Ge S; I � , ,� D '� G o - — _ a A A 6'-4' sr�. - � ��h)�, � �� . SK-8 C � i q---'I i ' � � � `---- � O '° -'- ---'- - A A � ""1 _'__11'�l9/16_ ` �' � �.".71� b j f�t�rF,,'11 a - � o ,�,Q,� l �r '"�'�`f �°'--P" u�j C= Casement Window D= Single (Store) Door D--D = Sliding Glass Door __ �f LINDAL CEDAR __` 9 —� Fl � �Z SUNROOM, SKYWALL & SUNWALL � U8E THEBE DIMENSIONB FOp FOUNDATION ONIY. �i�=,� -- -- ---�- -- - -- �- - ------ ---- --------- -- ---- ' NO. OF p- D 4 D . .-D-- -D G G ^ � G G G � BAYS _ _ OVERALLLENGTH __ -- - — - — - � ---- - — - -- - --- - ° 3 9' - 3-1/2' /� A A � A A A A � 4. 12'- 3-t/2' - -- - b 15' - 3-1 /2' _ 9'-6 1/];_�__ �. `-a�= ia'-e v+• _�_ 8 18' - 3-1/2' 7 21' - 3-1/2" �C-9 C-�i B 24'-3-1/2' ' F F s 27' - 3-t/2' � /0 30'- 3-1/2' � ADD'L BAYS 3' - 0' � - - � o o D - - � - - � o Notes: - -------- _ _ _ a _ _ _ _ _ ,p (1) Ba�ewell - Includes enpineerinp package and A A A A A A A connectors. __ __ (2) Sllding Gls�� Door - Nol available In a Front q•_j i��• _ � ��•_� �i�__� Wall eppiication, excepl es e Custom lealure. — ,,`;c r a(�r < r�.� • (3) 3' Openi�g Skyllght - Exlruded aluminum, �M� I�B'�� thertnelly brokan Irame, wilh interior ceder tdm $W� $ifl/-6 peckepe included. __ ___ (4) SkyWNla • Include no endwalls. II endwalls y deslrad, consull'SunRoom' priclnp lable. � 4 y (5) Su�Wdls • Include no overhead glass. _ � O O '0 C �0 Prieai �nd Spee111ceUon� �ub�ect lo chenge � � without noUce. 11� „�• - �1,� „�• CR-600 �o � -- -- ,��pU c c � -- II'-� 1/ib' -- I ,�' _ __'__ _ — _' —___ __.}� .AIILAJI-A_�Il_A_ll_ A_lOA�ll�_ -------__�g-� �ie• _-----_.__.---� CR-800 � m O i� � � "�, , ,' _. ..-. .j - r 'Wt�'Q�a L 6- 0 5'� 0/ 3S/YO�/ 9N/1 s/X� h�i�i N�o�y g/�L �Ity Nt U2 n� i � � /9-,6 �" I 'GY� '3n7 lL /J�os''-c� � ��o l� _ �-..9; 8 " �.G %� � . •� j/�d lN?t ' -� � t?��j 1 t/7� ,L . �oo� �sn �fi 0�7�d� �O _��P3 _f�lnos - � � � - - . . NO �� _ =_ r� �4 ' I' � �(7�0 PN6/ , / Woo a�Nn,S� o�sodt.�� \ � � ,;_- � ��d�n „%�=,9/ �-i . ` • _ Y � � . � - Lond PlannTny 6L75 Nfyhwoy No.6S N.E. . � Su u�2��an , . � M,��.oPo�;,, ta�d Surveying �j2�f,ytee�.cn�, nc ♦ � Minn. 534�2 Soils Testing Civil tngin�srlrr9 TelepF+on• 7a4-6060 Areo Cod• 612 Municipal Engineering Engineers & Surveyora • �� .Mortgage Loan Survey for Charles E. Johonson, �nC. � �l � �F ,O � NoR-rH . /� `� 0��"' Q� � . � , . . ;� / p , J` V � l /60 � •, � � � �,' � ;:� �� _ � � � ��- '� ,. . � 1;� ti\o. � , `�°.� ,��; ; , / �, ��r �,�a p �0 J � \ � �V: 'Q1� �� . , � S' ,o � �x , � i- °-o � �� D a J l� �� ` �� t� �L ��A \ '�- 1� � �S � �� ,.��( �. r4 .� . ,� ��1 � `s� � � [ S,�P �� ,� \ � / ! <_,uNtnowl pc �� 1 2 � 4 -�,�•J �'� � � .'� t� i � � Aa iQ� � � , � � � ��5� � � , �\ ' - - �� o' � ; �i i � `__� �` / \o� � ..; ; � •_� ,-- . a.� 5 } O ,, 2�. \ �� , , o.s i 55 \ � ��'� M/ ��` \ 1� �P'I S��SS/\� � 1 ,�o � ,,; / �iy�,� � �5� /�U' �.-u.� �� r ;�r� N— � �,� �--�c- . �� .or9,B��oc�5 y P�ARSO�v CRAIGWAY �sr��.�s 2ND ANOKA GOUNTY This is a irue ond torrect r�pr�stntofion of a survey oF the bo�ndories of fhe land abov• destribed and oF the location ol all buildings� if any� 1h�r�on� and all visibl• •ncroathments� if any� {rom o� on said land. Thif survtr is mode onlr in con�ecfion with o morfgoye loan now being p�a�ed on the property and no liabilify is asivmed excapt to the holder oi such mortgag• or onr oth�r infer�st acquir�d by the r�oson o( such mortgoga. It is understood ond ogr�ed np`mo�umenes hove b�� p�oc�d (or the purpose o� esfablishing lot lints Or boundary corn�rs. Datsd this zs L,doy of u k�' A. D. 1VZ!► . SUBURBAN ENGINEERING, INC. � Surve ors • ' Engine• s , ,�. Sca I e � 1 � 40 bY � � fZ�--c�: .-�.�-- � - i3 2�b . ' . � CITY OF FRIDLEY PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE BEFORE THE APPEALS COMMISSION TO: Property owners within 350 feet of 7818 Alden Way CASE NUMBER: VAR #97-20 APPL/CANT: Karl and Margaret Schurr PURPOSE: To reduce the setback of a deck from the bluff line of the Mississippi River from 40 feet to 23 feet to allow reconstruction of a deck in the rear yard LOCATION OF PROPERTY: 7818 Alden Way LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Lot 9, Block 5, Pearson's Craigway Estates 2"d Additions DATE AND TIME OF Appeals Commission Meeting: HEAR/NG: Wednesday, December 10, 7:30 p.m. The Appeals Commission meetings are televised live the night of the meeting on Channel 35. PLACE OF HEAR/NG: Fridley Municipal Center, City Council Chambers 6431 University Avenue HOW TO 1. You may attend hearings and testify. PARTIC/PATE: 2. You may send a letter before the hearing to Scott Hickok, Planning Coordinator, or Michele McPherson, Planning Assistant, at 6431 University Avenue N.E., Fridley, MN 55432 or fax at 571-1287. SPECIAL Hearing impaired persons planning to attend who need an ACCOMMODATIONS: interpreter or other persons with disabilities who require auxiliary aids should contact Roberta Collins at 572-3500 no later than December 3, 1997. ANY QUEST/ONS: Contact either Scott Hickok, Planning Coordinator, at 572-3599, or Michele McPherson, Planning Assistant, at 572-3593. Mailing Date: November 26, 1997 CURRENT RESIDENT FRIDLEY MN 55432 CURRENT RESIDENT 7844 PEARSON WAY FRIDLEY MN 55432 CURRENT RESIDENT 7835 ALDEN WAY FRIDLEY MN 55432 CURRENT RESIDENT 7824 PEARSON WAY FRIDLEY MN 55432 CURRENT RESIDENT 7836 ALDEN WAY FRIDLEY MN 55432 CURRENT RESIDENT 7830 ALDEN WAY FRIDLEY MN 55432 CURRENT RESIDENT FRIDLEY MN 55432 CLTRRENT RESIDENT 7815 ALDEN WAY FRIDLEY MN 55432 CURRENT RESIDENT 7818 ALDEN WAY FRIDLEY MN 55432 VAR ��97-20, 7818 Alden Way N.� . CURRENT RESIDENT empty FRIDLEY MN 55432 CURRENT RESIDENT 7841 ALDEN WAY FRIDLEY MN 55432 CURRENT RESIDENT 7830 PEARSON WAY FRIDLEY MN 55432 CURRENT RESIDENT 7800 E RNER RD FRIDLEY MN 55432 CURRENT RESIDENT 7823 ALDEN WAY FRIDLEY MN 55432 CURRENT RESIDENT 235 CRAIGBROOK WAY FRIDLEY MN 55432 CURRENT RESIDENT 7824 ALDEN WAY FRIDLEY MN 55432 CURRENT RESIDENT FRIDLEY MN 55432 CURRENT RESIDENT 285 CRAIGBROOK WAY FRIDLEY MN 55432 CURRENT RESIDENT FRIDLEY MN 55432 CURRENT RESIDENT 7838 PEARSON WAY FRIDLEY MN 55432 CURRENT RESIDENT 7842 ALDEN WAY FRIDLEY MN 55432 CURRENT RESIDENT 7829 ALDEN WAY FRIDLEY MN 55432 CURRENT RESIDENT 7776 ALDEN WAY FRIDLEY MN 55432 CURRENT RESIDENT 7819 ALDEN WAY FRIDLEY MN 55432 CURRENT RESIDENT 255 CRAIGBROOK WAY FRIDLEY MN 55432 CURRENT RESIDENT 275 CRAIGBROOK WAY FRIDLEY MN 55432 CURRENT RESIDENT 7812 ALDEN WAY FRIDLEY MN 55432 CURRENT RESIDENT CURRENT RESIDENT CURRENT RESIDENT 270 CRAIGBROOK WAY 7806 ALDEN WAY 290 CRAIGBROOK WAY FRIDLEY MN 55432 FRIDLEY MN 55432 FRIDLEY MN 55432 � �� - _ :r � � ,,., � � � �� — �� I ��,� '�� , �� ;�� ,�� ,� — � � ,_ - 1 � , ��,n� \ �� _T ,. , � ; �. � � -� � � �o�N�/ /� ,, . - � \ - ___-- - ' \�\ \ � II _��- ��- � � � � �� I � '� ��Y y� _� � �I � � � � 79 WAY NE ��' I�� ' i �� / \ ��P `� , �� , t� � �_ � � i ___ � �� ''�� _I�. �1 ' '; _R� 1 �,� � � ' °' � � � � � . ; , 1, � , � �. ue�v sr rF ueeaTr sr r� � _ � --- __, T _ , � - ,�; ,�. � � , '�, � , ' ti �� M��t - 1► � �i � - � �� l . � �� , _ �I ` 1 � ,��s� I f I � , '�R1 M1 ��`� � -- � i � f � � �, �, � � , �1-1— � ��. � , �� 1 � _i � � �� _��_ __ �, �.., _ �� _ , , --� � , � � R� � „ � , �i � i � , ' �_ _ , �'_111 i �,R►� ` ! � � , � , �[�.� �-�� i _��-� _ I d� �� —�_ , � � —�--� �� .