The URL can be used to link to this page

AF-V - 34932� _ �r� �� 4 ..,.�l.n � ,a�, .::ti�;{mw: ��'• �rA� ■�� ,� .. .' G►____ _ � �� ! �� ! wb j� �� y � 1�� j[ �. ii 0 _ /` �� CITY OF F3�lDLEY� SUHJECT 643'1 UNIVERSITY AVE. NE. FRIDLCY, MN. 65432 (6127 57'1-34✓O VARIANCES � .C� ADDRESS S'3s,� �,c Tu QA %nnr �n , DATE ��y °�� , � 9 $ � APPEALS COMMISSION: APPROVED DISAPPROVED DATE CITY COUNCIL REVIEW: REQUIRED: YES CITY COUNCIL: STIPULATIONS: N0. APPROVED DISAPPROVED DATE N0. �/ f � NAME �£iPT � lj i.Sh' /S,y __ FEE (�� RECEI PT No. Co 3 2-� LOT N0. BLOCK N0. TRACT OR ADDITION LEGAL QESCRIPTION: -� �- C� C��- - ��? �� . VARIANCE REQUEST(S): (Attach plat or survey of property showing building, variances, Q�� _�,} etc., where applicable) � � . ,L��-� � ;�,,,,, �,,,�,G'^�"' a � x � � � � 1 �E�u�� S�`rP�a�, FoR ��1 �'7T��t��'A ��/��E F1�o/� To � `� _�/ List specific hardship(s) which requires the variance(s): (�} fT� Ek'/S`T�1�1Ch S�Df A�OR $T��S ��t1EED Z 2� �GUI,vF C�AReT�Gr,� F�aR ,9D�Qcl�►r� sro,�zFf1C�E oF e�RS fin°1� AT,r�E,e �c�o�ssaxic�„ pATE � I�/� Y as" `�'� / 9 8"-2 S IGNATURE ��`%+�' C�Y!_f� ADDRESS S �f.'� �� T�l/Pi� �,t� . TELEPHONE NO ✓rT•�— %6 / � 0 YARIANCES � FOR C1TY USE 0!�LY Board members notified of inee�ing by June 10, 1982 . LiSt rr�emb�rs, (` date notified, and "Yes" or."P;o" ior plans to attend hearing. ` . Plan 4 Name � � Date� To Attend � Gerou � . Gabel Bar � P1 m - (' nl om� n __ ____ Per�o:� mnking:appeal and the foilowing property otvners notified: � fdame � _ _ _ .� _ - --� .. . �' I , " M/M'Harry W.�Zimmer 5324 Horizon Dr. N.E. 55421 h1/M Donald J. t�latterThoffer 5312 Horizon Dr. N:E Barbara J. Olberg�195 53rd Ave. N..E. 55421 _ M/M Russell R. Daly 5358 Altura Rd. N.E. 55421 M/P1 Frank J. Severson .5348 Altura Rd. N.E. M/M Raymond R. RasmuSsen 5336 Altura Rd. N.E. M/M Harold H. Anderson 5324 Altura Rd. N.E. M/M Robert G. Kishish 5312 Altura Rd N.E. ��Ben Bigos 3201 Orchard z�for�th, Golden Va55 Verna M. b�al ter 5313 Al tura Rd iV. E. 55421 Pfl/M Harold F. Geiser 5325 Altura Rd. N.E. 55421 Mabel J. Howells 5337 Altura Rd. N.E. 55421 P�1/P1 David K. Wenger 5347 Altura Rd. N.E. 55421 M/M David E. Mattila 5255 Capitol N.E, 55421 M/P-1 Merrill D. Davidson 5301 Horizon Dr. N.E. M/M Vernie E. Peterson 5313 Horizon Dr. N.E. M/M Dale S. Johnson 5325 Horizon Dr. N.E. 55421 M/M Darrell F. Manthei 5337 Horizon Dr. N.E. M/M Orville F. Haag 5349 Horizon Drive PJ.E. Date ving property within 200 feet 8y Whom Phone or Mail Notified • ► � . MAIL � � � - CITY OF FRI�LEY 6431 UNIVERSITY AVENUE N.E., FRIDLEY, MINNESOTA 55432 NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING TELEPHONE ( 612)571-3450 June 4, 1982 Notice is hereby given that the Appeals Commission of the City of Fridley will conduct a Public Hearing in the City Council Chambers at 6431 University Avenue Northeast at 7:30 p.m. on Tuesday, June 15 > 1982 in regard to the following matter: Consideration of a variance request pursuant to Chapter 205 of the Fridley City Code, to reduce the side yard setback for an attached garage from the required 5 feet to 3 feet, to allow the con- struction of a 22 ft. by 38 ft. attached garage on Lot 32, Block 6, Carlson's Summit Manor South, the same being 5312 Altura Road N.E. (The existing 27 will be reduced area). ft. by 14 ft. attached garage to a 12 ft. by 14 ft. storage Notice is hereby given that all persons having an interest therein will be given the opportunity to be heard at the above time and place. PATRICIA GABEL CHAIRWOMAN APPEALS COMMISSION Note: The Appeals Commission will have the final action on this request, unless there are objections from surrounding neighDor,s, the City Staff, or the petitioner does not agree with the Commission's decision. If any of these events occur� the request �ill continue to the City Council through the Planning Commission with only a recomnendation from the Appeals Commission. ( �; � Ct7Y rr- r=�ir��.�:Y. �UE3JE�CT �� rv�iNn��yor� ��'CVi�8��6�:�! �.F =�p C�i�i''��6°V [�=i � 1.4� 6 i:� \!1/ �.�•��,� Uepc � ro�s;cn� Iiurr�uer � t�ev r..,,i l:pproved �y �7�'D _ . . . . . . I �� i i FILE NO/ AODRG:�`.i FILE DATE COMPLETE= RCVIEW C4-9ECKLtSi' � _��a �,�""�J-� `�`j"� � `7 [�ETU�N TO C-�LA�!(V1NG • �c-�G.