AF-V - 34928�t �
!
�
2 � �
L✓ a ;�_
� �` � �I � �
� f
.i- �.. �r. . .
� i f-
,,r..� RECEIPT �
�
G� O NGGLL
� e� :
6431 University Ave. N. E.
Fridley, Minnesota 55432
Te I. 560-3450
��' �� �9�� No. 5970��
� nnraMma mc; sc ewi. �ueuagma
a � �°��. �� �'� �
R . .
g � - � . s� �v9
��J�. i�/, �1 ��
APFLICATYt3:'Y TO THE BOARD 0�+ AP3tEA�S AI+t� CTPY CGVITCIL �'-
F'OR SPECiA.L USE PE�ZT, VARYAtdC� IY3 REQUYRi;MEt�ii'S 0
CERTAY�I.ORDYFIANCE5 OF Ti3E CI�'Y OF P'liI17LEY
�Applie�nt to coa�lete lte�cs 1, 2� 3)
1. Nan� and Ac�dfmEe of An�licant
CHARLES E. JOHANSON IWC� �
— �Qn ti;a: h �vea��p N E. .�____._. - -
` � �ridley, Minnesota 55432
2. Legal Description of Property jalso �en�rsl locatic:t, sueh �rT"no�t�:-
eaat corner of !�'itFi Av�nuQ �nnd 5th 5treett0 qr 6ri15 �'ift� St�reet") �
� r
v�` % .� n � �� 5i ,� L� �/4 /G cv,� y� �S 1'.�i'�S � ti .b
2��— .s�
, 9. ��c�ibe the vari�nc� rnqueeted. �Attaeh �at ar S�tYVtrr �ri p#�o�ti►ty
-- �rhe�wing location ot praposed bufld�cs�, et�.� �t8o ad,jolni�g �to�ttiea
��1 ac�narehip within 2�' af said pro�rty. �
, '
, �<- ,�_ " ,,� ,
i
/
� .�� < _ �_� �..:._.:,
4. C�nt� by �da�ini�tsative affieial d�nying o�iginel requeet for batldfns
p�tit or ocher p�rrnit. (�'o be ca�sg�let�d �y a��in.atratfv� af�icinl.
App�opzi�te ord��a�cea and eectloa vf o�di�s.anc�J ts� ba eit�ed,)
0
�
�
_
s.
-2-
,_,_�........
l�oties of B�rSa�g a�pearad
dst�at
�must ba at leaet once �
attac6ed),
i pewspapmr an tbe follo�ring
�. �o�rd �sre itot if ieel of ineet ing by ����1,(. /al� y! 9L f=
�I.3at I�sra� �te PTo�ified, and "Yss'0 dr ' N'�or�TP�aaa� to stl�.
b�ring) , e •
.i. C 1� : .
j .,
►
;'�i� .. ` ` •
r� • _ � i .A "
i � .�_a� � ♦
y
� �
Pl�a� t° �A�
.
Y
�.
� � A '
�
7. B+�'soa �a1�a�� appeal and tbs follo�g property o�q►� ltavi� pro�ratty
�dtl�in 2Q0 qotift�d;
�
`•1,.�� . �� _ , � _z.��1.��
�„ i � �
� � �-1_'.� r . • f���
� I �:-:.1. ��1 � F 1/ % f .� •�
` �L :
_ �ill ��,_�l '_% ` � � s% J
! A � i
' _ �>> 1f. . � � � ?_. .:ri( Jl G� � yri
�
� �i �j�r ��, � • r
�
� '
/ �,
• ��/L_:1� . � �:.1 i1I i y
Dat�
—
�;; °��
���
py Pleo� $oRifi�1 by
oa�w (ir�itiai)
�
„ rYi.�l.
d• !ho l�oll�riing �osrd i�aabers and 4ntaroat� �artia a�ara �s��3�t at the
�s�rie�g t
BOA�D I�IDBBS
.
� � ��>„ .� _,.� • , , � i � ,
, �
�_�_�� .� '1-' � =�11. ' , �. .�l s� _�! t.�� - ' �1 �
..r
' '•
r
. 3 -
OTBER PARTIES;
1VA1�
�� e n �. ..� ,�,.� � a 0 . �.
\
�:.;1 �r[ ' ,� .' .i ./ ' r'-'1, i
s i
1� � � ,1 7 .� i�, �� , ,� .
;�
'� % i/.�' 'a.�.:_l. � %_!��
1
ADDRESS
0
I�.1 •i � �; ,� . /�l�i-�[.�_
� i
�•�i i[ 1L%_' ' f �/��-� i� ��_ i, ��
I
� �i_%'���I L r I, i I �;�_� �
�
/ A �
_%.' iL_f 'n.� _�j. l ' _.i._. 'L%' � �'' 'J
� '
IIL.. .�.!,� �_ �.�_� !'._� /L:�.uil i� �I /i ii � �/
/
1 � �• � �_ . . _ �n�- � . .�. . . � • ' 1 • '
� � l �' i�. / %
- _��.. ..►.!��._
/� � �
'L � � ' .� ( �' .; � �.Lr_��i'►� 1 � _.�aTJ%�1�i�I ��� �� � �_ .1. �:
10. For Above Recoa�endations
/kJ.�tir� .��J
����� -
,.�I�-,�► �1 � �-D �r► p �S -�
. .. -
,
11.•�ction by City Council and Date;
�
Against•Reca�cnendatione
/ �.r�� _
.
