The URL can be used to link to this page

AF-V - 35000. ,� ,� _ �_ UTYOF FRtDLEY CIVIC CENTER • 6431 UNIVERSITY AVE. N.E. FRIDLEY, MINNESOTA 55432 • PHONE (612) 571-3450 ;'•_ j /� •� :�1 •► :. ► ►�/ On Tuesday, August 11, 1987, the Fridley Appeals Commission officially appraved your request for variances, VAR #87-28. by Willia�n P'gckey, pursuant to Qiapter 205.07.03, D, 1, af the Fridley City Code, to reduce the front yard setback f ran 35 feet to 28 feet to allaa the v�nstruction of an addition to the c�rage; and, pursuant to Chapter 205.07.03, D, 3a, of the FridlEy City Code, to reduoe the rear yard setback fran 28 feet to 15 feet to allaw the o�nstructi� of a three-season porch on Lot 3, Block 3, Innsbruck North Addition, the same being 5660 Arthur Street N.E., Fridley, Minnesota, 55432, with the f oll aa ing sti pul ati ons: - I�NE - If the work has not commenced within one (1) year after granting this varianoe then the varianoe shall beo�ne null and void. If you have any questions regarding the above action, please call the Planning Deg3rtment at 571-3450. Sincer ely, Darrel C1ark Chief Building Official Please revi�a the mted stipulations, sic� the statement belaw, an8 return one oop� to the City of Fridley Planning Department by August 26, 1987. I� , v�ncur with the action taken. f . COMNMSSI4N APPLICATION REVIEW _ Fil• Dat� Me•tinp Dat• p�psrtm�nt Numb�� C'-�� Planning 66 7/17/87 8/11/87 FRlDLEY F��• Addr�ss/D�scrlptlon �� #87_28 COMPLETE REVIEW CHECKLIST wi��iam Mackey RETURN TO PLANNING 5660 Arthur Street � COMMENTS � �1`�RA ---DEBBIE �i M �� '"y"'�l �°N"`� �s .��r1� ,, s:d�. ya„�c .�.dt .�� J � �� tb �g r►of •. uo.v�+�KC.t . --DEBBIE OHN �/ �DEB IE � RREL EBBIE CLYDE DEBBIE IARK DEBBIE EON �-zg DEBBIE -- CiTY OF FRli�t.�"'"'� _ . . ea�� u�tv�smr �►v� N.�. : V�►�� . .'` ��"#` #�tfl��:: pY�i�1.EYr.�. F►54$�,t ., ,� : ` ` , - � � ' � '�? '�:�.'` `� "� ' 4 C"r0 � a �,a�. te i 2l si i*"��so . -. 'ti: '',� . : � , � ` . � � \ �`��' �,f `�� } �,a.�, '�;,�, 7'��-'"•-i��.� �� " t � , k1 �a . . . . , . � �t` .. ` . ~ � 51/�'�� c � � �' �. i �'i; � �ti' ` ti* --`t ,�;� �� '� "'`^�, . �i��ir�'i ��i�i'M �{+�' �� ' I�E� \ a � �S,"� a"-� ti:�� , � � t � � ,�.' � � . � � 3CHEDULED �tF'�$AL� ��T�# Dli� �i� � � .� PR�ERT1��#�#�R�11�'�1� � � .,� +�- ' � ''' �,'��`1` `, i ��;; � '� �. �; � �`` ��` � � � , �� ;�. �_ ' �� _ . � �y1 PRQBE��. hDDRFSSy: ; • ��. , . > - ' ; ,, �- . :,_ , ,,, , � .e �. �, , ,� . + � -.� _ �;-, ' 'e �. ,. , l � ,��,:. � ,\ "� `, - .�, � ,,. LDGAI. DES�RIPTIQ�: � . � ..:;, \ '.L _ � . . _ ;� . •. Lfl1�`" �,3 `'�LO�f �� ,�' : �R�CT/1�3TTI61�` ��''��.' " : t . .. ;� - , - � , PRESE1dT ZON ' �`�' . . �'� _ -�jC.�'' ;;� `•� -� �. ' '� �.,, ��, �,��`�,, � �� ,� .,�, `. � VARIANCE R�7QiTEST(S); 6tta� a pla� +or s�rey of the pr�ertg shcr�i� building, vari�ce{�), wYtere applicable. ,�,,, � �'" � � � J�! J!� �� .� � i . . _ � ✓ Section of the Code: t"'a'v �, v�, y 3o�.d�� 3 a List sgecific h�°d�p{s) which � e qu�re t� #�s�ssf= .,rs�t�*�s�r��t�t��s��s� F � � '� �� "��;� ��'� � �IAME (please priat}��/j��,,�._� �� . _ , , _�t . . . . N?�RE3S .3� szcxA�x� . � !$' � 3 s�...�.�k.. ��'��: �� a:�,+e��: s+�� s�f � � �►+►. r PHOi� �� ..�'iS _ note to rw��i��''��i�r�+►��.�+�+�r�'a��i��.�'��+��s�.�s +rs�r�rs�t� _PETIT#C�� 1NF�aATi�f NAI� f Please print ) �� Iu.�'t''�„ PH4118 I1DD�S - -- — - ------- - -- — -- -- SIG�dTURE DiITE _ ��f�ss�f�a��+t��fsttsss��.s��#��ts��t�sf�f#sstt�s+��#�+i►�►_�t+tf�r�tias��s�t��s+�s��f�rs APPEALS COt�lIS3IQA1: APF�fN�D �... D�IiEA ...�._ D��E '�� CITY COUiICZL: SPFBQi►�D .�_, DF1ixBD � D�TS ' STI�1L11TIODIS: � �- _ . � -�---- r ;�� r� � � �ss � ; ;} � �' i .:.. 7 . _i . . . * " �:�.;� �s R #�T� �i�� i9i/�°s �r��° 1��' �D�'�,�. �-4��'"�� , �� {.-�� %/�'e %'�� e�� _ . i,R�. 'f �.:; t�:.' � �/ / /%l/�`/ �^ '� ,��` ,,,l.r/`ll�iY�� -�'�� 'G� �G � ` ��; ; � _ . � . :�: r� . /�� . � . � ��1✓c � �',;��:�� ,�%l�� -� .� �� ;�: � _ � �. . _ � �. _ t� '°� , �� J�� `� .� `� �; �� .��5 . �/ / � ��i�� ' � , ' � »� �r � /_� , � � Dy.��' �� . � yi `�r��` � ..,��: _ . �� . ,��j��i�- ��c ��.�. r �t�'r��'°� r : . � tµ ;�_ _ .s . �� Y ± . . �..2� � �.. '�q . 4�, 1.��c. 4 -,. . _. . �� A.. '� � � . � .. . . . . . . . . .. �1.- . . p .� i \. � �� . i t ' s: , .. � . � . , !a .�h .. '� '�. � " �� . � �'� `� . . .. .t. .! � . r. . � � ' � �. T . ,, � � tr'Y .. . l. ` , • , . � C.i ;.. ". . . � . . ,a:, .. . .:. , � . . • "sy � ` ' ' .,� i -, � . �,5., ,,, . �y.� � . � . '..' . . x 9&, -•: �', .n .. ��,Ta"A.'ae -`�' �n ,i `s . .. 6, C �::. .. .. � . .. ...:: �. ..�' . ."'�,.., . a . , , . . . ' .. �., ..-� `..�.,. �� ... . e .. . ' %, ''� . , � s�' �„�,.. ��j�4� v;-�v. �' . _ ..o-' .. _ , � 4, �� z, . : ; ' - , - %�'.? . .<.�` <z.ft� �. i �;-� ..r. _• � " ��. a's � . t� � � < �. .. : _ _ _ . , �: , _ } . � 4�.