�_� i � ♦ ' _i __1� �� NE 79WAYPE 79 WAY � � �� — ��1 - , � , �%1, '\ � �., . i zonirg Designations: 0 R 1 - One Family lhrts R 2- Two Family Units � R 3- General Multiple Units R-4 - Nbbile Fbrrie Parics � PUD - Plamed Urit Developrr�ent � S1 - Hyde Park Neic�borFtood S-2 - Redeveloprr�ent Distrid � G1 - La�l Business G2 - General Busit�ess G3 - General St�pirxJ � GR1- General Office ' W�1 - LigM Industrial NF2 - Heavy Industrial � n�s - o�,caoa i�� y i�,a. � RR - Railroads r��< P - Public Facilities � wA� 0 RIGHT-0E-WAY N VAR 97-20, 7818 Alden Way A� A request by Karl and Margaret Schurr, to reduce the setback of a deck from the Nfississippi River bluff line from 40 feet to 23 feet to allow reconstruction of a deck. � ' Gorr�piled and drawn from oftiaal reaords basec! '', on Ordinance Na. 70 and Zonirx,� Map eff�tive ', date 1/271.`� tc?gefh� with al� amending ordin- ' ances acio��er� and effectiv� as of 2117t�7. , The City of Fridley has taken every effori to pro- ' ' vide the mast up-to-c�te irrformation availabie. ; ThP data �ted hE�re is s�+bjc�t ta chaa�e. ' ;�ihe C,�ty of Fri�l�y will r�t � re,sponsible for ' !; unft�rE..�een en�irs or usage of this dr�cu�nt. ' � � , • • VARIANCE APPLICATION SUBMISSION CHECKLIST The fo�lowing shall be the minimum submission �equirements to the Appeals Commission. Applications will not be accepted if the following is not� submitted: RESIDENTIAL: ITEM Completed application, with fee (Application is considered complete if all blanks are completed, and both fee owner and p�titi�ner have sia�n�d Scaled site plan of property showing north arrow, existing and proposed structures, lot and block number, adjacent street names, and buildings on adjacen# lots within 1� fest of the common lot lines. Elevation of building and description of materials. Narrative of proqosed buildina_ SUBMITTED RECEIVER'S COMPLETE REVIEWER'S INITIALS INITIALS/DATE ✓ � � i/ %L�;i u �, ✓ �i � COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL: ITEM SUBMITTED RECEIVER'S COMPLETE REVIEWER'S INITIALS INITIALS Completed application, with fee (Application is considered complete if all blanks are completed, and both fee owner and etitioner have si ned Scaled site plan of property showing north arrow, existing and proposed stn.�etur��, lot ar�d block number, adjacent street names, and buildings on adjacent lots within 10 feet of the common lot lines. Elevation of building and description of materials. Landscape plan for all projects requiring a parking lot expansion of four (4) or more s aces. Gradin and draina e lan. Erosion control lan. Calculations for stormwater runoff: � LAND USE APPLICATION FILE CHECKLIST Date Created: � File Number: {,�� '� �- ?� Summary of Request: � «. d�kl�=� r� �- �e�.-.� Date Submitted: � f- ��`�� Application Deadline: `1 10 Day Completion Notice: Il.� � l0 `� (Official Receiving Date) 60 Day Action Date: �c., �� I`�"�1 I, , understand that while my application was submitted for (applicant's name) review on , the application deadline is: , and the 60 day action window will not begin until I receive a letter stating that my application is complete. I also understand that the City may, at any time during the 60 day action window, in writing, notify me that the process will be extended an additional 60 days. (signed) (witnessed by receiver) Application Found Complete ✓ yes no , , ,'ho��, � �---� �f3-�- � Application Completion Notices Mailed: °j `1� ��- �� ,� � _✓. � c%�r•�� `c�_ /? ( �-, Scheduled Planning Commission: '=r. �c. � ��, r c��? Scheduled Appeals Commission: Scheduled City Council: � �� _ � _ C�TY OF FRiDLEY FRIDLEY MUNICIPAL CENTER • 6431 UNNERSITY AVE. N.E. FRIDLEY, MN 55432 •(612) 571-3450 • FAX (612) 571-1287 Tom Fell U.S. Army Corp. of Engineers 190 5�' Street East St. Paul, MN 55101-1638 Dear Mr. Fell: The City of Fridley has received a request from a homeowner within the Critical Area of the Mississippi River. The homeowner's request is for a variance to allow replacement of an existing dilapidated 10' X 36' deck. A 23', rather than a 40' setback from the bluff line would be required. If approved, the overall size of the deck will be reduced to 9' X 36, however, the homeowners do plan to build a sun/potting room over 162 s.f. (9' X18') of the new deck. I have attached a copy of the staff report prepared for the Fridley Appeals Commission. Once you've had an opportunity to review the report, I would appreciate your official response for inclusion with our staff report to the City Council. This item will be heard by the City Council on January 5, 1998. If you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact me at 572-3599. Thank you. Sincerely: FRIDLEY ��. J. HicKok ina Coordinator C-97-236 � r� U Minnesota Department of Natural Resources Metro Waters - 1200 Warner Road, St. Paul, MN 55106-6793 Telephone: (612) 772-7910 Fax: (612) 772-1977 November 26, 1997 1Vfichele McPherson Plamvng Assistant City of Fridley 6431 University Avenue NE Fridley, NIN 55432 RE: SCHURR VARIANCE REQUEST(VAR #97-20), MISSISSIPPI RIVER, CITY OF FRIDLEY, ANOKA COUNTY Dear Ms. McPherson: We have reviewed the application materials dated November 14, 1997 for the above-referenced request to vary the bluff - setback for a deck reconstruction, as it relates to Executive Order No. 79-10 for the Critical Area program and have the following comments to offer: We have no overwhelming concerns regarding the disposition of the variance request as it appears to be a slight improvement over the existing situation. If the variance is granted, we strongly encourage the City to impose conditions that require vegetative screening of the structure from the River and the opposite bank. Native trees and shrubs are prefened. Thank you for the opporlunity to comment. Please feel free to contact StaffHydrologist Patricia Peltier or me should you have questions. Sincerely, �� Tom Hovey Area Hydrologist c: Sandra Pinel, Metropolitan Council Sandy Fecht, MNRRA Hydrologist DNR Information: 612-296-6157, 1-800-766-6000 • TTY: b12-296-5484, 1-800-657-3929 An Equal Oppor[uniry Employer � Prin[ed on Recycled Paper Containing a Who Values Diversiry �� Minimum of 109c Post-Consumer Waste � December lg`, 1997 Scott Hickok-Planning Coordinator City of Fridley 6431 University Ave. NE Fridley, MN 55432 Dear Mr. Hickok, _ , i We are writing in support of Karl and Margaret Schurr's request for a variance to allow a reduction in the setback required from the bluff line of 40 feet to 23 feet. We can think of no public purpose that would be served by denying the variance. The situation of the neighboring houses (7812 and 7824) do not provide for seeing any structure in the back yard of 7818 from the residence or decks. The bluff is steep and the back yard or deck is not visible from the river bank or adjoining park land. The only place that the deck is visible to the public is from the river itself or across the river. Those times of year when someone is likely to be on the river, the foliage is too thick to see the back yard. The request of Karl and Marga.ret Schurr is reasonable in that it is compatible with the layout of their back yard. If any member of the public would have a legitimate issue it would be from our address (7812) and, as we noted previously, the back yard of 7818 is not visible from that location. We have a conflict on December 10�`, and do not plan on attending the Appeals Commission Meeting. If this appears to be a controversial issue, please let us know and we will rearrange our schedule. Please make this letter available to the members of the Appeals Commission. Let us know if you believe that additional information is required. Thank you for your assistance with this issue. � Sincerely, Wendy and Dave Sallman 7812 Alden Way Fridley, MN 55432 �, �, ,a,J - �� / ' � „ � ,. �. , . ' . ,�> ��„_��'� . �'�C��L/;��.L � �MPt�RTA1�IT MESSAGE F�R �L�� I DATE -� T.Ia�Z. TI .