The URL can be used to link to this page

AF-V - 35712I 1 } t crrr oF e�r�i:�;w �!1�1`UNIt��',�;"' yE. N.E. =F.��, �N �� vaR��Fa�r�s�r �oa�� , �t��.t-as�;o �' : u�,.�� #��+�-a�t < v�xxarrc� �� xn�iPr � a o �/� 9 sa��u.� �s r�rn�c ��e 5-i3 -8b i V PRi'�PERTY iNFORMATION �.y �ess _6 �(a8 A�NTan1 � v� ,�1% L�AL D�SQ2IPrr7(kT: �ar �� a�ac �oZ �tAQ'/ADDITDJN �,P-��L�y . ��.et� PGus �- oF (JA-eA �o ;�[te.�� PRFSFNT ZQJIT7G VARIAN(E R$t[JfST(S): Attad� a giat or survey o�f the property sharing building, �� varianoe(s), where apglicahle. �� to��' ,� � � . �„�i e1F�Sl�'�� k �s 4' - �- O Secti n of the Code: ��b°'°k -{-e b� laad ,+n 1�� Li specific hazdship(s) whidi t�u . � � o y ' ," ,� a/so variar�e (s) : �..�u�a�. S �oo�+n�., � o�� OVltNER 1NFQRMATION �e tp3ease �rint) �TF�i�.�i1/lE t�/E"G��i.�s.E'/ xioNS ur' 7/-�970 ,,- �. � �� sicr�vae n4T� �i�-.�S/-8/ ******..*«xx#****.*****«***:*:x.**�..�f***.*****,�**.*******:******��*****�*****� RfTIT14NER INFORMATION N�,iP�ease pcint) �/%%� PHONE _„ . 1�tYit1�S SIGI�ZSJRE nyy� *!�*************tk*****#**4**!tF**tk*******ir****if**##-**###!*#*********3r*#********t*k* �• ! i •' •• • d� M ��! N� '•• ?� STIH7LATIONS: � 3i 17i� i � t'� 1]I� � • .� /� , ti,... _ �' � RR Ci'PY OSE Qi.Y � , . Notification of petitior►er anci pFOperty awr�ers wit3lin 2D0 feet: . . .....�_•--i.»____'.. ..� . . ilato nntifixi ` � � � � � � ( � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ( � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� 1 � � � -� � �� D�p�r�111M1t Co�unity Develop. �� Ashton Ave. - I�"�'� t�'� �� r y • s 1� �.% � 18 #al! O�N 4-24-86 May 13, 1986 � ', sidej'yard set- ��'r�`•"'�•�'�� vnc�rnu�71: sase �ara�e area _ R�TURN TO PLANNING' ' 5� CON�VAENTS t�il^act �.o .lo-t" °� cpv; Ga-�..�, .4� �S �a...`� � �0 � 5�ao�Q-s— ? - `�^ou.4� Gc 5*+c.lsd( �u-c,�._, AJ'�.�,-c_ �e d.u.�,.� ' �� Y� . �� , � w'/ �G� J� nR��h.�� v�i %-�-�/ � eh .zQ ', a'�- �i.a�c%�� /�' "=° ,� _/,,,� - -o-v �LEON1.s- w�� .�.�� -----E�683� l��`t✓�h�..y �lovr+� / � Ger S�'! c..4� ll" ie /f' "� � �o ,G,�-y�. �,,�,�y�.o n ,.�:��.4.=� .�� v�� K�� y�� . �' ■ � _ � � C.I"IYOE' FR[DLEY CIV[C CENTER • 6431 UNIVERSITY AVE. N.E. FRIDLEY, MINNESOTA 55432 • PHONE (6l2) 5713450 NOTICE OF PUBU L HEARING ' Notice is hereby given that the Appeals Co�renission,a# the City of Fridley will conduct a Public Hearing in the City Council Chambers at 6431 University Avenue Northeast at 7:30 p.m. on Tuesday, May 13 , 1986 in regard to the following matter: Consideration of varaance requests, Variance #86-09, :. to reduce the side yard setback fram 10 feet to 4 feet and to increase the maximum garage area from 1000 square feet to 1300 square £eet for additional living space on Lots 4,5 and 6, Block 12, Fridley Park and 'z o£ vacated alley, the same being 6468 Ashton Avenue N.E. Notice is hereby given that all persons having an interest therein will be given the opportunity to be heard at the above time and place. DONALD BETZOLD (�iAIRMAN APPEALS COMMISSION Note: The Appeals Commission wi11 have the final action on this request, unless there are objections from surrounding neigh6ors, the City Staff, or the petitioner does not agree with the Comnission's decision. If any of these events occur, the request will continue to the City Council through the Planning Commission with only a recomnendation from the Appeals Comnission. _ � � ar�Ea[.s lri�t#�F t 9 . �4� �'"" CITY CAUPIGIL � � �' ``' �MAILING�LISP � - Vaxi�ce fE86-09 6�+x;.4shton Avenue N.E. Anna M. Huston ib5-14th Avenue N.E. Minneapolis, h8d SS4i3 Jerome E. Unglaub 6425 Ashton Avenue N.E. Fridley, I�4�I 55432 Arnold E. Kastenek 6435 Ashton Avenue N.E. Fridley, MN 55432 Edward M, Sha£fer 6457 Asfiton .Svenue N.E. Fridley, 1�FI 55432 Llyod K. Pound 6461 Ashton Avenue N.E. Fridley, AN 55432 (�arles Ames 6473 Ashion Avenue N.E. Fridley, hfV 55432 County of Anoka 325 Main Street Anoka, Ir4�I 55303 LeRoy A. Erlandson 6� Mississippi Way