�, �-�1 a,s.../ /�_Y/'�'�,,`"/ Qu�A � __ �. � �i'L'/YS°� � l^-C �=--_ �— � d iV� rl� � N i� '�J 1 �.. .� %� ,/�� 1 e( '(E � 6��4i �� /1 �� /�/'+ � t.�� Iet`�°"� ir�J� �L•� ;Jr �" ��`�� e M � r_�,. , ' / / ,/ � .- ! ` / � � • Z- �� ,c S G y �t,.�., . �� , c_,� ,a•�,.a,.a�.._.�_.�P ..<..=e-.�. ,.a-�� . u�,o . � -Y � <7 ' i t` ' � j /'' ` tl < � � i �'' t,' / u" � �L' �i � . '� ` �/.' " �� i n l �* , � Gv'r �� YC c�i ,, 4�'� I � � �' � ' _/ �./ �� ` �' V 9' - �- -,�? �?l �t � � �? F� t' C�( 'E�J'� �� l-C-i <'-F / i '� �� C ��i >b' i� �� L� � � ff ; / y �` � i-;I` l, r','� � � ` J , /� � , ,!! � -° /,�!I !� / rL. j � r / k .�-c n {"� � '�� - ,; , C- �: �� ,•. Item #2, June 15, 19a2 ADMINISTR.ATIVE STAFF REPORT 5312 Altura Road N.E. A. PLIBLIC PURPOSE SERVED BY REQUIREN�3QT: Section 205.053, 4B, #4, requires a mini.mum 5 foot side yard adjoining an attached garage. Public purpose served by this requiresnent is ta provide space between individual structures to reduce conflagration of fire, to provide access to the rear yard for emergencies and to limit the condi tion of crowding in a residential neighborhood. B. STAT�;D HARDSHIP: "With exis ting side door steps, I need a 22 foot wide garage for adea�uate storage of cars and other accessories." C. AllMINISTRATNE STAFF REVIEW: If the Board approves this request, the staff suggests that the Board stipulate that the north wall of the proposed garage have no openings and that the exterior wall be 5/8 inch type X gypsum board. e City of Fridl,sy APPEAIS COt�Il�lISSION 1�TIldG - JIIN� 1S, 1962 PAGE 1 CALL 10 ORDFR: � Chairr►onan Gabel call�d tt�e Jur�s 15, 1962, Appsala Commiaaion assting to order at 7�30 p.m. IaOLL CALLt Maabers Preaent� Patricis Gabel. Alea Barna, Jin Plsmel� Jean Gsrou Membsrs Abssntt Lesli,e Colesan Others Prsssnt� Darr�ll CLrk. City o! F�idlsy Mr. and Mrs. Aarold H. Anderaon� 5324 Altura Road, Fr�,dley� 1rA1 Ifir. and Mr�. Donald Ni,elaen� 115-71� Way N.B, Fridley, ?�i James H. Crosa. 6271 Jackaon Strest N.E.. Fridley. 1rAT Robert and Gail Kiahiah� 5312 nitura Road, Fridlsy, I�IlJ_ APPROVE APPFAIS COI4�IISSION I�INU �S OF 1rLlY 25. 1962 � I+�TION by Ma. Gerou� seoondad by 1�1r. Barna� to approve t,he May 25, 1962, Appeals Coms�isaion minutes aa r►rittsn. UPON A YOICE U�TE � ALL VOTING AY�, CHAIRWOMAN ' GAHs,L DFCLARED Tf� I�TIDN CARRIED UNANIM�USLY. � 1. TABIEDs VARIANCE REQUEST PURSUANT TO CHAPZ�R 205 OF Tf� FRIDIEY CITY CODE. � ALIAW TF� CONS7RUCTZON OF A DhCg AND A lasw F�tuT nmR �m � 1 S oi �T at . F'ublic Hearing Cloasd ��i� r�TION by Mr. Be�rna � secondad �► Ms. Gerou, to remove the above item from the ta� bS� . UPON A VOICE VO'IS� ALL Y�TING AYE, CHAIRWOMAN GA�L DECIJIRED T� I�fpTZON CARRI�D UNANIMpDSLY. M0� TION by 1+Ia. Gerou, secomisd by Mr. Barna� to open the public hearing. UPON A VOICE VO'� � ALL VOTIN(e AXE � CHAIRWOMAN GAEEL DSCIARPD TI� PUBLIC HF�ARING OPEN AT 7�32 P.I�. J�DMINZSTRATIVE.STAFF REPORT ii5 - 71� Way 1Q.E. A. PUBLIC PURPOSE SERVED BY RE UIREMENT• Section 205.154, 4, allows unoovered porches and steps to building entrances to extend not more than 10 feet into a required front yard. Public purpose served by this requirement is to allow for aesthetic consi8eration to reduce the buildinq "line of siqht" encroachment into the neighbor's front yard. APP6AIS COI4SI3S?ON I�STIliG - JUI� 15. 1962 PAGE 2 B. S TATE D Hl�►RD68IP : "Need a front door and need abave grade deck to use door." C. ALIMIIIISTRATIVE STAFF REVIEW: �e existi� dwelling was built in 1956 with a 35 foot front yard setback. In 1976, the City improved 71� Way and 9 feet of this property was taken for street riqht of way, leaving the existing house 27.9 feet fran the front property line. The proposal is to build a 12 foot deck and front step off the front of the dwelling which would leave a 15 foot front yard. T'he adjacent structures to the east and west are over 100 feet from this addition so this deck should not encroach into their "line of sight". T'here is an apparent problem aver the westerly 10 feet of Lot 32, Auditor's Subdivision #77. The City approved the lot split (L.S.#73-07) in June, 1973. For some reason the transfer of the 10 feet of land was never recorded at the County. Therefore we have tAld Mr. Nielsen that the staff report would be recommending to the Board that his petition be oontinued until proper recording has been accomplished. Mr. tiielson does have an attorney working on this at this time. Mr. and Mrs. Donald Nielssn. 