�T . .� _ ' i . a t . - � � . . ... �' �'. f . . .i . ...�� ...�.. . .. .,.. . .. . ._ ._ ,........�... ..... .�.�. �4 '..��.: �... . ... . � . . . �'�. ..,., . `. , � � t i•'-•.� h'� , � . "•: -- � . _ ' . . ..: : . . - . -. _ .. ... .... � -�.. ... _ .,.... . .. .. . ...._.. -. . � �.... . . .. . �. .:r . "t.. . �. Y '- .. i _ .� _. . ' E . - . z _ a . r +'{� . _. _ . " if'" ' 1' ';=.'YC. ' xi: ��#!� �� , . . "'� % . .o , . � . � .: ? 3 •n , _ _.:_:,_ . . . _ . %4 +. . . . . . _ . . .. ., . .. _. _. . �-� . _�w � . .� � . .... . .... . .. � . :t�. . ,. . � . ..- s�. �-� . .. - - . � � � . i, i n .�� . � . . . ' . �. . . _ _ CITYOF FR[DLEY CIVIC CENT'ER • 6431 UNIVERSITY AVE. N.E. FRIDLEY, MINNESOTA 55432 • PHONE (612) 571-3450 NJTICE OF PUBLIC HF�1RIl� Notive is hereby giv� that the Appeals Commission of the City of Fridley will oonc�ct a Public Hearing in the City Council Chanbers at 6431 University Avenue Northeast at 7:30 p.m. on Tuesday, August 11, 1987, in regard to the fallawing matter: � Consideration of a variance requ�est, VAR �87-28, by William Mackey, pursuant to Cnapter 205.07 .03 , D, 1, of the Fr i dl ey City Code, to reduoe the front yard setback from 35 feet to 28 feet to allaw the construction of an addition to the garage; and, pursuant to Chapter 205.07 .03 , D, 3a, of the Fridley City Code, to reduoe the rear yard setback f rom 28 feet to 15 feet to allc�w the v�nstruction of a three-season porch, on Lot 3, Block 3, Innsbruck North Addition, the same being 5660 Arthur Street N. E. , Fridley, Minnesota, 55432. Natioe is hereby giv� that all persons having an interest therein will be giv� the opport�mity to be heard at the abave time and plaoe. �• • � : • � « . �. ,. . .. . �• � � �• Nate: The Appeals Co�nission will have the final action on this request, tmless there are obj ections f rom surrotuldinq nei ghbor s, th e Ci ty Staf f, or the petitioner does not agree with the Commission's decision. If any of these ev�ts occur, the request will oontinue to the City Council throuc� the Planning Conmission with only a revo�ene.rx7ation from the Appeals Coa�anission. Rasheed Kahn 1455 North Innsbruck Drive Fridley, 1�flV 55432 Marlin Rekow 1467 N. Innsbruck Drive Fridley, MN 55432 James Alexander 1481 No. Innsbruck Dr. Fridley, I�IIV 55432 Orlin Wicks 1495 No. Innsbruck Dr. Fridley, MN 55432 Surendra Chaudhary 5640 North Danube Road Fridley, MN 55432 Teresa ICpller 1498 North Danube Road Fridley, r�A1 55432 Robert Swanson 1480 North Danube Road Fridley, MN 55432 MAILING LIST VAR #87-28 Keith Harstad 2121 Silver Lake Road Fridley, I�IlV 55432 Cheryl Nybo 1612 Berne Circle Fridley, 1�IN 55421 James Johnson 5657 North Danube Road Fridley, NAi 55432 Timothy Redfield 5643 North Danube Raad Fridley, MNii 55432 M Diocese of St. Paul Totino-Grace High School 1350 Gardena '�tvenue Fridley, MN 55432 Judith Hoggatt 5688 Arthur St. N.E. Fridley, MN 55432 Milton Bullock 5674 Arthur Street Fridley, NMI 55432 Appeals 7/29/87 Dua.ne Narog 1465 North Danube Road Fridley, MN 55432 Arthur Hartley 1479 North Danube Road �ridley, I�Ai 55432 John 0'Brien 1453 No. Danube Road Fridley, MN 55432 Clifford Egeland 1513 Trapp Court Fridley, I�HV 55432 Dale Lindquist 1511 Trapp Court �ridley, MN 55432 David Anderson 1517 Trapp Court Fridley, I�INN 55432 Anthony lNoj ciak 1515 Trapp Court Fridley, MN 55432 Lowell Mellum William Ma.ckey Lowell Russell 1464 North Danube Road 5660 Arthur St. 5680 West Bavarian Pass Fridley, NW 55432 Fridley, MN 55432 Fridley, MN 55432 John lacarella 5686 W. Bavarian P ass Fridley, MN 55432 Item #1, August 11, 1987 A�MIIJLS7�TIVE STAFF REEOdtT 5660 AR7�itAt SZRF�P N. E. VAR �87 28 A. P[�LIC PURI�0.SE SIIrVID BY R�UII2�1'P: Sectio�n 205.07.03, D, l, requires a frorit yard setback of r�ot less than 35 feet. Public purp�se served by this requirenent is to allaw for off-street parking without encraaching on the public right o�-way and als� for the aesthetic consideration to reduce the building "line of sight" encroac�nnent into the r�eic�bor's frorit yard. Sectian 205.07.03, D, 3a, requires a rear yard setback of not less than 25$ of the lot depth. Public purpose served by this requirenent is to provide rear yard sgac�e to be used for green areas which enhance the r�eighborhood. B. STPf�ED HARD�b'HIP: 'fihe hardship arises because the lat is a corner lot and the lwilder diose to plaoe the house in an imusual position on the lot. Rather than glacing the house square with the street he angled it sideways. Zhis p�sitioning makes it impossible to meet the setback requiranerits." C. AL!lINIS'7itA�IVB SPAFF REVffi�T: This lot is a oorner lot and either street could be considered its frontage because �e length of lot an each street is within 108 of each ather. Arthur Street was selected as its frontage since the original house met the setback requireaerit fo� frorit yard setback. The boulevard width on Arthur Street is 16 feet, therefore, if the garage addition is allawed the new corner of the garage would be 44 feet fram the curb. 7.he garac�; door faoes rortheast. 