N.E. Fridley, MN 55432 Ksnneth D. Hughes 6424 Ashton Avenue-N..E. Fridley, MN 55432" Anella J. Lee 6434 Ashtan Avenue N.E. Fridley, 2+@�1 55432 Jolm E. Glauvitz 644b Ashton Avenue N.E. Fridley, I�HJ 55432. Stephanie Bielawski 6468 tlshton Avenue N.E. Fr�d�fY, 39N 55432 �tedeamer L�yt�teran Church 58:Mississipg� �(,�y �,g, F�i{iley, M�I 55�. ' ,�<�� i � . Itea #3, l�lay 13, 1486 II Aa!lIIlI3PRATlVE 9TAPF � �I 6468 Ashton Avenue N.E. A,. PUBLIG P�PaBE SERV� SY R�QUIR�ITs Sectia� 265.87.3II.2a, requires a side yard of ten (19) feet between any 3iving area and sfde property lines. Public puzpose served by this requirenent is to maintain a minimum of 26 feet between living areas in adjacent structures and 15 feet between garag� and living areas in adjacent structures to reduce exposure to ca�flagration of fire. it is also to allow for a�thetically pleasing op� areas around residential structures. Secti� 205.07.1B.4a, requires a private garaqe not to exceed 1008 of the first floor area of the dwelling tmit or a maxim�nn of 1,000 square feet. Public purpose served by this requirement is to eliminate the condition of overcrawding residential areas. a� •.�.ti• °Single car garage is not adequate during winter months for cars and lawn equiFment. Things that need to be stored are: three autarobiles, two three- wheelers, two lawn mowers, two snow blo�rers (1 very large, 1 �all), wheelbarrows, 3 shovels, 2 rakes, 1 ice chizel, garden hose, weed wacker and other lawn and garden �,;pnent, two bicycles, 1 mediian Sized boat, motor, trailer, 1 uitlity trailer, work shop tools for house maintenance and others which should be kept in a garage or $1]EIt2I.° . G A�MINI8PBA7.ZVS STAFF REVI�T: The garage on the neighbors lot to the north has been removed. The existing garage is a single car garage and is located about 4 feet from the north line, it would be very difficult to increase its size. The owner would like to attain a variance to have living space 4 feet from the north line which would enable him to convert his existing gacage to living. Then he would like to build a 130H square foot garage,-one large enough to house all his cars and other personal it�s. The code allows 1090 square feet. The staf£ has reco�edned that he build one garage at 1900 square feet and has ' him that he then could build a separate utility structur of 250 re feet giving him a total of 1250 square feet of accesso es. If the Board approves the reduction of the aide yard froan 10 feet to 4 feet for living we recaimend that the Board stipulates that the north wall be a firewall with no openings. .�~` � . � APPEALS COPIPIISSION h1EETI1IG, MAY 13, 1986 PAGF 3 Mr. na stated ihat a�tua}7y the dafficu3t pert of the variance was done in 1981 whe ey a}lo�ed him to braild;onto �he back of the existina garaqe. The addition iving space now was already,�vithin the existing walis and wauld come na; c to tfie neigf�bor next door, .Tfiere was a driuev�ay on the P1-operty line no�•r, a there was already 20 ft. between livin� areas, so he wnuld have no objection granting the variance. 3. Mr. Sherek and Mr. Betzold agr with Hr. Barna. MOTION BY�l1R. BARNA� SECONDF.D BY MR. .REK, TO APPROPE VARIa1VCE R£.O.UEST, VARIANCE N86-08,�PURSfJANT TO CNAPTER�20 TNE FRIDLEY CZRY CODE TO RT.DUCE �TNF. SZDS YARD SETBACK FRO%t 10 FEET TO 5 FE -0R LIVIt]G SPACE ON LOT 24, BLpCK I� OAK CREEK ADDITILW� THE SAMF. BEING 11� LOGAN PARKWAY N.F..� WZTH TNE fOLLONZNG STIpULATIONSt 1. THE F.AST WALL BE A FIRE-RATED WALL WZ^'X NO � THAN A FIRE-RRTED DOOR. � � . 2. A XARD SURFACE DRSVEWAY BE SNSTALLF,D TO SF.RVE UpON A VOICE S�OTE, RLL VOTING AYE, CHAIRPERSON BF.TZOLD CAR[tZED ANANIMOUSLY. OTNF•R NEW GARAGT•.. T11F. l40TION ��MOTION BY.