�
_�. •
0
l�(.++� • '� s
�
\
�
Rt "R
� �
;
,}
RfiQJLAR COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 20, 1972 PAGE 8
Couacilman Breidex said that he would assume by this recommendation th�k thexe
are many sabstandard lots m commercial zoning in Fridley now. Mr. Fsldorl
Schmedeke, Planning Commission Member, said that �}►e zoning ordinance was
passed in 1969. Throughout the Planning Com�.ission l�inutes over the past
month, he said he has tried to explain what has happened. The Plang��g.,Com-
mission has had S- 6 requests for c,hanges in zoning �rhich involve substandard
lots. There �re four lots across from Sandee's Cafe which woul'd fit the
20,000 square foot requirem�at but have to be consid�red substandard now. liiey
have also had a request just north a# Sandee's Cafe by Mr. Walquist wl�i�h irt-
volved only 17,000 squsre feet. At the time the ordinance was adopted, his
recommendation was a,minimum of 15,t?00 square feet �hich he felt would be
proper, but the requirement was made 25,000 square feet, so the 20,000 squara
feet.would be in the nature of a compromise. He said n�st service stations �o
on 20,000 square feet or less and the Iot where Mianie Pearl was �.s l�s� than
1S,OOO square feet. He said as the ordinance is wri�tem now, they just ca�pt
live.with it, and he was s�rs there were going to be �re si�ilaT Tequests in
;t�e future. This prdinance was made for one a�cea, and it should �at bave 6een
done. He commentod that he had thought that the recomn►endation for the 25,OQti
sq�ivare feet,came from the City staf£, but he has since fourid out diffe�antly.
Cou�cilman Breider asked if he knew �pprouimataly Ihow mar►y lots in Frialoy would
be i�volved. Councilmaa Mittelstadt estimated about 50 to 75, and 1�&. Schmedek�
agreed there would probably be that m$ny.
THE VOTE UFON TI� MOTION, being a voico vote, all voting aye, Mayor I.ieb1
declared the motion carried unanimously.
�ApTION by Councilman Mittelstadt to xeceive the Minutes of the Planning
Commission Meeting of March 8, 1972. Seconded by Councilman Kelshaw. Uport a
voice vote, all ayes, Mayor Liebl declared the �otion carried urianimpusly.
R�Ci:�VING THE MINUTES OF THE �ARD OF APPEALS A�ETING OF MARCH 14� 1972:
A RBQUEST FpR A VARIANCE OF SECI'ION 45.053, 4B, SA, 1�0 RSDUCE TI� MINIMUM
� SIDE YARD WIDTH ON A STREET S�IDE OF A CORNER LOT FROM 17.5 FE TO 10
.�: �., PBET TO ALLOW Ti� CONSTRIICTION OF A DWELLING ITH AN ATTACHED
'� :<' $B LOC,ATED ON LOT l, BLOCK 4, PEARSON'S CRATGWAY B ATE 2ND ADDIT 0,
� �� • -- -- ---- -- - ----- ----- -- - -------- ------- -- .
��µ}w��
� - w♦
• Y •
• L •
T�� City �ngineer repoxted that this house would be located on th• coa��r a�'
'�'� 79th Way and Alden Way, showed the location on the projeator, a�d said th�t ti1�
Bqard�oP Appeals recommended appro�al of the r�uast with +� stipulation.
,;� • �; M0�'ION'by Councilman Mittelstad� to concux with the 8oard of Appeal� r�►ao�-
�, '�ts�ndaxion and gxant the request fAr a variana� to Cha�cles Joh�nson, �he rsasa�
. ,be�.�8 that th� hardship. is showri and to achieva maxintum uso of th� lat,
�� �?:'�' �'� ; pa�ti�u�.arily with the boulevard, trees and grad� of the lat, th�►t this 1ot
a. , rec�ui,aes. a house of � samewhat difierent design and this par�iaul�c ho�s� Would
�••f�� �►ic�1y. Approval is based on tiiese considoratiotis, with the stigulat�on
'� �. that the exit of the driveway be to Aldan Way as oppased to 78t�h Way.
� � Seaoutd�d by Councilman K�lshaw, Upaa•a voic� vote, �11 voii� ay+�, Mayo�►
'�. �.L9.�bi deciared the raoti�on casxied wianimously.
REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING OF MARCH 20, 1972
PAGE 7
r�LOT SPLIT REQUEST, L.S. #72-01, GERRAL HERRINGER: Lot 3, Block 1, Oak
Hill Addition to be split in half to create one 75 foot residential lot,
remaining used for slope and backyard for Learning Tree Day Care Centert
VACATION REQUEST, SAV #72-0_1_, RUSSELL M. I�DGE: Vacate Madison Street
lying between Blocks 1 and 2, Oak Hi.11 A dition.
Tlie City Engineer said that these three requests are interrelated, sa the
Pl�nning Commissian discussed them together. He then sho�red the location on
the ovarhead projector and said the proposal is to take the easterly �i of Lo�
3 and add it to the Learning Tree Day Care Center, the �testerly � of Lot 3
to be added to the easterly �3 of vacated Madison Street making a 75 ��t
residential lot and the westerly � of vacated Mad3son Stre�t to be added to
Rti�sall Hedge's property on Lot 1, Block 2. The �lanning Com�ission recom-
mended approval of the three requests. •
N�TION by Councilman Kelshaw to approve the request for the revis�on of the
special use permit by Social Dynamics, SP #7I-09 and the Lat Split request
L.S. #72-01 by Gerral Herringer, a.nd set the Public Hearing for the vacatioA
of �ladison Street SAV #72-Oi by itr�sseli �tedge �eo�r Apxil 10, 1972. Second�
"�y Councilman Mittelstadt. Upon a voice vote, all ayes, Mayor Liebl declar�d
the moxion carried unanimously.
k_:. � .