7xie groposed additi� in the rear yard will be 30 feet f rom the house to the rear. If the Appeals Commission approves this variance the staff has no stipulations to suggest. 42 l.r.�.+sic i .wr- �� i �t�, � . _ l �---- � �� w_ .� w+� � , s O � ■ .• lNIIyS�ilCK Y/X1AG �IPD ADlO/T/ON a ; �.�,�-« . � . '(�� :� J:` f'�'�� ---j - - - t; -� -�-� r � ;� �n, �w.w.i � � %.+7�r'� w , p� � "`' ��, r1�) i' I;�. � li►� ` �,;' , t''�"'r,s,' `•�• a '�� '""." � �rf �♦ 6 t y? l� �'• �.f !Li ��i l.�i� �! r .f �':.. �,•�,�,;�i 1 t- (�: � ! (� ��.� �� i � ; r,� t � � : � � �, .� +` �,� y, � `� � ��> >,� � � ` � `' � � j Y`' �• � � l%JyJ }�0� � !� � ��> w 3 ,Z l.r1 � r'�.�:r' i...;v� � t �Y� �/��1� i � .:� (/ . �'� �`•E � ;� � E � i ' �s ��:� , . :a �� , �,,.,�- .,��, ''�� r /y) �:.�� ,�. �,� T l ; s +, 4 � s Z !: s i ,c '�1 s \ ' ! 4 � , � �� ? . ' � �� + �� ` \� , � �S�` C�) V � �� , . ,i�� 1 "� �` � ,t �li) ti �`•'„ '�-:. w l� , � ..,�' � , " � �� .� ,r (�� , �.. � ' 'P�1��. t � •��; � r; II .` 'i (1`) +-°� � a � + � ,�� i• �. 1 •� �' • � � " +• yt (� : � ' � ' 1 � �� \ � b� � � i 1 �� / � •"., , � ! , / � �� !fy t // +� � ! l'�� ) � ��.� �� s �� f , K .� � 4.r t� � �j .. : 9 r � r �� * �. �� t� ' �� +t�� ;;. . �; `� `�;i� � i . � { ��,,� � a� 7%�.� �,r�� .; r � (3 G� �. � r i ip) � � �O k ,f�(�►� ' f N .� � s `�- � �� PMII�K �QK /NNSBI�'!CI 2N0 Ad � � in•rr� / � �.►1 .� �cc1�I l �Vv � I t I� 4� • f •� 1 �' � �> � � � 1 � t �� , � ►� , , , i � �� . Z t K�' 1.t r � '� : 1 / � � � •'�� j �' . �✓ + d � t j I / � � i -- • � � � --- t : - � �� ' - � � � � � � ... _ . .. � .... . .... � - �.-�RTH-�_..�;.�:.. � -- . _�. :� oa ti � `3 � , • ► a��y�� I � ��• :�: � . fr..'.�i� ' y Y..,� � ��/��w��i ��. � . J LOCATtON MAP . 6 � �� • � �7� y - P , - , :� P /, �t " '" �t K oa�� '� zr a� ri t [ ;,," �� H� t,CREST lE, L• 2 � ��/ r n �E : J�. � �t �' f �.� �i�' 1� ac .; ��, p, ,�� sr EL LA D N j 2 L " � �' `•3 ' � F,ai H .� AD ,wr �,. -��_ f �j� �' , e� --� — � �6 � � 0 ) ! , .� � ,, ,� � ! � �; ,�� ;... . ...II_► : ., `�.� � �� ' � .�� t�.. �, I��, � ��Q�. � �� .��.�."'i-�n��a� �v• i 3 3 jO � 4.�� 3 �• -- + � �a. � ' GRACE H/G'H r� a<. { �� : , - l 1 � s � � i Z � � , �1 �. _ . � `I 3 ,2 / � � � N OR'�!:' ^ � ;_` 9 SCHOOL ADD/T/ON r•- !� � P h�C :�� w'�, ;� = — �-. �-- . � '�g �. _ _ , ,a ; ,� � � �1 Q � `,,:� �..> :., � ` 11 1 (.,� � �,? �' 2 ,a� ' ,�ws,e� `' ',� �� 1 vw. �, t ' • �� - a+o.ao /' �.._ ' ' . . . -.4c �147 / 2 3 t S �� 7�B �IN 1 � � •• � ••�•• �•�•�•�•• i1 q u � ' S • • •�•�.�•�•�.�.�� " R • • • • • • • • � , 2 • i z , � �2 ; • � • � • �1 • • • • �3 z4 ,� n . . . d1,�lo� • . • 3 � � 5 ♦ ,� •l, • � • • • � • • t ,� • • • • • �5� � , ,, '� , , ,e � 1 ; � .� ��.. . �. �. �. ,9 . ,: 3 �S u T ,� � ,*�r .k. . . . ., ..... �� ` � ,g , ,c ♦ H � �Z • ► � • • s • • • • - _ i� • • • • • • 2. 9 5 : � L 5 5 • •� • • � • • • • • • • • • 3 � ,. �S F � a � , ; C'� � » • . . . • #-- - i♦ � _ ` ' ' 4 s � � ' Oq � �, . 3 2 / E 0 5 3 , L ••• • /I I 6 4 ^_1 � ') � l K .1 � ' �r' • ; � •• R � � ...r� � S�� ¢ N � ., s it = . �• � • • �� 4 j �� 4' ;;��.: b , s1t . . � �C � b � 3 .,... � '.�• • ��, - 2 n '�� ' • • • • • � ,o � s 9 �� 3 . 1 ' . 5 " .:FARR. ,� , � � 5 . 6 . . ,� , �+.:.�'!!:!�E. . . �• S z5 3 .�� 7 � i �...�:� • • • O LAKELA �s i ; . �-^ �. . ,� t • • � z n. ^� T ;�,"�:;,`''' •_ ' ' ��' - �- ✓o//ey View � 6 . • ..;, .. : ; . HEIGHT$ Chrislion � "��";'�:;,��"� •� • �'�� ' s� " _ . �^:�: • • • • • � � B 7 � C/AUrM i � '0 n' ,2 '-; ��z ��, ;� � . • 2 -.. �3 •��:.i.-?� ! o • IF i ��6�� * Z 2D. •;�ii;� �A� _ �' • � � h ;,, ;..,�.' • a p, - • �6 �� w • ; ,. ,;•� • p�., �. • � ,,t''.:�i� • • � 3 • � �5 •...•:i,; ��a�„� ♦ __� .: � � � �--r � - .:r�^� t', � . ...�.. �•�•�• '• � �. . �' . e�: . . . ,p . . . , r � - 4 � � -�__ . T' V C� 3 z' --� SKYWOOD LANE � / '' � Ci�tC� t�9 ''- �_ — . R _ . _ � MATTFzR1� _ C . � „ i¢ — ZONING MAP AERIAL MAP _ _ CITYOF FR[DL�,Y CIVIC CENTER • 6431 UNIVERSITY AVE. N.E. FRIDLEY, MINNESOTA 55432 • PHONE (612) 571-3450 _"-: !�4�V ��I : � • � : .� � �!