�MR, BARNA� SECONDED BY MR. SIIEREX��TO��OPEN THF, PUBLIC. XF.ARING. � UPDN A VOjCE VOTF., RLL VOTING AYE, CXAIRPF.RSON.BETZOLD DECLIIRF.D TNF, PUBLIC HEARING OPEN AT 7:46 p,M. � � Chairperson Qetzold read the Adninistrative Staff Report: ADNIFIISTRATIVE STAFF REP(lRT 6468 Ashton Avenue N.E, A. PUQLIG PURPOSE SERVED BY RFQUIREMENT: Section 205.07,3D.2a requires a side yard of ten (10) feet be�ween any ltving area and side property lines. Public purpose served by this requirement is to maintain a minimun of 20 feet between living areas in adjacant structures and 15 feet between garages and living areas in adjacent strue'tures to reduce exposure to con€lagration of fire. It is also to allow for aestf�etical}y pleasing open areas around residential structures. � � f s ' APPEALS C0�1"1ISSIO�J MEETIIJG, t7AY 13 1986 PAGF 4 Section 205.07.1E3.4a requires a private garage not to exceed lOD9; of the first floor area of the dwelling unit or a maximum of 1,000 sq. ft. Public purpose served 6y this requirement is to eliminate the condition of overcrowd9ng residential areas. B. STATED HARDSHIP: "Singbe car garage is not adequate durinq winter months for cars anA la�•�n equipr�ent. Things that need to be stored are: three autoru>biles, two three-wheelers, trro lavm mowers. two snow hlowers (one very large and one small), wheelbarrows, three shovels, tvio rakes, one ice chisel, garden hose, weed whacker, and other lawn and garden equi�xnent, two bicycles, one medium sized boat, motor, traiier, one utility trailer, workshop tools for house maintenance and others which should he kept in a garage or shelter." f„ AD�1It�TSTRATIYE STAFF REVIEW: The garage on the neighbors lot to the north hes Aeen removed. The existing garage is a single car garage anA is located about 4 feet fron the north lot line, it would be very difficult to increase its size. The owner would like to attain a variance to have living space 4 feet from the north line v+hich would enable him to convert his existing garage to living. Then he would like to build a 1300 sq. ft. garage, one large enouc�h to house all his cars and other personal items. The code allows 1000 sq. ft. The Staff has recommended that he 6ui1 arage at 1000 sq. ft. anA. �'`�� ha rmed fiim that he then could ild eparate utility structure 0 250 , ft. giving him a total f 1250 s. ft. of accessory structure. /:T � If the f3oard approves the reduction of the side yard froM 10 ft. to 4 ft. for living, we recortmend that the Board stipulate that the north wall be a fire wall wi*.h no openings. f•tr. Clark showed the Coronissioners a picture of the residence and an aerial photo that shows there are no structures that are close on the neiqhbor's lot to where the garage now exists. The petitioner stated thav have a single car garage and the square footage does not handle all the cars and personal iteris ±hey need to store inside, especially during the winter nanths. Mr. Betzold stated that as far as building the garage, the code allrn•rs a 1000 sq. ft. garage without a variance, ar�1 then, as pointed out by Staff in the Adninistrative Staff Report, the petitioner could build a 250 sq. ft. accessory building giving theri a total square footage of 1250 sq: ft. for storage. Ne stated that in order for the Commission to vary the code, the i \ Mr-,:=t► i i 5 CCY'ftISSION HEEI'ING, F1AY 13. 1936 � R pnr,F � *� petitio€�Pr �st show a demonstrable reason why the code should be varied. : fie std'��c! k�e had,difficw]ty with the hardshin as�this definitely seemed, Lo he a s�'if�-imposed hardship. . The petitioner stated that since they would h�ve to adhere to the code require- ment. thPy would withdrav� the second variance request to increase the maximum ,garage area fron 1000 sq. ft, to 1300 sq. ft. � h1r. Betzold stated the hardship stated in the Administrative Staff Re�ort actually addressed the reason why the petitioner needed a larger garage; it did not say anythinq about the first variance request for a side yarci sethack to build additional living space. The petitioner stated they need to have at least a two-car qarage, and since they need more living space, the most logical thing was to convert the existing garaqe to living area. Mr. Betzold stated that withou+. b�ilding a nerr garage, there was the possi- bility of a lot sptit; but, with tfie building of the garage in the proposed lor;ation, there was no way the lot could ever be split. He just �•�anted to make the petitioner aware of this. Thr petitioner stated that was fine with him. He had no plans of ever wai�ting a 1ot split. +lOT7017 BY IfR. BAR*IA� SF.0017DED BY 1�R, SXF.