Loading...
AF-V - 34911l�, _ CITYOF FRIDLEI( �1 FRIDLEY MUNICIPAL CENTER • 6431 UNIVE�Z����L� c�M�����bN 55432 •(612) 571-3450 • FAX (612) 571-1287 A ACTION TAKEN NOTICE January 25, 1996 John & Lillian AAeyer 7868 Alden Way N. E. Fridley, MN 55432 Dear Mr, and Mrs. Meyer: On January 24, 1996, the Fridley Appeals Commission officially approved your request for a variance, VAR #96-01, to increase the encroachment of a deck in the side yard from 3 feet to 4 feet 10 inches to allow the reconstruction of an existing deck on Lot 6, Block 4, Pearson's Craigway Estates, the same being 7868 Alden Way N.E., Fridley, MN 55432. You have one year from the date of the Appeals Commission action to initiate construction. If you cannot begin construction within one year, you must submit a letter requesting an extension at least three weeks prior to the expiration date. If you have any questions regarding the above action, please call me at 572-3593. Sincerel �__.._._. ���� ���� � Michele McPherson, BLA Planning Assistan# Please review the above, sign the statement below and retum one copy to the City of Fridley Planning Department by February 7r 1996. „ �; .: � ,, � � with action aken., / � r � . �.�J i�6�' -f �� r 1 � APPEALS CO�IlrlISSION MEETING, JANUARY 24 , 1996 PAGE 6 MOTION by Mr. Kuechle, secon d by Ms. Smith, to recommend approval of Variance Request, #VAR 95-37, by Ronal Zac�kowski to reduce the setback of an accessory strudure faang a streei from 25 feet 14 feet to alirnnr the oonstruction of a 22 foot by 36 foot garage on Lots 29, 30, 39, an 32, Block A, Riverview Heights Addition, the same being 314 Hugo Street N.E., with the ollowing stipulations: 1. The petitioner shall remove th e�asting driveway within six months of the final inspedion of the new garage� or pply for a speaal use permit within 30 days of appcovaL � 2. The existing garage shall be corn final insp�tion of the proposed ga� a special use permit for a second 3. The petitioner shall provide a hard February 1, 1997. UPON A VOICE VOTE, ALL VOTING AYE, MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY. i to habitable space within one year of the or the petitioner shall apply for and receive �soN structure. driveway for the new garage by SAVAGE DECLARED THE 3. PUBLIC HEARING: CONSIDERATION OF VARIANCE REQUEST VAR #9fi-01 BY JOHN AND ULLIAN MEYER Per Set�ion 205.04.06.A.(3) of the Fridley Zoning Code to incxease the encroachment of a deck in the side yard from 3 feet to 4 feet � 0 inches to allow the reconstruetion of an existing dedc on Lot 6, Blodc 4, Pearson's Craigway Estates, the same being 78fi8 Alden Way N.E. � MOTION by Ms. Smith� seconded by i�,�: �Cuechle, to waive the reading of the public hearing notice and to open the public hea�ing. UPON A VOICE VOTE,14L.L VOTING AYE, CHAIRPERSOIV SAVAGE DECLARED THE MOTION CARRIED AND THE PUBLIC HEARING OPEN AT 8:00 P.M. IVIs. McPherson stated the subject parcel is located at 7868 Alden Way which is at the irrtersection of Bellaire and Alden Way. The request is to allow a variance to increase the enc.roadiment of a dedc into the side yard from 3 feet to 4 feet 10 inches. If approved, this would allow reconstruction of a deck located on top of an underground storage facility. Ms. McPherson stated the petitioners are in the process of constructing a 6 foot by 24 foot porch addition onto the rear of the single family dwelling unit with attached garage. The area of the variance is an open dedc which provides egress from the porch to the side yard. The underground storage facility was constructed after the dwelling was constructed. It is not a pa�t of the structure itself. 1# can be accessed only from the outside. Because the storage facility is c�nsidered an accessory structure, it does meet the 5 foot setback Therefore� the dedc would also be set back 5 feet as required by c�de; � � APPEALS COI�IISSION MEETING, JANUARY 24, 199f pAGE 7 however, it does encxoach i�to the side by 4 feet 10 inches as opposed to the pertnitted 3 fee� Ms. McPherson stated the petitioner has one altemative which would to � to shorten the dedc by 1 foot 10 inches whid� would then leave a portion of the roof of the storage facility uncovered. It would look aesthetically odd but i# would not adversely impact the dec�CC or the exit to the side yard. Eliminating the deck altogether is not an altemative. There is a drastic grade change along the south and west sides of the storage facil"dy so code wouid require some-type of railing. Ms. McPherson stated the request is within previously granted requests. Staff has no recommendation. Mr. Kuechle