115-?1+� Way N.�. � Fri,dlsy. I�1 s+ere pressnt. Mr. Nislaen barief]y revieWed his variancs requsst. Mr. Clark notad that t�hs document that transferred ten feet to the eaat to Mr. Aielsen's property was recorded on June 10� 1982. Chsirxon�n Gabel added that they w�ere atill discusaing Lhe same variance requsat. Chairaoman Gabal ssked about the aize of the boulevard and Nr. Clark responded that it uss aix feet. An aerial photograph vas available aa ti+ers current photographs. Mr. N3elsen explained tisat there is ar� existing b�ick patio � 12x14, whiah xould be where t.he proposed deck ia to bs. In addition. a door rill ba added vhere xindows preaently axiat. Chairiroa�an Gabel aslaed if they iud spolaan With an�y neighbors and Mr. Nielsen indicated they hsd and the neighbcrs had voiced no opposition. Mr. Barna aakad what the use of the room xith the escape xindow xas and l�lr. Nielsen aaid it ia present�y being uaed aa a bedroom. Nr. Barna aslaad if escape `rould atill be possible iS the deck was added and Mr. Nislsen aa3d it �roul.d be. l�DTION by Ms. Gerou aeconded by M�r� plemal� to close the public hearing. iIPON A VOICE VO�, ALL YOTING AYE, CHAIRWOMAN GAPEL DECIARF.D Tl� PUBLIC HEARING CLOSID AT 7e42 P.M. � by Mr. Plemal� aeconded � l�fr. B�rna� to grant the variance to allox the construction'of a deck and a nex front door to bs 25.91 feet fron the Pront property lins instead of the required 25 feet� on Lot 31� and the weat 10 feet of Lot 32, Auditor�a Slibdivieion No. ?'j'. t2ie same baing 115-�'1� Way N.E. UFON A VOICE V01E� WI1H 1�.SSRS. BARNA AND PLEI�sL YOTING AYE � AND MS � GEROU AND CHAIF�GAOMAN GA�L VOTIldG NAY, CHAIRWOI�iAN GAEEL DECIARED THE MOTION TIED� THUS FAIIED. Chairwoman Gabel >PPEALS C014�lISSION I+�TI�iG - JUi� 15. 1982 PAGE 3 iadicated� for tbs r�cord,t2iat she voLd agairzst the motion bscauas oP ths preo�dsnce tisat aigbt b� ast !or bnil.ding d�cks iri i'ront yards, r�hioh dscision s2� l�lt should bs mad� by tbs City Council. and bscauae ahe �+oas unaure that a h�rdship had bsen saLblisbsd. Sbs explainsd tLat this item �uld bs referred to t�s City Council and �+vald appsar on tb�ir agends on Jn�y 12. 1962. 2. I+DTION by Mr. plsmel� second�sd �► IKr. Barna, to opsn tt�s public hearing. UPON A VOICTs VOZE, ALL YOTII�iG AYB, CHAIRWOKAN GA�L DSCIAR� THE PUBLIC HEARING OPBN AT 7r4� P.M. 1,DMINISTRATIVE STAFF REPORT 5312 Altura Iioad N.E. A. PL�LIC PURPOSE SERVED BY REQUIRF.N�JT: Section 205.053, 4B, $4, requires a mini.mum 5 foot side yard adjoining an attached garage. Public purpose served by this requirement is ta provide space between individual structures to reduce conflagration of fire, to provide access to the rear yard for emergencies and to limit the condition of crowding in a residential neighborhood. B. STATED HARDSHIP: "With existing side door steps, I need a 22 foot wide garage for adec�uate storage of cars and other accessories." C. AllMINISTRATNE STAFF REVIIIeT: If the Board approves this request, the staff suggests that the Board stipulate that th e north wall of the proposed garaqe have no openings and that the exterior wall be 5/8 inch type X qypsum board. Pr. and I�ra. Robert 1Ciah2ab� 5312 Altura Road IQ.6. • Fridley, 2� �ere present. Nr. CLrk provided the Comnaiasion a�embera �rith an a�ial phetog�aph. curr�nt pictnrea and. proposed constructi�n pl,ans. ChsirWOman Gabal astasd if ths reducti,on of the garags to a 12 foot x 14 foot storage area �ronl,d allox the building to bs largs enough to b� aonsidared an ae�asory nae so that a apeeial uss per�nit Waa requiredt Mr. Cl,szk eaplained tt�at t�s existing house rrith the proposed addition aT�nost meeta the 2� m�ucimum coverage so to atay under the 25� lot co�rerage Lhat dwelling would iuvs to bs reduoed. Mr. l�ishiah explained that he oaned t�ree vehiclea, snoxmobile� boate� canoes all of xhich require more atorage spacs than he presant�y has. Cisairwomun Gabel astoad about the wir�doxs APPCSAIS COMMI.SSZQN 1rBBTIlQG - JUNE 15. 