^ER, TO CLOSF. T77E PC7BLZC HF.RRZf'G. UPON.A VOICE VOTE, ALL VOTING A�F., CXRIRPERSO77 BF•TZOLD DECLARID TNE PJBLZC HEARIIJG CIASF,D AT 8:09 p,M. t•1r. 6arna stated the petitioner had withdraam the second variance re,quest for the garage to exceed 1000 sq, ft., so they were looking at the conversinn of the existing attached garage into livinq space. The exis*_ing garage rias a stucco structure tied into the existing house and it would not r�ake any sense to tear it down. He would see their living space hardship as the only �vay to make the existing garage a usable space without going fnr a special use permit, The petitioner had said they would rather have living space than another garage. I1r. Sherek stated that in soite of the fact that he would lil:e to have heard the petitfoner ex�ress a little bit more about why they needed additional living-space as opposed to why they needed a gdrage, he could not see anv problem taith changing the presenti garaqe intQ living space. � Mr. Betzold agreed that the hardship was a little thin on this variance request. He could see what the petitioner was try�ng to do. They do want to increase their c�arage space as they do f�ave a fairly se�all existing garage. Ry increasing tfie garagP space, it did make the existing garage someYrhat su�er- fluous. It did exist and was already closer to the property line than it ,� • �---.� 1 APPEALS COt41ISSI0N MEETIN� 13, 1986 __-- P116F 6 ' ' should be, but he did not see any problem with convertinn the garage over to living space. It was moving the property line or changing the structure-- just the use. MOTION BY 14R. SXEREK,SECOI7DED BY MR�. BARNA,�TO APPROVE VARIANC.F. REQUEST, � VARIANCE #86-09� BURSUANT TO CHAPTER 205 O.° THF. FRZDLEY CITY CODE 4'O RIIDUCE � THE SIDE YARD SETBACK FROM-IO FEET TO 4 FEET FOF. RDDITIDNAL LZVING SPACF. ON LOTS 4� 5� AND 6� BLOCK 22� FRIDLEY PARK� APIP 1/2 QF VACATED ALLEY� TBF. � SAIfE BEING 6468 ASXTON AVENUE t7.E.� P7ITN THE STIPULIITION THAT THE MORTN G1ALL BE A FSRE WALL WITH NO OPENZNGS.� .- �. . � UPON A VOZCE VOTE� ALL.VOTING AYE, CHAIRPERSON BET20LD�DECLARED THF. MOT709. CARRIED UNANZMOUSLY.� � � . � � . �� . � , . . � . . . . � . Mi C�l� . KOhaneK, les2 Iecnnology, 1nc., 9tsc� - tys, Hn. 55429) TO CHAPTER s 1•f0:'SON BY t�1R. BARNA� SECOtIDED BY MR. SHEREK,. TO OPTU Tf1E PUBLIC HEARINC. UPON A VOZCE VO ALL V027NG AYE� CNAIRPERSON BETZOLD DECLAF'.F.D TNF, Pl�RLIC HF,I�RING OPEN AT 8: P.M.� . � . � Chairpers�n Eietzold rP the Administrative Staff Report: AD �ISTRATIVE STAFF R[PORT 5 - 77th Avenue A. PUf3LIC PURPOSE SERVED BY RE REFIENT: � Section 205.78.4D.2 requires twa not less than twenty (20) feet. Public purpose served by this requi space areas around industrial struc purposes. , STATED HARDSHIP: s1�1e yards, each with a width of is to provide aclequate open or aesthetic and fire fiqhtin� "The property has extrernely limited buildinq sites ue to t�SP Gas Company and Sanitary Sewer.° C. ADI1IWISTRATIVE STAfF REVIEW: The existing structure is located on the east side of tfie rar oad tracks. It is approximately 275 feet north of 77th Avenue. 7he petitio r would like to add onto tfie south and east. The new east wall would be cated 1 � �Ks £ st.