asked if the 3 feet they are talking about would normally be 10 feet Ms. McPherson stated, yes. The side yard setback is required to be 10 fee� The code allows dedcs in the side yard to encroach 3 fieet as long as they do not come closer than 5 feet. This request meets the 5 foot part of the code but not the 3 foot part. Ms. Savage asked if staff had received any calls from the neighbors. Ms. McPherson stated, no. Mr. Kuechle stated construction is underway. Is this something the City saw that was added iater? Ms. McPherson stated consiruction on the porcfa is underway. She did not believe construction o� the deck portion had commenced. The petitioners were told at the �ime of applying for the building permit for the porch that they would need a variance for the deck Ms. Meyer showed pictures of the existing porch and d�c. The �rc� and deck will be the same size. They are just repiacing what is there. The wood is rotting so they r�eed to replace it. Mr. Meyer stated the railing in question has been there for 29 years and has always encxoached. They are not increasing the encroachment He understands the need for the space. Their land and their neighbor's land drops rather abruptly so there is no way an emergency vehicle could acxess there because of the slope. They could cut back the deck to 3 feet if necessary: However, they had a stoRn shelter built after the tomadoes� and it would be ugly if it was not covered by the deck. Ne thought it would be appropriate to keep it the way it is. Ms. Savage asked if the neighbors had any problems anrith the request � i� APPEALS CONIl�lISSION MEETING, JANUARY 24, 1996 pAGE 8 Mr. Meyer stated they have no problems with the request Ms. Meyer stated the only one that would s� the deck is the neighbor who has a high fence to shield their pool. MOTION by Ms. Smith, secc�nded by Mr: Kuechle� to ciose the pubiic hearing. UPON A VOICE VOl'E, ALL V017NG AYE, CHI�IRPERSOIV SAVAGE DECLARED THE MOTION CARRIED AND THE PUBLIC HEARING CLOSED AT 8:10 P.M. Ms. Smith stated she was inclined to vote for approval. While it is not necessarily a hardship, aesthetically it makes sense to extend the deck. The actual amount of increase in feet and inches in so minimal as to be non-�xistent Mr. Ku�hle concurred. Although there is not a clear hardship, it would be a hardship to have to step off the deck on the roof of the storage facility. It is far enough in back of the house so it does not visually have an impact from the sfreet. Ms. Savage agreed. MOTION by Ms. Smith, seconded by Mr. Kuechle, to recommend approval of Variance Request, VAR #96-01 � by John and Lillian Meyer to inarease the encroachment of a deck in the side yard from 3 feet to 4 feet 10 inches to allow fhe reconstruction of an existing dedc on Lot 6, BIoGc 4, Pearson's Craigway Estates, the same being 7868 Alden Way N.E. UPON A VOICE VOTE, ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRPERSON SAVAGE DECLARED THE MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY. � 4. UPDATE ON PLANNING COMMISSION AND COUNCIL ACTIONS Mr. Hickok provided an update on Planning Commission and Council actions. ADJOURNMENT MOTION by Ms. Smith, seconded by Mr. Kuechle, to adjoum the meeting. UPON A VOICE VOTE, ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRPERSON SAVAGE DECLARED THE MOTIOIV CARRIED AND THE JANUARY 24,1996, APPEALS COMMISSION MEETING ADJOURNED AT 8:23 P.M. Re pectfully subrr itted, � avonn Cooper �� Recording Secretary � � DE�RI�TION OF REQII�ST: Zi�e p�itio� requ�s tt� a va�ia�ce be � to al�ovv tl� enaoach�t of a deck in th+e side y�d to be �sed from 3 feet to 4 feet 10 inches. If approved, this would a�low recon�udion of a deck which is la;ated on top of an widea�round stora�e fac�ityltomado sheher HAR�SHIP: "To re�a�ce the no�#h end c�f ow exi�in� deck" SUMMARY OF bSSUES: S� 2U5.04.06.A.(3) �ti�e Fri�ey City Code requires that decks not �d more than three feet into anY req�ired �de yard. Pubfic P�pose s�ved by this �� to grovide s�c�e be�v�►een i�i�idual � to reduce the possi'bili�y of fi�e tzavel bet.ween b�din� to provide access to the r�ear yard for em��es, and to mai�tain upen space. 