% P. M. ` � �� M '(-� 4 , �� iticx�C.G�"r-� OF ��" L.i�U PHONE ..� AREA CODE . . � , � NUMBER EXTENSION ❑ FAX ❑ MOBILE .- AREA CODE .. NUMBEA � TtME TO CALL' � / � L�� / � - � / , � � � � � �./� ..a��:..,�.,v / ` '�� l�;�3�L� TOPS l� FORM 30025 �� LITHO IN U.S.A. � ` . � . , rA � I � CITYOF FRIDLEY PROJECT SUMMARY DESCRIPTION OF REQUEST: The petitioners, Karl and Margaret Schurr, request that a variance be granted to reduce the setback of a deck from the Mississippi bluff line from 40 feet to 23 feet. If approved, the petitioners are proposing to remove an existing dilapidated deck and construct a two-story sunroom/potting room and deck addition to the rear of the dwelling. The overall impact of the proposed deck and sunroom/potting room is 9 feet by 27 feet versus the existing 10 foot by 36 foot deck. The sunroom/potting room will occupy 9 feet by 18 feet of the addition. STATED HARDSHIP: Stated on application. SUMMARY OF ISSUES: Section 205.25.08.C.(1) of the Fridley Zoning Code requires that all new structures and uses shall be placed not less than 40 feet from the top of the bluff line overlooking the Mississippi River. (See pages 3-4 for "Public Purpose") The Overlay District for the Critical Area of the Mississippi River was adopted in 1977, one year after construction of the dwelling and existing deck. The Critical Area requirements state that all structures must be 100 feet from the ordinary high water level and 40 feet from the top of the bluff of the Mississippi River. The petitioners' proposal reduces the current impact of the existing deck. The Minnesota Department of Natural Resources has submitted a letter stating they do not object to the request; however, they desire additional plantings to screen the proposed construction from the river and properties across the river. Several neighbors submitted comments and letters of support. The proposed request is within previously granted variances. A variance to 5 feet was granted in 1990 for 7806 Alden Way. STAFF RECOMMENDATION TO THE APPEALS COMMISSION: As the request is within previously granted variances, staff has no recommendation for the Commission. If the Commission approves the request, staff recommends one stipulation. 1. The petitioner shall work with staff to provide additional native plant materials along the bluff line. Pro'ect Summa � � J rY VAR #97-20, 7818 Alden way Page 2 Petition For: Location of Property: PROJECT DETAILS A variance to reduce the setback of a deck from the bluff line of the Mississippi River from 40 feet to 23 feet 7818 Alden Way Legal Description of Property: Lot 9, Block 5, Pearson's Craigway Estates 2"d Addition Size: Topography: Existing Vegetation: Existing Zoning/Platting: Availability of Municipal Utilities: Vehicular Access: Pedestrian Access: Engineering Issues: 21,000 square feet Sloping to the river Sod, grass, trees, and natural vegetation on the Mississippi River bluff line R-1, Single Family; Pearson's Craigway Estates 2"d Addition Connected Alden Way N/A None Comprehensive The Zoning and Comprehensive Plans are consistent in this Planning Issues: location. Public Hearing Comments: To be taken Project Summary � VAR #97-20, 7818 Alden way Page 3 � ADJACENT SlTES: WEST: Zoning: P, Public Land Use: Park, Mississippi River SOUTH: Zoning: R-1, Single Family Land Use: Residential EAS�: Zoning: R-1, Single Family Land Use: Residential NORTH: Zoning: R-1, Single Famiy Land Use: Residential Site Planning Issues: REQUEST: The petitioners, Karl and Margaret Schurr, request that a variance be granted to reduce the setback of a deck from the Mississippi bluff line from 40 feet to 23 feet. If approved, the petitioners are proposing to remove an existing dilapidated deck and construct a two-story sunroom/potting room and deck addition to the rear of the dwelling. The overall impact of the proposed deck and sunroom/potting room is 9 feet by 27 feet versus the existing 10 foot by 36 foot deck. The sunroom/potting room will occupy 9 feet by 18 feet of the addition. SITE DESCRIPTION/HISTORY: The property is located south of 79th Avenue on Alden Way. The property is zoned R-1, Single Family, as are all the surrounding properties. The property is approximately 21,000 square feet in area. Located on the property is a 75 foot by 80 foot dwel(ing and a 24 foot by 32 foot attached garage. The dwelling and garage were constructed in 1976. Also, at that time, a 10 foot by 36 foot deck was constructed on the rear of the dwelling. ANALYSIS Code Section Section 205.25.08.C.(1) of the Fridley City Code requires that all new structures and uses shall be placed not less than 40 feet from the top of the bluff line overlooking the Mississippi River Public purpose served by this requirement is as follows: Project Summary • VAR #97-20, 7818 Alden way Page 4 � a. Protect and preserve a unique and valuable stafe and regional resource for the bene�t of the health, safety, and welfare of the citizens of the state, region, and nation. b. To prevent and mitigafe irreversible damage to this state, regional, and national resource. c. To preserve and enhance its natural, aesthetic, cultural, and historic value for the public use. d. To protect and preserve the river as an essential element in the national, state, and regional transportation, sewer and water and recreational system; and e. To protect and preserve the biological and ecological functions of the Mississippi River Corridor. The petitioner is proposing to construct a finro-level addition with a sunroom on the upper level and a potting room on the lower level, as well as some additional deck area. The sunroom has direct access to the family room. The existing deck measures 10 feet by 36 feet. The dimensions of the proposed construction are 9 feet by 18 feet for the sunroom/potting room addition, a 9 foot by 6 foot deck to the north of the sunroom/potting room, and a small 4 foot by 7 foot deck area directly adjacent to the house which creates an L-shaped deck. This L-shaped deck will provide access to patio windows for cleaning purposes. The overall impact of the construction will be 27 feet in length and 9 feet in width, somewhat smaller than the existing 10 foot by 36 foot deck. The O-2 Critical Areas District was adopted in 1977 after construction of the dwelling. In order to comply with the district requirements, the petitioners' proposed addition would need to be moved 25 feet south of its proposed location. This will prevent access from existing doors and internal family/living room spaces. Any improvement to the rear of the dwelling would require a variance due to the Overlay District r.equirements. The Department of Natural Resources is required to review all variance requests within the Overlay District. The Department of Natural Resources has submitted a letter stating that they do not object to the request. They want additional native plant materials planted along the bluff line to provide additional screening of the proposed construction from persons on the river or on the opposite bank. The request is within previously granted variances. A similar request was granted to reduce the setback to 5 feet at 7806 Alden Way. Project Summary � VAR #97-20, 7818 Alden way Page 5 � STAFF RECOMMENDATION TO THE APPEALS COMMISSION: As the request is within previously granted variances, staff has no recommendation for the Commission. If the Commission approves the request, staff recommends one stipulation. • 1. The petitioner shall work with staff to provide additional native plant materials along the bluff line a�lJ ��+j�, �� M;' 4 '� �"�'�`. :r. - ..,�. , ,�. . „ � . ,.F.... . _..., .... . . ._,.. ... .. .