�s �€ �SSirt� . COUNTY OF ANOKA � I�G , � t� A� .t�LS�li33I0N PROCB81>IlHI3 � GITY 08 FRIDL$Y t; : , Ia t�s NaLt� oP � Ya�'iance V R#86 09 '_ locatec3 at 64fi8 Axhton:Avenue N E _ Stephanie Bielawski , Owner VARIANCE The above entitled matter oame before the Appeala Commisaion of the City of Fridley and xas heard on the 13th d�y op May � �g 86 � on a petitlon for a varianae pursuant Lo t4e City oP Fridley�s 2aniag Ordinanoe, for the follaring described propert� T _ .,,,�.. .. _-'. . ��—......'.—_ _°..—.,.._ .-.,.—._--.,:."„_,� a .�,...'- .. . . . To reduce the side yard setback from 10 feet to 4 feet for additional living space on Lots 4, 5 and 6, Bloek 12, Fridley Park, and 1/2 ; of vacated alley, the same being 6468 Ashton Avenue N.E. , TT I3 ORDERED that a variance be granted as upoa Cho follariag conditioas or reaeons: See Appeals Commission Minutes of May 13, 1986. STATE OF MINNESOTA ) COt1NTy Og dt�10RA ) CZTY OF FRIDLEY ) OPFICS OF TfI6 CITY CLERK I, Shirley A. Haapala, City Clerk for the City oP Fridley with and in for said City of Fridley, do hereby certify that I have compared the foregoing copy asnd Order granting a variance xith the origittal reoord thereoP preserved ia my oPfice, and have found the same to be a eorreet and true tranneript of the whole thereof. IN T�TIlIONY WHSREOF, i have hereunto Fr1 ey, Hinn sota, in th County oP �, 19�. DEAFRED BY: Cfty of Fridley 6A31 Ooive�slty Avenue H.B. Bridley, 4Q� 55432 aubacriT�b�'7�r Hand at ize 6ity-of ---- Anoka on the ?�c day of . 3HIRLEY A. Variances are valid for a period of otae year folloWing approval considered void iF not used xithin that period. -'� := i �''� : .�i ��x;� � -�� .,�� F �. .� �.y �,�,,F x �, '9 � •, ." r. � ;.,�, (sEj�) , '� . , ,,,�, � , :.:. , �� ,:y � -�.,,�` y. ; �., �� r . . � � rnr,F 3 Mr. Barna stated that aetually the difficutt part of the variance d�ne in 1983 when they allowed hir� to build onto the back of tfie exist garaae. The additional living space now was already within the exi g walls and would come no closer to tfie neighbor next door. Tfiere a drive�•�ay on thP Property line noei, and there was already 20 ft, bet .n livinq areas, so he ' vtnuld have no objection to granting the varianc 14r, Sherek and t+,r, tietzold agreed with I��arna. .� . MOTIOIl BY MR. BAWlA, SECOADF.D BY . SN?!REK, TO APPROPF. VARIiNCF. REQUEST, � YARIANCF. i�B6-08, PURSURNT TO TER ?05 OF,TIiE FRIDLEY CIT1' CODE TO RT.DtICF. �. � THF. SZDE YRRD SETSACK FR 0 FEET TO 5 FEET�FOR�LIVS7!C. SPACE ON LO^' ?4� � � 87.O�K._1...>Q1lK-l.&SES:, _If,k��..T'�6E�.,SA�B%FN&�ri�2i�F-,2ARA79AY N.R.. �7�m(i . � THE FOLZ,()IlINC, STI TIONS: . � . 2. TH£ F _ WALL BE A' FIRE-RATED P1ALL WZ'"N Np OPF.NINGS OTHF,R � .� T A FZRF.-RATED DOOR. � .� i� � 2 NARD SURFACE DRIVEWAY BE INS:'ALLT.D TO. Sf.RVF. THF. NE{7 GARACT.. � ON A PnICE I�OTE, ALL VOTING RYE, CNRZRPEILSON;SF.".'20LD DF,CLI{P.ED TIIC 1lO; ZON . � CARRyF.D UNANZFlOUSLY. � � 3, P:OTZON BY MR. BARNA, SECONDED BY TfR. SttF.REY,, TO OPE1J TNF. P�•BLIr, NFARI.NG, UPO1J ,A VOICE VOTF., ALL VOTING AYE,. CXAIRPF.RSOPJ BET7.OLD DECL1lP.TD THT PUBT.IC HEdRIhG OPE1J AT T:46 p,M. � Chairperson f3etzold read the Adninistrative Staff Report: ADT1ItlISTRATIVF STAFF REPORT 6468 Ashton Avenue p.E. A. PUQLIG PURPOSF SERVED BY RF.OUIREt1EIJT: Section 2Q5.07.3D,2a requires a side yard of ten {ln) feet be2ween any livtng area and side property lirses. Pubiic purpose served by this requiremenr is to maintain a minimun nf 20 feet between living areas in adjacent structures and 15 feet hetwPen 9a►'ages ami iivinq areas in adjacent structures ±o reduce exposure to conflagration of fire. It is also to allow for aesthetically pleasing open areas around residential structures. ,, .