'The p�i� is co�cuc� a 6 foot by 25 foot porcdi addition to the re� of the �ngle f�y dw�ling writ. In conjuaction with t�gs con�ruction, t� petitioner proposes to recon4hv�t a deck which was constructed on top of aa unde�'gc'oun�d �e �ityhornado shelt� at the northwe� corne� of the � 1�e pragos�ed �ck �s t1� 5 foot s� yrd s�a�Ck require�rt; howeve,�, it eacroaches four feex (a�e foot beyond code allowance) iato ti�e side yar�d. The petitionea� could reduce the width of the d�k bY � fo�, t�Y m�ng the �xxoachmem requirement. A reduced width decdc in this case, however, is not pra�tic�l be�use of tt� � of a�ue below which is e�san� and would e�raa$ch anyw�y. T7ie requ�t is vvit�n previouslY �ed retNe�s• RECOMMENDED ACITONS: As t� request is vv�thin �viouslY gcas�ed variances, staff l�s no recommendation regarcling the reque�t. � l�� VAR #96-01 7868 Alden Way N.E. �a PROdECT DETAILS Petrt�oo For: A varia�ce to incae�se the �aachm�rt of � decd� in t1�e side yard finm 3 feet to 4 feet 10 inc�. I.ocation af P�,operty: I.e�al De�tPtion �' Properiy: S�e: Topography: E�ng Vege�n: �mg Zoaing/Platdn� Ava�7ab7ity of Mwucipal IIh7ities: 7868 � Way I.ot 6, Block 4, Pearson's Craigway F,�ates 22,OQ0 square f+ee� Slop� from ea� to we� toward the rive,r Typic�l �; tree.s, sod, s�u�, etc. R 1, Si�e Fam�y;- Pesrson's Craigway E�s 1959 . ����:� �� Vehicular Ac�cess: Aldea Way F�an Acce�: N/A Engine�eg is�ues: N/A Site Pl�tnning � n VAR #96-01 7�8 Alde� �Vay N.E. Ps�e 3 �� � � • � i�. �''1 s�cion Zos.o�.o�.D.�a�.(b) of the Fridley City Cade re�ires tl� a cieck tmt e�d n�are than 3 feet into any ��� ' .► . ' i e s� - � � �� � �t � �e �� a����3f1 � ii • ���- �,� ; v- ra � cat ��� �� �+e �►t� • c�� r .1�c ��� '�� �' i �) 11 - A : - 1 :� �:?1 i = :.'•) 1 ' !!II .� • 1 • ,1�' : Mv:�l • li' �:! :! 1 •7 �311��3 � �il M � :II!1 • IL:A I1 ;1 i • 1 �31 °,Ir: v' li Jc' �i t:iiil : f=3 ! 1:0�� 1�� t�l � �C ��IOIIE�Y t�}I1C.St8 � 8 V811811C8 �� t0 BgO�V Pl t��C �llq'O�L'�ICIl� ItI�U 'L� ffiC� ��O � ffi�8� fiom 3 fee� to 4 feet 10 i�, ff�ea�ted, tt� request w�l allow r�truc,�ti� of a deck loca� on top of an und�d storage fa�y/tornado sh�er. ,, �-� ���!z! •�� :,��, �� � � Tl�: � parc� is lncsted � tl�e northwe� comer of t� inte�secEion of Bellaire and Ald� Ways. Loc�ated on the �.i� P�� is a s�ngle ia�r dw�lin� umt const�uc:led in 1964. Tl� dwellin� mea�res 38 fe� by 46.5 feet and �ncludes an � g�rage �rin� 24 fe� by 22 feet. In 1966, a 7.5 foot by 10.5 foot unde�rowid �orage �y was �ed. T!� �e �ity is loc�ted at t1�e northwest corner of the dwellin�, is �t �tucaua�Y part of c� �or�d bY tt�e c�i�i dw�llin� u�. Tlus ac�sory �u�ture c�ot be a�cessed directly from the dwellin� �ut. Tl�e p� iu�ca�ed t�ai t1�is �a�e � also ct�bles as a torr�do s�edter. 'The �ora�e ffi�itY ��Y ��d had a decic loc�ed on top of it. Tl� petitioner is in the process of con�n� a 6 foot by 25 foot pacl� additi� to the rear of tl�e d� umt. As part of this const�uction, the petitioner is proposing to reconstruc� the deck loc�ted on top � the s�ora�e fac;�ity. ;:��� T�re petitio� has the alte�native of con�uctin� the deck in such a way tl�t it meets the three foot encaoac� irrto tl� sid� yand setbacl� o� foot of the roof of t�e �e �ea wo�ld be beryronri the deek. T� p�itia� �es ��e tt�e c�ion of n� c�n�u� the proposed deck as tt� gn� cl�an� fr� tlffi top of th� �ora�e b�ing to the na�ual g+�d is � t� 18 � e�ema�y alon� tt� we� a�d south � of ti� �o�age l�ding. Tbe deck provides the safeiy � for the re�de�s of the dwelling. Red�u� the width of the deck would nat adve�Y � the acce�s from the three �d o�l� season porch addition. Howev�r, the reduction of t1�e deck width is � p�l be�se of th,e pr�e�ce of tl� storage faalit�► bdow. Loc�ted on tl� adjaceni property to the �th � a��Y dvvellin� with a�ac foat tall privacy � in tl� rear yard. The inc�se in eaicroachmem by t�e p�oa�'s dedc 1� no adv�se � on tl� propaty to t� north The request is wittrin Pre�'iouslY �ted reque�s. � VAR #9b-01 78E� Alden Way N.E. Pa�e 4 �Y• Ilil�i'dl �.:lA �'1 � i�S � I�QtI� 1S �V1�1D �1tEV10U�j1 � V8i18II� ��183 IIO fBCOIDiri�OII fC�f(�1$ �1C �11CSt. �ST: � �ST: NORTH: Comprehee�ive Plannin� �SSees: Pabli� Hearing Cvmmeeb: i � `� �: P, Public Zo�g: R 1, S�gle Famt�y Dwelling Zomng: R 1, Si�le �a�nily Dwellin� Zoaing: R 1, Si�le Family Dwellin� I.el� U3�: Pei1C Land Use: Re�dential Land Use: Residential I�nd Use: Res�d�tial N VAR #96-01 7868 Alden Way ,� • • I , ,. �� �, . q ' � ` ^ �� \. . /. .= f � , �,���. ' n •/ , . ��°� �-- �=. � . �,a: on,,�' �; � . � G✓ � _ . .//1 . ��. � • �. ' � • •` '� � _ n ��' � '� � ,��. 0 �� ' � - � •� � O� �� . `o . � , ' � . \ � � �� � � � � , �.� � � � X�� � � � : � � F � s�� . . . . ,�� ��, � '�d � `'� � � . , ' � \ �O� � :'� � . �0► �'` ��". . � . , �---- . ' � . � . , �p0 � `� . .� � �. � ' � " . - � ' ' � . G . ' I ; l ' � • '' I ' I . . � . . � . , U .. ,z r�-� , �O � , w r / Z. � _ � • ✓ � � � � � � � <t , U , J',1 yW ' L � . � � i �, 1 • � � . �Lu � 1 � � U � . � � .