�vACA�riON REOUEST: SAV #72-03, BY JOSEPH A.
build a two car garage.
N�TIBN by Councilman KelshaW to
$AV #72-03 by Joseph Laurent fo
Mittelstadt. Upon a voice vot�,
atotion carried unanimously.
OF
' INC.: Con c
o Outlot H.
Vacate the easterly
�nstrom's Court. T�
set the Public Hearing for the Vacation Reques�
r Apri�. 10, 1972. Seconded by Council�asn
all voting aye, Mayor Liebl decla�ced the
FOUR
aa
T}�,@ City �ngineex reportad that tha Planning.Cwmaission recommended aoncept
approval and will have a further recommendation at a later date.
�ION �y Councilman Kelshaw to raceive•the i�.€ormat�.on from the Planning
Cotami.ssion. Seconded by Councillaan Mittelstadt. Upon a vo3.ce vote, 8.11 aye�,
Mayor'I.iebl declared the motion carried unanimously.
CONA�IERCIAL ZONING REVIEW MATERIAL: C-1 $ C-2, C-1S $ C-2S
Th� City 8n�ineex exp�ained that the Plannin� Coma�i.ssion is xeco�tendin� th�
_aptea�dteent to tb� zaning ordina►nce be adopted to incozpoxata th@ chan��s of
.:,,�du�tion� of r�aquired square foot$ga f�com 25, QOA squar� feet to 2Q, Q00 � qua��a
�$e�t a�nd tho lot widt.� a�educod from �00 feet to 160 feet. '1'he woacdin$ t�i'e
� Qr�}in�nae #4S9 is aot changod ottuerwise and it would still raad tbat �ith r
���,�em�rat must be �aet, but not �both.
,;�?TION by Counailman Mittelstadt �a concur with tt►e r�coma�endation af the
P1�►in$ Commission and iazs�ruct that the pxoceduxe �or thaC ���1 �i ����h�w�
�tA ths amendu�r�t to the ordiaana� bo �tarted. SeGQA�� �Y ,
,*
- `,;,: .
.�
THE MINUTES_OF,TI� BOARD'OF AFPEALS MEETING OF FEBRUARY 29. 1972
The meeting was called to orc��r by Chairman Minish at 7:30 P.M.
�ERS PRESENT: Minish, Harju, Crowder
1�I�ERS ABSENT: Wahlberg, Sondheimer _
OTHERS PRE3II�: Clarence Belisle - Building Inspector
� .
MOTION by Harju.to approve the minutes of the Februarp 15, 1972 mee.ting as•
written.
Seconded by Crowder.'� Upon a voice vote, there being no nays, the motion carried�.
unanimously.
1. A REQUEST FOR A VARTANCE OF SECTION 45.053. 4B. SA TO REDUCE THE MINIMUM SIDE
YARD WIDTH ON A STREET SIDE OF A CORNER LOT FROM 17.5 FEET TO IO FEET TO ALLOW
THE CONSTRUCTION OF A DWELLING WITH AN ATTACH�D GARAGE TO BE LOCATED ON LOT 1
AT_MTt /. o�e�o�n*r1e f�'�ATnTJAV T[1TARfTff� n.,,. ...........,.,.__ _� _._— _—____ ____ __ _
Chaircnan Mi�ish said Mr. Johanaon had called him to explain he would not be
able to attend this meeting but he would still like the Board to conside� the
nasiance.
A suxvey of the 1ot, with the proposed location of the house drawn on it, was
shown to the Board. The 1ot is a corner lot and has an odd shape having a
frontage of 57.94 feet plua a radius and a back footage of 1fi0 feet. Tize
aagle is an the south lot line. The proposed house is 48 feet long plus a
24 foot attached garage. The house will face Alden Way with the driveway
possibly exiting onto 79th Way. The driveway would be very close.to the ��
intersection having to ex3.t on either 79th Way or Alden Way.
Mr. Belisle said the buyer that Mr. Johanson ha� for the lot,_wants the house
positi,oned as groposed. To poaition the house this way would s�ve some treea,
as this-:is a wooded lot, and would also preserve the back yard. The grade of
tl�e':1ot:rais�s.toward the back of the lot. To face the house toward 79th Way,
wh�tch could be done without variances, would involve removing part of this bank.
To position the house to meet the side yard requirement, while £acing toward
A1den Way, would.also require removing part of the bank.
There is a vacant lot adjacent to the south, but there would be no problems
in building on this lot whether the varia�ce on Lqt 1 was grgnted or not.
MOTION by Harju to close the Public Hearing.
Seconded by Sondheimer. Upon a voice vote, there being no nays, the motion
.
carried unanimously.
Mr, Harju said the buyer has a specific tloor plan that he wants to build on
this;lot and i,t does not constitute a hardship just becaus�e this floor plan
will not fit on the lot. They could put a different style of house with the
same amount of �I.00r area on the lot without needing variances.
Chairman Minish asked if�there woul,d be any traffic problems with visibility
or backing out onto 79th Tnlay?•
0
�
�;�`' � T`he Minutes of the Board of Appeals Meeting of February 29, 1972 Pa�e 2
�
Mr. Belisle said I�� didn't think there would be any problems.