1962 P1GB 4 in the plana and Mr. Eishiah sxplainsd tbat bs had apolasn xith Mr. CLrk vho a�id that �rirs gLas could b� put in a lir� wll. I+�. lCiahiab ir�dicatsd sn intsreat in using such vindoxs aa ti�at �+�ould allow soae light to oo�s into ths gangs. Ths xind.oi+a in tbs bouss �+ould bs blocbsd oit and gypau�d. He addsd t,i�at a 13 z 16 foot dining arsa wuld bs addsd to the reu o! th� house . Nr. Plsmsl aslosd xho jroold bs doing the �+�ork and 1�4r. 1Ciahiah said bs �rou],d do th� fir�iahing himaslf but nould oontract !or soss o! 1t. ChairWOm�n Gsbel aalosd if Mr. bishish �aight juat tsu tl» sxisting garage doxn and be aaid hs Mou1d. Mr. Barru aalasd if hs siould hav�s sccssa to tbs back yard through a garage door and Mr. 1Ciahish sa3d hs �uld. Chair�roman Gabel aslasd it tb+s aaaie aiding Mou1d bs available and Nr. ]�iaDiab eaLd it was bnt tbat bs iras conaid�ring stuccoing t�s ezt�rior, but �+hatsvsr hs did hs ti+ould slas it conaLt�nt. I�.and Mre. Aadsraon, nsighbors ot the lCiehish'a. �ars salosd to aom� lorrrard. Hrs. Anderson indicatsd tisat tl�ir ao�aplaint Mas tiut tbs addition would �ing it too c2.oae to tt� prop�rt� lins, eapecial]y xith t�s r�of overhang. She alao fslt tbat it tirould cnt the valus of their property to �hich CheirWOman Gabsl responded that Mr. 1Cishish•a i�eproving tiie looks of his property would inorsase� rather tban dscreass� t�he ralus of thsirs. Nr. 1Ciahiah addsd that ths Citsy tlannar aaid he tira�ul,d �nork xith thes on Lndaoaping to laeep ths propsrt,y looking nics. Mr. Anderson addsd tbat hs felt it i+oul,d alao crsats a ratsr Probl�n• Chairrromsn Gabsl aa3d that ev�sn if the vari,ance xxa denied Mr. Kiehiah oould still build the garags just tiro fest ovmr. Shs aalaed Mr. ard l�a. Andaraon if they could discusa thia aith t.he giahiah'a to malae it more paLtab].s and Mra. Anderson aaid t�sy fslt it �as juat too cloas. Appropriate draining should be used. IldTION by Ms. Gerou, aeconded by Mr. Barna� to closs the public hearing. IIPON A VOICE VOTE, ALL YOTIlJG A7fE � CHAIRWOMAN GA�L DECIIRED Tf� POBLIC I�ARING CLOSID AT 8:05 P.M. ChairWOman Gabel astasd ttsat it bs notsd in the record tixt a valid hardship had been establiahed. She aslasd Mr. Clark if tbeewire glass xindowa were aquivalent in safaty wit.h tha tire �rall and Mr. Cl,ark sa3d thep �rere. MOTION bq Mr. Harna. seconded by Mr. Plemel. t�iu►t tbe Appeals Commission recomm�end to the City Council� through the Planniag Comrnisaion� approval of the variance to reduce the side yard setbnck for an attached garage fro�n the requirsd 5 fset to 3 feet� to allox t,he construction of a 22 fest bq 38 feet attached garage on Lot 32, B1ock 6, Carlson's S�mmit l�nor Soutii� tbe saYae being 5312 Altura Road N.E. xith the atipnilation that the north xall be a fire�rall tirith 5/8 inch type x g�rpaum board at�d t,hat ar�q kindoxa in the north �all bs fire safa ateel mesh �indoxa. UPON A VOICE VOTE� ALL VpTING AYE� CH/11RWOMAN GAE�L DECI�RBD THE MOTION CARR� UNANIMOUSLY. 3. APP�AL3 CO�II�iZSSION I�TTIl�iG - JUN� 15. 1962 PAGE S _ by Mr. Plsmsl, ascond�d i� Ms. Gerou� to opsn t.hs publio hsariag. UPON A 1I�IC8 W� � ALL VOTIl�IG AYE, CHADiWOMAN GA�L DBCLAR� T8E AIBL� ATARIl�TG OPEN AT 8:10 P.M. AD�MII�IISTRATIVE S'AFF REppgT 6271 Jackeon Street N.E. A. PUBLIC PUR'POSE SERVED BY RE�UIREMENT: Section 205.053, 4A, requires a front yard setbadc of not less than 35 feet. Public purpose served by this requirement is to allaw for off-street parking without encroaching on the public right of way and also for aesthetic oonsideration t� reduce the buildinq "line of sight" encroachment into the neighbor's front yard. AND/OR Section 205.053, 4B, requires a minimum 10 foot side yard adjoining living area. Public purpose served by this requirement is to maintain a minimum of 20 feet between living areas in adjacent structures and 15 feet between garages and living areas in adjacpnt structures to reduce exposure to conflagration of fire. It is also to allow for aesthetically pleasing open areas around residential structures. B. STATED HARDSHIp; "Only location where I can build a qarage of the size needed." C. ADMINISTR.ATIVE STAF�' REVIF3�T: This home is located at the end of Jackson Street and there are no other hoa►es that front on Jackson south of the petitioner. The petitioner wants to build an attached garage in front of their existing house and have the access door face north and utilize their existing driveway. They would also like to keep th eir exis ting garage of which they will be requesting a special use pexmit. If the front yard varianoe is granted and the special use permit denied, they will then need to corn►ert their exiting garage to living area a�cl they will need a side yard variance for it. If the Board approves these requests, we would reconmiend that no windows be placed on the north Wall of the converted garaqe. Mr..Jamss H. Crosa. 