Loading...
VAR 05.77s* City E of OF FridTWIley AT COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIV. j x: r PROTECTIVE INSPECTION SEC. 1 . 1 ( CITY HALL FRIDLEY 55432 "•J 812-560.3450 '5""J APPLICATION TO BOARD OF APPEALS NUMHEN 910-F23 flEv. 1 DATE �� 3/21/75 GAGE OF .1 2 APPRp4FD HY 800 Name �p� ''^ A ��" Address4366 �'� Phone b3V Z�(C tJtt i� + 'rh�r 4)M pi 44iLL5i►���! SSI Z V3 -153o Legal Description Lot No. is Block No. ITract 3 or Addn. 10 ` NS�3RuC4C 01T10A/ Variance Request(s); including stated hardships -)(attach plat or survey of pro .pert showing building, variances, etc., where applicable) C�MuF-STI / tj6 %Ae %AMW- mom IK'� LYi ZO- 2S `Z+o ��-�t�trc�t—n[f �� 4 FffIi- t0 �� �-�t l�t� fAt1Nb 1 1ST auk' U)151 WI�EttlC€ Q+1v S AKA POPL k2. v�Ehl�Q [3� �� P-0 I? �� THE �Lj-LV `►0&l C�hRACo wn�I_b 13t "�O f�(1 07 Fyv� i�-'�NNs. �QayE �Y FAC%Mco mic t�use ao�cT�lI�2 � ►LsON I" �+Nc�L€ MAx-",E- u�,2� -S 'T-e� QOa t) lar cbCs�Vt-A. 'M w1�>` 6+11i � e ttLSsSA4LE 1 ,,/� NOTE : A-ftACwE'� tf"rTEFL aOM A49. 1t'RI tAJU Lk Da LAS 7 Meeting Date Fee e* dv.O® Receipt No.. � Si Comments & Recommendations by the Board of Appeals a� City Council Action and Date EC( va< �► si zi I, `l . i �. �� 4� .. ! s � � .. .. t t .. . . i.. ... .. .... .. .. .. .. j � � .. � � .. ... ... .. .. .. .. I I -.� 4 ..:. i� _� r -. .' N. i i .. .. ' ?,;i .. .. (. t'.. .. .. � .. .... .. .. .. ... .. ..... ' I� i •f •: _. �. � � ,. ` ii. .. � :� f .� :. ;a � I � .. _, .. _ .. .. _ .. .. a }} � .._ 1 : � .... ... ... .. � .. „t _ ... _. _ .. .. ._....i .. i.t - .. _ .._. j. J -- — •- —I - - _ ...r_. _ + _ t .y 4 ,.. ,.- .> , .. I + , t ._ _ .... , .. ..._ _ .. .. City of Fridley SUBJECT AT THE TOP OF THE TWINS APPLICATION TO BOARD OF APPEALS r COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIV. (Staff Report) 1 PROTECTIVE INSPECTION SEC. i � ��"1 •� CITY HALL FRIDLEY° 55432 NUMHFH HEV. DATE PAGE OF APPROVED 6Y _.__.K 612-560-3450 910-F23 1 3/21/75 2' 2 800 Staff Comment Board members notified of meeting by 6-10-77 List members, date notified, and "Yes" or "No" for plans to attend hearing. Plan Date To Attend Virginia Schnabel Alex Barna Pat Gabel Jim Pleme Dick Kem r Pearson making appeal and the following property owners having property within 200 feet notified By Whom Name Date Phone or Mail Notified 1st Wisconsin Mtg. Co -8200 Normandale Blvd. Mpls 5437 1st Wisconsin Natl Bk of Milwaukee 777 E Wisconsin Ave. Milwauke6, wisc 53202 Mr. 4 Mrs. Herbert Franta-1415 North Danube Mark Dooley -5581 Matterhorn Dr. Fridley 55432 Mr. 4 Mrs. Fr nk Budzynski-5660 West Danube Road Mr. 4 Mrs. Kenneth Bureau -5630 West Danube Road Fr. 4 Mrs'. on Yurk­eW_-= Lincoln Terrace Mr. & Mrs. Elmo Ness -5647 Matterhorn Drive N.E. Mr. $ Mrs. De p in Becktola-5663 Matterhorn rive . Mr. & Mrs. Ro ald Varvilli-5674 Matterhorn Drive N.E. Thomas B. O'Rourke, Jr. 5695 Matterhorn Drive Mr. $ Mrs. Be jamin Ewers -5680 Matterhorn Drive N E. -E. Mr. & Mrs. Ro ert Sorenson- Matterhorn rive 1r. Mr. $ Mrs. Ke neth Miller -5652 Matterhorn Drive N E. (Over) Mr. $ Mrs. Melvin Stolquist-5624 Matterhorn Drive N.E. Mr. & Mrs. Derek Rolk-5610 Matterhorn Drive N.E. Mr. & Mrs. Garry Towne-5600 Matterhorn Drive N.E. Mr. & Mrs. Dennis Ulmer-5590 Matterhorn Drive N.E. Mr. & Mrs. Donald Blanding-5653 Regis Trail N.E. Mr. & Mrs. Curtis Rupert-5659 Regis Trail N..E. James Sprungman-5679 Regis Trail N.E. Barry J. Marchant-4366 Arden View Court-Ar'd�n Hills, Mn 55112 r �' TY a �' �r•'aCG��. .5'-Zq- 77 i .s7G 3® W . 4wouB E �D . - %_ A Item #3 June 14, 1977 ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF REPORT 1401 North Innsbruck Drive A. PUBLIC PURPOSED SERVED BY REQUIREMENT: Section 205.053, 4, C, requiring a rear yard setback equal to one fourth (k) of the lot depth with a 25 foot minimum. Public purpose served is to provide desired rear yard space to be used for green areas which add to the attractability of the neighborhood. B. STATED HARDSHIP: By facing house due west, mature White Oaks and Poplar would be destroyed or the elevation to the garage would be too great from North Innsbruck Drive. By facing the house southwest, on the angle, mature trees would be destroyed to make garage accessible. C. ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF REVIEW: Facing the house to the south means the actual rear yard is on the north side. The City Code defines the front yard on a corner lot as the shortest side, therefore, the west side is the front and the length of the house protrudes into the "technical" rear yard to the east. The house to the east faces West Danube Road and not North Innsbruck Drive. The layout appears to fit in with the existing neighborhood. GERALD T. COYNE 300 BRUNSWICK AVE. S. GOLDEN VALLEY. MINN. MINN. REG-. NO. 4741 INDUSTRIAL — JUDICIAL COMMERCIAL — TOPOGRAPHICAL CITY LOTS — PLATTING ROBERT LAUGEN HOMES INC. I LOT SURVEYS COMPANY LAND SURVEYORS BBG78TERED UNDER LAWS OF STATE Of 11@IREWA UCENSED BY ORDINANCE OF Crff OB NWNRAPOUB 5747 W. Broadway Minneapolis. Minnesota SS428 533-9922 l�'ttPlJitrS QZPI'�ttgfP �Q clfi /, '7LJ/ 4 01 RAYMOND A. FRASCH 6917 IDAHO AVE N. BROOKLYN PARK, MINN. MINN. REG. NO. 6743 INVOICE NO, 58 54 F. R, NO. SCALE I"= 3,0' 0 — DENOTES IRON MR Lot 15, Block 3, INNSBRUCK NORTH.' We hereby certify that this is a true and correct representation of a survey of the boundaries of the above ;. -,e d®scribed land and the location of all builldings and visible encroechmenfs, if any, from or on said lend. %6�� ;' Svtveyed by us this -1th. day of 19 —-- SURVEYS COMP OFFICIAL NOTICE CITY OF FRIDLEY PUBLIC HEARING BEFORE THE APPEALS COMMISSION TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN: NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the.Appeals Commission of the City of Fridley will meet in the Council Chamber of the City Hall at 6431 University Avenue Northeast at 7:30 P.M. on Tuesday, June 14, 1977 to consider the following matter: A request for a variance of Section 205.053, 4, C, Fridley City Code, to reduce the rear yard setback requirement of 25% of the lot from 34 feet to 27 feet, to allow the construction of a dwelling and garage on Lot 15, Block 3, Innsbruck North Addition, the same being 1401 North Innsbruck Drive N.E., Fridley, Minnesota. (Request by Barry J. Marchant, 4366 Arden View Court, Arden Hills, Minnesota 55112). Anyone who desires to be heard with reference to the above matter will be heard at this meeting. VIRGINIA SCHNABEL CHAIRWOMAN APPEALS COMMISSION Note: The Appeals Commission will have the final action on this request, unless there are objections from surrounding neighbors, City Staff, or the petitioner does not agree with the Commission's decision. If any of these events occur, the request will continue to the City Council through the Planning Commission. I I t CITY OF FRIOLMY, SUBJECTi MINNB90TA COMMISSION APPLICATION ._.. 7ivisiom NumberRev e9s Appreved 'by FI� NO/ ACOR6198 ..-- RILE DATE - ----. COMMMTE REVIEW CHECKLIST y =as i 1=tUY'ittA#M tQ iS4An#N1Nt3 3 MUM DA IN -7 COMMENTS i Darrf3l -- �l%v Ll,vgTorte Dick Deb APPEALS COMMISSION MEETING:-- JUNE 14, 1977 PAGE 9 Mr. Barna asked Mr. Holden if a fire door and fire wall would be required between the family room and garage and if the room would be heated year round since it would be a part of the living area. Mr. Holden said that Mr. Frisk would have to remove the present paneling and install 5/8^ sheetrock on both sides of the wall that would be common between the garage and the family room. He also said that a solid core door or a rated metal door would have to be installed between the family room and the garage. Mr. Frisk requested Mr. Holden to go out to his property to be sure that he is meeting all the 'codes• Mr. Holden said that he would have to have a layout plan when Mr. Frisk applied for his building permit- MOTION by Mr. Barna, seconded by Ms. Gabel, to close the Public Hearing. Upon a voice vote, all voting aye, the motion carried unanimously - Mr. Barna agreed with Vr• Weems that the proposed plan would enhance the home and the neighborhood and it would give additional living space and he would have no objections. Mr. Plemel said that with the assurance that Mr. Frisk would work with Mr. Holden, he would have no objections. MOTION by Mr. Barna, seconded by Ms. Gabel , that the Appeals Commission approve the request for a variance of Section 205.053, 41 B, to reduce the 10 foot setback requirement on the living area side of the house to five feet, to allow the enclosure of an existing porch, on, Lot 22, Block 3, Melody Manor Addition, the same being 7381 Lyric Lane N.E., Fridley, Minnesota. Upon a voice vote, all voting aye, the motion carried*unanimously. Chairwoman Schnabel indicated to Mr. Frisk that the request had been approved and that he was free to apply for his building permit {within one year from June 14, 19771. 