2.
Mr. Crowder st�ed he would be in favor of tabling this item as there were
only 3 members of the Board present. He did not have any objections tc� tha.
variance but he was concerned with the grade of the driveway.
1�TTON by Harju to tabie this request until the March 14, 1972 meetin� to
enable the Board to discuss this variance with Mr. Johanson as it appeara
there are many aolutions to the problem that can be proposed to make the
house conform to the'Code.
Secoaded by Crowder. IIpon a voice eote, there being na nays, the motion
carried unanimously. .
Mr. Dick Fuda.li, co-owner of the apartment complex, was present to present
the request. Pictures of the complex and a plot plan were ahown to familiarize
tbe members of the Board with the project. •
Mr. Fuda.li said (in su�rsnary) that the original owners of the land initially
conceived this project as a 294 or 295 unit complex. Prio,r to his purchase
of the property, he went over all of the minutes of the varioua committees
a.nd Council meetings concerning this complex to make sure the property was
adequate, as represented to him, to accommoda.te 294 or�295 unfts. .He then
read portions of these minutes to the Board, and all the minutes, even as
l�te as November of 1970, were covering a 294 or 295 unit complex.
The mistake in computing the land area was ma,de by Dolan Engineering who made
the site plan for the original owners. When drawing up the site plan they
agpare�tly took the acrea.ge from the half section map, which included 1�alf of
the East River Road right of way along the west side of the property. 7�ie
si:te pla,n dated July 26, 1970 that was submitted by the original awners to
the various committees and Council showed a land use schedule which stated
"actual land area 17 acres"a This acreage was incorrecC in that it did
include the right of way measurement. � � �
The error in acreage was discovered when Five Sands Development was filing
the plat.
Mr. Fudali explained to the Board that a11 of their contracts an@ orders
are all signed and ordered for a 295 unit complex. To cancel the contxacts
and change the orders, etc., at this time, tv acco�anodate less than 295 units
woul,d involve thousands of dollars. �
Tize greesx area in this development is a common area for, the whole comglex.
Therefare no green area i�ould be taken away from this specific building by
granting the vaxiance. �
:�
�� �
�_--
������
��� � �,
� �
�� � �� � ����-���
L�- � cl .�J" = ,,
�
�/
�.� �? �' �
�
� n
�- /t� - / U ���
CO �� /
d �
G� Z �
� ^ � ' �� � - ��• .. . '. � E j �v � �� --..
�t � +s, r ' +e
� �� � �� � �� � �''� �`
.. . . �` ♦' ; � _ �1 ~�� S ����
� �� - . . _ . . . 1 �, .
+ ` i i!`
"� � ., ��° i p 0 o i� � r`� _
_ ���j� . - ' -�"°`�"°�,
� ti d �, ,�' °/� '>.-
�o
. � %� . . � . . . ., �- ... , W ra a�.
. i �+ . � ` . . ' ,.ly� S.-'
�r r���
�'• 1 \
.� / � � . � rr"r��.. � � e� ,�,.4�_
� f � ��Q/py�,��: a�,p���"�y�- •_ +
� / � p"j.}� � ,.��r'�� n: �',' .. .. R.. T� ��;�,�
�, j ' j . : � �7 �"�;> . : c� �'
� . . . . � � • _ s � � . �� . �'1 . �'� ` � � .
, � j ���r e-�• ° �`'�` ,�p ` -,�'`;
� � W` op V� y+���� ti. ��C�b � v'�flT'i 4 A`��i�++ `o�!
� ��(( � .�.� � e:F ���
- ��. . �� �/ Gdc .a . .r. , . .- . . o i �4,
� ..�5 ... .. .
� / �. �� � � T,� V.�.
_ ��%./ � ��tu`a.±y�s �1'm b o�-� � V,'a t�i� � v `b u,: - �.�
.. .'. � � _9 E �� i.. ( .�.. `�.• e @���.
/� � t'1� 'r►� !�� 4,�' � � �'�, �: ` -a
I / ` � e � � ,; .f�.... .' . .i., n ., . . �., \ .. . • » ��� , �
'� ,P/ ja � �'" �° F I° � . . � {�.. � � h ti ►� ti ' tv
f �� el � � i �� '°'I't' �+, l°� v �o � o � la. .p � � V �o o � n, w . ,� 6. �.
�'�r� � �� � � N � { s ,-1. � • � � , � e °,�
-�" ' ��. � � :�___ . . _ - . — c� mf. � � sn�eFaee. "a ;;
, � � %' a ; �ts
' - :�� L '� � ;' J �
� �
S � -y� : � � �
!� �� ; � �aa' `F`' � �� �1
.. . � I ��� �. ' ��� y '. - v � 4.. -�'1°ys Lre• V
.. _ , � p�.' � � . ay' � � A1 � �
` '� % ��*' 3 _ .�°",?�� � : �� g�` .iuvi � ,
; � .,,< ! �� - �f�0 �; .. '� , � „�� ` { �� � • +
, � *° '+ , "� . � � � � _
s• �'-:�� '�.1 ' �a ��,� e �, �m
� . ,a .'��4i .y, ;�`�,,.' . �. � �� iea•�.
� � b;�' �•�• F'�_ ��� °% a� '' � T p����$w'�.