� On Tuesday, August 11, 1987, the Fridley Appeals Commission officially appraved your request for variances, VAR #87-28, by Willi�n Ngckey, pursuant to (�apter 205.07.03, D, 1, of the Fridley City Code, to reduce the front yard setback f rom 35 feet to 28 feet to allaa the wnstruction of an addition to the garage; and, pursuant to Cl�apter 205.07.03, D, 3a, o� the Fridley City Code, to reduce the rear yard setback frcm 28 feet to 15 feet to allow the �nstruction of a three-season porch on Lot 3, Block 3, Innsbruck North Addition, the same being 5660 Arthur Street N.E., Fridley, Minnesota, 55432, with the follaaing stipulations: � If the work has not commenced within one (1) year after granting this varianc�e then the variance shall beoome null and void. If you have any questions regarding the above action, please call the Planning Deg�riznent at 571-3450. Y. Darrel C1ark Chief Building Official Please review the r�oted stipulations, sign the statement belaa, and return one oog� to the City of Fridley Planning Department by August 26, 1987. I, � f , ooncur with the action taken. � .�.: SuB�ECT City of Fridley 19136 BUILDING PERMIT " AT THE TOP OF THE TWINS - i � � RECEIPT � � COMMUNITV DEVELOPMENT DIV. � r rL -----•. �- loo !�3 � PROTECTIVE INSPECTION SEC. � i = , 1.--- / �'��,'� CITY HALL FRIDLE� 55�32 NUM/ER REV OATE PAGE Of AVPqOVED 9Y �� 612-571-3450 9t0-F7S 8 27 87 / / J08 ADDRESS 5660 Arthur S.treet N.E. 1 LEGAL �OT NO. BLOCK TRACT OR ADDITION DESCR. 3 3 Innsl�ruck North Addition 2 PROPERTY OWNER MAIL AOORESS ZIP Bill Mackey 5660 Arthur Street N.E. 3 CONTRACTOR MAII ADDRESS ZIP Same 1 ARCHITECT OR OESIGNER MAIL ADDRESS ZIP 5 EMOINEER MAllAODRESB 21P SEE ATTACMED SHEET PHONE 574-9136 PMONE LICENSE NO. PHONE LICENSE NO. PMONE IICENSE NO. 6 U8E OF BUILDINCi � Iiesidential 7 CLASS Of WORK O NEW C� ADOITION O ALTERATION O REPAIR p MOVE O REMOVE 8 DESCRIBE WORK Oonstruct a 10' x 10' Z'hree Season Porch and a 22' x'12'� Garage 0 CHANOE OF USE F110M TO STtPULATIONS See notations an plans. Variance approved by Appeals on 9/11/87. Provide a hard �.urface driveway . ATE PERMITS REQ�IRE AND IGNS• �EPAR HEATING, PI-�MBIN� w�Ri�. WARNI�� Befae digging calt local ufiifities TELEPHONE - ELECTRiC - GAS E,�. .,R�t�QUiRED 6Y LAW SEPARATE PERMITS ARE REQUIRED FOR ELECTRICAL, PLUMBING, HEATIN(3, �� VENTIIATING OFi AIR CONDITIONING. THIS PERMIT BECOMES NULL AND VOID If WORK OR CONSTRUCTION 20NIN(i AUTHORIZED IS NOT COMMENCED WITHIN 60 DAYS, OR IF CONSTRUCTION OR WORK IS SUSPENDEO OR ABANDONED FOR A PERIOD OF 120 DAYS AT ANY TIME AFTER WORK IS COMMENCED. • NO. DWlt3. UNITS I FIEREBY CERTIFV THAT I HAVE iiEAO AND EXAM�NEO TMIS APPLICATION 1 AND KNOW TNE SAME TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT. ALL PpOVIS10NS OF LAWS yALUATION ANO 011aNANCES OOVERNING THIS TYPE Of WORK WIIL BE COMPLtEO WITH WMETHER SPECIFIEO MEREIN OR NOT. TME GRANTING OF A PEHMIT $5,850 DOES NOT PRESUME TO GIVE AUTMORITY TO VIOLATE OR CANCEL TFIE pERMIT FEE PROVI510NS Of ANY OTHER $TATE OR LOCAL lAW REGULATING CON- STRUCTION Oli TME PERfORMANCE OF CONSTRUCTION. $SG. SO LAN H K fEE $14. T3 SIG U CONTFACTORO AUTMORIZEDAGENT IDATE� . WHEN 1 � ' � � � ;iN�� ' .SiGN�T a OF EAU�O NE �LDER� _ _ DATEi BIDG �NSp DCCUPANCV GROUP OCCUPANCV 30. fT. CU. FT. OfFSTREET PARKING STALLS GARAGES . u tax $2 . 93 SAC CMARGE TOTA�FEE $73.56 RLY V I/�TED THIS IS VC]Ilii PFRAAI' � �a . -� t.� , .. , ..�: . .�4:- _._-:. .. . �. � , � � � .,s.. w, . CITY QF F�IDLEY , , 4 � , .. ,, : , , �x .: , .�-: ; ��, �`� ' � � APPEALS COMMISSION MEETING ` _� ,� , � A13GUST.IIy 1987 . '�� , �:.:� ' � �` , �.� �-��. ;,,CAi.L : TQ � 4RDER: _ � Chairperson<Betzold called the August 11, 1987, Appeais Comtuission meeti.ng to order at 7:30 p.m. ROLL'_CALL: , �,.-. Members Present: Donald Betzold, Alex Barna, Diane Savage, Jer�y.Sherek Memt�ers Ab�ent: Kenneth' Vo sls Others Present: Darrel C2ark, City of Fridley . - William-Mackey, 5b60 Arthur Street i�E, Fridiey, !!�1 Gregory tlortenson, ,6191 I�.srry Lane NB, Frid��.ey, MN APFitflVAL 0£ JUI:Y 2$, 3987, A��FEALS-, COE�@iISSIflDT MINiT�ES: MO_ T_ IQN by Mr, Barna, seeonded by Ms. Savage, to approve �he,.Tuly 28, t987, Appe`als Eoauaissiorl minutes as'written, UPON A VOICE VOTE, ALL:V(3TING AYE, �HAIRPERSON BETZOLD DECLARfiD,�HE MOTION � CARRIED UNANINQITSL�f. , , 1. Mt3��ON hy Ms. Savage,:'seconded Dy l�r. Barna, to open L�e Public Hearing. '�TPON .�1 Y��CE VOTE, ALL ,1/0TI_I� AY£s CHAI&�'ERSOI�. BEiZOLD DECI�,ARED ` THE PUBI�IC H�AARII�G OPSi� AT 7e32 P.M. ; Chairperson Ptetzo�d rea�d the Ad�in�strative S�a:Ef ,�e�rt: � �;, , ,. , ��' . ;. _ AI�MIN��'BATIYE ,STAFF REPO�T < � : � Sb64 �THUR STREET N.B. vaa �8�-aa � A. . Pu�LiC p�E s�RVEg �x RfiQl3Z8�E�T: =- . _.� . Section 205.07.03,-D, i, requires a front yard setback of not less ` than 35 feet. _ , . - _ � . ti. t �� _ �. ; � . � :: ,�.,,,. . , , �: .�� x , . , -.. .,: .�. �. . v� � � � . , �,_,� . .��..� , .�.,� .,5..,. � . ..._� ., :.M �►pP�A�.S COMMiSSION �ETING AUGU�T li 1987' PAGE 'L ' Public purpose served bq this requirea�ent is to allow for off-street.: "`��, parking Withoat encroaching on the public right-of-Way and also for the ae�theti.