� � �- � MEETING, t1AY 13 � 4 Section 2Q5.07.1t3.4a requires a private qarage not to exceed 100Z of the first floor,area of the dwe7ling unit or a maximum of 1,000 sq. ft. Public purpose served by this requirement is to eliminate the con�iition of overcrowding residential areas. . B. STATED HARDSHIP: "Singl•e car garage is not adequate durinq winter months for cars and larm equipnent. Things that need to be stored are: three autoriohiles, two three-wheelers, two larm mowers, two snow hlowers (one very larne and one small), wheelbarrows, three shavels, tr�o ral:es, one ice chisel, garden hose, weed whacker, and other l�wn and garden equipment, two tr'f�y�tes, one medium �3�ed boai,"moior, i"ri`�iT`er, one utility trailer, workshop tools for house maintenance and others which should he kept in a garage or shetter." �. ADIfIIlISTRATIVE STAFF REVIEIJ: The garage on the neighbors lot to the north hes been removed. The existin� garage is a single car garage ancY is located about 4 fee*. fron the north lot line, it would be very difficult to increasP its size. Thr owner would like to attain a variance #o have living space a fP.P? from the north line which would enable him te convert his existing garage to living, Then he Wnuld like to build a 13Q0 sq, ft, garage, one large enough to house all his cars and o±her personal items. The code allows 1000 sq. ft. The Staff has recommended tha± he buitd one garage at 1�00 sq. ft. an�i has informed him that he then could build a seoarate utili*v structure of 250 sq, ft, giving hin a total of 1250 sq, ft, of accessory structure. If the Qoard approves the reduction of the side yard fror� 10 ft. tn n ft, for living, we recommend that the Roard stipulate that the north wa71 be a fire wall with no openinqs. tir, Clark showed the Cormissioners a picture of the residence and an aerial phoio that shows there are no structures that are close on the neiqhhor's lot to where the garage now exists. The petitioner stated tbey have a singTe car garage and the square footage does not fiandle all the cars and personai ite�ts #hey need to store inside, especia3ly during the rainter rionths. Mr. Betzold stated that as far as buildin!� t+.P qaraqe, the code allo�•�s a 7000 sq, ft, garage without a variance, ar�1 then, as pointed out by Staff in the Adrzinistrative Staff Report, the petitioner could build a 250 sq. ft. accessory huelA9ng giving ther� a total square foo*.age of 1250 sq. ft. for storage. He stated that in order for the Cmmission to vary the code, the � �-_- " �� ' � , � , APPEAL5 Cfl"tti5SIt1H HEETIt�f, WAY 13, 1936 pn.rF 5 �,. . _ _ ; petitioner �wst show a demonstrable reason ►vhy the code should be'varied. He stated he �rad diffitu}ty wi#h the hardshi� a5. this definitely seer�e�l to be a-seif-imposeA hardship. 7he pet4tioner stated that since they would have to adhere to the code r.equire- ment, thPy would withdraw the second variance request to increase the r�eximur� garage area fron 1000 sq. ft. to 1300 sq. ft. 14r, Betzold stated the hardship stated in the Administrative Staff Reoort actually addressed the reason why the petitioner needed a larger garage; it did not say anythinq about the first varience request for a side yard sethack to build additional living space. Tla� peiitisaner siat�d-they-nee�l--t3-ha��a�-:3v!as�=a�two-car qaraqe, an�i since they need more living space. the mnst logical thing was to convert the existing garaqe to livinq area. Mr. Betzold stated that withou*. bailding a ner+ garage, thPre was the possi- bility of a lot snlit; but, with thp buildinq of the garage in the proQosed lor.ation, there was no way the lot coulA ever be split. He just �•ianted to mal;e the patitioner aware of this. Thr. petitioner stateA th�t alas fine with hir�, ilP had no plans of ever wanting a lot split. 1lOTI0.7 BY lfR, BAtt:A, SF.CD.':DED BY 1dR, SNF.^EK, ?O CLARF TliF. P(�I37,ZC HTARI"�. UPOti A VDZCE VOTE, ALL ?+O.TING AYF, CHAIRPERSO77 BETZOLD DECT.IIP.T.D TlfE P.'7BLIC NEAP.I:lC. CLOSF.D AT 8:04 P.M.. t'r. Qarna stated the petitioner had withdra�•m the sec�nd variance request for the garage to exceed lODO sq. ft., so they were lookinn at the conversion of the existing attached garage inro livinq space. The existirg g�raqe i��as a stucco structure tied into the exis•'.ing house and it wouTd nat naL•e any sense to tear it dorrn. He ��muld see their tiwing space hardshin as the only �ray to make the existing garage a usaAle space without going for a s�ecial use pernit. The petitioner had said they would rather have livin� snace than , "`-_ - �riather garage. 