� � �' O ,: U ; i ' i ' , ;i '.. r � , � ., , ,� �� �1 ��� Z�_ � 4 . ��, N O @ � � �� � � � �__„ _,� � .� ` . �s�� � . }:° � . W . . `� �:� s � � .� ��.. ,�:. i . � n ; � . � :d,. , , � . . , � . iii ii�'� � H � � � �'! �r . ; :. �����,�� _� , :��� , /��,,y , . ' U11L'IJ . . � , p ��y , ..' I � ,� � �. pp�LIYC�ry . ,. i _'. ,. i o� � � . , 4K- . . � � ~ � . L-�-4, ' � . �t 1 `; .(��, i�� � � �� ' � ��� ,i� . i' W. . .�� � r�P v � ri � �,' . �i :� � �� � �y�( :r' = F ��r �j � � � � � W . LL �i� �"' ., � ,'�V N�3 r{' I I.r, .,�'Z��O ' �� .. � 2i . .'!. - F- t i � � ., . �• , , ' � 1 � {L � � ' : �„ n�', w 4 ��r4�Q��a 'r �' • � , � . F ,a 4r���� , w , Tpx� ;Fwf„ t 'i �� , , ].1 ' O�i {,:�I+�j,�Q .� ' I • � , IC � .�tnl: �f �� �� � . \7 ,� � � . .i �� � �i{ �mO:���, s4 i •ie �� . I ��, j, � i' �,�, r . ' ; . I . , . f i ! �' , .. ;: � �, i � � ; i; � , , . �' ., , , � , , ' � • �: , ' ' � � ' � ' ' � , , , • .I � , i ,, . . . � ; ,. i. . , , � . , `�' ' . ' O '0 . , . � . . — , , . , . . � . ;, �_ . . . . �� � ��� � , � " � � � � '�,i,W�� � :«� ' : � � Q � � , , � , �.—�� � � � � ��� ----, � � � . � __ _, � �. -, Z , ^J � � � -- "'1 N 'ei' -_ --� Q ..-. �� — ---� 7 I y w tu 1 ui � 6 � � � � � �� � � o � o a ,�ry w 0 w u~i p � �- cn r (La 3N V �� 7_ '" � 7 L � � �j � }. � '� 10 11_. I �� __ zl o '� gi �� � !� L � L N � � � 0 � O�� � x `"�� Or ��� �� �'�° ��S . . � ,� , �. ., � , �r. �v. u J W � �-m 0 w � u� �C � � � U i "i ' , . � � .��� � �� �'� - . � , �, .a ' . � , r �. ;. � f �, h . '�.. t � . . �=� � r��1-t, � 3 � '�' r .K _ :' a a ~ �� � � �'iw c� � V 'r ,� ro � 4 n� - X 5 � _ �wa r � r M � � Y ,+� x J � ` ,� � � + i 2"y_. t i � I ; � e ' 1; i o ° � „� , ; i. � 3 �,'� s { � � �` �:. �r'i�'�a E}',^` ��.- a�. i ka r7a i� �"+ �'r��k ° a� � t'.� h, t'���Jt.� s � a� d&y A =_ .� y t� '� .'�s � - �.'i o � � ar� �' �' x - t ; � � t ;_ �.,+3�rs'_ "' �..� � �; Y r t d � tV •. � � �`.i.f �� k�.'F.f.-� �a -y + �b is�� ��4N �` a„ ��A�t-�T+S � .� � E. L x"S' � 4" � � .'+?,� ri �s� r � �,n; 'f j a ,� �`�-� ,, K �� �,� �'� s:x�r ?� � , r [�y� �a "� 3 � s, 'i ��� �+ �i �t�s � �= �t �, � � �' �'�rS�� : `,��a r°` . 'M-�>,u u •� 5> ; r at, ,s ,, -.�e �... � .r . �s r}, � �� s'�v"`,� �., c �u i�+ l s��� T� > ? �cu.� � . . `, �� .� . � �.p . �A ,� �l � .�st w ;��v .� � � l'..' �e eu ''§ 'r' �'J� i �, �J �l. Src u � +.'�-p ^� . . .r �l�,-� � �� t� ay �. , ,as .+t" r �: x '�° u,$r w, .. c�14 y} ��rz '� t ar i �(�� t � � ri �54�'i;�" ..:s �' � J r��,t s; . 1`_ 'r �'- i d' %� . ��ra = .dE v �:., Y � d. <� � n az.r . �.. ?-a 4�� � � ' �:"��, tF�"xi � — gH�,( `•� - �f� - �" 'R �: Y{� �. s i °�y`�'t^.� v�fa�'e���-`� ",;,,°��" >$ �� � �+�� *'��a' � � _ � r'��s`_ � - �;'��;-� � � , — - — ..,. � � ..�° _ r _ . �^-. �g:.. . s` ' :., - - _ � _"Q � , ,,., . W , 1..}., � ._ ' : - . K. ._ , . � .: � .:, � _ � , _: �a_ ° " .�� . � . fi, _�� - ' - _ ., i '�:. . _ _ - . .� � .. . • ... _ . . q`Y - � . " ' 1. � �� � . .. � . . . �� k ` � ' � + � .. �- s z��� �� .. � r�*.. �� r i .a d r-r o. _ a+a �a r ' � � � '�! $ { �� � .� a � '�` `�"' {ev 3 "� . � r y -s . , . �� �.�.+ er 3 �. � ' � ;i< J ,.' .: 4H� F '. . , - , Q .� � . � , y: ..,�. `�� '. � „ t� .._ k �?_. � .. ���F �,� a .%r '.�°' '� .. �.K'� � . . .. - ! ' �+ � H l � �� .���- . . U . . � � . . - .. . i .. . .. . . _ � . �� . w � �� . ., �. . � � . . O � y� - .. . . � _. � X �-a�� ° � . � �, " �� {� '. M.: i i �_ YeS•. R l : \i� . ���� � • R� , '� " L � � � " F. � � � : -iF ~ + 1 .. �' 1 ) j+.s • � 2 6 • � , ` • V� . . - , .. . � � . � � � 3 a d � :- � � � . . � � .. . '- . a � . � �; . , � ���, t ; � F` �a � � .• S $ e' "� , $ <` ^' � d�,iyy 4 V Ss� - ,�°4a� :.i r �, �q T t � � ."� t .,: � . .�+ {`y : 3al ''�i $ �.�x` �� ���t `, .ir<�' � ;�d��q'Y�'�3��..,.� �y�.�"�zi.l� �- � .'yr �5� `�`�$�"' 9:, z.x,m�li,�,,; �,F' :t,L,�"�`'t�;`��°3W��S�T'+�s���� t`At t4u /' c" •��s � '�t'�-�"�. i. P ;s,i�.�'4tr.�;�: A._ ...r'4r &: � . +rYr h.-'.'�, r 'r�r:,;,,,•� �i�i+�%-qa �, � �"y'�a PJ'S+� 3+':^k3'i^<�.�,,,'��+..a�; r�n �.r� t `� � Y.��. �',�(� ':��r� � �a� s�i�� �.a ��;..�� ''..,�� ±�§ o.,�� � s�.?,�t ��m_ u r..�a� fi� c'�v.�� t� ,4���a"� , �.^ ,� `-��;.�v � ��.�:* �x -x� d�.`�3��;,� wr a���^'� � �g� ,�{�a �" '` a.��ro; ?� r ��,: `ri„F�.`y?�.. �� .a �� �� .�, �t t a �' �`�, {a F� k�'t5 � ..y' pY�' � 5���t �. � &1 ., �' 7� -. �.,Y' .�q, :r��5 .N�'°, .n.�,xs�'s �� .�+s;r:. . , �:.�. ,u r .{3 aT �,J..:fti.� ti .t�- .j`x' a ;�' �' ,'�,�� € .� �� ��lqv 3Ty,�t'*7� . i , , . r a�.� , � �. �> .,-, y> .:� j� x2�.�, _ � . 4 a irr'.�t�s y ��t�� ;r �,�,�$ �°`�z�F� � �'$� '��A � :�..1_„+� i�gk , .� 3�:; x �i � �? � �d, .