HRA 08/01/2013
CITY OF FRIDLEY
HOUSING AND REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY COMMISSION
August 1, 2013
CALL TO ORDER:
Chairperson Commers
called the HRA Meeting to order at 7:00 p.m.
ROLL CALL:
MEMBERS PRESENT:
Larry Commers
Pat Gabel
Stephen Eggert
William Holm
MEMBERS ABSENT:
Gordon Backlund
OTHERS PRESENT:
Paul Bolin, HRA Assistant Executive Director
Becky Kiernan, Accountant
ACTION ITEMS:
1.Approval of Expenditures
MOTION
by Commissioner Gabel to approve the expenditures. Seconded by Commissioner
Eggert.
UPON VOICE VOTE, ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRPERSON COMMERS DECLARED
THE MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY
Commissioner Gabel
asked what the Service Link charge was on the last page.
Paul Bolin,
HRA Assistant Executive Director, said that is the third party property managers used
by CitiBank and Wells Fargo when they sell properties.
Commissioner Gabel
asked about the administrative operating expenses.
Becky Kiernan,
Accountant, said that $51,000 is for administrative charges that are applied every
quarter, for City staff time and HRA overhead.
Commissioner Gabel
asked about the Star Tribune charges for the public hearing notices, if it was
just one hearing or multiple hearings.
Mr. Bolin
said that charge was for multiple hearings.
2.Approval of June 6, 2013 Meeting Minutes
HRA Meeting of August 1, 2013 2
MOTION
by Commissioner Holm to approve the minutes as presented. Seconded by
Commissioner Gabel.
Commissioner Gabel
asked for the following changes to be made:
th
Page 6, 4 paragraph, second to the last sentence should be MPA MPCA
th
Page 8, 6 paragraph, should read Commissioner Gabel stated asked
th
Page 8, 8 paragraph, should read what the rental fee structure
th
Commissioner Eggert
asked on page 6, 5 paragraph, should read development plan team
UPON VOICE VOTE, ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRPERSON COMMERS DECLARED
THE MINUTES APPROVED AS AMENDED
rd
3.Approval of Resolution Authorizing Sale of 5755 3 Street
MOTION
by Commissioner Eggert to open the Public Hearing. Seconded by Commissioner
Gabel.
UPON VOICE VOTE, ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRPERSON COMMERS DECLARED
THE MOTION CARRIED AND THE PUBLIC HEARING OPENED AT 7:08 P.M.
Paul Bolin,
HRA Assistant Executive Director, stated that Home Detail is proposing to construct a
home on this property. The home will have a different roof line and a mix of exterior materials.
This home is already sold and the layout was designed specifically for the buyers. The home has
over 2,100 finished sq. ft., 4 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms and a finished basement. The projected value
is $230,000-$235,000. Staff recommends approval of the resolution authorizing Home Detail to
create a new investment in the neighborhood and the proposed home design is consistent with HRP
guidelines.
Chairperson Commers
asked how many more Gateway West lots were left.
thrd
Mr. Bolin
replied four lots; two on 57 and two on 3 Street.
MOTION
by Commissioner Gabel to close the Public Hearing. Seconded by Commissioner
Holm.
UPON VOICE VOTE, ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRPERSON COMMERS DECLARED
THE MOTION CARRIED AND THE PUBLIC HEARING CLOSED AT 7:11 P.M.
rd
MOTION
by Commissioner Gabel to approve the resolution authorizing sale of 5755 3 Street.
Seconded by Commissioner Eggert.
UPON VOICE VOTE, ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRPERSON COMMERS DECLARED
THE MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY
4.Approval of Motion Authorizing Staff to Develop Documents Needed to Consider TIF
Assistance for 5601 East River Road
HRA Meeting of August 1, 2013 3
Paul Bolin,
HRA Assistant Executive Director, stated that Mr. John Allen of Industrial equities
purchased the former JLT/Tiro/Lamaur site at 5601 East River Road in late 2012 for $1.3M. The
th
property is in the Northstar Transit TIF District and it is anticipated that 57 Avenue may
eventually be extended through the site. Mr. Allen is planning to develop this site in three phases.
The first phase consists of a high finish flex office/warehouse/showroom building of 134,000
square feet. The second phase includes two, five story office buildings totaling 300,000 square
feet. The third phase includes approximately 120 residential rental or assisted living units.
Mr. Bolin
said that beyond typical development costs the city has asked Industrial Equities, John
th
Allen, to accommodate the extension of 57 Avenue. Mr. Allen needs to acquire a triangular piece
of property, from a neighboring property owner to accommodate the extension of 57th Avenue.
When Mr. Allen puts in the access road into his site, rather than just a driveway with 2-3 lanes, it
th
will be built to the proper roadway standards to accommodate 57 Avenue coming over the tracks.
This would involve more turn lanes, more medians and a minimum of 4-5 lanes built in that area.
Based on the numbers that Mr. Allen has from his construction contractors, that would add
$180,000 to that drive access area. Mr. Allen is asking the Authority to give consideration to
providing assistance to cover the extra cost associated with building the driveway to public
roadway standards.
Mr. Bolin
stated that tonight staff is not asking the Authority to make a decision on providing Mr.
Allen with assistance. Staff is asking for a motion to allow staff to move forward in developing
documents necessary to provide Industrial Equities with assistance, not to exceed $180,000, for
installation of the proposed 4-5 lane access into this site. Actual approval for assistance will not
take place until documents are brought back to HRA for approval, at a future meeting. Staff will
come back to the Authority after everything is documented.
Chairperson Commers
asked for clarification of who owns the property in the orange box.
Mr. Bolin
replied that John Allen owns all of it.
th
Chairperson Commers
asked if the 57 Avenue extension happens, will Mr. Allen give up
property for an easement up to the railroad tracks.
Mr. Bolin
answered yes. He has been working with the City Council to get his master plan
approvals done. Council has agreed to let Mr. Allen know within five years if they are going to put
th
57 Avenue through. Five years from now if Council decides it is not feasible then Mr. Allen can
develop over that area.
Chairperson Commers
asked for clarification that five years relates to when Council says to go
forward with the project; five years.
Mr. Bolin
replied yes.
Commissioner Eggert
asked if that would be made a public road; that section would be built to
standards for a public road.
Mr. Bolin
answered yes; that is where the additional expenses come in.
HRA Meeting of August 1, 2013 4
Commissioner Eggert
asked if the city would take over the maintenance of that road or if Mr.
Allen would maintain that road.
Mr. Bolin
replied that if it is a public road the city would maintain that road.
Commissioner Gabel
asked if he would maintain the road until the city took it over.
Mr. Bolin
answered that the first 300 feet could be a public road.
Chairperson Commers
said that the down side is if HRA puts in assistance and the public road
never goes through.
Mr. Bolin
replied yes.
Chairperson Commers
asked about the traffic generated from this development.
Mr. Bolin
replied that Mr. Allen had to review traffic and potential environmental impacts as part
of the EAW process.
Commissioner Eggert
noted that five years is not a long time, many projects take 10 years. He
was wondering if a five year term should be placed on this.
Mr. Bolin
said that City Council has given Mr. Allen five years and Mr. Allen agreed on five
years. This extension was first talked about 7-8 years ago when the City started working on the
Comprehensive Plan that was updated in 2008. Last year staff met with BNSF and they said the
th
road could go over or under but would not allow any supports in the rail bed. Any bridge over 57
Avenue will have to span the entire section of tracks and the estimate is $18M for a bridge. A
tunnel is questionable too because there et Council sewer line under the tracks and staff
are not sure how to work around that.
Commissioner Gabel
asked about the increment, when it would be paid back and if the increment
could be lost.
Mr. Bolin
replied that he found out today the increment would start to be collected in 2017 and the
increment would be collected regardless if the HRA helped out Mr. Allen or not. The first building
will generate $182,000 a year in increment and 5% interest on top of that would take about 15
months to pay back the $180,000.
Commissioner Gabel
road reverts back to Mr.
Allen if increment would still be collected.
Mr. Bolin
replied that increment would still be collected on what is generated by the building. The
worse case is the Authority issues a pay-as-you-go note, he builds the entrance to standards and
th
57 Avenue ; the Authority has helped him make nice entrance into his site.
That is the risk.
Chairperson Commers
asked what development agreement the Council had.
HRA Meeting of August 1, 2013 5
Mr. Bolin
answered it has to do with the master plan approval.
Chairperson Commers
asked if that was separate from the Authority development agreement
Mr. Bolin
replied yes; this agreement is not as detailed and talks about landscaping, storm ponds
etc.
Chairperson Commers
asked why five years because nothing will interfere with this development
if this goes to 7-8 years.
Mr. Bolin
stated that if Mr. Allen had his way he would have pushed this building up to the north
and east and made it larger to begin with. In order to help the city try to make this extension
happen Mr. Allen is willing to leave the space, for the roadway, if it can be done.
Chairperson Commers
said that the City Council should have consulted with the HRA so
everyone is on the same page.
Mr. Bolin
stated that the city master plan is completely separate from anything the Authority does.
th
The 5 year timeframe for 57 Avenue to go through, was and agreement between Industrial
Equities and City Council. Mr. Allen has acquired the property and now is asking the Authority
for assistance to build the road to the standard the city needs to accommodate a future extension of
57th Avenue.
th
Chairperson Commers
asked what happened if 57 years is too
short of time.
Commissioner Eggert
asked if the five years started when construction is completed. Is that the
solution we are forced with; to build the road? Is that a possibility?
agreement is but would like more information.
CommissionerHolm
said that the worst case scenario is we proceed with the $180,000 TIF note
th
and the ultimate result is 57 Avenue ough; we helped improve the access and egress
th
for that site. bad outcome. It is not feasible at this stage to determine if 57 Avenue will
ever go through. It is worthwhile to have staff proceed with the documents.
Chairperson Commers
agreed.
Mr. Bolin
will get a date as to when the five years would start and report back to the Authority.
His understanding is the date for the 5 years started the night of the Council meeting approving the
master plan for the site.
Mr. Bolin
will invite Scott Hickok to the next meeting to discuss the city actions on this item.
MOTION
by Commissioner Gabel to approve the motion authorizing staff to develop documents
needed to consider TIF assistance for 5601 East River Road. Seconded by Commissioner Eggert.
UPON VOICE VOTE, ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRPERSON COMMERS DECLARED
THE MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY
HRA Meeting of August 1, 2013 6
INFORMATIONAL ITEMS:
1.Development Agreement Hyde Development
Paul Bolin,
HRA Assistant Executive Director, stated that the Hyde Development closed on the
th
122 acres located at 4800 East River Road on July 10. Hyde Development has been working
towards acquiring this property since August of 2011 and the Authority created TIF District #20 in
the spring of 2012 to provide assistance with the clean up and future redevelopment of the BAE
site.
Mr. Bolin
said that on June 6, 2013, the Authority adopted a Term Sheet for the redevelopment
project. The Term Sheet outlined the redevelopment and public finance terms that were to be put
th
in the Development Agreement between the Authority and Hyde Development. Since June 6, the
Developer, HRA Attorney and staff have worked to put together the attached Draft Development
Agreement.
Mr. Bolin
said that the Development Agreement further formalizes the terms previously approved.
The Agreement covers how upfront assistance (grants) would be provided by the Authority and
reimbursed by the Hazardous Substance Subdistrict (HSS), pay-as-you-go assistance from the
Redevelopment District, the disbursement of third party grant and loan funds that will flow through
the HRA and is
perform as promised.
Mr. Bolin
said that Mr. Hyde had a conflict to meet tonight and would like to have more time to
review the Agreement with his legal counsel. The developer has asked that the Authority consider
th
approval of the agreement on September 5. Staff will continue to work with Attorney Casserly,
th
Mr. Hyde and his legal Counsel on the agreement and bring this item to the September 5 meeting.
2.Housing Loan Program Update
Paul Bolin,
HRA Assistant Executive Director, reported that in July, one Deferred Loan was
closed making six year to date and there was one remodel advisor visit for a total of four year to
date. The quarterly report for outstanding loans includes the same three that have been on there for
the last few years. One of them will be a write off because the person is deceased and the home
was foreclosed. There is a chance we may be able to collect on the other two.
Mr. Bolin
provided a Gateway Northeast Update the Vet Clinic's last day of business was
yesterday at this site and they will move out this month. The plan is to get the hazardous material
removed the first week of September, then the property has to sit empty for 10 days and then the
property will be demolished. The owners of the Citgo Station from Florida have been talking with
staff about knocking down their building and assessing the costs back to them. This will be
coordinated by the city.
Mr. Bolin
said that Roger Fink from Lyons Contracting would like to purchase the Gateway
Northeast property. Yesterday a rough draft of a purchase agreement was sent over for the site. A
typical staff will work with him over the next few weeks
until a suitable agreement is made. This site would need master plan approval with platting, street
HRA Meeting of August 1, 2013 7
vacations etc. Mr. Fink is looking for documentation to give him comfort to spend money on the
site as the Authority will keep control of the land until he is ready to build.
Chairperson Commers
said that the Authority just wants control of what he builds on that site.
Commissioner Eggert
suggested considering a deposit of a certain amount of funds applicable to
the sale that would be non refundable if he pulls out of the agreement.
Chairperson Commers
thought that was a good suggestion.
ADJOURNMENT:
MOTION
by Commissioner Gabel to Adjourn. Seconded by Commissioner Eggert.
UPON VOICE VOTE, ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRPERSON COMMERS DECLARED
THE MOTION CARRIED AND THE MEETING ADJOURNED AT 7:57 P.M.
Respectfully Submitted,
Krista Peterson, Recording Secretary