� .. . ,...w. .• -�';^a r�•.„, �.�° e.,:. .,.v...p:, �';;�e�.�A :. tn"d'-y r:an*;., . �i 18�., x°��" .R+.¢� s �:a,�:� :..Fi' �.r �..i:; :,:. _*,� .�: � . .� fi�rF`,',,"'' ww,.. ..`. ,,.°",,,�`.�w„� ' . ��` .-:•'.�^:.:� .� ��,. ,�:'^��5' �� a. :.��... iaw " ; ,.."�. �-'_';�.�, '�� e!'.`','".�. . �a. ?" � ."". s�`` •z. .�4,� ��'�� _� �?'�re; :«u�.;�,,. e, ��; ,. �..�. t,�`:"�d.,��.=��"sxk ,�"* .:s�.�� +aa�r�t..� :,,..,: '�+Ex -�� ,:r,�vrk �:.�wta:, +..��a.; ;1 �..t a di' .r,��:�:. �..�. � :, . �,�'x" �,,.�� ...yu'+tr ,, � �y .:_ � v .k`,. "� rv, . � w n .;'!3�¢. .�e�: �4�n:; o�J rt�.� ��i' ., , . ,� �,:. � ,��. � .'�'✓, � }`�E`".^�, '.e': ti^�h'.' '� x �:,:..:' w' wi: ;t ,:,.4,�. g �j:. ,::: � �,.1;, � . : ,. ,. . . . }'� :. . . ' . �:, '4 '.,, �'. [ i''-,�. � ..:#"- +i, ' :z 'r. .,. C� �`1L�� ,"-. .�-r=-'r� t -:: .-.� , 't :"��;Lrr , w t y;�;" p 4 r�k t ',� „r �? �,4 �� s �a.�. F` 7,r �,�. r;S _. a� �w'��, , t� , -.".�r . r , � . �aK.�., � i...:, 4 'u 4 a ,x. �e� - �,��* � , . #� . '". ; . . �, . �, � . !3a,.... �. .. ��..o., .�.:; �., ,,... �.....�., ., x5.: -,.-�:.,. R�.,....;: . �,.;°•�:. ,,r � �� -.. t a,e.. rt� m F roz�` �'`,� ;�, <.x� �T ,�"`.rA o'k,.�k ,��rt ?� ,n ��1� �i��l��,� '�1+ �.. t.� ,� �;� r� , � ....,< , `�, °' y :a- .,r .. a,r � y�� r . , �FC..,..'., ,,. $ ...M,�,�k,;. �,nr _:.:r .. ;�:�, �*e� ...,r„i�, � �......,M �}�...,, -7 ..;r.. >�°E� s " ?�p, 2r.r"'m. �t �{:.,:? 1vA�R°:. t.�. ...�, � "'k,.�,"�', a:,;�`, ..�� .H ��F:;� ,.,,�, �.-.d .... ,...,1+k-�,.r, rv -;: , i� :�=� :'f�. "rn� r"S<.. ..,e . �^�'� �,�:". 1 ., ,r^, ,:�,.... . ,,,. .._x.� ... ..,., ,......ti ...,:,.: . ... �:..,•,. .., ,y.. .i�.l� �4+u. �r� '�� :(� ',:�4r, �� '�.K� •�4° ..'� � ... ✓^, . .„ �.�. n � . ,« .'� . . $�i`rr .». . . �."., � .e. ,,._ .`��.,.'� f, r . , +�a.'. f i �1 � ,t ^u: �'i.,� �'. � �,,. �-'_*� .�.x ':ks ,3�--`,e." , _ . ...r � . .F. .,, .:�4� .: :. �. c� ..�kr . :t.�,,y-,� . ' `t�. ... . a .-c, �'i �r ��:�- �� ,�;. n .+.,�:- �-;-.....�, r.. ..; ..��:. �, _ `F.•>..44.,:. � .;,, �� i _,t' -�h,. . .. � �d� + � �,:h .: a�'.� r°, ...; ,�..�� . . . :�.,�,,. � _. ,� , ,..... �d". .. �. .. �.., ��n.y:� w.. .x.,. � )r ��: .�,:�:'� r,.:, �.t �::, . .: ::M. . .. >>,..,� , r-.<�:, .� .. ,. a.. . :.,.-. *7 ;,'^�'i� ,,. .}y., �' 'rt.� �A Y.. £1 ix :A"�'i. �,, ^J'•:�. r . .;,w.. , 9 .,�c:-�, � ..:...,. �,..�.._ .�.. �,, , y��:�-t <,:,:�� ..'.e � _.t,a+, ,> MI d.k., 9� 4i. .� 2.: _.,-, t..=;.,... �......*.4ni..4_ .�c�:.�,,,. .-..,,:: �..,....r. .. .... .��.:*4'�1 ;:... , � �, . „ . �.. e.a;. � �-.,...k�....r.,m*,� �..,k; ..J .. . , . ., ,i,,.:.-, ..��. ;.. _ . .. ... : , � . .«� a ��+,�,'. a :. . a ....a6 :�' .� �,. i.�,�� i:.. v��y�'�� '�k �� . ...,.� , ,. . . . ,,� .. �r ..�rv . , K . �.. �x, �. , �;. . .,.- i � � .z,... ,z'- z k "�,� i. , ._. rE .: .J �.��. ...: ....,e � .. ., .'2� . ,. . a+; ,±. , n .: . ..: : . , �: .... �_ , ....:,., � . �,>�. �n . f . . x , "�t = ��,. ��," i, �, �ii�x• � .3.u< �� q . .t .k; ...'?I�; . , fl � �n�.� t'R 4 i.l. .,-#. �� .y �. �l �N . t..''�r . `�i�i'. Y. �W., i. �'�f a� 4 t3i ,4 . �r.•r'4,�' �`�,...M ,;�1� �a, ,,?; , a.•,r.�r5.�.. ? .:Y;;f��,. s,. ac, ,.0 w.�".:?'� �§`, t�..^�P. .� � "��:!,._: . � ` u �? :� '�- F. , v s � � ..,} , - ,.. ! �$ : < R j'... � t` :7is',. ,x,i F , ,nj/s. k . , ..i.{. ,1» v,r.�°.. , } ,!t '�,a..... ., � r. :. , . -� s-:-..! , �._. .. ,.`C.�` �g.r ,.,,..,•: a'°�,.. .� x. 'Ny,,.,ll��°, •} `;� 9." «.� : a. . �:.�-; t�'�s, ... ,. .,, . , :... � ,... ;,- �y �.. .i .. ,� <n..�,. 4 s ,.,, .� *a . ;.:.. �:"'� � w ,y,� �,�, � , i�t�;" c� i� .; ,' N .b r.� a .ma: :fi, .. .. .... . .,,.. �... � . .ex `�."1 �.. fi . ,. w�,,,�v±�. 4M:'^u. . „k" '� � ,_ . ... s: r x.. .e 6z,�"- ' ", b'�4�:'.... 1 .., t,.: u M �' �! � � t �Y ..:V:..... � ..r,..k , .Rr�.:� .:.,r. .. �..�.. � .. .�&, .. . �.'"h".^.) : ` ,...:,.y"`4' . �:..�;1�. :. f. . .N t:*rF,� .� ��.�.�` ..,:,9' �a�'W'.� ., .,� �:t," �ey hi �(�'.�� 4 �y C i!;:�" k:s:�.. i. �...:.,.� , „, .y,.,r'.,.. ?a ;.� ,�.y �..,.a;�,, 'te4, .�.. .;,_¢�.,, .� �. �,. ;er-i'�n' .4yy "}.�,.t }`i.+.�id�;,'."'ti tp•;.��. .a.;�, �, , . � � �. . ,.� � , ,.-.„w 1 ... r . .,. .., / � r,.'.. :: ' � t�:i; .� »�'t,e. +� �'y §� i. �.v�.�, .5��-; ,+S' �, � . _ ,:f ;, �,�' �..`�_:; .`.� , :'�.% , ..,:., �':.;',vi� �S.a�' s>_ . �v.. , � y��y� r 3 1� e;»kac� � r y a „: �r,, . . . ,,. �,� x. . >,.. v w ,;�r, . , : :,, '� a,.. �w, � ��; . Mr,.;' -t�. .,. . . . ..��„<>. �f ,'��; . d�, � ':� d�.� 4 ,..,A:a„ q .� q ,y�..,,�.: ,�, �`. s.,»^ .t ^�� , , x, . y=... mr.�:< < :�� 6=% ..,_.,. m . ,.Md";;' �j.ue>:°x'� , �1i:i� a �+' .a:�w:� 5«.a _ . . xs :�s.�'. . . , .._ .:., � . .. v; ��: ro- , `;:.o. ,r.. .,y. `n .,w ;�'.., .�. `. x. .,, �.,(:� ). . t::.�?�" „4� ,`x: �.�,,,a �`�r x F ,; . .�,.,•.: _.: t.:�� : �.., :.,. .r y."r 1 +. '� �,,.... ,@'3a^`�P^i, t� .. ::.} .•'!s ..k _,.:�., a, ,�'� _ r�.' � y .�., , ..4 � i.a � �1� � -�. .nr M .it ..a Y� 'i:-.�A� , ,%°`. s...�' . . .:. 'ry .�a.°'!4: +' �i, ,,,,,��. �� .,;� �+� A, a' i s' .,"'. „ ., . Y� . : i ,, „ � . t,, , . ,t ..A. �. z ,...., ,. , .. e, � ,: ... � a� ,.� .,.: � -, ,:a� �. .�. �^. '�..: c�.. +. 3 r� 4'�s} � .r.�.. 3 5,1" 'r'C•, �1 =�:;r. � „ , . -,. , , w'� ,.. ...s, . • °�i ca,. �. '�:i �.x^, 3.t.. .._ n,' ::.,._ y i� a� ..t ;3 'g �� . •r ,`iF �iV` '.� Y' � ,;,. ' :.;. . I �y ...� .y. • <, r .y . .. ..& a� y 'S :t� a�' ^�� ,..,w'...... �, 1.3�. •.. ' ..:. � . �:..t: s ' ' .� �,. �;... S�T.t ' k ':.�. . � �n;�� e�y �` . ... , � . ..".k�.:. � . ,... '� °�: �:'+ �a'�.. �� . �. . ' - � � ' .. �r, . _ .�,-. wP$..b`' u�.'yu;.r. s Y '°�C: X ^;�..:. • �'e� .�.; t ;'k i� n� t �'� � �_`-�i f�'� .r�:^� - �.:� r.. �4: +, , .,:a� . r w}, �"w;..,..r.° .a.'B<,`. 4 .: ��.^� �.':'� i .'•.,. �„a'ix, � ' �.:�. � .t�.i!}; : . 4`+'� " f4� � �Y i'1 �.�:` ' , � h 4 �, 4�,- � C .'3 �:a'3 .u+`.b .�...<: .� �z �, °�,.�, i � .0 . ,.��.�Y;ae r.:.. C°,�,?F':.?.., ,.,.. ...;:. . :+.,.� a+;�a ��i� r>�'�"' � �1�,� ��'�`'°^�� ; y.+�r.�'�' .,y'� .y" t�" -.y..-� �:2 .n4"�;s'.,. .r., '_...�. �8,. A �. . �'�'j. k ,_P�n.."Y"�.�A;♦ +`eY..�. f��ak'r�. �:%s�'`+�'i`� '�a'�i�.. tI. ,1�i �.) p, r�. . , ...�. , ^r.:M •r, , , . .��... y..,;, . ,. ' .;,a t.:,', L .#��° "AL. ii. � ,:y>.,.'�r y,�.e. ..x-. � .,t' r'14 1: �.�:P:.'q,�.. x .-z� z .'.°t, .'�� a :.a. � , . . . .y.� , i . > K u�.' t'Se. w : `§ 'c . ,a ,,. (w; ; . : s'Y - ,� " 'h ! .q,, � +� baF> + ,a�' , 4 r.., � 1� �'�i ,� ' , � � . ,. .,- �. �, ` �'� '�, ,. Q, �.,.:.'�,. .�,+�,. : :�.. .,,,.,., _,..�:w �,� ,< . � ..,..., . , ,_,,s.. c-.:. N".. �' -- .. ,,. :... � �, ,.�.; �'r, � �s, :�v �b'�2a :6�,, .�r *• -.^.. , - ..h � -_,. -...., . .. .��. . .. ��. ,..e �.:+;� ...a� .. �.r . ;, w a'.� '3. '. � .-. r, -..,,� ��,Y-.:. . . _,-._..7°::r. � - - .:�,., .. . r ... „" ',. .,�- ,.�... .., '1N��` . i vt ��e� rt":'f"�,.. _ ., s� . .,. . . ..:,.,.k . � . , +�.,;, . ��a>, x 7.�. �. .: w.. I . :,� ^*� ,, ..,, ,,-:�i. , ;,. ; �,' �e � . s• x' � .