� as'�y+ #3. ':'"r�'�. .t � j� E� � `� �`r tr �] ��+t� an �t�ka �,�T'� �� s.� ry. t?` � E Y,�., �+ i �` r�- s na,k�' r:" 7'�,A. g� f `x' ,�.re... � _ � e 1 . '�# .^�?'RC �� ; r ° � " � e.� ,._. , �. .. w _ �. _ . . ,, � ' 3 ' . �: � `. .. - . - � . - .. _ ii _ . 7 . . � _e , .. � . .. . . . • . _. . . � �_ . _i r ' a 0_�. � Q ,� � ,1 f'� � ,I.,<!, � . , _ . r ..0 �,� .'7 aA �'Z '��,� r� � � � PITBL�IC HEARING BEFORE THE APPEALS CONIlVIISSIQN t"��, ATotice is �eby given t�at the Appeals Cammission of the City of Fridley will conduct a Public Hearin� a� the Fruiley Manicigal Ce�er at 6431 U�uversity Aven�e N.E. on W�nesd�y, daa�ary 24, 1�6, �t 7:30 p.m. for th+� purpose of Consideration of va�iance requ�st, VAR #96-01, by John and Li�ian Meyer: Per Section 2Q5.04.�.A(3) ofthe Fridley Zo�in� Caie, to increase the encroachment of a deck in the side yard &om 3£�t to 4 fe.�t 10 inches to al�ow the r�o�truatioai of an e�xis�ing deck on Lot 6, Block 4, �earsaon's Craig�►ay Estates, the same being 7�Cs8 Alden Way N.�., Fridley, MN 55432 Any a� all �rsons des�ring to be heard s�all be given t� oppom�nity at the above stated time aa�d place. DIAN� SAVAGE CHA�RPEItSOAT APPEALS CONIlVIISSION A�►Y 9ue,�ions related to t�s item may be referred to the Fridley Community Developa�ent D�partme�, 572-3592. ��B �P�� P�'�� Pl�� to atte�d who need aa i�erpreter or other persons wixh disabilitiea who req�ire au�ciliar�► aids s�ould cont�ct Robesta Col�ns at 572-3500 no later than January 17, 1995. d d � �,� y� ��1 _.-' f"���` ir '�: I, `t�r`��:�==�. yr�'��-�'�,��'_ ���i���1i����������l��llli sx av4'67 B9 0 (� : �' :-� . •°- � . � , � ;;' . , •.: ,. . v � , ' v� � 4 �` . . ° ;; „ p . .: _ �� � � ,-� ,. .. a �- ,:, K� „� ; :� - A � '� 6 � P 9 � b i �� " " � �Z '°' � � � L��eF �i�!''!��"` ti/ ' � J/O'a < � ' a ,.� • _ r ,W .. . _. , a . .. . . � . ,. .. , . . , •• .. .. „ o „ � '�� • . h .�M.: � - . .. � : � - s, �_�f 'R" Q ' A � ■ �V !1 [?. 7 ,.4 p e � �9 ' P 9 ' _ . �l ` (� ) �° a ° ' - , , - :,� � . � . `. .s � : -. _ / ' "` • : �� ` ` ►�1 • (i , . .�.. . � , ; :�, b .. � s o o � , '� ,+ * _ �. fe � : :� �. ; , � � - " ' 3 8 � 7 6 .. : ; ,�- , Y r , � � • !11 � � � � ��� � � . . r � �� �p..:4 4 '. s . � . � � . � Y.� �, s, � ` �= • � � O ' � � 0 / z • ' .. .. � o D � r' 6 � '� 46.6 �89i ' i c.°: � a I.* 4' �' vt �1 , r ` � • � .. .� ti � // /� .! i 8 �D) a - • �� 7 f • � � M ;• ' 0 8 � Q. • r p „, � �e . . A „ 1 • •• ., 7 t � 3 ; � // 3 .s, .. _ � a n' M h.i0 rl d0 �I it 9/ - � L �' tl / ���' . . � � - � � � � /Q 0 � ��� .gf'-"` �:_ ,�..p, ntsi - _-- "' .... . ..... � " 90 ' . � ass� � . .._ , .. � ,.r�� � ��,-� -_._�--c�r_Fi.d�1s �1s` �'�*� �ax�a�[ , P- �� �\�'�••26478: �� � ' �J , - � / � r'�/i (f� L iy RT-.. •• , �� � �� � � �t . � �� � ,,�I�'f O� . z . ( /'z 7< < � � `5� e /'� � :� � � � �� : � �� - �f" • � � A */ : . � � �,o L f� .. t L��. % , � � 9p l�'% l �ti Z ♦ , . � 0 : . y: � } ��� "a °' -� � �j ��QD/i� $ �� � _- __ �; .� P .t� � '� � . � � ° , t '� 9 �t � 3�" -_ !� '�, O� r��,6 �iy is, ,� p ,, \ , ! � 1 � "�� "$ `, h _ t � . Q . ��6. � � � � , � � ,� � r � '�'F � � � � �' ���! ;, , � , �(y y Q i �. �` � P� . , �'�, � �).° � � ��� '� . .�,� � � ! . .� . S, � b� �', � '��� � - - � � �i� / � �� � �y) `s � `� � + ,; Y�'� 4 � P _ , �j � ..r-�� a ; i . � b r, i J ��� _s�' 1 . y . �, _; �� (�% �/I� `6 �1 p�i � d B ,, �6 � � � , �� �s� tf'�'� i � �' •• u ..�`'�, � v;�s�a \, �� �y � P': � G�� " �, . 9 , � : �i*i y"b'- ° � y� �.. t � � "� �y,�OF !!�)� ��� ' %y � $ �"� � f� �� + i � � :, " - �� •� � /}� � ' H � `' • � �' ' '� ,�jp� /A, � �� //�� N8� 9b �� $ �,�� e . � . �+ ` , i /,H�' �.�, y '� '1� l �1 [ � �c :, ` i� 'J� �, C � li� t � � I , � ' : � � � s .;�� ,• � (�) Z �'1� ��, �'�� ;,�r , �, . � _ �, -� , . � � �' � .-e..� '�6� ,,�' � 9 �;�. � S ' ('k) , '' � �(f�I� � +" � "(�,� � �....� � e. �f• �(i �' � i � � d . � t/ "�� q C��� � .� C� 'qI� , - = . � � �Z� ~' --��' ` � �� �O �. �. `'� � 4 -� � � � �� ��� �'' �' '� � ,,�' � �i+s � .� �. �: �'� y �w� .�$ � �'�� �,' �n�r� / MJ �� �W� � ' �� 6 8 p!� /�,� � s,i � �,•, `. I _ (.. 6 •S% (�y1 � �`a�° a � � �+ �V� L� � ���b �� ��� O� �V� � � � � � � �� ; . �, ' tit� ��,� p .� ¢,. C��� �, � ��� C . , �� } � -. . ` $ � � �l,C�, �{ tw � k C�, . `I� ``�Y� �a (4�) ° -� �51�� �ti' � � Q' ,�� � ..� �� �$� �� ��. �(�, / � . `� � $ � �� ,y.