� considera�i�on_to,reduce the building "line of sight" . et�croaci�aeat into the neigi�bor• s front yard.;, :�: _' , ,�.. . ., , Sect:ian 205.07.03, D, 3a, xequires a rear yard setback of not less ,. Y, .' t�an :�5� o� '�pe:.iot depth. . --�:. �.. . -Fub3i.c gurpose served by this requirement is to provide rear yard `�` space to be used for green area� Khich enhance the neighborhood,� B: "STATED HARDSHIP: , "The hardship arises because the lot is a corner lot and the builder chose ta place the house in an unusual position on the lot. Rather than placia8 the house square with the street he angled it side�ays. This positioning makes-ii i�possible to meet the setback requirements." C. ADI�iNISTRATIVfi STAFF REYIEW: �i'his lot fs a cora�r lpt.and eitt�er atreeti could be considered its ��ront�ge because the,length-of Iot oa each street is within lOX of each other. Arthur Street Was selected as its frontage since the original house.tr�t t�e setback.requirewent for ftont yard setbask. � The boul�►$rd wirttA on Arthur Street i� i6 feet, therefare, if the garage addition is alloWed the �,eW corner of ,the garage xould be G4 feet from the curb. The garage door faces northeast. The proposed addition in the rear yard will be 30 f�et from the house : to the rear. If :�he ;App#�� Co�mi,ssio� approved Ltris uariar�ce th� staff has no :;stipulat�ons to suggest, _ _ .. . _, . - �r.`Clark ��at�d thst th�e praperty is ]:e�atad on:the corner of North Danube '�d and Arthur �iCeet. Mr. Clark showed �he locat.�.on of the property on ` thg location.m8►�, zoninB map and aerial map. The house �s situated at an angle and actually faces the corner of the.lot. The survey indicates tne original faundation with .the proposed garage addition and the proposed p+�rch adtfit-��n to ths: rear. The rear of t�te porch �rd��d be approxinately 30 #eet from the a@jaceut garage and the comer of the garage addition ��d �be� �i4� i�e�t °trun tt�e i�urb on arthur Strest. T�e house> to the north - faela Arthur Street and the house .�to `the ��rt faces D�anube, so in regard to the additions there Would not be et►croach�enx of vision to other front yards.and traffic sbauld be able to see around the corner. Photographs showing the front of the hou&e aad rear yard were shown to the co�ission ,. ' me�bers. tir. Ciark added that xhe dri�at{ap ares out onto Arthur Street• _. ° !!r. C1a�rk felt the: proposed additians Ft�ould probably fit if the house r,aa been turned o�he�rwise, but the problem exists because of the position of - th� house oa tbe �ot. l�ir. Clark indica�ed >the�ce •�.:e �q 8re� areas. . , . Y , . .. . , , �.. .n" . .i.? r°ii. .::P,'' ✓' i. ,. . . . . . . �: . �'� . . , .�: „ :..v r . i..' . .;� . . �:.. .�. . . . . . . . . .. . . . . - . . . � ' �. : ,,.��.. � . . . . �.. . . . . . � , .� ' . :�..: ..:. .. :, �� .. . AP�,PEALS COMMISSION MEETiNG, AUGUST i1��.98°7 ;� PAGE� 3_ `� Air. Maakey indica#��d t�at, tbe garage addition,WAS �tended.to house a van,.wh�.ch is cu��entky kept outside or.stored $t a diff��erit lacation. Ti�e three-seasvn porch is for a�lded space Lo Lhe kitchen �off the back �_ side of t�e�.bouse.: Tl�is ca�r►ot be �locatad in ;a� .di�fe�$n�;�rea. , The house is :a multi-l�svel ba�ase, and tbere is no 'athe�. �+lac+e� �r#�e�e . a,,.porch Would fit. There �.s .�urrently a small deck but iC is not i�as�a�le because ; it -is, on�p fowr fea�. . Tbe backyard .is w.oQded and also �a�. �c�K. �r.ound with-a terraced Wali. Bas�callp,.the additi+�n of the tbt�e=sea�on porch �, _ .�.. �: wuuld �,ea� that ti�e. cu�rent roaf �ou�,d b� ext�nded, aPProxi�,ately .3� feet. „.. -,� . Mr. ::i�ackey provided bluep�i�ts of: the p�p�er��r. fn� the eo�ission's - revieYw. . : , _: ._ MUT�t�� by Mr. Basna, s�cssnd�d bp Mr. Sherek,.to close the pubTic hearing, - UPOD1 A VOICE �OTE, AI►L YOT�I�IG ,�YE, GHq,I�PExSQN BETZQ:LD DEC�EA THE �UBLIC HEARiNG CLASED .AT;. 7 a 4� �'.�[. . ; ., - Mr.:Barna stated �hat he eculd ��e•the h��dship ca�sed by xhe Kay the house was pos�tioned on t�e lct.: Hbile tbi�>was nice in the beginning, iL �ow creates p�Qble�s,- T�s l�t �is alro a�,odd shatpe. If the bous�: were parallel, there would probably be no need for a varian+ce. Also to be eonsidered -is the indivi�ival's lifestyle and the neig,hbarhoQd. !4'r. Bar�a considered the reque�� val„�d, Ms. `Savage .agreed. Tt►e ac�i�ior�� eet tl�e spirit of the ccde in that they fa11 within �he sestlaetic coasiderations.that the cqde is considered abou� a�d ent�ance �he �AP��nce, : � ,: ` Mz. �: �h+erek fou�d . the �e4��st.: a�c;�Ptable.. Mr. Betzold agreed. The additions would fit in with the property and the �e ighborhocci. ' : . , M(�TIUN by Mr. Barna, s+e�anded by Ms. Savage, to rec�o�mend to City Council the approval of VARIAKCE REQUEST, VAR #87-28, BY HILLIAM l�,A�YEY, PURS�IANT TO CHAPTER 205,07.03, D, 1, OF THE F�IDLEY CTTY CODE, TO RE1)UCE THE;FRQNT YARD SETBACK FxOM 35 FEET � 28 FEET TO ALLOW THE COHSTAUCTIODI OF !