� � �°,°•1' � e+
� t: � „ �s �
/� � ��• � !� ' ��
fi .
tR�
� � '' �� t° Q�•��oti �� : � �
r� o` 05 �,�/b "W
� , ��at�, `� �� T g. � .�._- .�����ia
.;.•.� / :/ ��� �. '^� � w ���t . n � �_ � �
��;�f ' ,�,7'C'� �.� `s y� .ar �.e�k' � *,�, o� abc�'0E� {m1� ��'�e � �p 4 • � _
` � % �: � �\ 4ys�ba�' Qq� � d�• � g� 'n } 8 � R �� d a . 8�
/%�j// � % F,�4 .�`'�� �G j t6 �� � � N. C•: � � a 'a V .
;! � �. ` `t I :�°u �� ,�� �r tt' �"4ti' � u �' � ? t�' �"
m
f � �;,�, �c a j ' ��,4'�� �' � , e ._� V ��b'.:..,� � �i '4 c. _.re � 4 `D
\ Y �'"~%i. I 44l j �` \ , �� i -� �"�Sf \ V i d!'+{� a � r � .
�l �� � `'� s . B '� 9 e� �. $
� � "44 ,'� R �\ ;�,� � d, A�� �+�% '��m yy ° . P ... . '�;�a -,,,,.� '�. C O ° ( � , �
) �s�. ,� ,�j.a "'�� '�'� ° _ , : . .
`'� - v. � ,� Ar. x +�
f / !, .�`� % \�� � �°� � °' � � � � o .., a ' �� h,��.p"� " �� '� ° 4' a
� � 'V" ��� �v ti �� � k� ��`' v E�^e�\�� q � + $�� • ti� �,
� % "3 q�b B ' �\ m Gp� �� ° '$ � � . . 3- �. �'o . � � .f f ° � t9 d�
� �. . S4' � � �. ; °�� . � � • � � .
i / �`` � � � '�, p.� _ T,>, S� o+.�, e tf �' 9 .
r / �t . y'� _ , � �f %.':...f�' ,a.s� ! y a �
� � � �t , � � ���pA f • _ _ � �� r,� =
/ , tl` '� � �� � ��l �� � � � �� . � ....�"ip'P . � �a
� . ' � ��� � �. ° � T�af ' ..� �� .�
.% I � , �- ,F�,y1f �'• � �' �� � •�< �� Q �1
� $ � `\ �' p' `� ���el� � � � §�C �` �� b � `� �.� �ji,
i � � ��•',��` � ° � � � � � � � pe _ �:� 30 {i�
� ��► G'�" \ \ � � _ �s . �
'� � �� .� � ,� � , �,, OQ ,e, ��,,.� t
_�._ � �. �', � ,x �.�' � '� j4l$� A •_` , - � .p � . �
.m . `(�� E` p ` r � ��� � � �•� �' - �i y �° � � �?6 � ' �T
, v� � ot y � �, �•9 �;, . al �o
y�
�, '�, e � � -' �`$� � `�, �l [ �.M' � = /
• y . `�;, �,, \ r ., a. �s , j � `��; �; � �, ` •� � d� a,� � ,�r �
. � � �;P � � .�, . � . ` `�. , . �; . .d� �'`".�'�
, ` `
� d . _ .... _ _ _.
� � z ..L. - �• ---' �'°'� -r—og `-�." S—� • - - - � "-"r •/ �
.� _ _�„fP__ srr�'_^ �. -�a �� i! ..._ ,.
~ �K � .� r� � � ,M
�u+' � : g
ri :. ;� � ,-0:'� �,�. 1$ � • �' � 7� '� � �o ' �
��`` � o •' • s,G��a �� 4�+< g��./�'' Y�S � ,� ��'�'14 '�` � V ¢ i. i .lL o ;°
� 1.� /�1� . `b y �. � � � de
: .�, w� i ` I; *.-s� � � � �I \�" e ' / '- $� ,P.P` .�� ee .� ��` � . . �v % ; w �
, � .
s
��, .� . `� ��t'w+� .� �-� �. �� �� .� e v
o ,.
� •s4.. a �' � .� ''`,a. � � �} `�' �, `�� ,� '� -� / . �'"� � �
� �'"'° e�� ••`� , , a � .� � -- � �.
� � ° ��� 'S' +t� � ••' � s %� it �. �° � 'i'^� _ '�
� ' �,
. .. . _ . _ � _ . l� , 9 � �' �' a�
I
; _ _
,:�,. ,.� �,
t �"`` " � �'' � ��: `' ,
,'"��"���` t � � � �,, �
� q T:
*' I + ' 4 p , .. ' .. C �
�• ''���1��'!r � #,� e a.`� �Iii H�� *�rRA ib� �
" �p�'�,� �, ,s' i iit +�' .x 5M1 lYl�il�e�li�a!#�,t
� � k x �� ���� - .j ���`• - �r��►� �3�3� -
;� '��, ���� ��� , '��� i�4.�a0�a`= �
_ t� n�� ��r ���i��e+��� �c � �4:4:±u�c��+�'�� " ��� ��t�
F - i , - L i j.:j i 7"
� . ` �'� ��.�� :� ����t�� �;��_ '�.
_
., ,
.
, � .. .
�+��t:���.���� of �?�t�r�� `����} -
� . _ . .�
�
._ , .,. , ,, . _ e . �
,, . � . �
. : . .,
o �.. �.' � . .
P ,: ,
. A � �
� � � � �__ '.-4 � � •
�_: f _ ai y `�' y r:.
� t � ..c� .4' �y _ 7 �' - �
_ .-c ' ,�",� • � � � � I ; � .
i yc T .,. Y' `
Z � f ) �� t `�•:�.