11r. Sherek siated tl�at in soite of the fact that he would lil;e to have hPard the petitioner express a tittle hit more ai�nut why they needed addi*.ional livinq space as opposed to why 2hey needad a-garage, he could no+ see any probten r�5th changing the present garaqe into livin� space. Mr. Betzold agreed that the hardship was a litt}e thin on this variance r?our.s±. , He tould see what the petitioner was trying to do. Thev do want to increase their garage space as they dn have a fairly sr�a7l existinq garage. Ry increasing tMe garege space, it did r.�ake the ex�sting garage some�•rha*. suner- fluous, It did exist and was already closer to the property line than i± �- +rw a ' ,�v' � -. - . . . . �fry .1 M� . . .. . AFPEAI.S CO!t1ISSI0N f1EETIN �, �tAY 13. 1986 PAGF 6 4. should be, but he did not see any prot+lem with convertinq the garage over to living space. It was moving the property line or changing the structurP-- just the use. MOTION B'Y IfR. SHEREF.,SECO77DED BY MR, BARNA, Tt) AppROVE VARIANCF. REQUESI',- �VARIRNCE NB6-09, PURSUJiNT�TO CNAPTER 2D5 OF THF.�FRIDLEY CITY CODE [!'O R]^DUCE THE SIDE YIIRD SETBACK FROM 20 FEET TO 9£EET F'OP ADAITIC�IAL LIVINC, SpACF. ON LOTS 4� 5� AND 6� BLOCX 12� FRZDLEY PARY,� 1!!7P I/? OF VACATED ALLEY, THT �SA11$ 8E77lG 6968 ASHTON AVE77UE t1.E. � HITH TNE STIPt�L71TI0N THAT �TNE NORTH WALL �BE �.A��`•FIRE WALL WITH NO OPENINCS. � � � � � � UpON.A VOICE VOTE, ALL VOTZNG AYE� CHAIRPERSpN BETZOLD DECLARED TXF. MOT709 CARRIED UNANZMDUSLY. � .. - _._ - �--- -- �- -- �� -- COIJSIDEPATIOIJ OF A VARIARf,E REQUEST, VARIANCE N86-10, PURSUA!JT TO CHAPTER � . �wnancn� �ca.y �c�nnuiv9Y. 1fiC.� t4inneapolis, Nn. 55424) F10^SO7J BY ltR. BARNA � SECO7lDED BY HR. SlIEREY. �.^0� OPllfl TIlE UPO.N A NOZCE VOTF., AL7, VOTING AYE, CHAZRPF.RSON BET20LD NF.AR.TNG OPEfJ AT 8:09 P,M. � � Chairpe.rson Detzold read the AdMinistrative ADI1I N I STRAT IVE 55 - 77th A A. PURLIC PURPOSE SERVED f3Y REQUIR Section 205.18.4D.2 re uir two not less than twenty � feet. enue orth, � P[�D . HE�IRIPIC,. . I.AP.F.D TXF, p[�RLIC (2) side yards, each with a 4lidth of . Public pu�pose serv by this requirement is to provide adequate o�en _ _. , ... _. �space areas ar0u ix�dustrial structures for eesthetic and fire fiqhtinn purposes. B. STATED HIP: "The operty has extreriely limited buildinq sites due to tlSP �as C any anJ Sanitary Sewer.° ADt�INISTRATIVE STAFF REYIfid: The existinq structure is located on the east side of th� railroad tracls. It is approximately 275 feet north of 75th Avetwe. The aetitioner would lil;e to add onto the south and east. The ner� east �vall would be located � M FN a r�'"+� r j� p M +G� m•�i • I'j F+• w a tn r• r F � `�C N C � z �n '_ �F 00•QTf LSTM98-9T-b � \ w � � A � � � T � o m ,$ c � z g y 3 � .F � � T � � Z N m .. z � my ° 2 �3 r � � � � � >m d„�'? --�g��c�c�z �a < < � 3 iw-s sm 3w,�,o �� 3 la * � � g a g � � � s' �, K � 0 3,�n o x I 0' p, I N �a m �n� � s s�o �(� j s � � �� _ � G . .° . � � � � . _ : ' a,.� _ � � ------ -- ----- — ------- �- ' � - __ __ _ _-- -- - ___ - _ --- -_ ----- - ------- --�'°-�:�?��.�e�:,a� — ---- - -- — _ ---- --- - -- — � �w-„` n�� - --- -- -- - - — - - = �? - ,e��w _— � _ �o�S��t, _ W�_ _ _ � 0 , - - - 3 SG�.�_ �- l � ,�, �- --- ------�� -�- -- ------ -- (� --- -- _ _ -- _ e.e� w o-c�-.�_ a.H.r9. _� _� �,_ _ --- --- �- �-....�-".�` ---- ----- ---- ----- ___ --- -- ---_- -- . � _ � � � � - w o-�,�--�, � h-FG..� ,.,C° -- -- _ �_�� n.��«.�. _ � ��- x�.- <� ' 1� �� : : 'r�°� �'�.:� � .� ^°�'� ` D � +'/{��aF_1 �_.15� .ra-.r�_.. __ t �,� � Jyb�` --m----�.r � �� .� �� t-�t�� _. �� - �� ` ' � _� � :� � �;s� : . � . � 'r""� ��i . :cr�.a.� ' : , � � �: � ' s ` � �i :�� f; �_� ,' ", ;:� fi- ,3� .