6271 Jackson Street IQ.T.� Fridlay, Hinneaota was present. Mr. Clark auppl3sd Co�owi,ssion membera s+ith aeri,a�l ar�d current photographa of the propert,y. I�. CLrk explained t�hat }�r. G�osa �+ishes to construct a ttiro car garags with the driv�e`ray oi�f to tiae za��th snc�. kaep his exiating garage for miscellaneous atorag�s. Zb do �is he wuld nsed a apecis� nss perait for ths seoond gsrage. I�lr. Clark auggeatad that the Co�isaion membera deal With ��tch issuss aeparate�r� ge aaid that the northerly neighbor had called and ataf.ed they s+�ould rather sse the old garage left as a garage and not �de into living quarters. Mr. Croas aai,d t�hat although they plan t,o build a doubl.e garage tiysy APPEAIS COI�IISSI�ON I�ETIldG - JONT 15. 1962 PAGE 6 intsnd to inatall a siaals door at�d uae it for storags. Chait-�roman Gabel aalaed Mr. Crosa to eatahliah tha bardahip ard hs aa3d hs has tbree vshicles� a camping trailrsr. bca` trailsr and a singL �angr. Isr. Cross aaksd tbat the variance requeat to reduce the aide yard sstback from 10 fNt to 5 feet on tbe living aide of the dwelling eo the eaisting garage can be convsrtsd to living area bs atruck from the r�queat. Hs atated that tbey sitber wnt to go ai�ead rlth tWO gsrages and obtain a speci,al use permit or stay xith xhat they have nox. $e added t�at ths majority of the work �ould bs done by themaelvea. Cbairrroann Gabsl ir�dicated that there �+aa no one �aho �rould be impacted by tbe viaval change becauae of xhere t,be d�wlling ia located. 1+lOTmN by Mr. Plemel� seQOnded by Ma. Gerou� to close tbe public hearing. UPON A ViOICE VOTE �ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRWOMAN GAHEL �CURID TI� PUBLIC HEARING CLOSID AT 8i2? P.M. Zbs hardship eatablished ia the need !or storage of v�ehicles. ?�DTION by Ms. Gerou. aeconded by Mr. Plemel� to grant the variance request to reducs t�e front yard setback from the required 35 ft. to 11 ft. to allow ti�e aonat,ruction of a 22 ft. by 24 ft. attached garage� aubjec� to tbe approval of ~ a speci,al nse permit for a ascond asseaaory building at 6271 Jackaon Street N.E., �idley� Minnesota. UPON A VOICE YOTE� ALL VOTING AYB, CHAIEtWOMAN GASEL DDCLARSD TAE MOTION CAR.RI�D UIQANINIOUSLY. MOTION by Ma. Gsron� secordsd by Mr. Barna� to der�y t.i�e requeat to reduce the - side yard setback from 10 feet to S fest on the living aida of the dwelling� ao the existing garags can be conwrted to living area on �ot 4. Block l. Irsne H�nry Addition� ti�e aa�oe bsir�g 6271 Jackson Street NE� baaed on t,be petitioners request and the neighbor's objectiona. UPON A VOICE VO�� ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRWOMAN GABEL DECLA.RID THE MOT7AN CARRIED U1�tAN]I�pUSLY. • wi�; : t, i Chair�roman Gabel requeated that Mr. Clark hav�e avai].ahle for each Commisaion member at the next meeting a copy of the mecoorandum dated Auguat 2� 1979� from Mr. Hereck to the Fri�dlsq City Council ti+hich dealt �rith variance information. Chair�roman Gabel addressed the aubject of having a hsrxiout avail.able for people coa�ing into Mr. Clark's office on hox to prepare for an appe�►rance before the Appeala Coeanisai,on. I4r. Clark aaid that he does indicate to people hor to prepars. but it the Commisaion desired he �+�ould drar up a short checkliat for paople to fo]1ow (i.e. have other altsrnatfves bean conaidered� what ia t�he hardahip� and xhat to expect). � � � 1: J�� ON bpr Hr. Barna. seconded by Mr. Plemel, to ad jo�nrtz. UPON A YOICE YOTE � AI.L YOTING AYE � CHAIi�WOMAN dA�I, DECLARED THE APPEAIS COMMISSION METTING OF JUNE 15, 1982 � ADJWRNFsU AT. 8:45 P.M. Pat Von rbach Reaording Seoretsry OOiUNCIL l�:ETII�1G �' J[A,Y 26, 1982 PAGE 2 � �— Mr. Flora, Public Works Director, stated this