:. _ .,._� � z .
� y t =�i c�� ���°5 '�}..{�� ���� je �
� . . �: r � , �'' r r �
. . �. . . ... ' 'F' �
h. r�+' -P� ' ,�4' ,.. ..�, � .-. Cd���.-- t ' -. d -'
- ,��. .. � �. .:y y�
.4� t" _ `:r,�.r.- ��
��i,
w� 7 g
.: ��'. v ,. �.. � � � 3
�� �': S
F 'f « � " � �.�' !! ��� �,'� '
i � _ �� _ X�d � '� �s 1
y �' :. .. . . - �a, Y '�9 ��� Y � ,_ � �eu 4 � 3
��.` .i } i� ' �!. '��� � I {� y
� 1 � s ^-+.. I._ -
q ., �: ' '.� ':� � _ ; ? .
3 ��4 4 ��� � �� �t � , � J�
h '_ . e i
` r � - f � j ..-` � •
+ � x' i`•� .;; ,,,� ,� L �, �, d w .
, � ' ' ' ,:�'�p t
z 'S ,
� �" `` _ �ri' �. °�"' , ', t � _
i � ,, '�� I � t+" �. ai:V' ��'•�`
. °�. �, + � _ _ yi '� i IP 4 �,
. _ , .. y � , .f � ,��
� � S
y � '"' .ir! ! i ,� � :!i '1��`'� Y � � .!
_ l� �Y
fi a � + - . � A . ���� 3.: § � . � `' k °as 4 '",
a,�� ����. - - t(� �` c
� �� �
�"�'a t � - �����r , t 'y � ,_.
�� � f � _ ///����... , _ t �• . �' 9 � � � a - }e:-
.. f � � � � F � �- S+ �
).� S e �" � - 5 _� {� '; ',: �
yw �__F :�� > ��t'i �,c} 4` P` f � � � �,
i.
i � f - '� R } ��.' �- y� .
. r s � h i � F � � ' �
� J ��.. � � 4 � � �S,
.: F' ��:1 k - - � * 4� i � '�' F�.
t� 1 # � n Y A'. '� J _ �~ F �
i � � c � . �� pS '
..i 1 � :` � ,���GeF�°� ��� F��l��i���� � }
V - � m?y 'f -�'
� . ; e c ,y,� n' i . `;k
�. ; r F� ; r $i: �' _ r
r , " �
� ,� �-" � b ✓ fi ?* a .c .� x � r � A f l � r�s' % 'k F 3 � � � ��H' � ���, #
r � �� `° �, � _ ,+� � - (y' ��?� K
�j t � �t � t itE� . g.-....
T i .. . , � ,� § . -:.: _. ' :
. ��. ¢ l, . . 4�.�..�� . , _ _ � ''� :; .�aa .���� �'�� :� �.�. . .. �� .. . � ,{ � � ; -. g, �_!,k 9, .... ,., t. . . � s.�%a.. ..�.. _ . , ._ . . % �,*�..3` t i. ~ ,�.
LT3'
t��' :'i. �� :
� � f . Sp'.��-
Y - M1
�'!� �� � � t �
����� ��
�
d�
�i � T� ���
F
y � M
• %'.�.
�_
�y 5
� �
�.
r^-
�
7�
1.
THE MINUTES OF THE BOARD OF APPEALS MEETING OF MARCH 14, 1972
The �eeting was called to order by Chairmaa Minieh at 7:40 P.M.
�ERS PRESENT: Miniah, Crowder, Sondheimer
�ERS A$SENT: Harju, Wahlberg '
OTi�RS PRESENT': Clarence Belisle - Building Inapector
M�. Cxowdex.said the February 29, 1972 minutea should be amended ot1 Ra$e 1.
The motion to cloee the public hearing was seconded by Crowder iaet�d of
by Sondheimer. �
1�TION by Crowder to apprave the minutea af the February 29, 1972 tpeetiug a�e
�neaded. ,
Seconded by Sondheiaeer. Upon a�oice vote, there being ao nays� ttte tt�tion
caxried unanimously.
Mu. Charles Jahaaeon wga present to present ttte request.
Chais�uan Minieh atated thie item wae tabled at the �'ebruary 29, 1972 r�ting
to �11ow the.Board membere to discuss thia varisace with Mr. Johaasc�u,
I�c. Johanaoa�stated hg waate to uee this �ot to the beet advaatage. aeyitt�
the house aet at ati aagtt, ae propoeed, the view would be downetxeam iu�C�d
o�.toward the flood.area houaes. He said he could put a emaller bous� oa Xbs
1at �xtd not hgve any . probl�ne but he would prefer to use thie split �ts'y
houae plan on the lot. He �icked thia house plan becauae i.t ha� a difiereu�
dssig�a about it aad he 13kee to build housee that havs a deeigsi tbat i� Agt
plaim� .
M�r, Johansoa .eaid there is a 36 foot boulevardt per lot �ctsvey� on 79th Way'
�hich ia a lot widsx thaa �n averag� boulev�rd. 7�ere ahouldm�t b� att�►
psrobieme with traffic visibility i� the variaace wae graated a� tbe►s� wauid
bs �46 #eet betweea the h�ee aad �he paveauant.
Mt. �svwder aeked ig be had a buyer for thie h�ee.