�` r' ����• f `����� �`� . �+ � •.i �p . fi ` . \� l�� . S //4 CORNER �w� • � �� �� ��\� ; �, SEC. 3 . �� /�. _\ � . ��* �—� VAR #96-01 � rCity Manager 7868 Alden Way N.E. Fridley, MN 55432 7ohn & Lillian Meyer 7868 Alden Way N.E. Fridley, MN 55432 James & Debra Holtzlider or Current Reside� 351 Bellaire Way N.E. Fridley, MN 55432 James & Elizabeth Sydow or Current Residern 7863 Alden Way N.E. Fridley, MN 55432 Thomas Truax or Current Resident 7891 Alden Way N.E. Fridley, MN 55432 Mohammed & Yasmin Khan or Current Residem 7892 Alden Way N.E. Fridley, MN 55432 Cteven & Julie Zimmer or wrent Resident ��74 Alden Way N.E. j 'dley, MN 55432 pnald & Janet Crego or i�rrent Resident I 54 Alden Way N.E. i 'dley, MN 55432 Diane Savage 567 Rice Creek Terrace N.E. Fridley, MN 55432 City Properties, Inc. �,��.�u�.uL 4428 7osephine Lane North Robbinsdale, MN 55422 Allan & Delores Schoonover or Current Resident 361 Bellaire Way N.E. Fridley, N!N 55432 Ronald & Beverly Erickson or Currem Resident 7877 Alden Way N.E. Fridley, MN 55432 Gary & Kathleen Kinser or Current Resident 7899 Alden Way N.E. Fridley, MN 55432 don & Teresa Headley or Current Resident 7886 Alden Way N.E. Fridley, MN 55432 Ronald & Amy Losey or Current Resident 7866 Alden Way N.E. Fridley, MN 55432 IlVIV Imernational Corporation 6870 Shin�le Creek Parkway Br�klyn Center, MN 55430 City Council Cwrent Residern 341 Pearson Way N.E. Fridley, MN 55432 Richard and Katlileen Kemper 7857 Alden Way N.E. Fridley, NIN 55432 Sholeh Chatraei or Current Resident 7883 Alden Way AT.E. Fridley, MN 55432 Richard Keller or Current Resident 7898 Alden Way N.E. Fridley, MN 55432 Stephen & Myra Hrenchyshyn or Cwrent Resident 7880 Alden Way N.E. Fridley, MN 55432 Nck and Mary Klaers or Current Resident 7860 Alden Way N.E. Fridley, MN 55432 Current Resident 7646 Alden Way N.E. Fridley, MN 55432 �:_`� 1 1 � CITY OF FRIDLEY 6431 UIVIVERSITY AVENUE N.E. FRIDLEY, MN 55432 (612) 571-3450 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT VARIANCE APPLICATION FORM PROPERT INFORMATION - site plan required for submittal; see attached Address: '�8� � �} f cPe,•1 I��. � ,, �l� Property Identification Number Lega1 description: I^ S o r�'s I 1r O �ra 30• a�t 3� oo � t oo s/�5 l 5 Lot Lo Block � Tract/Addition - - - Current zoning: fPes E �i�,� �; a/ Square footage/acreage o�o�, �� Sg ,� Reason for variance and hardship: � ;�, y�.Q� �� ��, �'L'"`-� °� Sec4ion of City Code: Have �you operated a business in a ciry which required a lwsiness license? Yes No � If yes, which city? _- _ � If yes, what type of business? �� �_ �-� Was that license ever denied ar revoked? Yes No - �'EE OWNFR T�vF_ RMATTnN (a$ ;t appeaxs on the property title) (Contract Purchasers: Fee Owners must sign this form prior to processing) NAiVIE ADDRESS DAYTIlVIE PHONE S�GNATURE DATE PETIT ONER INF(�RM,�T�ON NAME � o h n w- 1-.. , t�► a n 1� e. ti/ e'- ADDRESS 7�6� /�Cc��r� Gf%a yV E' DAYTIlI�IE PHONE_ �% -.5'3 � SIGNA ,�:�?��,r� ATE� �� %S—._ Fee: $1�.00� $ G Permit VAR # �/'/� - C> 1 APPlic�tion received by. Scheduled Appeals Commission d Scheduled Ciry Council date: _ � � for residential proper�ies Receipt # � '�- � � �s� �. �q � UH� W�O (Y Z U _ � H � - H�-+Oz U d +� �.� �I m �� � a � - H �- � � � � �� � �W . .� ' � _ H U � H W UQ O d? - _ , � d _ _ -- - - m _ _. .; _ _ _ _ - _ � � _ � � N � � v � - H @ � � rl � _ - - � H a�O� � _ w _ _ RC U Q O . V � - i, � l i° ` I ( z �• H 3 � - c�t H aw �'!a '� - . � ca r � r''� �`1 � D� CITY OF FRIDLEY COMMI88ION APPLICATION REVIEW File Number File Date Meetinq Date O1 12-29-95 1-24-96 File Descriptions VAR 4�96-01 by John & Lilliam Meyer, 7868 Alden Way N.E. Complete Review Cheakliat; Return to The Community Development Department *** Commehts *** Barbara Dacy Scott Hickok Michele McPherson Jon Wilczek John Flora Ron Julkowski Leon Madsen Dave Sallman Dick Larson � � I'� "\ �� . ��' APPUCATION REVIEW CHECKLIST FlLE: �!m -D •. ...s� . • . �,�. . : <r.. ,£w. .;a. .. . .i.? , , ..xx •E • : , • - ;• ,;{, • • .� . , .. } : : . . � . ,. : :� • . , • : '' ;: Y. . :ti .' .: :'..:'w'i\ S '`....; t , �' �.. ''•B•.. : �5 . ¢� d4' -..: . ..:. • . .,. . .^•.;.. ... . + ' : ' � . Y` .. • ..• •� • ,:: APPLICATIOPI � � ��1� RECEIVED ,iu�'t� � DEVELOPMENT � � g711Q��- Q.✓✓Q��-�'� _ � J�7DJ REVIEW COMM / � � (� r.i/1��-� ��� F�� � i8 09�� �� � � vs' �`d,.� ReviEw� l�lAO= a.�-���-f' 7 S'� /D.'�'' .e ��1 * uwo usE ✓ !�Z[�• 2�,,,��f- �9�'u �.S` FILES� . ZD ` x 22�C��� P�moN�t C�LLED SITE VISIT/MEETINO AERIAL //�y PHO�ro NUnE ✓ MAP9 DONE i/ / �� REPaRT WRI7TEN - �, � (l O Z � %U � Ci -� �rn a � � u� � A z m r Cl , U � � O • � �� 3 Z / ! rn � �. O � Z (l �'' . \ �r �� ,�//�, o '! - �°8 � �. � �.�" � /., . .� . ,� ' "_.�.`--°_°.� _, � \ 2 ���',�, . , ;r ,�' � - � °� x �^+ 3; '��.6 \ d.t(r � t�, \( / ,, / � � 0��� \\ _� �jp ;� �� � �� �� _ .r � v '�, d �� \ � a���1 � � N � • J p iC lj� � � ly' j , � � m � � � -n � z < � � C) A r- m O � r-(� �� z a O � z r � � � � 0 � � � � � W � -� ..