�'. ,n�.a�.� ,.t� l � V �, t "�b � s ,;, : ;�: { r s ;�� z' �a .'kk r -t: .t. >� s� P�,, .,. ,, • .,; ; . . . ., „, s ' �s •, ,r�':,. '" sie...«�i ,x. ;a^_.;. ..t.! �.' � �' �� ' ,�.�, t :c_r *,%%; ' ''?.'• ' ,a, �s`#a�:^... ' ./`�+.`!�'o-� -'M��trar �� ,vs�t:. `.+r^4 �, �H..:,,+K �`� .e{'�.,.,�. :$"i. i'�• ,t.: �. ,.b,;: �. s±.... .^r`.., :..... . . +yy�i,,:�„ h?"'+' ,�' .,;?�.'t',. 77. �� n,."+M' �', -.., x ,. .; . ... � , , � x. , . , � - �,,, ,, , � . , n � •'� . � 4 ,. �!�``.. tr�` ,� ° �', .,'� ,v�� ' "` ."�ar>.. .. ..g "tY�y . �..<y ..�+d. �y�,,�t� y, �.r�t r .. .. T�.' 'if �Y R ��...4'�t 3';� �� " M, �c • k'�`�'N- �a'�.r, n :- ., ':;; .,r: ,,, r � . N - �', .,' � , b�... �.. .,.,.,.. . . s, , �.. .'� '+�wa-� �:... :7, .."t'�'ae� ��(%".. ^i.�+ ,%.... �,9 .h ' �" "t:�, . -�n'*'t.+r^.� Y-,�.,;"_ #, °"-4 �� .:;1�''� i��`��i�:.�� .x.; rh,ri.:; 1 .�. M .� ,.v. . -, s.; .:_w ;. �: .,'�!"` u .:,..�, �t e�-,i..;� .�f,� „ g..;. .. o ��. � z �s� . ir@ ' -1, i'} . .,t�!. y� � e ,:....,K &'iA = ,...� , ._.', i.,.a-s ,��,'+a`„-t ., 7 .�,,.. �. .yq �'Y.r:,�.�„ .' . . ,. , si� - � �,S�r 'lw�. `:.�'Y?f . f`. �,,,'�'a..�.p»n{" = .. "�' ,,:,; , ,„, ,. ,.� . _ .�, `= e. • ,•".`'+, fi � �, . �:� r a :�`"� �, iu � >�;, 1. �. ,� > , :�v. .,<.i-: ., ', � F :„ .!„ ,� �., .. _�. . ., �,.� �r�. t�'na.�`� � a:iia� ,:�:: re.. "xr- a y., ..+.. . ,.„.,. . , . . ,wr`�'�� :� � . ,�,,� ,, t,, , , �� .�.� � � ;� �y�� ;:t' : „ �« 1 .: *.,,� ..,� ,,u�� ,;. ., �µ,r- ,;,. . ,�;� ��s+k�},.�,-�.�,��. . 9,.,.:� �.,,� ..rt,.� r ,. ...;� �� "a ;:r � �: ;3 ■ W.� t c.t� �., ��,tS �F ..... 'r�N' �N - . ... a. .�.'... .. .i :,. , '�.;'°_ ,4�.-.� , :i., x �. ' �jF �i:F.. •`t. F.� ! ' 1�'� A r.�1I. , � �1 � t y ;R, y �� i� ,.;e�.,.d .:��s,.`*c+.�.. <,�r�'"�x?»,,.��$' .;SEA � r>;.. �t� .-.��R �r� � �k�: t}^:�- -:.:r'y �, - 5 .,A . q .�.._ @?".+� �� r '�` ^ .,ra ° i��w... �, t�. ,.� t� � t� �;sr%s ,�� q�'' ti b � � �k" ��.*ffi . r'�: ^�'° .. yw y � �' ; � � . �k. ..y. � , ;Y,,. . ,4;::.:. ,� k +,�,� F ,� t :AS ¢�.; y�, �_ �.� ", *.,�„ :� �,„a, �� - `°w t .�. ",��. ",�,^P„tG t.y;��. .'r'� 1� `�,:� � �:t:�.. .tkx� �'r4,. •F` � r .h�S '•i� 4 ..4,�. "r ' ,� �a A{ '.. yy w t.� .:.� , '�' t -.a� t�i..a , +....� i .�.,:; §o:. � a{ �i� cr" ,W, „x�r . y�y�> �Yka ,.trY�, -�-��.-t„� sa` «s ;Y� yr `,� : �, u;. �,'' � �.� .,{. q ^s�: . . . v.. �� . �•' . +, k 2 � � g^3 &� i., .. �` . en k.�-, a:t+r "3 Y'.- ti� k.`.�. ��'. if� �., yi,_ ':w` w �4, � '�'1 �. `:4' « Ga"�" � - � � '��w�..h... "i"�'" ,� . � M t,.;,. } �7 x p Y}�a � i,r. : k . . ,.�Y , . . � . ..� � o .6 . �.. .. � 't, °4; � �� } § {�Y S!`'r t � `aY� i;, ' �M . T' 4 + . ,4 . ' � k, .a._� r � ?A.� 'F.,. �*�i Cw '�''"Y4'l,id �.:x � $i , i 5. L. .t � �. S }M, , .. , � k . , - .. � .',�a .,,� �.. ,`�.« . :;,,r�.,.�� b. s;=� '�.i� ;:r �` ,i X tx�' ';< ae��, �� ,„ i '�, '�' �, < , 4. 4 ti �*a :. . ... .�, ..::, . ,y�.u,±4� v,.. �w .;f;Q .-..;.. tc .., ... �. "�!��:i 4. � ,y.;:,+� � :r �:G�" s, . ,�f�` �• •;....�.; ..�... '.:. ♦..6�� '.V� r ,q '�k ��++' y"�v- �'� G;�.� ._�r.: .s�� s;'� i.,k�� ..n �� - - _,.:<»T ,.. �, . �, , 'a < , „�..:. .. . ,..�. .. .. +.. ,i,� ,., , . ..� � � �+°b �'.£v a ... t5.:' M ,,.; .,� ._< . , t f,� . . >�i. .. 'h+�:.t � ^ .c»,' �3. . :' .. - ... ��..a �"�' � ..� �' y,,� '� '�"'� ��` . ,a-?`A, '�'�,. �� ' .>„ � �, "�a ,�, :6'rr.., ��,.. � � :; t �,a.� t �, p� -*7 .,' '.;>. � y�;. � t„�'.,c,« � �; v^ �F�.� ' ".tC �.i�''�'Y? '.r?3�`#n _ 5k - S . 1� +� _� ' - � , M � � q�� 6, ax,..-t 'y.� .'�,a,. 'g:j;,N `�^�,.",��>.. a'r ar�i`,'""Ti� `�� `; edt"�dM,. � ' . � ek+�.`�:. � ,x.�� _':P�� h� � ��r . .. '. a� .^ . � � < . . .v � ,y= eC4}� ,.. ,,. R ..a. d 1 � �._ ��' �+* � � t - . ,. �� . . . " ...' ,., �. �.- .::. .�? . � � � v �T � .. _.r. . a,..:�Lx"t'�3 r�.�.,s '� '° �� `^x+�.r�.;',yll�eq�y ,�ix �'k:" �. �'�{� �' � . � 'n,, ^ e ak. � .� .z �.: . .., �� ...:.. tg'y t�r� ' �. ? {� '�' W i�; �.. .. . ,;r � ... . . ,.,. .., , +�. �y� } ... �r3,. . ...y �.--.;�:n . a�r:.<:,q"�, i ,,,.�,�TS,,� :. 9A1 �:� t s : a � y : „ :,.:` '. .' . .'. . ..,-. .. ,.'<^"Y .....:1 t <. ..,. ,.,.e.�, . � �� py �:, ,�. �i d �''4k ,Y��'�eh!' i�' µ:! �i{,.�+F. r 'i5`.fs�x:�:.(+:i�, ... ., . , �5.. � - }., >. r . x; -: � ,. �+� ,,; .�F z k;t�, � i�; �'�� "�`' a S ..� w, „y,�� g ��,. ��t� y .� -� � �p �, � �.. � ��S �,�.#, r� }�k.- ,��'�:, �.;��. 4r�� ... +F "�;ye.'„ ,a�""° i a _ �i :5��.�.:�" _��.��'�+� a: .l,m„ 't � , �y � +,�li a' , T ..� ;;� ..�: N,-.: 'A -� �:. .� ..,R +F ;.,, r"�i .r '��.�� ;�i �' .,�.,,.�'' tl@�'` �,, �-,S �!"*Y�' �.,a "4r ad ,�.!�;`,�6t� �.�:� ]yb,.. 3`" w�V$k �"� "^,A �. ,}. P. :.,y.41� �. �.' �i..� �I�'�" �, �� it' �,, ��- ;-.::a� � �"°- ,< �� `� �,. � =i: Y a �'„`v�,�'• �..� �* t �.`��` iR' s!e'r��'� -+ �y x �.n..a�."^^� 9 ° . '�^.�. *�" a ,�5�, a'!F � ,� ':Y ,3i.�. .. �. 4 ; � " • ..f .v i t � . : ..r_ ,:.. ,. .,f ,;"# ":.:3. .`<��c � .y,:�hc'�t� S 'x� �r � ,�s�'M �� +,- F'"� � `" `5�� .4%,� ,,, � , • � �' "� �1 " � � �'��' 'Pdl � � �'� i . i �F, y k.: R4'�n �,ra�,� .t f��C'�, 3'�";:; ; ��•d�� a�' �ro.,�'T?'! y' '�` rdt }�„� � � 1"'�' � ,.S'3 . ., �� ` +, ,. .: ?. . �, �''x a., . , , `� �` � , <,' n�. . ; L , • �� 1^� ��a�*y,x # k �,� � �, e: , s � . '� �T,� ..,._.. . :.Z > F, �,. �h�. _,,.� �.�F.;;h.'� ,;,a'� _.;; � �9�sv� ,<;� t "�l �, �'.�+:� y�.�r� �,,H, ,�fy . . � .;��i . - ...>�r �.�- r .��., �;# s:��+� ""°'t .;?:. �y: ;n q ; �� g f�� xg{`',�,� P �,q, •,�ft� y�..'?yst�.,�T'r+ -.�4k': � �yyk: �� F� .u,. f�r�� _." q L l�: . `.�F�r:. � � :.'=�°� ._ a" �r �.� .�' � h �°" s�_-.;: �.�� +y�t.i;. � - ai:;'V. ,'�'� 'h..� 4. � .�,A� r � � �. � t > �t,-r �,y.. i.{ ?� ..�.a :: ,� »� fxii3 �•..�R �.a ' -h,�� ,t s ,<,�. ;y� l � '{ x.. �.�" �.hF�; � - x . 9e � . r' � '' ,1�`�y , y y.,. _. �i� { 4. @�: '4" y t �i,_ sa,p .:.'�'�'- ~ � .�,.� �' S' `Mr".: �' ."c.� .-r .ra _ , � . ; f� .�r "$"�`.r - e. ��' `�a�� r¢, °'�, y�:�'±�"�'`p�i� ,�� ,/ 4�:t' .� "1 ',t r �4 .t� �e�.: .. "i �� su �:'Xt`'z . 2.a . 3? .i*i a° t�</iC� 4GY 1 :"� � :,;�;. i41� 4 #' . 4S'`c i�i ..?w.- „�t� "«�' r:. .'K�. .�..`' .1.. S � �. . ' . ,� s t 'a .• -' , .+ ' , .� 1 7 � ��t.a 3 `k � p � , ' ,� .. i. ��'c. �.� ,.,w �lr:"�;.� ;�5�` ''R�,.-.,��g. �f�l- �� ,�, ' � .,:�� , e �`'. ,: , ., _ . =. 1,�, • . . . . , .� `, s,'� .t '`��e:'�V+� *�y-.' .y� �' � Li� - . +9,' �- .�� ,.rt��' r '°ri.;C � t� , `{` .�.e�' - 'i�Y� ,�; f � � rr M� . � - � S t ��'. S ,s,� ?'d` ;�zii�, �d+a; :,,.y , 1�� 7 �"x� I .b• ��,�` ! ';Y , i' �d � v � ,� ..: . -� , . �{� �:.. .. - :'. .. . . ._ ''�,.,y.. ` �• < `� t„c�. �-,,,� 'w�+ '. ..;'� i.�. ro�^S�va ° .'' t-��_ �Y i �}qa.-,^�^^`4 -:* t� t' �t t . ._p .' .�.,i ,,, . . . �,: � .., . �.Y+e, � •, .G},. .� . � x'. -.: .p.;;.:' 't . t a b .kI ,.=�{ < y �i � � �:. , , - �nMe!" F #7wwk' < 4._..,_ i � 3r'.>'P s+�„',i t_ .'�"k `r,5-,.�' a + � ��'h.•� . , rtp4 �Y , fi �, � a t7 '�.+ r r,� Eet . A � !, a a �-�` � � �� a .�,-. �,"�� ' '��'«,� ,.:i- �. � ,�;n �� '�';�1 .t� .� "° �#. `��`�.�x s;�.� ; :: # .. .� .� � � ,� k .� M F :':.�, �y,.� ! xd.' A" \. � r�t "'�"'4 ' r' . .,r >q + f+�[��,,� `t� ,y , � ;,,, � ` :., ' $ .; � } �«,�,�c .�Y. � �'7 C�_`�, ''.�t ; � �� - -2> , tt �,� � _ , , x a'S°4 �� \ � � „' � �s f � : 9 u ,l � ^'e q ^y... � �"? ' `t.y, � t�y .:� '1s .'.. r ,� '�s.�C� �,,,. �'1$��r��.�"�-J� /:;. ., �y 4„ �°�- . }��, a �: r� �` a4-^� e"# :3 � �� .,�'�� - f �la5t ��P ;er`s'*Y �aS'] ..ro�?L'��''�P -+,'.�.�. 'Y,. b � !�° aa1�, . � .*;`[' 3 ' t ,a� � � , p ,�. .. y,, . t _,. � 3� A � �f .