Mr. Johansoa aaid he does not have a b�q�r �or t�,ia bou�e a� ye�fi bax �� ��lt
iC would be a ehanme to build a em�lier houae aa t4is lox. Ae had �►laaned te
�ti�,ld Chia houae far the "�arade o� Howee�' buC hs bad to start caaets°t�c�ioa
Aaa aaother lot for that purpoee becauae oi the tis�e elem�ent.
Tb� $oa�cd aeked aboat haw �he driveway wouid �xit.
Mr. �phas�o� eaid be plaas to have the drive exi,t ou A1deu Way. T'b�• wottld be
�t �b�arter dxive w�,tti lee� of aa incliae. He ehot the elevati.os� va Ch�e 10�
�� '�s kuowa the driveway will ba decent.
j The,Miautes Of The 8oard 0� Appeals Meetin�z of March 14, 1972 1'a�e 2
Mr. Jvha�ason �sid the froat yard setback ie pl�asd to keap i,n al�.�tae+�t wi�b tha
other iota and wi,th the curve of the street. 7�e lot dixectly to the South ie
vacaut at t�liis �i�+e but be plane to us� it witbiu tba yeas.
Mx. Soadheimer aeked how the �rade runs an thie xo�.
. 1�I�. J�aha�aa �aid the 9.ot runs fairly flat and then drop� o�� ve�T 81�t7�p1y• Tbs
, garage e�.eavatioa wiil be aet at less than 48 iaclis� above tb�a �txseG t,�icb i�
� ti�e� �cimwn �ode elevatioa. Se eaid tha� he would lae� �ome txe�� �� bs he�$ to
p�ai'tiQA the house fusther bask on the lot.
2s
l�s. .TQbaa�oa added that during the las t 5 yeare i.n the "Aeggie. Aw�rds �' category
oP placesnent af a house on a lot, he has won eithez 1at o�c' 2ud p1aCe� eacli ye��e
$� �a�id it takee a lat amore than luck to win thie.
i�D'�ION tay Crowder to reco�ead approYal af tbis r�c�ueet ta t.be City Couaci.�, to�
th� �ollaw3.pg reasoas ;
la Tl�e hardship heiag ahoWn, to maximize the use of the lot, par�icul8�ly with
the boulevaxd, trees aad grade of the lot.
2a Tbis 7.ot required a house of �o�awhat unuaual� desigu and thie p�zticu�.a�
#�ouse fite that bill.
3. W� recomnead that the exit of tlie driveway be to Aldeu Way ae �ppoaed �tt
79th Way.
6��oad�d by Sondheimer. Upon a voice vote, there being no �ys� the rt�tiot�
�a�ci�d tu�aaimously,
Mx. ii, �wwan�o� was representiag Caetle Mobile Homee ou thia requeet, a pl�oga
�� t.la� eac�e�ing �ign and a copy of the half sectiou map �ahowiag t�s �g�aC��A
g� t.he� �i� o� tha property �ere ahoWa tp the Boasd.
1K�r• Sw�o� stated Casti� Mobi�e Hamea �.� in th� p7roce�� o� �►ia�$ t�eir
��,��� oa].es offic� xo thia property aud tbese i# ��xit�� �Ta���la
Q�tdA�� Adver�i�ing bill,board om tbs propert�. 7�e siga ie 2S �s�t b�► �.�
���te �e► •aid ttie�► would i.ike t.� g�t the variance ao the ei$a aa� be� t����
��� t�s�.x bu�i.aes� sigu �nstead of bavia,g to m�ee tliie �isting bi�#�bo�xd
�ti�h�� tQ t�►� Nvr�h anc� laaving t4 put up anotheer aigu fo� �hhslr '�t��►��� ��•
�c. �e����e� �aid the City wcn�ld rathez have the billboard at tb,�.s ���i�� �s�,
�o� bav� � ��� e
:
7�e Minut�s of the Board of Appeals Meetin�t of March 14. 1972 Pa�e 3
� Mr. Crawder asked if this eiga would �tay claseified ae a billboard if the
variaace was granted or would it be clasaified as a bueineee eiga.
Mr. Belisle eaid it would stay a billboard becauae �.t ia awaed by somebody
other than the property a�waer.
Chai�a Miniah aeked who would owu the eign.
Mr. S�,iaaeon eaid Naegele would own the aign aud Castle,Mobile Homea wau�.d laaee
it from theffi.
Mr. Beliele added that if the property was ta chaa�e hands, the si8u cculd
posaibly revert back to bsing used ae a billboard.
Mr. Crawder stated he would feel a whole lot mare aecure if he kaew that i�
�.:��,� after the Board granted the r�uest, the siga would beco�e either a aign or
�. a billboaxd.
Mx. $oadheimer added thia will psobably set a precedent.
Ghaixmaa Minish atated Caetle Mobile Hamea wae gra�ited a Special Use Peswit
by t�e City Council to operate their buaineae at thie location for a pe�iod
o! 5 yeare only. At the end of 5 yeare they will have to go back befo�te
Cot�acil if they �ant to continue at thia location. 7his variance if g�antedi
would be for Caetle Mobile H,omes only as long ae they are at thia 1a►ca�ion,
eo the aoard iea't looking at a permaneut fiut�ttre. Also, according ko aur �
aiga ordinance, all fxee etanding advertising eigns that are aoa-capfo7�mi.ng
a� the time the ordinance wae adopted have 5 years from that date to aot�o�at
to the ordinaace.
Crawder aeked if there wae anythiag ia our code that would prohi.bit Castl�
iKobi�le Hc�es fsam adding things like flashing lighta� neon lighte� eta.s to
Cti4t 8 igA.