►�N ADAITION TO THE GARAGE; AND, PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 2D5.07.03, D,� 3a, QF THE FRTDbEY CITY CODE, T0 REDUCE T�iE R£AR YARD S�T�AC�C FRQi! �2$_ FEE't' TO �S FEET TQ Ai�L�1� ,THE: £fll�-�UCTI4N OF A T�EE-S�LSQN� PElRCH, OIZ. I.OT 3, BLOCX 3, INNSB��3CiC NORTH ADDITIt}N, TEIE SAME BEING 5660 AR�iiU� S��EE� ,N.E., FaiDLEY, MINNESOTA, 55432. '' UP�QN- A 1GQ�CE V�TE, ALL VQTiNG AX�, CHAIRP�RSON B£�ZOLD .flEG�iEF THE MOTiON _ ; ; CJlRR� . tINAN�MUUSL�E . � _ , . 2. CONSIDERATION OF A VARIANCE RE UEST, YAR #8.7-29 BY �t G4� �, QN ,-:4 �, --. . PURSUANfi' �0 CHAPTER 205.07.03 . D, 2a," OF THE FRiDi.EY Ci ". DE TO AEDUCE : �HE:.R£ UIRED S:IDB �(AR� SE��CK FROM 1Q� ��T TQ 6> 0.�%Oiii THE rnuaTnll�Trnu nc en�TTTnxsi. t:?VTN[3 SPA(:F f�N ' . BLOCY �.- :HEATHER HIL1.S Hr. Glark stated t problem has arisen re$arding this varianCe whi.ca has been dis with the petitioner. �he house and garage is not locat�d " the lot �rhere it was thought to be. fihen a,;p�e2,imina�y site r'� was aade, it wa� determined there probably was an error in the . _.. .. . � . ! �-�� .. - � . . . . . . . ?_�.� � A�'EAi.5 GO�.�iIS�S7�t�ETING, �t�� .1, 198� P�8 4 � �. : �� x�; �ai 1o�xt�t�i of the �t. Tt�is was eo�►fi�tmed by a survey. iher�fcrEe, ".' �"� tir� ` variaace -wauld be 4.4 �eet rather than tit�t sttated in `the handont, `" � , � iri ars: t,��;o�s �s+3th �ir.'=MortettsQAs :it m�y be possi�ble-to jog the additiora so i�t wonld be '�- �c�e+s� a� ��3 Eee�• �fr� the • I�ni l it�e. ,-Al� ' Qn the sa�e .-' . . y_ . ..� . .'� ., .. �.> �- . ' . ' �� '. � ��. .:r,: �. �ro;�E'�'ty, a��f�o�P=ai�s�a� ex�rst: - b feQt on this 1v�.,�d.:b feet on ti�e : _ : :� r.�•'sth�� r:in� :��t. �otqri�i� �action is required is aliox �ncr�taahment ,on a� � , ., Y sr_ "" easc�en �� kely�th�t the -�t��ci1 xill ask � the pe�itioner to get � - this �uca ed. Mr.��laric;has checksd with Lhe Engi�seering.Department, and � " �`' they state `theq see n�'re�� need'far the easement at this ti�e or in the � ' future, sa i is poss%��e��i�at��'�he ease�aerit Will be xaca�t�d. This process .; takes quite bit of tia�. The Council could allow a temporary ez�croachment o an $�croach�aent for as long as it,takes to get the ease�nt vacated. �1r. Ci rk h�s�$iv��-Mr.'Mortenson a-Petition-for Vacation of Easc�meiit whi�h sh ld be signed by the Lime the commission considers the v�riance request w�'tiie ct��reete� sideyasd seiback. The petitioner Was asked to attend the eeting at �thie ti�e so'that the commission meaihera could hear any co�en from neighbors to the proposed variance. No . neighbors have •'come �o he°'�mee�i�tg, so it ia 'assumed th�re i�t n.o objectian. �The eommission��atinot ta e�acti�n on the vartanee�request at this time. �.The variance request �tri�� s- rep�blishetl ` for �facussion a� the Septe�aber t meeting. - . , MO+T�IQi� by Mr. Sherek, seconde br �i�s. Savage, Lo table -cons-ideration of VA�{jANCE RF�UEST, YAR #87-29, B GREGORY MORTEN30N, PURSUANT TO CHAPTEit - .. . 2U5.0;.03; �; 2a�, 4F'�£ �IDL£Y ITY Ct�E, TO'REDUCE THE REQUIRED SIDE ° i�'ARIi SETBACK :�tt3H ��= FE£T �#� fs FE TO AL�ii TEl£ CONSTRUCTIO�i OF ADDITIONAL LIVIN� SPACE ON LOT 3, B �Z, ��A�HEx,fi�LLS SECOND ADDITION, 7HE SA�1i�: BEIIvG 6I91 KERRY LANE N. E. , BIDLEY, HINI�ESOTA, 55432, so that tne requ�� can be republished�� wit� �D ge�e - fer the �t �e�tiag of the Appeals Commission. U�ON A VOICE VLTE, ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRP ON BETZpLD DECLI►RED TH£ MOTION Ct1RhiEU ui�A;�i�i0i3�LY. 3: bTH�R; Bt�SII�itE�S , � . - . , , _ , . . > > ,. : _ ,. , a. � Pragosed' V`ariattCe T�t#o�national Hant3out , "' Mr�. '�a�r� indic�te�f t�tgt people are conf�sed by he° legal: ha�d8hip and f�lt i�'�i�eneficiati if B�e �exa�ples of �ardshi�°•. p.l,anations could be „, , � givet�. � � , � Mr. Clark st�ted,that this is difficult to do because of varying � `; �ac�cors� inc2�diug t�e n�°i�c�hood, object.�ons by ne' ors, >and also - �_; the final decision as �ade by the City Counci�. �lr. �i k: indicated ` he talks �rith those- per�ons--�ak�n� -uariaace-reque�is amd.�, rie.�;.to �` - expl�ia �a�t is r��e��.red. ��,�. r �{ ,S�r �r�»�,r^ . - � . _ .. . .. ... . . . . . . � � � Ms. �S�v,�e a�+e�d .tt�s�t tlti��s ai.�w�t,_aeeds ��o be done ot► a case g casmm � � � �. _ �. . — }a? �;,.3� , ? . ' ' . baai�.._ _ _ . . _ _ . SUBJECT City of Fridley 19136 AT THE TOP OF THE TWINS g U I L D I N G P E R M I T r ; � RECEIPT . � �y ____. COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIV. ��D�� r � � PHOTECTIVE INSPECTION SEC. i . � �.--.� ��'��;,� CITY HALL FRIDLE� 55432 NUMBER REV. OATE PAGE OF APPROVED BY 612-571-3450 910-Ft5 g�2��g� / / 10B ADDRESS 5660 Arthur S.treet N.E. 1 LEGAL LOT NO. BLOCK THACT OR ADDITION SEE ATTACHED DESCR. 