�. � � � Z � Z � W � � rn � N -{ � �= Z na O D� W CA tWv -�-1 /� �A .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. ' .. . .. � 000N���o���`o �-- a, rn �1 A ' m�mr"���r�t rn0� � m� D�1 -0 �tl il � 3 3 ,�� � zcl��p �m � , � � Z � m � rn z � � � i � � ;� 3 u � �''�► N , �� � r" � � � ; :, • E N, o z . r". „ (1 �,' � �- m � D D m tzit U� r�m � N � �Np�l7 r XX-�i � cn b` p O -�-8 � � n „r m � —� L O �►' cp fl N � �� O � � zN �Q p N AX X.�rn� l�� � r m � n.� m --i z,�, a� �,l� i -'( m m m n� D� � A�� m-+ m��� -(J �� m c» D� -p w =+ a � C7 � Cl �. D m !?t � � $ O � A 7�C 0 m � � m �� - D � � D � b70 rrt cn Cl n d .. � �c+ _ � `� � �p ' � �_ �. °' � N m A 0� -� _ �; m t i � mc1 � � � t i - -- -- ------------ � 7� C7 a'- A i i i � i .�* Z o � 0: c� N i i �+ � i � i 0 m J z 7(1 = i � �.. D _ � � � - r , - 1'71 ' � � � i � 0 �� � � � t �� � i 0� � i n�, i i �� ]�. m �, � � N -t z U 0 i i �' - i i � • N ( 10'-9 3/4" FIELD vERIFY 6'-0" 3'-9 3/4" /2'-0" , 4'-0" FIELp vERIFY , �, , � � �, _� � � � � _ � �� �� II � j} 1i\� --� U Z - �— u� � � • � ������ ������ rp m X 6� WXz � O � m�7ll �. W o�8 � � . � ��� � �. j '. � �n� . �� _ ' _. ,: „ � � � . _, D -� Z � m *� .,, r � Q � �+ �N 6� � G� 0 �— D 3 M � 0 � � rr� �y �� I~W ' 0 0 W �� �. � �p1 � � �Q O NO E" � �'� -Ni � -D O b� Xg mca � ' 4r � � _ _ ' � N . �t � X . 0� 0 � (1 O � N 0 � a? o • . n 0 N� '� < �+ 1l! � � �n 16'-0" 20'-0" /j • /j �� 4'-�"f in �1 3 i� �p ��+ � CP rtl li --( - °i � � � --IN�m Z �m�z 3(�1��E O m�l�n . rnm O�« � Is-�17 � N z �" c�r ,. ,,. � .,,.,. :.. ,. ,.:... ,,., .�:�� ,i, , „ ,:' , �� � J. N � . , . � • . W i � �' � � . , „ . . . � , , o d� �rn �, u,' � W • ;' :. �I :. O :. C7 p rD, , Cl -p.a.DO�-zn D��' �j�m z Q'� zr r'D�p? �j X (�IAID� � � m m-"-+r�' � �N;w� � cs' ' tn� n��(1Clrn ]-*� Nws• v E ���rn�c� � XXXZ' cn � �D-�x-, �� �j r "i+ m �r z�--� � 14B0O m � ��� � Dz t� V` V' .� �'�`zn� N�D (1 �, �Oprn- � � �� brn(p--�� �r ���Cl � r A� x� p< t�1�Dw� m. p �r D f�ir � �'Zi � � d m ttt c� r m�n - �_ �� ��rn07I1�� �z �1>�m m p gC� = d�dcn (1 D m E � � � -( O m Dm nD � G� D �C) �m mr C7�p xl z �► � �, r m -�( D mcn �X pm�� �nr�'-� �X N r�Z -' p � C1rD�r' ��, u'DQ-r' O �g 7mtiv7mp� �� n {.� -tt m O � 7� �l Z �!�m m �c .. z O cn Fir � p �' A r- � �� � m O � tDi� Z� �<� �'G� � rnG� G�5 d E �' �cl rlr ^'� Y' X-=i T rn E rn 7U � '� C <<� al m n r, U�� n � ..{ N b' r -C � N I Z N � � � o. . � m � $ U � I s � -�-w I� � D _ � � Z � �rTl � n n� � rn� � � � o �� z 0� Z m � O D � Z n • �'� �� i �� �i � -� � � I �� I, � � -�- � � i p � � � , 4 N � , ,� E w s� a X �} �- � 0n �d 10'-9 3/4" V Y � 6'-0" 3'-9 3/4" , 2'-0" 4'-0" LD vERIF D D 70 XI � � r�== � � O � . ��1 ����i� � 1i �� P`) N �_' �_ '�o 0 0 0� N� � �� n D � �1 � � � rn � � � I r � � I \ � � � I DN QU x �m�z \ rN �N I'riUm I m� �<�'° ���� m Os m� �pxN �� �� �� �� �� �� u'rn i r�g / 7U � � /,�! N I L � � � x � � .��.CPtA� � mJ?'��' zz-�� � �-a«m z���� {�� �m�r �' � ���Z ,� AO N �m,,��� ���� �f�-o`-rn �� � IR � g � �o�� I � � � m���v �' vc�n� r I �fT1��� m � -��'3= , amOD � � �� , 0 p � , � D�. , � � :, � � � , � � e --� ' . , , ' i i D' � � r � � ' ��i � ' '� i;;' ''. f"' .:';' . :a. i �.. i�,� �... . .� . ..i � . ., ,, . . , i' : . . . ' ." � ',,_...� � � j'� � � �.i,.. , , i '�' .� ; . , � � ,i; .� 14'-0��.� r , �'.0" 4'-0° � p, i � ' 6'-0n � � m � ' 20�-(du` ' � � �* , � , �, , A � ��, , ' ' • ,� � ' . n, , � I �' , I .A. 0 N\ � o� �b I� � --�t z � �rn Q r � �-9-p � � •• m �' �� � , � e �. t ��� � ��' �, � . \� 0 Z � � 7[J c C� � rn U � � Z m � n � � � �}% N N � C�T m u -1 r r �A � A1 O �°' d o m --t � m i `� � � c> �— -- '�' N �^ -- � � � �--- -- v, —p r— -- L---- � � rn { � � — --� � �� _� i , '� . � � ., � � � , � � -�' , 4 � � q + .ly � D C;! Cl � Nrng ��c� � °°'D 0 ��fif °��° Xrn �mcn � cnE OXp. cnm D='z � � �p ��� �. � 3� = o. O rn � � �m XDb � n �� Nmz � �' 40 d u � i � � � n Xm � E 'A' C� N ��►1 �N m ��Di) � in m _ � I � n � r---, ! � . g o I � r �$ ,X R � � � °a_ n' � x , .-� C � � ' -< � � O� X � O �� i' m � vd �r � � z ni (. �� � � �, , . ' ; , � , , , I m } �� x o� . � -��N ,"N� � , �' � -i Q ` fq � 3��' !�� , � .X . � a. ..� � ! � � N , m : =D3'', �1p' 3c� � • � r � �v -n � Z j �`Nr�n i:� 70 pr �jj � � � .� � �. �. ' � ',�' � � ;' •��r!; � �� Z � � � � � � � �� ,��j O ftl (1 �y w � , It� C�� i � ' � .r . 