��i -4 � �� "+c. a;�`�" 3*;f �(,:. ., a�'�_.�.. -.k'� '#�ii�.�., .`� tz�� . �� ,1}Y�� i �.�. � � .y f � f . � '�; k `��'�.�'� y ^ � N's �' '� .,;a � �l �. .. � `� 5:r„ � � . K � �.. .> . � - . �+ +,�''�.� �7'� t <,� ,� �' .$, :.h �' '�"" . , C�.' t p'•,s.. �� :t s� h � � '� � ,g �� , � . . .'y �� _...� :+ .,v..� � , n.;�. �$. � tt,;,e i,�°"�.,, t+ '� �i � 1'� �i 2�� . ..y,'t"`,� �` �.+� '�'� �"5`- � ' d Td � ,�. .. y� f� e., �- k• J.,� "' . �',, "n t xr.� ry. � � �^. . �i r �y., ' Y _:rq 4.i- �� r ��,i' ' .: t k<��s. . - "fK4 °�s,•M,�+ � A � � � Tx .'.��, �ti'�� it 'A •yy�, � .s . . � e ^�� 'x Vr '. �.�- . . . � -, . r , 'k' �3;: 4�"�ze,1'*M � a � rr -v.. � �t^ • � . � . : � ?�`�� A � ` -`, : r "� E ,a+m r . -,✓,� � � �' < � t`,� �¢r! p: � .&' „'�! s�: t� a .� � `f� �+t�;�'. -'s,` � ��,'�'�°y��` j t'+�%c �y'�, " ��.,c � r?� -,;;g ��: .:;t�°� yv% i.�-�a� K �M°c�-., �.%'� `� . . . � sw �`a�. ,.fii'�;m -.:' a��yh. �9t \�,k i g� �72; '�`. ' .,`d�. ?y,- t��, d }':� Y+C .� 4 �x.�� 4�� .� ' , � , . :� .'fi�� t�+�- %..�, �a.".::� Y�, .� ii`-I � i,r'��P'lc..�.e � �O.: ��_' ��" � . �� aal r>:'�' +.�tt.� u:. 4s , .�r b'." x A"�. "�;w"3 "✓.� � �'��i',t, P:, ie- � x� �' ,.� �� x � a � :.in�, ��°af.,, ' .: . . ,., a Y , :'��3. �e �,u .�€�R,,,y.� a ia,a ;�r> ��`'�c �� ?V->Y r xr- '� c;�; t,�t'�� ,�v' �_ �', .�^ � ' ' � .� t ��y � 5, _ ,i�',`9ti.��'" lu �,,.. 7�;,�� `:�� - " al _4'','+d+,,,Y ��r� �,l', t_ r t ", �..: _4�, �,L?%V!k'A 9'�!7 � 4 P� �'�}�'�4'�'�'e*v 3+c' r �cn . . .ai - � - � C r?a4,;�y �G^ ¢ � _ � ,� �, � � ,y .: �: �t} �,� -� , . ��,, � x y��•". t, . � • 4. ,,�' i k�'' ��Y� ,�i ��`� r. ti r ,, ;r �� 5 : � , „ _ �� ` s v � p Vt� `�� '� �`'p, �., � . 1�;. . a` ._ . �'y ..�• � �� 'ry�.� °+� ^� �?�� .. ` .yF� �4�M-.s r 3te ,"� 9`A vr l.i� � r! uy 4I � r s,. �� *�� ,i;- �`'. �, �ffi x' � ^i t r { �.. � p M . �. �`� � �,�. � ,� � w • �� . �, `�+'es <� �� d �' " . . � r• }�t � �i �' , � : t. , & „�,„�!'i .. '�v . G� Q � � . �v � � � ��4 � 4 ,a '�S } �t � �� i' �. "�'. �•�",. yi v.: -i A� �� +��c �� x� ." 1.. . . 1 +}°cb � � ;� ''� ��. ,i • tl � fl' �€�' � '� �� ..y �ry► y�.,� ��' �9!° ..� _ , � `� L p �s 3 . .+..i ° a3y',�3`�.!: ,�. `F�'� d} N.,S)"� / . ,�. ..�; •s�en Y��' ��' b t x'� 'iz3=�y"rr.+�. .. �..� r "= 1 � ,e' ' E '� , � ; S+e'.�kY. �' }.i i1F:� * !� ;'�y.� A } f . . . � � :� � '� � � � '� I I � ` r �:5�8 s. �` - S�-� s� � t _ st. `i � i� N, � �'} . , -,:y�., _ � .�j I xY fi a , � a r ''"��C x �f � S � � i,r5.ti' A. s . : � i 'p �'A � ,�t"� ,* 4.4,� �T��,' �,f '' '.. 'i � '" " "' �` `�� , '� 9�4`°�' . ^ u 4��"�s„ -.d"b .�, ��t i i 'd�p� 4 rh� ' � .. : '" 'a� ,� a' 3 '`"�` ,sY�" ."�1�„W� "'#ri�"t'7� ' ti �: y d �{,&t k �� ''�it , a i .-. .°�k` �'t" . +lt�v � ' � � } : 4. �. h'�� y� �M'y� � fi r : �, �,,.;;� � ��'t� �, 3 ,+�'�' 1 ,��',,�,� "r t� �;;�,<� ' a.' ` �,t� � a r � `�„�r,, z�`;�; � + :' �s � , � � �e. r }�`9�:,, ° �„v� 7..� ^ �.w � ,,�,� , r ��.� " , �i t �'�� #� f g`��a� '�£ S� } a'��:�� kr: , ::' � k�v.. ` G g.. �vbr � ; rr �' � c: �,.�"� � ; � y� �� . f .� � _r. � .,q�'� y � ``/�� rY� t.0 ,h ,t u, � �, �i ��`�,: � u' R�. �" �� S� �i��J 'v R, 1 � �l d F . . _� �, 1 i �� f. � � k�a Sfl.+.r. 1 � �i � � � e � yf � � .. Y � ,� �' �, : .. �v:y. G� y>-�,`z � e+, ,., r � tK� ; � � �"Y`s �'*r �,z�'�� Lr I � � �Fe�� ,�� y "fi � ./ . � ,. .wa.»... s r`,�t ��"�.R F,'' +' E � } . � , �.,� • . `�� : f k j �k 't ,�° 3. > r � j ,� � . �,. ....J` l. „� � 6,2�,,-",^�' t � . 4.., .� �'. �� •"'" �� T . "�F .3 ,'� p � .5,�� ! n : �+:. , v . .- ' / .1. . j�i �.I4} 1 Y µy - 6 i,�y� � . y�r 9,.. 4"' � ' � �4a"'�i �T � f. � '}i� �(t NA P�l �' ' _�,^�'�'T!a �"� . . ., r' � �:1.' . . . . �il a.y� � ,��'d'' �,:,:. �� ti �r Yt�i -r L,. ►ndAy� '� �, . �' .� y � �..� • � . . ��."+e j• x,.. �' '� ��7"'.: .x,*t�s S. C ,r :, iMS. t � ��-�: "Xf�;' � . v .,}�F�t � t",_�";, ' � ` � > � �� "�� r., t ,, �., �,�6.�*� � ;�.�, 3 ; , - � ,G.",2 � � ��`. i , , � . , � �, � 4 & �-s ..� �: � '� �� , �, s< �; ��.�ay� '°��` ` a,y ��'�" �' � : � '^". � ' 3 R ' �,.lA` : �k� ��, �l 9��.t'.�� fl 's 7 �t��f'Y _ �.a z .. � �C� { �''� r F � 'n� . ` � _ � '[C"�� -.. ,� 3 i.`.� � ,�` "'1t �,_�,m � .� r 'a i � �° � 4`�', t � �� . +F . . . . r�.� i � � ��:.i . i. � �.Y �.; � , � �� ., � � . .. ,nin � < A � , � � ^ . 1 a'.i r � �" ^� � p f �� W �`x � i t.`i`'r � ` .. e" ` tir�� a -= y � Y'r� ,E �' 'a*�„ �' ar:' cy . �''` � �,r z �� l� " '"� r <, I � � :�„�,�,.t,.� � ,�' `, '' _ "�^�,��' > x �1' f�5�, � _ � 1 �' • � � } - g i`x, . . � � . � .,� 4 � a t . . 7 , . .:. y � 'S 4` � _ a,.� _*' •�� r� � . y�t'i}� .�� , `` �� "� :° r r `x tr�.�..r „�" .�,SS#�" a-*,+�.: � i � � � .°'�, �i � \, . L � � q `.^'4, _ 7w�� _ r 3?•c,..,,y, � . l � .,9eF K.. Jll, � . 'n'i � � s� q� ; � ':!' .^Ry } �-: ' a { : � f _ P. fw�. ..x .. � �, ;�'e��y.�r �a �' . s� � ��^y ,a�'�. ��"� ��, �z_ .S Mt a a � �-� ' _ ��'�� ,y,w:` i.r �'j^ . � .. ��,`_" "`,F � FA� h'�.,,Fn��"�y.{. . c.� �°`�'+�► -�'�'.i.;`+k � `+°,°y �, �'��,�; « l � }� � . � � �� „ �;�,i ,� , � �, �. ";� �* � � x � � �'� ""�E, � �_ � i�: �," �' ��; �� . ,� � � �� - � , s e> � • � " , ,. ,�, � r >. � _ � �� , ' � .. � � +�n ; �.� Aa� �r � , �, i, ` . � � �� ^y.s.. a ',• � Z� A k � f �� . +• .:�f �T��; rt� `��Y' _ y�• •L \ � - � . �. S'.# k�' 1 . A� 3:+ '�� M'w ..Fj.* J x . . � , ' „, ' �i ' � 1 R�Y d :.'^!7' �d.; � .' �� t" �" � k ,# � _ �. !N '� �' ��`� ��" t , . ., . i� .' � ��, ► ,�.,� , ��.' y .,y- t.:� S ��`.�'�' h4!�.� . �'r=' a b�Nr fi..,'� i.�. �:. �°i^ �}_ .�i. �'F�}. ,i < i,.�' u �'sx..a v � .�`, �x ,qyi,' s r �" �*,� ;':�,r*,✓ d. i '*` d'a`''':; ,'�1 ' rnJ-1 � '""�..� . t ;t.y ,� �s,'�� !\ , � � �,� t � 's�. � a ; � �. ':: �.+ 1�.. �vi'�i4 �e� ..;� •,_."'C*ti r..... s � _ aX ,�,1C.�5 , µ'-�. . 't �, - c- � k., e� � -. • . `'£ .�'s�' ,^. > �%.�,d �. ;. ,,� `� �u,� . . � ,. . , ,,,aF.. "n . ,� .t r . .�"i � . , " . � : a�n "�" s:; � «� s�. ' � "�w " ,+`u ,, _;. 4 a T , �+�'; , � $ F� '�ii„`i� f f' �t t` � .,�K;, �` ��` s ,:> i �� , �� 5 ; x��",�"��' S� '� -,. ��`_ �� . �' � .� 4;' �.`` ..�, '� .� . 'i _ ;: �, .. X� x'� T.r ;. t t^�E �� a �' r.> �w ..._ . . Z'M`"; � . � . `sy��r, '�e n� �g �'rs� � � . � i�� ``�<< F4� - ..��,K �: .r p{' �,1�'E,..r b'� �"' , . . ..:� �.�"L� �, . .w. . ... . . � � t ��'+� i. '�'� . � :n�, ��','��NIC�� ;: �;�� S�. ��F� '�: ; �`. �&h4M'fiaba '�` � .~�{?� � }' ��P t� ; � x y. . ; � , ,�'. � Z : �., S1� � . � + .. ?` '� F` k� k'.?�huv J'r . b ,..^+I . � . • l _ A b4 ,� .� . . . i�,.� �: a .`. . . -, -'r y " r ' , ._. : �. $ . . . . ��fi � vt . k . � � r : : 1 + . {l� � �� Y {�. � r � �} ' i �i t � Ri� f �'� �, , "� e z � _. „� .� � �;�� ".+ £ 'a� j t � � : , � - ti .: � �a � .. ,. r�''��: x"��Z '. x , r -_ . � � � .i `� ` r ,. *� , �x,. . ,� c � �' ,, � � �� : r . �tt��e?Y"� ,.i ` .. °"�. '�.4 ,il � ., �S" � �# . .. _ _ a;,� ' ,�_ . _ `�..` ,rj'; AYt � ^ T -Y�""��1%R�� ;ft . 9? �� `�� ;., e , y �, j0�3': ? ; �x� . �y � #Y. °'�';t;. y�n� � � x ' k� r � '"' , s'i`%ga+,7"�� s . ,r-�.� � 7�.•.�� ..13. ��r �. . . � u�" ;" y�. } ty"��.�•'u � �p ...k 'A��sa�;: 'H' 3 yy, �"' .:.�:. F � ' � � - . . � �3'�'�"'�f .; a'N .: .,„` .:i� ea • �,/,n/� ' ( t4 ',Y,`P�t�. f.� t "d'. .r, g�t `tpy/,�A . ,.Sk:` �w . .` . .M= .iG�3. �� 'r` �Y 'i "A`M Pi i d� ' `C. .y�.'` h''+. `a-} St�� C= ; ' 4 �i�' �' � �"akr• �da+ '�;�°�,st " h,� � ��R 1'% yy+ �, � �� , . � �` . a.w,w. �"�; � �;� Q, ' ��e�� : � ,�� y ? ,�ra k,ytq,� � ,� � .a"�° ,� ` � i'� a � � � � ''.y�� r^� � :y � „-- > �' � �� t x i ��; Y�n �� g�� , - , � "�� e. �� ,e<'�h r . ° . r �^� k � � ,F,, i i , � �, ��` ;. i�7 �.. � 7� � aa�. . .. �.. (''k'�af.