Ms. Beliele stated that would be conaidered altering the siga and they ptue�
aoaios�a ta the code. If for any reasoa thie biliboard is removed, the eigu
axoa p�rmitted would revert back to onlq 100 equare fe�t ae that ia tlie
tu�7ci�ttm eize �.a thie zoning.
��;, ;- �.; �i0TI0N by Sandheia�r to cloee the public heariag.
� �eao�d�ad by Crawder. Upon a voice vote, there beiag no naye, �e matia�A
ca7c�cied u�►aaimouely.
1�. Crc►wder etated be would agree with the Eagivae�riai8 Departmeat iA havia�$
oaly 1 eiga to identify this proparty and he h�td no quaLne about ch�tagiaag
th� billboard to a bueineee eign. Se would recoma►end that this aign cauld
o�1y exist aa a buainesa aign for the time that Caetle Mobile $ouuat �s �t
t1�is 1aGati.on and also that thare be no other bueiaeae eigae.
1+�OTIO�N by Cxawder to reco�ead to Couacil appraval af the xequeat �it1i th�
follvwin� etipulationa;
1. There be only 1 bqeiaee�a aign allawed oa thie pxoperty.
Ea
i
The Minntes of the Board of Appeala Meetint� of March 14, 1972 Page 4
3.
2. Thia sign will only exiat as a buainesa �1�u far the time that C�t].e Mobils
Aames ia at thie location.
Mu. Sondhei�er added the etipulatioa that;
3. The eiga stay as it is except for the iascrip�ioA chap$e #p� the salee offiQe.
9econded by Son�eimer. Upoa a voice vote, there being ao uays+ the pw�ion
carried unaaimously. • .
Mx, Dav�.d Dockter and Mr. Roger Omtbedt of 3ussel Compaay were pse+seat to
p7cesent the xequest.
A�ttxvep showing the addition drawa in, a plan layout of the.addition� aad
photoe of the �ielliag were ehowa to the Board.
Mx�. Dockter explaiaed he plaas to add on a 16 foot by 10.i foot fawi.l.y �ooin
t,�at wi,l� be flush with the back of the houee. 7he exieting door aud �art
o� tbe wail wiil be removefl and a 6 foot arch will be installed betweea the
laiaily zoom addition and the kitchen. 7�►e garage wiil b� poaitioned ahe�d
o� tiie �a;nil�► room and wiYl extend 5.3 �eet ahead of the houee. The gsx+tge
�t�,ll��be 16 feet by 21.5 feet.
'Ats �x�.ating dwelling hae a front yaxd eetback of 40 feet and a eide yazd
�e�baak of 20.7 feet. The�front yard variance seked �or ia 3/10 of a�oot
�ud the �arage needs onlq a 3/].0 of a foot variaace. The liviag asea �ddition
t►eeda a 5.3 foot variaace.
, �Z. G�xowdex�asked haw�;close to thie lot liae ia the houae oa the adjacent lot2
1�r� $eliele staawed tha Board a verification eurvey of the adjaceut 1ot. I�
�bawe�l the hause 10 feet frcm the lot lia�e, and set back 39 �eet �rc�a the
#xont 1at li�ne. Thig dwelling has bedrooms alaag the adjoiniag 1i.a�.
T� �ha var�ce were�graated there would be 14.7 feet betweeu etxuCturA6►e
bd�s Q�'�wde�c asl�ed M�. Dockter if he aow uaes thie same area fo� parkiug hie
���a �d i�' t.tae fa�u3.ly room would be encloeed.
�, D�6ktax ax�swexed h� duee uee this area for paskiag and the fami.ly �ovon
Wot�1d be emcloeed. �ere wauld be na wiadowe iacing the Aei$hbo7c� p�co�ex�y.
'��;� �vauld be s].idiag doose �aciag the back ya�d aad theze wouid b�a oue�
�1l�dsw �t► the garage.
�. �ondheimer aakad why he dida't mo�v� the propoaad additioa towurd tb�
b�ak �o�ce�. U
,
�
t�
y
8
The Miautea of the Board of Appeals Meatin� of M,axch 14, 1972 Pa,�e 5
Mr. Dockter aaswered he has a walk-out house and the back yard drope down. T�i�
wvuld re�uire landacaping before it could be built oa.
Mr. Crowder asked if there was aa eaeement along the side propertq 1iae.
Mr. Dockter said no, they were along the back lot li,ae.
Chai�aa Minish asked if he had talked to hie aeighbox about the vari�nae,
Mr, Dockter answered he had talked with him about i�. The ne3.ghbor bad a d�ath
i,a his �twn�ediate family aad the funeral was today.
Chairman Minish aaid he thought the Board should knaw the neiglibore opittiaa of
the+ variance be£ore tt�ey make a decision on the requeet. �e aeked �r. Docktex
�.f he could get .a letter from hie aeigbbor that would at$te hia Op�,p�,OA O� �S
vari.ancea . '
�TION by Sondheimer to table thia request uatil March 28, 1972 to allow tite
�tpplicaat ti� to �et a letter fram hia neighbor.
��a�9ttded by Crawder. Upoa a voice vote, there being ao aaye, the motiaA c�ti�d
t�aan�ue ly'
AA��i1�NT :
The� mee�ing was adjourned at 8:50 P.M. by Chairmaii Minieh.
R�apac�fuXly aubmitted,
� U
� �TT
Secaretax�►