lot fs the last lot on Jackson Street and is a deaciend street with a cul-de-sac. He stated the petitioner is requesting a�ecial use petmit for oonstruction of a second garage. Mr. Flora stated the original plan was for the petitioner to convert the existing garage into living space, however, he now requests the use of both garages for storage purposes. Mr. Flora stated the Planning Crnmiission has recommended aproval of this special use permit-to allow the construction of a second accessory builaing. - MOTION by Counclman Schneider to concur with the recmamendation of the Planning Caimiission and grant special use penait, SP #82-08 to allow for the construction of a second accessory building at 6271 Jackson Street. Seconded by Councilman Barnette. Upon a v�oioe v�ote, all voting aye, Mayor Nee declared the motion carried unanimously. Mr. Flora statecl, in conjunction with approval of the request for a special use permit, a variance is requested to reduce the front yard setback fram the required 35 feet to 11 feet. MOTION by Concilman Schneider to concur with the recammendation of the Appeals Carnnission and grant the varianoe to reduce the front yard setback fram the required 35 feet to 11 feet. Seconded by Councilman Barnette. Upon a voice wte, all voting aye, Mayor Nee declared the motion carried unanimously. 2�?. ooNSm�� oF vp,�crioN �vF.sr, sp,v :si-oa � v�� s-rREer x�cx�- OF—in�Y AT 56 00 4�1 SPRE�T ZV ALIAW �iE OONSI�t[)CPION OF A F�WI�PLF�lC BY S& R INVESZMIIar OON4PANY: MOTION by Counci].man Bamernik to set the public hearing on this vacation .request for August 16, 1982. Seoonded by Counci].man Scxu�eider. A gentlenan representing S& R Investment Company stated the variance doesn't really have anything to do with the building permit. ee stated their plan was to have attached garages, which would have been on part of the setback, but then the City decided they would rather have tuck-under garages. He stated they have changed the plan and will have tuck-under garages arx3, therefore, w�ouldn't be on part of the serback. Mr. Flora, Public Works Director, stated a portion of the parking lot would be on the property requested to be vacated, therefore, it would be associater7 with the building permit. Mayor Nee stated, if this is the case, they can't preempt this vacation proceeding. Upon a voice vote on the above motion, all voting aye, Mayor - Nee declard the motion carried unanimously. 2 v F'ROM APPEALS 1KEETING OF J�JE 15, 1982 — OONSIDERATION OP' A VARIANCE - ------ � ALIAW �NSTRiI(,TION OF A 22' X 38' AZTACHID G1�RAGE AT 5312 � ALZURA RQAD N. E., R(JBE�T G. RISHISH: _ ,: QOUNCIL MEE.TING OF JtJI.Y 26 , 1982 PAGE 3 � Mr. Flora, Public Works Director, stated this is a request to reduce the side yard setback for an attached garage framthe required five feet to three feet to allaw the construction of a 22 x 38 foot attached garage at 5312 Altura Road N. E. Mr. Flora stated, during discussions, it was found there was too much square footage on the property and, therefore, the petitioner will remove part of the existing garage, leaving a 12 x 14 foot storage shed for the property. Mr. Flora stated one neighbor objected to this variance, as she felt the roof would be too close to the property line, and result in a devaluation of her property. Mr. Flora stated the Appeals Canmission has recommended approval of the variance with the stipulation that the north wall be a f irewall with 5/8 inch type x gypsum board and any windows on the north wall be fire safe steel mesh. Councilman Fitzpatrick stated the Appeals Commission unanimously recaim�ended approval of this variance in spite of the objection of the affected neighbor. He pointed out the varianoe is only for two feet and is prepared to recatunendation. Councilnan Fitzpatrick stated he believed the person who objected, and the petitioner, were both present his evening. Mrs. Harold Ar�erson, 5342 Altura Road, stated she felt the roof lines w�ould be too close together. She further stated there would be a problem with the snaa and a lot of m�isture in the basement. Mr. Fora stated the plans indicate a roof overhang of 18 inches beyond the wall. Mr. Rishish stated the roof line follaws the existing line so he felt any snaw would either go