�f+. � C ��F;:�� S '�C�f�r?".'a't+,. f� B. �k4 '.4' � � . � *.' u t'y t, � �A�f»� a.'�� h rx±' ��'�^?m`� �.c °7� ,if'*�, �� ` � °� ,�j ..i � � �„ : , y �. • si. � �, ;' t ?��;� � �� Y �, - fy�� '� � j� � ,� � , �r": bV's�"�"� � r r. r` �"�� ! l.' T��,r"F � V ,.�1%, t t w 4"� t�;..4 ."�°,� iY '. 'a . . _ ,. �. : �� .. �� . } .r . , ,. � F n � �. .''` � �t, t , ,�. °'"` � "�., v 3 � '" �! �,�,� wN�� + ; � � � � � � _ . ,. � .�� , �. � ,� . � , .'1 �: u � ,, �p ,t , ; L vt , ". , �,: , � � . Yvi4 i � � + t �. �.1r' �' � �. � �'f "�;�� n �3 .�� r. C • rv . ��"� �,x:�•y"e...: � . l? � 1 � �� v 1,�� " i,`N.., "`,�t'a" �� , � k ."} 's"; ','•� r. ,.a� '� .;;,r- � ,r:, i , r,r' .:7. �� .�", �.� �i ,it ?�.. �,e" �4 .a.,, � F� ��,,. "_; � ��'` ��+�2a�".r ak'� •s^' 'i� a tN �i �; ,�±� � 't� & �,,r�`+`� �;y�,""� �4'' 1 ir,"� �,�,.`." aG �e,.nK« •a� -r '�'�k'�, t` ,:$' �, ',�M �t.,, �v. � .. , , ,.. ; `,: '� . . , � ,.e � :.;° � .:; '� � �' sJ� .�k .. � .,;�;. ' . tr r�;"�`,' .. y i .. Ft�`_t:'. ,r�s+'r�.� -4.,... w� � ,� ' �e. .� o � �, t. � � � � . �a"�"�� `��.�t�. c5�'"' �a� �" �'', "� �� •;�"'�X+: .� �.ra � - �� °r'.�,.�� ., �"�y1fr ,�._� �" 'L;: 1+ �i� �ar� ? ",.�' �. `'� �{y � ' .:.r `. } � 3¢ ',i � a � �� .��;i� , ,,f�'L„ <*`yaf � �5.. /� {: °-W°' k e� t r.� � �� .42a,�� ^ S �ii, �y � �� , nb �..., �.t.x . ��.� � � i � ! `.� ,��i��'«'° � a h�.: .�� 1� � � -� ".'s # � 4: a "4; . � �'�`��' �. �A� q,�ik. # „y,,� . �� ,^r4:; �d i �" , r;. �.� �,. r� 'i4 t �; ,�,r�`i, * 3� . k.3 �.�� 3 �i y ; �:'� r�'">a,� r .;t a �`.+r��+� �b ,..� y, ,.,�,� � ��s p� ' .r�l r v� . . °��r ..�5 +f .ef ,� �i "� C.ri,„ � ,� r'� sa, �, r� �al?��e�s. ..° '�u._. .. .. "' u,__..s..�a�tr..��.. _ . ' � �� . �....d„eF� ._.� v,..,__u�.,.�,. �'N`,-,_,.�....,..._"�..5 . _ . �'.�'�i .». �,..wt»�'.�._ ,.... .�'.`1,.,...�..�o-s.'� , .. �� • CITY OF FRIDLEY • APPEALS COMMISSION MEETING, DECEMBER 10, 1997 ROLL CALL: Chairperson Kuechle called the December 10, 1997, Appeals Commission meeting to order at 7:30 p.m. ROLL CALL: � Members Present: Larry Kuechle, Terrie Mau, Blaine Jones Members Absent: Carol Beaulieu, Ken Vos Others Present: Scott Hickok, Planning Coordinator Karl & Margaret Schurr, 7818 Alden Way N.E. APPROVAL OF NOVEMBER 12. 1997. APPEALS COMMISSION MINUTES: MOTION by Ms. Mau, seconded by Mr. Jones, to approve the November 12, 1997, Appeals Commission minutes as written. � UPON A VOICE VOTE, ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRPERSON KUECHLE DECLARED THE MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY. INTRODUCTION OF NEW MEMBER: Mr. Hickok introduced the new member of the Appeals Commission, Mr. Blaine Jones. Mr. Jones is a resident of the City of Fridley and was recently appointed to the Commission by the City CounciL 1. PUBLIC HEARING• CONSIDERATION OF VARIANCE REQUEST. VAR #97-20. BY KARL & MARGARET �CHURR: Per Section 205.25.08.C.(1) of the Fridley Zoning Code, to reduce the setback of a deck from the bluff line of the Mississippi River from 40 feet to 23 feet to allow the reconstruction of a deck in the rear yard on Lot 9, Block 5, Pearson's Craigway Estates 2nd Addition, the same being 7818 Alden Way N.E. MOTION by Ms. Mau, seconded by Mr. Jones, to waive the reading of the public hearing notice and to open the public hearing. UPON A VOICE VOTE, ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRPERSON KUECHLE DECLARED THE MOTION CARRIED AND THE PUBLIC HEARING OPEN AT 7:33 P.M. Mr. Hickok stated the subject property is located at 7818 Alden Way and is along the Mississippi River. The request is to reduce the required setback from 40 feet to 23 feet along the Mississippi River bluff line. The overlay district for the critica( area for the Mississippi River was adopted in 1977, one year after the Schurrs built their home and deck. • • APPEALS COMMISSIOPI MEETING, DECEMBER 10 1997 PAGE 2 Mr. Hickok stated the home is on the west side of Alden Way and overlooks the Mississippi River. The homes on adjacent lots are positioned in such a manner that they will not have their view impeded by the addition. The addition is located at the rear of the house, centrally located on the home, and facing toward the River. Mr. Hickok stated the home to the south is positioned on a curve of the River, and the owners have positioned their home to take advantage of the view. It is possible that their view from a window at the front corner of the house will provide a view of the comer of the addition. The home to the north is set closer to the street. The addition should not be visible from the neighbor's home to the north. Mr. Hickok stated the code requires that new structures be placed not less than 40 feet from the top of the bluff line overlooking the Mississippi River. The purpose of this ordinance is to protect and preserve the unique and valuable state resource; to prevent and mitigate irreversible damage to this state, regional and national resource; to preserve and enhance this natural, aesthetic, cultural and historic value for public use; to protect and preserve the River as an essential element of the national, state and regional transportation system; and to protect and preserve the biological and ecological functions of the Mississippi River corridor. Mr. Hickok stated that, as constructed, the Schurr's home has a deck which is 22 feet from the bluff. The deck is now dilapidated and is in need of reconstruction. A new deck, six inches narrower, has been proposed. As proposed, the deck would have a 22.5 foot setback. The addition includes a two-level potting/sunroom combination which will occupy 175 square feet of the 275 square feet of deck/addition combination. The mass of the two-story building will not be visible from inside the adjacent home to the north and slightly visible from the home to the south. In the past, variances to 5 feet from the bluff line have been granted. Mr. Hickok stated that because the request is within previously granted variances, staff has no recommendation. If the Appeals Commission wishes to approve the request, staff recommends the following stipulation: 1. The petitioner shall work with staff to provide additional native plant materials along the bluff line. Mr. Hickok stated staff received a letter from Mr. & Mrs. Sallman in support of the request, a copy of which was included in the agenda packet. Staff also received a telephone call on December 2 from Mr. & Mrs. Samuelson who indicated the Schurrs are wonderful people and that they would like to see their request approved. Ms. Mau stated that it appears the majority of the proposed deck falls within the 40-foot setback. Mr. Hickok stated the bluff line curves at the back of the house and is 44 feet from the south corner of the deck but 23 feet from the north corner. The bluff line falls away from #he majority of the mass. The new construction at the south comer will be 44 feet from the bluff line. The north comer of the deck is the point where it falls under 40 feet. Mr. Kuechle asked if the petitioner would need a variance to simply reconstruct the • � APPEALS COMMISSION MEETING, DECEMBER 10, 1997 PAGE 3 existing deck. Mr. Hickok stated, yes. Mr. Schurr stated the DNR asked that they provide additional native plant materials. They have maintained that bluff line and the slope in the same condition