7I1 U Q. � � �„�' � � ���m N—il � _ l � E � � i mTrn • � iiiiiiii � N . iii ii� n � �� u ,�r � mm�� rn g-�p � � � $ � � v omt� , �� � �' � �-�p�� _ —q � ��pN � � Dmc�i� . � ' �1 � � ' � n O z � � • � itl c n � rn O � �. Z rn t- � n � � � O � O � � m -o � m � r (1 N , , �O � m D �X m . � r 3n m O' O-' � 3-' rn C7 3 � �' ��,, � D � �i D � D m -i r st� � � -( ��i N N � �' C1 D � m ti A X 3'i N� '' -� �u' D ' `p � �- X� X 'c�n l� -t � X D � E � O � z- b N m tn z-�i�� �� �' ��E �z m � N �1 Z -" N z � � rn'��� D m =�c� rn c�i� ' m' o7n�. � � � � D � � g X � p -m+ m � �! � r `U m � g � 0� V� ,-N� �rii � � rU G� (11 �� cp Cn -( D � � .�,, � � 3 �' ^�-- � N `�=' 3 D rn � U UJ z ` Cl CJ Cl ��1 � -n � � -n tn � -zi -��' � ° _ � -�-� z m -zs D d 7� N r O G� ;, � c`d O rn ii�i x m� Z rn� c ok� � � rc- �'"-d z d O �� dm� O � �-' O � ]� � m b O �� � m { � p m.A �-( A � � cn �1 � ;E� � �, rnG 1, � D �,iC r-�7�C D O � � � � �,D� 7U � O� O � � �� u �� � � � � m � � � p p� -n � 7U � tU ��, D � � � U3 ;' cmi� crnt' '� � � � � 00 � 7�U -��icrt� zmm � � � O -zi � � O �� �m � m�Z �m � D Oz � � �m � rn clN� � � � . D � n � � ' � X � D b � � -Ip. m � . � � , d I N � i ' , , . � �; i � � ; � �. � � i n � , , OY °' _ � • ' � � I , . , � ,. � i ., : � � ' . , � � .. . �. •i. —� Cl O Z N --i � � n � � � CI1 -� -U D z �� r- �l :� 1= -n --e O �� 3 z z � � --� �� L � � , , Z 0 � . N � � rn �C � � � � � � I� '�� � � —� � � � � czi� X `�' ?�D D� pDNN �z � m� �3"ilz = = 4`G� D� X C7 cl 7� r z r-m- �= O L �ii -e -��- n' n O-� �m, m �i tl rn � 3 m ,Z1 L � m -�n'�17tf � �ii E D -�� � -i � O C3 U � m � rJ � E_' {� OJ m ]U � r' 0 7C 7C -, O � 7►J 3 �prj m00 z0 --�( D X --� --� cn -� � � � L= � � .`��C � � D m D �' � � rn�z � � N (�l e. -�p � �' 3 �il � �_ � O� r , � � N ' . ' � � � � (1,� � � --1 I -i o� z � O z _� N ..N� ,"r'( �� m mu Z Z �, m m rn� C1 --� -' O O z � I i 3 � • � ` D ' � , --� � � . , � rn = z m j � . D' X;� N � . � --I 0 � , v ' , � N � � 1'�ft ILTI 1 � , . 4� �,' � D . n E , , ; O = � � o �� � rn � � n � � , � � � � � �; --�'' , z �. , � ° �— � o� � J.� � � � � .V N �I r � . �� � �' � � N x � m O i�' ` , � .�. � p� — 3 � m�, '�` cn � � r 3 r�- .�. I , �, � � -iy � 7� � �"! (1 � '� 7C m v � ' � . � p `" ' rr, m. 'T� � --� D.m -� m , 11 '. i � N; N�'. D v�' 3' �� � � � � r ; --� . . A� ; '����o' g� � 0' � � � � � II ' � �,•n � z ��� � � � � ' O , � � I O z cn � �l � Cl � I�tl � � -t � Z Citi t�' /i1 � �, � , ' . �3 , � Z i m , � , 3 �y � ' ti �? { � � n� � D D � �1 O � � � m �,-t ,.. � �I� ` a N , L.,_� � � ' , A � ', Z --� � n � ' � , � � � . � � i �, , � ^ , , 7� i , N ;� � � �� � � �� m � � � � � �- X ' Z � r .A. O � m � � � O� � � . Cl D� m n-- � � � �� � �k � -•��� u � ---� II �� x � o'� � � � �,o ' -�-��' rnm� u' �_ �,Dz � ZO �rl� m ..� ��G�. AN O3� � O N �3 D , o� oz3 R � � � , �lp �f�'i� � m w(� �:�jjr n x 0E N�-c ��—, ° o �; � °° . � C1 � r z � �i � -o m - v m — � �� � �i I 11� l Dm p X z X;�Az m� c`r+ �.� �'i0 � �O G -a � D D x -n � �--�j � 7U � � �1. A � 0� r � O�1 ��r `'' 7(1p l9 X Um �� �a N��x�°' � N�' �3 � , N � � O .� -i O � Y,, U� � p � � cn � � D ,r- � tl �' .4_ l7 C� O 0 � � . � • r D � � 4 � i ,n O z � ��'{ � -�i rn a � � Z C17 r /� � � � O � 3 z z � � O -� � z c> Z 0 � � O � Cl � m I N X � N , X n� � i N C7 � � �. z � � � x � � � �o rn � �3 C7 ,,, 0` O O �' rn � D � -N-� v 7C � m � O -fl -0 � O � r�' D A N �1 � r r r --� C7 o l � , , N X � Cl m � N -0 z � r m e� � O (1 N x � �X m .r�. p D m 70 � � � A r- � � � � jT9 = � W �a \� �) 0 X m X � � Q �, c\t+ .� � � � � X �. � 3 -� p` �O p Urn � D � C3 n m 7C -� O � � S �l1' E � �-- n O D �'} D D � � r r- --�'i � z (� ( �� �� o� �� ;�-�- rn� r U �+ � 7�0 ce I ""1 .� .. . � � . � . ,, _ ?� r. . , , � � (1 � � � � CP --s �7 I �- Cl -� , �� �J L1D -{ � � Z C�1 � C�l i(ti �S �06 --� UO 3 Z Z C� 0 --t A ( ,I � ' � II �� II ��<-:___-}__ ,,. - - II �I II � �� � ��� . ' -� �i �u—� � u � 3 � a� � �r -i t�i� �m� rn � x m _ �, mOt? Z U (l D (1 -+ �-n k = , � � � � `"-Ur rn � " Oxl� 9 m 1> tn (� � �J � � � � o 0 � o � � �; � Np-�A` N inW p7i cl � 0,iI �`� Y, O X tl� ,�, rn rn � r` ���, t_' N' 0 t�l ttT r � r" z � , r" . rErt � � � � mmmN�� �3 �� -� ��d z� � p3 Er � O'� p��X '�� O ��,X� O � O� m N�, . N m� 70 —$' � n —� bo �o �� �' o� �� � ' A�%' g�l m r. -n �' tri� ��� , N� dv, �v Qo rn � � `'U � � O Or � � � 3 �l , � Z � � _� � (l � <, 7 � , -I :� � il --I f�9 � (l.� --'C � �> L f �f t- tl �9 �'> -➢-s � O ' -ry 3 z z rw� cn O -a � z c� �,. --'-- —�m � — ----- �w .. � � � . � , � N � 3O N N � � ��� z m -� v �' � p� E � � ���� R .� � � ' �p�'mr �i cn ,« � --� � —i � O � � ��-�p � , C�'l --g r— m m N' ' � � D �' � rn � , . , ;, � � , �, �, -- �- --�-- _ - _ _ � � � � � � -� q I � � � �� �_ , , � N � -I z mG' —'� U U�1 rnN �� � �� �N r7-� � --i � 'N v ��� ,�o � � m m � z � � � � . t