3 3 Innshruck North Addition SHEET 2 PROPERTY OWNER MAII. ADDRESS ZIP PHONE Bill Mackey 5660 Arthur Street N.E. 574-9136 3 CONTRACTOR MAII ADDRESS ZIP PHONE LICENSE NO. Same 4 ARCHITECT OR DESIGNER MAIL ADDRESS ZIP PHONE LICENSE NO. 5 ENGINEER MAILADDRESS ZIP PHONE LICENSENO. 6 USE OF BUILDING Residential 7 CLASS OF WORK O NEW G� ADDITION ❑ ALTERATION ❑ REPAIR � MOVE ❑ REMOVE B DESCRIBE WORK Construct a 10' x 10' '1'hree 5eason Porch. and a 22' x 12 F' Garage 9 CHANGE QF USE fROM TO STIPULATIONS See notations on plans, Variance approved by Appeals on 9/11/87. Provide a hard surface drivewa.y . wARr�� U1RED F�R Before digg+nS catl loca! util:tiPs $EPARA�E PERMIT P UMBIN� AND SiGNS• TELEPHONE - ELECTRIC - G�S �:�. �11R11�'� HEATING, ��QUIRED �Y Lr�►W SEPARATE PEFMITS ARE REOUIRED FOR ELECTRICAL, PLUMBING, HEATING, TYPE OF CONST. OCCUPANCY GROUP OCCUPANCY LOAD VENTILATING OR AIR CONDITIONiNG. THIS PERMIT BECOMES NULL ANO VOID IF WORK OR CONSTRUCTION ZONING SQ. FT. CU. FT. AUTHORI2ED IS NOT COMMENCED WITHIN 60 DAYS, OR IF CONSTRUCTION OR WORK IS SUSPENDED OR ABANDONED fOR A PERIOD OF 120 DAYS AT ANY TIME AFTER WORK IS COMMENCED. NO. DWLG. UNITS OFfSTREET PARKING I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT t HAVE READ AND EXAMINED THIS APP�ICATION 1 STAIL.S GARAGES AND KNOW THE SAME TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT. ALL PROVISIONS OF LAWS VALUATION SURTAX AND ORDINANCES GOVERNING THIS TYPE OF WORK WILL BE COMPLIED WITH WHETHER SPECIFIED HEREIN OR NOT. THE GRANTING OF A PERMIT $5, 850 S2 • 93 DOES NOT PRESUME TO GIVE AUTHORITV TO VIOLATE OR CANCEL THE pERMITFEE SACCHARGE PROVISIONS OF ANY OTHER STATE OR LOCAL LAW REGULATING CON- STRUCTION OR THE PERFORMANCE OF CONSTRUCTION. SS6. SO PLAN CHECKFEE TOTALFEE $14.13 $73.56 SiG UR CoN'aqCrOAO AUTHORi2EDAGENT �DATEi � WHEN PROPER�Y V I ED THI IS VOUR PERMIT < � ' c�ol -� 6 c� _S�GNATUA OF EAiiFO NE UILDERI IDATEI BLDG �NSP p7E ' ��' � � —# z . --- . . � . . . � . , . . . � � '. `ti� . . - � . .. .. . .a� � �. . , . . .. . . ' .. t .. ' - r ' b .' A'� X • • ' •'=' . , � � - �. : . . ' .... �f�y i . fry _ 'T � . Lt'`' , r''f` � r # 'l.�Tt � i (!'+ `", .r,- � ...: . - _ . .;i F�:�'i '� + �� : i ,;ir`;`• �� , . ,, ' ._ j � t-,� .., . � _ . , -��' • Y'�%.�S,t�,r� . ... ._ . _.. .. .. . . . .. - . ... . . . � , �" . . . . _ ... ._ . . _.. . . . _ ._ .. .. . .,_ .. _._ . . .: � . . . . '. 1 ..�-- N�w ' [ l �ADDN. pLTER. ] City of Fridley �R-1 AND R-2 Building Permit Application Construction Address: t�4��/� ?�N�' �T• /��• Effective 4/1/86 Legal Description: Owner Nacae & Address: ��,//�•�� • ��'• `�'' Tel. # Contraetor: �:i�i�/1Ci Tel. # Address• Attach to this application, a Certificate of Survey of the lot, with the proposed construction draxn on it to seale. DESCRIPTION OF IMPROYEMENT 3 �'� �� u A: Length �D, _ Width ,la � Height Sq. Ft. �5.�_ I GARAGE AREA: Length yzr Width /= Height Sq. Ft. �, DECK AREA: Length Width Hgt/Ground Sq. Ft. OTHER: � � �� 2 �. �o Z 2 U'8p � X�• � 91 = �/. O Corner Lot [� Inside Lot L � Ft. Yd. Setbaek Side Yard Setback Type of Construction: Estimated Cost: $�•�� Approx. Completion Date: Alt. A Alt B Proposed Driveway Width If New Opening Is Desired: � � See Back Page for Explanation �f ��y♦9�3` � o - � s' DATE: '�� APPLICANT: � ' Tel. # Permit Fee Plan Check State Surcharge SAC Charge Park Fee Sewer Main Charge CITY IISE ONLY $ ,��•�� Fee Schedule on Reverse Side $ 25� of Building Permit Fee $ +`7 �7 $.50/$1,000 Valuation $ � 525 per SAC Unit $ Fee Determined by Engineering � ��'^� nt Necessary [ ] Not Necessary [ ] TOTAI. $ STIPULATIONS: �� U �}z' � �' g� d gy 8j't�V I � i �� 'Z�Qa�" 30�.� yyo 6 a �f. �v �'�� • � 0 BUII.DING PERMIT FEE SCHBDIILS The Chief Building Official shall, before issuing permits for the erection of any building or structure, or for any addition to any existing building or structure, or for any alteration or repair to any existing building or strueture, upon applicatio n therefore, require the payment by the applicant for sueh permit of fees to the amount herein below set forth and��in the manner herein provided to-wit: Total Valuation �1.00 to �500.00 �501.00 to $2,000.00 $2,001.00 to $25,000.00 $25,001.00 to $50,000.00 �50,001.00 to $100,000.00 Fees $10.00 (Minimum Fee is $15.00) $10.00 for the first $500 plus $1.50 for each additional $100 or fraction thereof, to and ineluding �2,000. $32•50 for the first �2,000 plus $6.00 for each additional $1,000 or fraction thereof, to and including �25,000. �170.50 for the first #25,000 plus �4.50 for eaeh additional $1,000 or fraetion thereof, to and including $50,000. $283•00 for the first $50,000 plus $3.00 for each additional $1,000 or fraction thereof, to and including $100,000. .