for 20 years. They have added native plant materials to prevent erosion.. He saw no problem in continuing that approach. This is really not an addition. It is a replacement. It is not practical to move the deck further to the south to fully comply with the state regulation which passed a year after they moved in. They then would not have a proper entrances to the home from the replacement deck. Mr. Jones stated he stopped by the house and looked at the site. He read Mr. Hovey's letter about the native plants. It appears as though the bank where it drops off has native plants already. He was not clear where the native plants should be located. It seems pretty natural all the way to the River. He also noticed that, from where the doors come out, the only place for this is where it is proposed. The request seems reasonable. Ms. Schurr stated she keeps native plants. That is her hobby. She has columbine and early spring flowers. Today, she saw an eagte again. Mr. Schurr stated that is something that was not seen 20 years ago but they do see now. Mr. Jones stated he saw little evidence of erosion. He would think the DNR would be pleased with the way it is working. Mr. Schurr stated he did not know if the DNR looked at the site or if this is a standard response to such a request. Mr. Hickok stated that when there are proposals along bluff lines, the DNR looks at the staff report. Quite often they do come out to the site. He thought it was standard to tequire native plant materials. While this may not be required in the present state, whenever you do foundation work or any small excavation, you may disrupt a natural amenity. This stipulation would make sure that the natural state is restored. MOTION by Mr. Jones, seconded by Ms. Mau, to close the public hearing. UPON A VOICE VOTE, ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRPERSON KUECHLE DECLARED THE MOTION CARRIED AND THE PUBLIC HEARING CLOSED AT 7:47 P.M. Ms. Mau stated she thought the petitioners have shown they are interested in keeping that area as natural as they can. This will be an improvement for their neighbors to see rather than what is existing. She had no problem with approving the request. Mr. Kuechle concurred. He believed the hardship is that the ordinance came into being after the deck was built, and with a fairly minor incursion to ask them to not have a deck there would not be in keeping with the spirit of the code. He would like the stipulation included. He did not see that the stipulation would create any hardship for the petitioner. This is something that they want to do and it can be easily worked out. Mr. Jones concurred. CJ � APPEALS COMMiSS10N MEETING, DECEMBER 10,1997 PAGE 4 � by Ms. Mau, seconded by Mr. Jones, to approve Variance Request, VAR #97- 20, by Karl and Margaret Schurr, to reduce the setback of a deck from the bluff line of the Mississippi River from 40 feet to 23 feet to allow the reconstruction of a deck in the rear yard on Lot 9, Block 5, Pearson's Craigway Estates 2nd Addition, the same being 7818 Alden Way N.E., with the following stipulation: 1. The petitioner shall work with staff to provide additional native plant materials along the bluff line. UPON A VOICE VOTE, ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRPERSON KUECHLE DECLARED THE MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY. 2. UPDATE ON PLANNING COMMISSI�N AND CITY COUNCIL ACTIONS Mr. Hickok provided an update on Planning Commission and City Council actions. 3. APPROVAL OF 1998 MEETING DATES MOTION by Mr. Jones, seconded by Ms. Mau, to approve the following meeting dates for 1998: January 14 January 28 February 11 February 25 March 11 March 25 April 8 April 22 May 13 May 27 June 10 June 24 July 8 July 22 August 12 August 26 September 9 September 23 October 14 October 28 November 10 (8:00 p.m.) December 9 December 23 UPON A VOICE VOTE, ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRPERSON KUECHLE DECLARED THE MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY. ADJOURNMENT: M T N by Ms. Mau, seconded by Mr. Jones, to adjoum the meeting. UPON A VOICE VOTE, ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRPERSON KUECHLE DECLARED THE MOTION CARRIED AND THE DECEMBER 10, 1997, APPEALS COMMISSION MEETING ADJOURNED AT 7:49 P.M. R spectfully submitted, , �,�,.,�,�� ° � Lavonn Cooper :,P , Recording Secretary REGLV TO ATTENTION Of ` DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY ST. PAUI DISTRICT. CORPS OF ENGINEERS ARMV CORPS OF ENGINEERS CENTRE 190 FIFTH STREET EAST ST. PAUL. MN 55�01-1638 December 11, 1997 Construction-Operations Regulatory (98-01959-NP-TJF) Mr. Scott Hickok Municipal Center 6431 University Avenue NE Fridley, Minnesota 55432 i;�a� ili. I31�:�::;:: � U�-+�- �c 7- a.� � � � � �� We have reviewed the information you provided about a project of Karl and Margaret Schurr to replace an existing with a sunroom on the rear of their dwelling along the Mississippi River. The project site is in the SW 1/4 Sec. 30N., R. 24W., Anoka County, Minnesota. deck 3, T. The work proposed at the location stated is not within the regulatory jurisdiction of the Corps of Engineers. No work will be done in a navigable water of the United States, and no dredged or fill material will be discharged in any water of the United States, including wetlands. Therefore, a Department of the Army permit is not required to do this work. This letter is valid only for the project referenced above. If any change in design, location, or purpose is contemplated, this office should be contacted to avoid doing work that may be in violation of Federal law. PLEASE NOTE THAT THIS CONFIRMATION LETTER DOES NOT ELIMINATE THE NEED FOR STATE, LOCAL, OR OTHER AUTHORIZATIONS, SUCH AS THOSE OF THE DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES OR COUNTY. If you �zave any questions, contact Timothy J. Fell in our St. Paul office at (612) 290-5360. In any correspondence or inquiries, please refer to the Regulatory file number shown above. Sincerely, _---� ��. �, � ��v�� / �% Julett R.�Denton Chief, Western Permits Section Pnnted on � Recycled PaPer � _ _ CITY OF' FRiDLEY � U FRIDLEY MUNICIPAL CENTER • 6431 UNNERSITY AVE. N.E. FRIDLEY, MN 55432 •(612) 571-3450 • FAX (612) 571-1287 APPEALS COMMISSION ACTION TAKEN NOTICE Karl and Margaret Schurr 7818 Alden Way Fridley, MN 55432 Dear Mr. and Mrs. Schurr: December 17, 1997 On December 10, 1997, the Fridley Appeals Commission o�cially approved your request for a variance, VAR #97-20, to reduce the setback of a deck from the bluff line of the Mississippi River from 40 feet to 23 feet to allow the reconstruction of a deck in the rear yard on Lot 9, Block 5, Pearson's Craigway Estates 2nd Addition, the same being 7818 Alden Way with the following stipulation: 1. The petitioner shall work with staff to provide additional native plant materials along the bluff line. You have one year from the date of the Appeals Commission action to initiate construction. If you cannot begin construction during this time, you must submit a letter requesting an extension at least three weeks prior to the expiration date. If you have any questions regarding the above action, please call me at 572-3599. Sin erely ; . S tt Hic{ nning ; SH:Is �/ ��1/ �= Please review the above action, sign below, and return the original to the City of Fridley Planning Department by December 31, 1997. `�!�� Concur with action taken.