forward or back and wouldn't build up between the houses. Councilman Barnette asked Mrs. Anderson if she had problens with drainage. Mrs. Anderson stated she had not, but guessed others had problems, and was sure the houses would be too close and would cause water in the base�nnent. Councilman Barnette stated he felt the drainage could be taken care of so water wouldn't drain tawards Mrs. Anderson's house. Mr. Rishish stated the natural drainage pattern now tends to be to the back of the lot. Mr. Nee stated, overall, this looks like a good improvement and this addition voulc3 be built, without a variance, if it was two feet shorter. Mrs. Anderson stated she was aware of this, but two feet was two feet. She stated she felt the improvesnent was an advantage for Mr. Rishish, but not for them. OOUNCIL I�ETING OF JULY 26, 1982 PAGE 4 Councilman Fitzpatrick stated he can sympathize with Mrs. Anderson's objection to having this building close to the property line, however, he w�ould have to concur with the recomner�dation of the Appcals Catmission. MOTION by Councilman Fitzp�atrick to ooncur with the recommendation of the Appeals oaQnission to grant a variance to reduce the side yard setback for an attached garage fran the required five feet to three feet to allow construction of a 22 x 38 foot attached garage with the stipulation that the north wall be a firewall with 5/8 inch type x gypsum board and that ariy windaws in the north wall be fire safe steel mesh windows. Seconded by Counci]man Schneider. Counc].man Barnett� stated he grew �p in Minneapolis where the houses were close together and doesn't remenber any problems with drainage. Mrs. Anderson stated the averhang would be right on top of her fence. Mr. Flora stated the averhang will be 1-1/2 feet inside the property line. Councilman Schneider asked if Mr. Rishish's contractor indicated any problem with the fence, and Mr. Rishish stated he hadn't noted any problens. Councilman Hamernik suggested possibly adding a stipulation that this addition woulan't disrupt any drainage flow that is currently existing. Mr. Kishish stated this would be satisfactory if they can establish what is cvrrently existing. Ae stated he has never seen water come to the back of his house. Councilman Barnette asked if he ever had water in his basement. Mr. Rishish stated he has because af a cracked foundation, which he hopes to correct, but there was no water in the basement because of the manner in which the water drains. UPON A VI�ICE VOTE TAKIIV ON �IE ABOVE MOTION, all voted aye, and Mayor Nee declared the m�tion carried unanimously. The Council received the minutes of the Planning Caiuni.ssion Meting of July 14, 1982. 3 OONSIDERATION OF AN �1GRE�'1II�]T WITH DIARRF.L A. FARR DEVE�APME3�Tr OORPORATION FOR B�I�ACR FORRFST l�ARZMIIV'I5: Mr. ¢i�eshi, City`Manager, stated the development agreement provided by the Darrel Farr;�Corporation indicates they had a mortgage ca�nitment prior to the effectiv�e date of the City's ordinance regarding a moratorium on condacninivan ooizversions. Mr. Qureshi.` statec] the staff, with the help of Councilman Schneider, worked with the Farr Corporation to work out certain oonditions which gave additional cons,ideration to the existing renter�. Councilman Schnei.der stated that State law on .condominium conversions preempts the City's.,authority and, as the development agree�ment indicates, Farr Corporation had obtained a mortgage cansnitrnent'�prior to the effective date of the City's ordinance. � - CITY OF FRIDLEY 6431 UNIVERSITY AVENUE N.E., FRIDLEY, MINNESOTA 55432 TELEPHONE ( 612)571-3450 CIT1' COU��r,IL July 30, 1982 Robert�G. Kishish 5312 Altura Road N.E. Fridley, MN 55421 ACTIO�J TAY.EN fdOTICE On Jul_y 26, 1982 , the Fridley City Council officially arproved your requesi for variance to reduce side vard setback from the required v��ith the sti pul ati ons � i sted bel o��: 5 feet to 3 feet, NONE If you have an,y questions regarding the above action, plezs� call the Co��nity Developr�ent Office at 571-3450. JLB/de Si.ncereiy, ��_ - RROLG L . BOAROhiAN City Plarner Please revie�� the noted stipulations, siqn the stater�ent below, and ret�rr. one copy to the City of Fridley. Concur with acti�n taken. 