�100,001.00 and up $433.00 for the first $100,000 plus $2.50 for each additional �1,000 or Praction thereof. DRIVEHAY DEPRESSION ESCROH (Concrete Curb Streets Only) Alternate "A": Removal and replacement of curb and gutter only - Driveway width plus 6 feet times $13.50 Alternate "B": Removal and replacement of curb and gutter and install a 3 foot wide approach with 6 inch depth - DriveWay Width plus 6 feet times $15.75 YERIFICATION OF FOUNDATION Permits for construetion Will be issued a minimum of 24 hours from the time of application to allow for proper review of the proposed structure and of the construction site. A Certificate of Survey of the lot, showing the location of the foundation onee it has been constructed Will be required before proceeding with the framing. �. : 0 I i. 0 * � -� r--�'1 T-�-----( �--� ; � � � � -- -�__ . _-T , � � I � i � i I i S/lF�tt/ �Jea / F IMoa,L '1r1i9w! Q �',� /g'' QC� F�.t)t�1� [�FT -_��i.� � a s t %O" � - -1�--- � . - , _ _ . a-� _ _ ___ , , � � . , ._..._ - � ,_ _ ____ - - _ . _:-= ,., _ � . � � , : .. *. �,�$ti, ��: � �'i� �� -� _ . . . . . � � � . . .. � . .•; � r � . . . . � - .. � � ., . . - ' .._ . i . . _i.. .. .. . �� . Y . . `.Wr . .. .... . . � �. -. ,... �_ . .'. ..., i.� ,. •...'� ' . .. .. ... . . � . .._.j:.. .... �. . — �'4 ._.. . � �� , ,'` ., rt e• • a ' .3 � �� , .. � i� � � 3 �r � � __ ._ _ _ 3 ' • � •�a:�x:lo '� � '� .. .. I �' �� _ , I � f ,�i � � � r-�- _. - � � ,,, . __ # � _ ,� 1 ,� . � � . � .: f �l � � . . � � � " �� v i ''� Q : 4� eF' � p a� � l � � � i � r �� . � ;�i I � ; � 3 �� i .� � � � � � � �.� : � � �, :;� � i; '� i: �; r--� � I ,� � ,� i � ! I I � � z � � b� °� z � � ��. �� u; j d: i �i . i�, ` � t -� '�� : r� - � - � . Q. _ __ . _ � _ :�.� , - -- - - - - , -- � . _A t ��. ,� b _ 0 t . ----r-- � ;, .� f _ « . . � . ,.,�� ; � r ,.� '�� . � . -�� ., z� �€ �, �r.. � _ �I i� _!�.� , � �o� 4r , .:. ;� �isT� r N�� n � Hpc[G4� �J(M siDN�t 1 TF MP'tut �x� RAI� `.�-�.b,' �g � . -..� � . r�,v�t�. �• ��e� ��s� c�� rw�. �v . . • .,: ida, D�w�W� � �scWpant-t pV�e�A o►�Y � P►ao apa �,§" Tt�i !r�°t• ao. � u��r. :� i�''�� M� "W MAK6 WI�`( F'b�c N64i � . °.��(P►`(, �i► /w. �[FuotW�� t.i.ti�ll6s�t �o -��nn�p, t . tK �: 2x a .��tK++a�.. � Ta IDE ZXGi cF,eWe►iE�(cT (�oti�eG , � �"% l�lW., s�..,�FiQt�l,i Gt,Ct�1'I!'�C.T /M,h,o. t _ ..,� _ _ . _. ._ �, � �� _ . - . ,. _ . �, � R . . - . .. . • � i. _. .. +. ,. . - +4 w " �. W #�- . . . . .. },«A �, - :S ._ . . , . . - « R � ��' K �„ ; ��-, i kiol�ts hv�rno�l !�R : t�1t�- t h1Fb• 6tw N!*l,�c`f �� m ,�,�- `" ,: _ �.� - • : � � �,��,'� � � r _ �, , i i'�o�..�i Ht�. f _. .€��"� _ ..�_� "`��:� >:�� . . - , . pe►E,�,Mt JbY� 'i�''� M0�6� — qi�}-�sos .'.. x _�< , � � �' � ';`*'' � � .as �: .;; ¢ � �'p1c �/Z _ `��a:+� �r..x _,_ L , . • 9c.,"w ' • .•"� ��" 'b ) �!T= ` ,� - g �4' . `� . .. ' . . . ".��'�Cr ar , ` T - � , - . � � ? A `�' � `�.y� a � � � � . -, t � .�� .mt .� f''�.�� ,�. .c ,r . � a � . . . . . .. ,;�,,�{,r y Y 4'f ,� +" 9��,iJ.. . • ` , p="[ ��'' ,•"_� <..ry'� ,� �.;. + ws.° �.,5�'^ ¢ x x -s 9 r �t � � � .� .�. . _ - � �' " h''�' � �� ` � � .. . � ,�x.. � i��..� ' �\ � ' . � � t � �'� � L A ;� q� ! ' . ?�...-� . ~� ��. / �, ,, . , . _ �, --� �, � . .�" � -� * ., „ t.�'". u- � ; -�� ' �� Z« c+ ~ - ' � � ` < � � :I ` � � � 1� 3 .Nr. � � � � � o - v r: : � , � � ,� � � 3 � .� ;# � ; __�. �. -� �� X � �� ■�. � , �, jJ �y'': . . � � � � . _ � / / . r�=-'�'�' 1f� �± � � s��3�� ' ' � '' T � '!� J _ i C� q`; � a :�'; � A : , . , � . vl�; ��CS,b� ' . y,. � � i '• . � ,-�- • --�' - . . . �-�.. _. ,r ._, . . .�! . . �._.� . . � � �"�I u,� q�f, t i'� � .. � � � N � � _ _ .�' , ` � ,p .- � , . -. � � . . h---+ - I i J , f I � `� \ . _ /, �� = , . �---- i --- � �' � � , i i � �� ; � 4'-0' M'.o" a=ti" � f,nc - � ,� r . ' Yy^ f � " , , , m� _ '' � , , � � . � I . ' , �= i ,��. , . f . ;,r , � f t f, , ./' f ; y, _ � ,C� ,- , ; � ,- : � ... �-�- -�- <� , , : : . . . � �. ._. . _ .. : . , � . - _ _ - - - - _ ±._. _ _ ` � v ,�` 4� -� . + � ,i h . . � . � ._ i J -�,� � y .�f c . ' _ . .. . : �. r i qCg^��.ry�� ..... �.�, . . �...,,�. �' ' . . � ,'� ;"S3r �� . ,. .� � . . . - ... .. _ . ,,.�,..�::.� t:3 ��> ar - . � � ' � . . . . . - � a; . `�:i. f � . � __ Q�,s-ibw yG � - - , — - - --- 4-21G� 1�� .�oe o � - 4x� � � ��. ah . .� ��¢x`� � � . _ �,��; ��.. �w� � - T Q---��..- �.��.� �U� _ � �y��. �;o �� . : _ . � _ , , .� ,� , • � . _ �� ,` - ., �. .,.�.�, �1,�+ Y � ,'y "4 r� /. ' i = •' •� . � ,{� � � :��' ' `''- �'�!l:�,;•;R. �;in;..��>. ` , ` . • :�+�is,.'-S�ifiRa`.. , �� - . � � . � ' y� � , .l.. ��.,, , . }". � � . � -�-;•�:.;:.. �� • j`'• �� `,� `� z ,.'�+'' �^*F �� ;- y *;4�. :,: � «� . ''�r _ :e, `, ,*' t ' -' ,..� . . 1� .�. `�9,+! • .. . � .'Y: . . �. _ `�� . - `� � �PI ,� - - „ ��R♦ . � 'Ri j . . . _ . Y��, i� I