�. , �. �� : �t��r� � :,��I '�#. . � `�� . � � ' �' � �.. . � � � � ? . � • , _ �1��` � . 1• .� � .' ' � . . �, . . �� ; � N �� t; � ;� ��.�� 1 , ff� � ��: �,°�� _ � „ F j� y: ��{j; � x�� r.:�� .� �� `.��; �� F�� . �� }��is�Ti 1� ��1 � (�) • � �� 1� �:,� s" � ��, �� r�l Ir �_ .. , , op�-.r�: . .. . � .. ... _. ... ___... �� . .. ... ._ _.. ....__..��_� . . . . . � � ��.v � ��.:: .:��RT��l�AT:� �O� .�i�f2�/EY � ` : iCURTH SURVEYING. lNC. . . M007 JEiFEN6OM 67. N.E. . . . " COLUM161A MEIGMTB Qf421=. .. . MINNESOTA � Q�STRATI 5�b � �� J � �� __ _ _ � n°�� _ p � o� ; . � � �.,� � ; , , , , , .----+� a3 z� ; .� ,. � s ... � � �_ t �: ' ..� N {�. L— - - ---' , �� ew wo�ow* ow� �wswro rr sK ow u�R yr euiet auoaawM ARYOI� YMOfA 1N� 4�Mi�0� �Mt frA7i O/ MIMMOOTA. � ... DATE MAY b . \18'�1 SCALE 1' � , �_. �N NO. � ►G.N3 a � ��N MONUMEN.T '. ��8� . 3O � T°�! �� ---15�0 --- -- - - _ -: _ � � � brJ�B 14�.5-SS ... . � A R. Ix '' • '_- • , , � � � � 0 � , � _ _ _-� ______ ____ _ _ . � , _ . _ , ^ — - - -- . ; _ {,} ,,_� � � e ��.� 7 . . � . . � . . . t � ' .. i � O CMAlK L.��iYL �'E�- . . �' +' � _..154 •O "' � l.::a^CS �1 , 5 AND, � I � BLO C 1� 12. ,"C'OG.ET NE.� W ITH I � � �-1ALF OF VAGA�1� A��--�-E`� `z }Z,1Dl.,.E`( QARI�, _ . �►N41�.A. cOU1.1�TY, .��1JE�TA _ r 1 1 1�! Q � � 0 � � _ _ �'- � � il . � -<�;�J,r2 �, �;, _.�:.r:�, � �. � �' �* ,: �, �'.�!�'€',�k, � . �.�" , �;�a . :. "',a�py E3kir � . � .� . £ / �rP`"E ��. , : 'n��_. v��n'Y e : �` '�" �� fFa . sa .W,. ..+� �.F , �v- � � - _ � �e r�, �'- � .: , „ �, � �� '� `� � � _ ��m � YN i � � ,,, �..� >. ' _:. , ��,�.�' . � "�' 4" � "'��-��'� APPEALS CO!f1ISSI01� tif�'fIN� Ft�Y 13 1986�`- � _��„a ,�,,,': _ �. : � � °. ;,..� -, r.�x. ��.� ; � ,a should be, but t�e did rwt see any problem.witt� �Qno�r�hangingstheastructurp � h. w � •` "'� 'ta�living space �IL�wasmovingpthe proper,�y 3 � � � r, ., �� .. . , ° jusi the use. ° ;: _. _ ° � , � , " �� ti� s. , ��. .� •� � v-�-., „ ... . M - MOTION BY IIR. SHEp ��Tf1� CHAPTER Y�OF;TH �R DLEY G T�C��F'� �DUCE TXE SII�E YARD SETBACK FROM 10 FEET TO 4£EET FOR ADPITIONRED ALLEY STiF. ON lATS 4� 5� Af!JD 6 BIACK I2 � FRIDLEY, P11RK� AE7H��-T�^T...�E NORTtt VALL .. SRlfE BEZlJG�� . "-��E !. F72 �T � � - �, ;: : � � � � . . ,. ...; ..>. .'*8�. ta �.t��= � :; � ' :,,� . . . _.: e . . _, . UPON A VOICE VOTE, ALL VOTING AYE� CNAIRPERSON BETZOLD DECLAREP THF MOTION ' - �...� < ;,„. F � CAR72IED UNANIMOUSLY, ` �,.�� ,.�t -�i ., ;.a1.�! t�a � T`'` .. .. ` _ . �. ,;,� . :. .,_.. . ........ ' . � �' �. . _ ____.. _� ..,.�..��r orrriccT VARIANCE N86-10, PURSUA'�T TO CNAPTER � 8� r Minneapo s, t1n. � � FfO:'IA7 BY lfR. BA1 est. echnology, tnc.. ?8ca - ��• � - - 5429) � �c.-. ^,s?C�«w..�4� F, r,; �• �, SECOl7DED BY NR. SNEREK, 7'O QPT.q TJtE PL�BLIC. REARTNG. � LD DECLAPF.D T'HF. PIBLIC UPON A t�OZCE VO ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRPERSON BETZO HSARIt7G OPEN AT 8s P.M. " . r. •� , . Chairperson Detzold res the Adr.iinistrative Staff Report: - t AU� �IS7RATIVE STAFF REPORT , 5 _ 77th Avenue . , . . . . ._ ,� : : ,. � . ,;>, � . , ' A. PURI�IC, Pt1RPOSE SfRVED BY, RE. REHE1�7; �� ,�;, Section 205.18.4D.2 re,q uires t2) sidP yards, each with 8 width of not less than twent (20) feet. �' ,z . .. � � , .: : Pubtic purpose sPrved by this requir nt is to providP adequate open space areas around industrial structurr. for aesthetic and fire fiqhtin� . x.. �urposes. , , • � > - - �.. STATEp NAROSHIP '° ,". � : � � _ _ . _� � � '"The property fias extrenely limited buildinq sites ue to f�SP �as ; `Ct�pany and Sanitary Sewer."_, , _ � , � _ ��,. - - „ „ . , . � '" °'�.: �DMINISTRATIVE STAfF, REYLEFL• uy� ; , , . The ex�sting structurP is located on'the east side of the rat oad tracks. It is approximately 275 feet north of 77th Avenue.''7he petitio r would " likp to add onto the south and east. The new east wall would be cated. _.. � _.__. _ �_ _ --- � _ _�_�- --�-- -- _ _:_ ---- `'