0 ��-, � I,�_? , � }, -- O �J 'O ;;� I---- - _ . _ _ i i l , ' �.� ; �� ; `,� ; N , � ... __ _ ___._.__._� _� i2o` �, � s�� f�� r !�i � U � _ �,-(� `� -._ _ _._ . ! ` � a" 3 E� ' T' a N � C�' i �„e� � � " � �p�OSE� � pD � � `> �'✓,.. ` `.� � 3't"1— �� K . - , � ± , � N L �s' � K i ��-� . _ . Sf�ps �, . ,, .. �. ,. � �'_ � �� 1 -� ��' . -- - - -,� ' �' 7� Lv . � � .. �- • _� � iµ .. . . � . .. . . . ' I �, ,. -�. �"�''"'`''� � :- � + �,--, � � I6 � N r �� n � � � ��J 'u R 7 r i '�. •., � .•:, � �= ` i _ . . , . . � , i - -. �� 1 �;:' _ _ _ �{ , ` _ _!i � � ` = -ti._ _ __ ___ __ _._.� - _ � ----.._._� - --- -- -�~ � .�. C.�� /?r+, �twri z f� � . �. Q.+I �%� i�'`" �' FF C ^ .�11 � i-: �}" ... � l��l ��..�yy�M. ___.__.__________. --_ __. .. . . _ -- .. . _ � �7' __ _._.___ .. _.___ _ ___ ---- —. � � , _ . . �, . ' . . � — - �� ' � ;, SGA:�� I ,�� _ ' �,� � � �. M ;� �, �,:•.'.3 . , � � : _ � {' . . ; :, ., , , � � . ;t:�� , - � �- ; :, I'.>_ �' a.rJa ! 11L.� � �,�:^._.,. ,. _ ,s ;.. _ � '� ' � �' . ',, _ . , r,� ��; >.• ' r.',. . �. 7 • r}}} : � s �� 1 � . . .. . . >: . . 4 � �r K .. - . „S;� . � fI.�N t1 . . .. . . . . - . .. . : � . f( V ' � � S r�� . � 4 � �y • � � . . . IMi " � � � 4 . � { S .� d 1 .. +. . .. _ . . . _. - . T � � .. ( . . •'1 . •� . .. - . � 4 � # . , '�� , i�� :, , . a �`° � E � 1 . ' ` � c .`� �i ��iY�oP� . � + ; ' �i�►'� j � � � �lPD�aSE� � . � � � ' ` � �" � � �: � 3."1 ° �'�' , _ - I � � •:. `..�1 --a � �Y � : , � , , � � r � , � -' > _ � . 3�ePs K _ - f. �: >: ; %� " y �.`�' ' ,* t ; � , ` �. >. , ,_ ? °�'�' ¢ . - _. �' _�.' � .. , , , j .. ``��7,' r �.` . : � �s � � �� : •; , %; -- � . - • __ , - , • N . . y-.'.y . . . _ . .' ._ _ . . . . . , � . � ' � '. � Z.L`�J � .. � . . .. - . . . . , . . . . . , a i;� � ' �� , �:� 1 �1 , * .. • � 4� i �,._; �- , � , . _ � � , _ ;: } � � SJ � � r 4 ;v �` , � '^ ' d .J � � r r: '..� � !j C , , ;� �, ` � � � . Y`.'_,.'j � � � � .. . . � . j � - f , i��y ' e. �,i . -� - aJ . . .._. .- ; . {�. ` . � . .. . .. . 4l3 . . . . . ��- l � '�° - � .�,� �.-. .�,. ,�.e. � . . � -e_ �.. � � ��..�� .� � � � � . .. �. � �•i ��.y q I �^.. . :v.""_" .. ^ . . � .�s! . . .� , i �..7 � � �. � ." --' r; � � �..✓ 1'"i � i r . - �- r:,• c •-: � � � i e 3� �'1 ` ._ , 1 . .i i , J�� , � � , ' 1 ;- ; �� - -r� � J ��'} °� ° 4 ' T �/ . I' . . :'� � )' �� T .. ' . !s .'` ' . t. � " . �. a . �� t_ �l . . � �,� i; ' .. . , � Q . r. . t; :..� . � . 1 f_. . . . ' � . i� : , I i i: � , =: � '�-'��---^^.� f z� �2�' : �� ?i�l.pv ��G�_ .... �et_ r+:'.,:�i: 1:....e_..�...�. ....'n�..._, . ... ..��t= _._. _��`r- -- �' �. • �� . � ,. .d � l " _ r " ' � . � ' ,_ , � . • . _ _ ' �/ - - _ - -- :- "--_._. !,�. _ e ..,.�..,.. _. . _... ....., �.iit��J� _'-'_-"° ' , i��:, ._�'........:... C . �._� _ � 1::�'....°iG._ <.�d .7......s..�_.. �.,C -._ ��... "✓ . .�.�i._.1 __- ' +.4 ... .�_"v , :1a.1 • ... _ .Urd' .....9 . ..� .. _a ¢ ., .. .. _ :�.�...1 _� = e . r° _ - .� .�r ..._ � ��v��lJGvl�: ..-. t...J.'�. � �...�. .v�. �...��.ee. �.edsi�.w�r�'.=id., � , " �. � (�� .v'+a.!�-c+`_..- '.� . . ... ' � ... . . ' . '� -�-,+-+�—�..� .....�..t....--�._.i......m-4 . . '° . ..��.�.{_�_.�- . . . _.� _...... _ '.. "' ' -.� "'_ .. . .... . _.. ..� .. . .__ .-.�_�...�....w��.��...�� ...r�. ......�.._. � � � �o�A-r ��;N �� .� 'tir�Y N r 4 :..a... �. o ;..�:: �. ,,..� �.. 4 Yr�� {1 s to�uwu 1 c ME�arts STR�Ei k1A.P-CITY OF FRIDLEY- �� e � ;�"�'.� � � ,�. ; ,' . � �v��"°" � � �� ,� � �S �'s. ,€' �"a, �� :��: a, g�� ' � �� A�� . � � � � �$ �� a �� - . .&�. ; -, '' � � �. ' ' a.c ,�.� � m. � �� _ '�a �Y � 4 ; �ry ��k�€ � ,��;1 � � •�#• �.� 3 i n4� F9 � . �� ,�� r 3,'@*�' � �. �, �' � 3 34= �� d � �[ � , T 5 � �s �`t +%� .. , . � , �"�.�d:�. � � . '�.. �+ � � � , � : . . . . t _ ' i= � � At3a � � ` '� ,.,�.._r�. �w ._. ,., � � � - � �- � ..�,.,�,.. ��.+.-..: .k .�..s. . . � . . . . , .l1+e:+•..� ..,..,.,-.-..m,-�r.+.,r*.,.,,.,-.., .. ,�, _ .. . � � :� y � �p�� ro...; � _ �'� - ; , ,� � A �t � " ��. .� � ... - � � �� . � �� . � i , Y�� '"F': S � ,� .�{ r�s .t' ,� s-�+W,�$ "a "�°`'� . � �' � ��,� � ; . � � s• s ; �� r a � � " � g `� ��' ,� _ � �' � .� �`� �i � �. _ `��^� ,, a � �. a. ma�a _ . _ ��+� �" �� .�. � ,� , �. �r�i:� f �,r;, ,;.., �r` h$��a�� s � .� ��"� r �+�� , � �.,��,�i�—�� ..,. , e . , , �' �ti ,.� , �' �� °��;;i: