The URL can be used to link to this page

AF-V - 46991CITY OF FAIO�.�Y� SUBJECT d43'1 UNtVERGiTY AVIE. NE. FAIDLEY, MN. 6343C [B'127 671-3450 VARIANCES �C�o.o 0 ADDRESS �� .3 /�-i-jL,T�� ,; JC� � DATE � /c� �3 APPEALS COMMISSIOPJ: APPROVED DISAPPROVED DATE N0. CITY COUNCIL REVIEW: CITY COUNCIL: STIPULATIONS: REQUIRED: YES APPROVED DISAPPROVED DATE N0. NAME Cv �;N I�iom45 Gerrc�y FEE��G RECEIPT NO.�_g LOT. N0. BLOCK N0. TRACT OR ADDITION LEGAL DESCRIPTION: �o a7f Sov�k y�� /ocK�/l CS.q-k 2ove l4��: �'�� VARIANCE REQUEST (S): (Attach plat or survey of property showing building, variances, etc. , where appl icable) � _�,�____ � _..... ..._.: . ,.:.:-.�. , � � c.,��A�i� �'� � 'S�, ax,c r� _�$.7 "�'v �'�:.��..,� G� . °�a J � , _ . . r �. , � /% ° � -----_ _ ._. . List pecific hardship ) which equires the va iances(s): �„1; �h a �,1,� 11re.� �rpsP�f� � t dv�e �'N �TA�I/✓/�ry, V✓e tia.v� o�d-9row/✓ ovr hovse. 1„/e tiA✓e 1 1': c�c� %oJSes o�/ f� 2 'T►'1a rK� A�/� e.�lN�✓of ig�F'�r� i-fl mo�/e �bes;dps ►✓2 , �,� �1 ��' �-�' a r✓ t,.1 o v� c� 9,' ✓ P vS �d P� v.s ��e �! K� O�r �re5�.�fi �ocw�ro„� ��r'NC� /�N /'� Rve.,, �' r Q� �o,..�r .v�j -�Ar.. )y � �}� v� '�r.'c� �-`.'e e.g.✓ ct F�or c� ,�Dvr J-�ovs-A ( S �O /¢ �d° i'-� ortJ 7L� 7�P Fre�a/� �S Pt�oA�o'� �c � abearoor� �o�se w:�-h `7loj�s � � p�' R C�.�2PCf.ea, /fr'd ►nsrQ loq<cql ,�.v� JQ5�2P�b/P ,�h�-�v 9�:.Nq DATE C/7�� SIGNATURE �� ADQRESS GrJ�%5- �6e�tvr S�_ �� TELEPHONE N0. S7� 7y71� . ... - - - - YARIANCES � fOR C1TY USE Oi�LY . ._.. -- - - _---� Board tnembers notified of ineeting by � �. Li�t rr�emb�rs, ' date notified, ana 01Yes" or "No" �or plans to atten� hea�ing. ' . � Plan Name ' • .S Date � � To Attend � Ners�:� rb�:ing appea notified: � ng property o�vn�rs having property within 200 feet . t�ame � 8y Whom - - ;_� Date Phone or Mail� Notified t - ,. , �M Arthur Demeyere 6620 Anoka. St. N.E. _ . M/M C.L. Finney 6600 Anoka..St. N.E. � ' , M/M Donald Peterson •6584 Anoka St. N.E. M/M Roger Weitnauer 6562 Anoka St. N.E. Ms. Ma.r�uerite Bell 6544 Anoka. St. N.E. 1�,M. M/M Gary Isaaa:son 6535 Arthur St. N.E. — _—____� � _.__ 0 CEt�TI'FIC�4TE� OF' SURVEY J�MES L. I�URTK. _ . LAND SURVEYOR a�� ,�� g�K S,- - CoLutitt3Ea� htttFtpCr''� =� MiMK. '7$$• �oU.c�� 1 MERE9Y CERTIFY THAT �TNI6 6URV[Y, rLAN, OR REPORT WAS PREPARED OY ME OR UNOER MY DIRECT SUPERV1610N. AND THAT 1 AtM A OU�lY REGIETICREQ LANO QURV�YOR UNDER TME LAWS OF TME STAT6 OF MINNESOTA. — °`- "� MINN. REG. NO. 33 Z--- SCAL�E 1 ( DATE �� . t�� L�b2- , � � ' I. : , 30 1Z.8.ZD � I •• .. b � . .o� � � 4'.3 " . ' Zg � � Fto.�3 t�- ':_ � . � ... . N (�583 v_ . c,�, � .. A.. o, � . ►r . .; ; o' � �.:; v � � '�`�� J , � �. ib z - — � . � .. �,. �r ,� 7 . �� 32 y 0'' �� ' , �_ , . n ' _ , � ._ __ _ C�. . . � �', 0.�d' �9 3 � ; � I • � 0 . "' � ^ �� f _ � . � I. . ! � , � �q . . � ' s�vsn oa � � - "t� Loti 29, dk tiia �or�D � ot Lot Z8� �loait 4� Osk Gro�� dditioa� '` , City at lh�idlq, lnoDm CoaaL�, � � t "e" Lot 27, � tb�� o! Lot 26� �look 4, Osk arove Addition� t � Ci� y o f l� r i d l h� l n� o k a C o u n t y, N�. � � � ; � � '� � . .�---= �� ------_____�_.�----- _ _ . >,� __ � � � -� � � . � _ ___ , ._ __ � ►�-� , � � C� � � ;� .�.9 � _ .-_..__._--.. _.__.__.---- __�_._____,___�___,,....�...� �o (� �-"" � � �� 'Ctl ' ['� ; tl i ;�- , M , — f b----�-�� 1 � ' �, �N, ,_,_ i . x ..ti. ..'. ----_. `� �� i � j ' � Y � j � � o -�� fi � � �, i� �'Q'. �_ s �—�� ' I � i � ----;� v - � � � ��`- ---_____ � �i 111 �—'�'� , � ` .�k- � � � 1+J — � y� � . . � ::"� _. � _"'� t V `d i �-i�� ; G i � ( .. � . . � n'^, , 1 V \� - � -- _ � , � �. -{� `� � -�� :�� .�,,.�.--�- � .. j •':.. . •--� . -- . `t . �t :� ��: .Ai+�' _"-T� .,�� ' �; , �. . ��'4� .... M + . �.: ..u�Yl_l 1 zm�f� - CITY OF FRI�LEY 6431 UNIVERSITY AVENUE N.E., FRIDLEY, MINNESOTA 55432 TELEPHONE ( 612)571-3450 June 16, 1983 NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING Notice is hereby given that the Appeals Commission of the City of Fridley will conduct a Public Hearing in the City Council Chambers at 6431 University Avenue Northeast at 7:30 p.m. on Tuesd�y, June 28, i9s3 in regard to the following matter: Request for variance pursuant to Chapter 205 of the Fridley City Code, to reduce the required front yard setbaak from 48.7 feet, to 42.0 feet on Lot 27 and the south 12 of Lot 28, Block 4, Oak Grove Addition, the same being 6573 Arthur Street N.E. to allow for an addition to the front of the dwelling. Notice is hereby given that all persons having an interest therein will be given the opportunity to be heard at the above time and place. � PATRICIA GABEL CHAIRWOMAN APPEALS COMMISSION Note: The Appeals Commission will have the final action on this request, unless there are objections from surrounding neigh6or,s, the City Staff, or the petitioner does not agree with the Comnission's decision. If any of these events accur, the request v�ill continue to the City Council through the Planning Commission with only a recorrmendation from the Appeals Corrrtnission. Item �3, June 28, 1983 ADMINI3TRATIVE 3TAFF REPORT 6573 Arthur Street N.E. A. POBLIC PIIRPOSE SEaTiED BY RBQUIxBME11T: Section 205.153 i2) requires that in areas with front yard setbaeks greater than the minimum, the average of the setbaeks for buildings within 100 feet on either side shall prevail, with a deviation allowed of six feet more or less. Public purpose served by this requirement is to ensure that any nex struetures do not greatly impede the fro nt yard "line of sight" for the existing house sites. B. STATBD HARDSHIP: "With two children presently and one due in January, we have outgroWn our house. We have prieed houses on the market and cannot afford to move and we do like our present location. Building an addition wo uld give us adequate room Por a growing family at a price we can afford. Our house is a two bedroom with 768 square Peet. Also, adding onto the f ront is economical and more logical. and desireabZe than going any other direetion." C. ADMINI3TRATIVE STAFF REYIEW: In 1978, the petitioner had planned to convert the existing attaehed garage to living area and build a new garage off the alley. They have since changed their minds and now would like to add onto the fro nt of the house. To do this they will need a Pront yard varianee. With the proposed addition, the strueture will be 42 feet from the front lot line. The required setbaek for this lot is 48 feet due to the large front yard setbacks the neighboring struetures have established. If the Board approves this request, we have no reeommended stipulations. (900) (/.ia�O) Sit•�t O%��/ai► r/t/[/N F�vyd F For/;M 2 '��3 -- --� 1�'1 . �� I0�,�--,,; � p� � '� ; ♦ �� . eek_ � : �� _ - � ; 1� ra� . ��0'°� � ti�� U3� 0 � �1�Y...�r, e\, ��,.I, :�z ,�,a--- .:`'�� S4 � I � � .� Aaih t EE� � �R : R ��i ENT � . ��M o0 � G� ��,� � �� , 5 � � I . ( !� � � �M C �r Ofi7lAl 4 � •�' ��;r;r �•:/ 'b «6 � KS6 � 3 1 j� 1 . V , ,a ,. • � 2� 27 s J 4 Fi �• 23 tz 2/ 2�..�� va� ei T O �'' 2 : C� f/ wI' fi.//!r/ / /U..t /f./e.l,% � �' !i �r :: �� s . �� !� AVE. � � f � � � J 0 s � C:fj .f fi+�/hr ��P� ( I�Ys.t /i�/f.1 j i�'" �■■� ■ � # -- � � r3 � ' a = IIrOS i�lt ��t, " 16 � 661/'Z AVE. N.E � iI .�u , �,�� .----- .� o t z� 1�, �o t�,,, s�V W, . �� " r � �� •g�.. a'°�' � 2� ir . � � ' O °` � `�• 1 S � � �: . -� I V� �� i � ' . / 'S y ��. 0 \ V � �I �`�7 � ` • � ' � 8 'f � - '� / � . se K3� Ii�IS 1i55 1� 5 16'9 -�.,. �r � .: �• •, :•-� :- .. � � _ .�ys _ � u'` J E/ • . RQIAML?' W. ANDERS� Appeals Commission Meeting - June 28, 1983 PaQe 5 Mr. Betzold questioned the hardship in this matter. Mr. Van Hulzen said the �ain hardship is that his wife Nishes to take care of the family and still work, that she �eeds the job and this is the least expensive and most economical to accomptish this. He said other options would cause considerable disturba e and expense; the entrya►ay wou�d then have to be through the back yard i o the basement and through the laundry room and the pool in the back yard wo d have to be fenced off. He felt this would also be additional disturbance to t neighbors and the existing area is the right size. Ms. Gabel felt the hardship s now defined much better and stated she had visited the area and there woul be a safety factor with customers and the pool and the construction costs are obv' s and this appears to be a better way. MOTION by Mr. Setzold, seconded by Mr. 8a a, to close the public hearing. UPON A VO— I-�VOTE, ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRPERSO BEL DECLARED TNE PUBLIC HEARING CLOSED AT 8:50 P.M. Mr. Plemel said the original obj tion of the neighbor's dissatisfaction has now been removed in this matter an he has no probtem with the variance. Mrs. Gerou and Mr. Barna concurred. Mr Betzold felt the additional information has clarified the issues. MpTION by Mr. Betzold, conded by Mrs. Garou, that the Appeals Comnission has reconsidered tts earlier recommend ion to the City Council, and based upon additional information presented that was t available at the last hearing on this matter, the Appeals Commission recommends to the ity Council approval of the variance request to reduce the side yard setback on the ving side of a house from the required 10 feet to 5 feet, to allow a converted gar e to be used for a beauty shop, located on lot 18, Block 4, Brookview Terrace, the ame being 901 Overton Drive N.E., Fridley Minnesota with the stipulation that this riance be restricted to the use of the Van Hulzens only, that this is granted r a period of one year and to be reviewed annually at the same time the State license if renewed, by the City Council. UPON A VOICE VOTE, ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRPERSON GABEL ECLARED THIS MOTION CARRIED UNANINqUSLY. 3. REQUEST FOR VARIANCE PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 205 OF THE FRIDLEY CITY CODE, TO REDUCE THE REQUIRED FRONT YARD SETBACK FROM 48.7 FT., ?0 42.0 FT. ON LOT 27 AND THE S� OF LOT 28, BLOCK 4, OAK GROVE ADDITION, THE SAME BEING 6573 �THUR STREET N.E., TO ALLO1+' FOR A.'� ADDITION TO THE FROhT OF THE DWELLING (Request by Colin T. Gerrety, 6573 Arthur St. N.E.. Fridley. IrAI 55432) MOTION by Mrs. Gerou, seconded by Mr. Betzold, to open the public hearing. UPON A VOICE VOTE, ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRPERSON GABEL DECLARED THE PUBLIC HEARING OPEN AT 8:55 P.M. � Chairperson Gabel read the Staff Report: LDMaISTf�SIYB ST�FF 1EPOlC! 6573 arLnur Str�et �.t. �. l48LIC lDRPOSE SERTED D? �EQOIA�l: �ctioa 205•1S3 it� �uire� tbat io areaa �ith froat �ard aetbacka srcater taan tre �inieum� tDe average of tDe set�acks for puildtag� �itbia 100 feet oa �StDer side aball Pre�ail� vitD a deviatioa alloveC of ais f�et �ore or l�sa. , APpeals Commission Meeting - June 28, �983 Pa9e 6 tublic purpose aer�ed p� atructures Oo oot �reatl� t:isting nouae aites. S. a?1T� B,lBDSHIP: tDis r�puire'ent is to �asure t8at •ny neY i�pede tee iroat �ara `lice of si6ht" tor the �'Mitb tvo cbildren prsaentl� �nd one due in January� ve �ave outgrova our Douee. Ye �ave priced bou�sa on Lbe aarket and canaot •fford to •ove and ve do like our preseat locatian. Building sn addition would Sive ua adeQuate room tor a arowiag family at a yrice we can afford. Our bouae is a two pedroom vitb 768 aquare teet. Alao� adding oato the f roat is •conomical and �ore logical and desSreaDle than Soing any other direction." C. LDl�IIiISTfUTIOE ST�PP �E4IEY: In 1978� tDe petitioaer bad planned to convert the ezi�ting attached Sarage to living area and Duild a eev Sarage off the alley. They bave aince changed their ainda and aa+ vould like to add onto tbe fro nt of the bouae. To do th3.� t�ey vill oeed a lront yard •sriance. Yith the propo�ed addition� the structure vill be.�2 feet from the front lot lioe. The reQuired setDack for this lot la #8 feet due to tbe large front yard setDacks t�e aeighDoring etructures have established. If Lbe Bosrd approves tbis reQuest. ve bave ao recommended stipulationa. Mr. Gerrety was present. Mr. Clark explained that the petttioner is still using the single-car garage and presented aerial photos of the area. He said there is no real set pattern of setbacks for the whole block. Mr. Gerrety said he requested 18 feet but will actually 6e using 16 feet - he wanted to be on the safe side as he did the measurements himself. Ms. Gabel asked what the space is to be used for. Mr. Gerrety said they want to convert the living room into a dining room and have a new bedroom and living room and they have discussed the possibility of just adding the bedroom. Mr. Barna noted it would be an L-shaped house and make it easier to tie the roof in. Mr. Gerrety he will have a contractor do this and everything will be tied in. MOTION by Mr. Betzold, seconded by Mrs. Gerou, to close the public hearing. UPON A VOICE VOTE, ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRPERSON GABEL DECLARED THE PUBLIC HEAP.IdG CLOSED AT 9:03 P.M. � Mr. Betzold felt the variance should be granted as tfie public purpose did not have much application in this matter because of the foliage and varying setbacks of the other homes in the area. Mr. Barna concurred. Mr. Plemel said he could see the need because of the growing family. Mrs. Gerou and Ms. Gabel agreed. MOTION by Mr. Betzold, seconded b� Mr. Barna, that tfie Appeals Cortmission approve the variance request to reduce the required front yard setback from 48.7 feet to 42.0 feet on Lot 27 and the S� of Lot 2$, Block 4, Oak Grove Addition, the same being 6573 Arthur Street N.E., Fridley, Minnesota, to allow for an addition to the front of the dwelling. UPON A YOICE VOTE, ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRPERSON GABEL DECLARED THE MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY. 7 . ,� , _ STATc OF t1INNESOTA APPEALS C0�1�1ISSIOP� PROCEEDINGS CITY OF FRIDLEY In the Matter of request to reduce the required front yard setback from 48.7c�feet to 42.0 feet to all an addition to the front of a dwelling at 6573 Arthur Street N.E. Colin T. Gerrety ' , Owner VARIANCE The above entitled matter came before the Appeals Commission of the City of Fridley and was heard on on the Z8th day of June , 1983 , on a petition for a variance pursuant to t e City of Frid ey s oning r inance,�or the foilowing described property: Lot 27 and th� South one half of Lot 28, Block 4, Oak Grove Addition IT IS ORDERED that a variance be granted as upon the following conditions or reasons: As per Appeals Commission minutes of June 28, 1983 on record at the Fridley City Hall STATE OF MINNESOTA COUP�TY OF ANOKA CITY OF FRIDLEY ) ) ss. ) DATEC thi S � � �. , � w.r,"°.�--� CHAIRPERSON, PATRICIA GABEL OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK I, Sidney C. Inman, City Clerk for the City of Friley with and in for said City of Fridley, do hereby certify that I have compared the foregoing copy and Order granting a variance with the original record thereof preserved in my office, and hve found the same to be a correct and true transcript of the whole thereof. IN TESTIMONY WHEREOF, I have hereunto subscr bed rt�y hand at e City of Fridley, Minnesota, in the County of Anoka on the 1�.G�► day of , 19�. DRAFTED BY: City of Fridley 6431 University Avenue N.E. � �. Fridley, MN 55432 SID��EY . Nt N, CITY CLERK �� Variances are valid for a period of one year following approval and shall be considered void if not used within that period. ` (SEAL) ��,ri a.�+cc. ►Jcsr F lt� o,n�Tarr�rys �ro p�er�y