3. REQUEST FOR A VARIANCE OFSECTION205.0531 41 C, TO REDUCE THE REAR YARD SETBACK REQUIREMENT OF 25% OF THE LOT FROM 34 FEET TO 27 FEET, TO ALLOW THE CONSTRUCTION OF A DWELLING AND GARAGE, ON LOT 151 BLOCK 31 INNSBRUCK NORTH ADDITION, THE SAME BEING 1401 NORTH INNSBRUCK DRIVE N.E. lRequest by Barry J- Marchant, 4366 Arden View Court, Arden Hills, Minnesota 55112.1 MOTION by Mr. Plemel, seconded by Mr- Barna, to open' the Public Hearing. Upon a voice vote, all voting aye, the motion carried unanimously- APPEALS COMMISSION MEETING — JUNE 141 1977 PAGE 10 ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF REPORT A. PUBLIC PURPOSE SERVED BY REQUIREMENT= Section 205.053, 4, C, requiring a rear yard setback equal to one fourth {1/4} of the lot depth with a 25 foot minimum. Public purpose served is to provide desired rear yard space to be used for green areas which add to the attractability of the neighborhood. B. STATED HARDSHIP: By facing house due west, mature White Oaks and Poplar would be destroyed or the elevation to the garage would be too great from North Innsbruck Drive. By facing the house southwest, on the angle, mature trees would-be destroyed to make garage accessible. C. ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF REVIEW: Facing the house to the south means the actual rear yard is on the north side. The City Code defines the front yard on a corner lot as the shortest side, therefore, the west side is the front and the length of the house protrudes into the "technical" rear yard to the east. The house to the east faces West Danube Road and not North Innsbruck Drive. The layout appears to fit in with the existing neighborhood. Mr. Marchant showed the Appeals Commission the plans he had for the construction of a home. He explained to the Commission his understanding of the City Code regarding how to define what is the rear yard of a lot. Mr. Marchant said that they had examined the possibility of facing the house due west and explained that the problems would be the loss of a tree that would end up in front of a, proposed garage door. He felt the way that they propose to situate the house on the lot would result in the loss of the fewest number of trees. He went on to explain that to situate the house facing north the problem would-be an approximate three foot incline in a 35 foot area. He said that even though that would face South he felt there would be a problem with snowpacking and ice forming on the incline. He explained that the way the plan is proposed there would be only an approximate 6 inch incline I APPEALS COMMISSION MEETING — JUNE 141 19?? PAGE 11 r Chairwoman Schnabel asked Mr. Marchant where the garage entrance would be located. Mr. Marchant responded that it would be on Matterhorn. Mr• Marchant explained that basically the request was based on aesthetics and the wish to save the trees and also he felt that the house he planned would fit the lot best as shown on the plans. Chairwoman Schnabel asked Mr. Marchant if he would want the house to face Matterhorn. Mr. Marchant said that he would not basically because if the garage would face North, he would lose the White Oak tree and if the garage faced South he would have the incline problem. There was some discussion on several other options as to how to situate the house on the property, none of which were satisfactory with Mr. Marchant. Mr• Marchant favored the situation of.the garage with the entrance to the side of the home rather than having the garage entrance on the front side of the home• MOTION by Mr. Plemel, seconded by Mr• Barna, that the Appeals Commission receive the letter from Mr• Kenneth Bureau of 5630 West Dan O --e Road in which he states that he would not object to Mr. Marchant's proposed house being as close as 25 feet of his West property line. Upon a voice vote, all voting, aye the motion carried and the letter was received. Mr- Plemel asked if the home was being built for Mr. Marchant's private use or would it be sold. Mr. Marchant responded that it would be his own residence. The Appeals Commission reviewed Mr. Marchant's house plans. Mr. Barna expressed that he could see Mr. Marchant's reasoning for not wanting the garage door on the front side of the house. A APPEALS COMMISSION MEETING — JUNE 14, 1977 PAGE 12 MOTION by Mr. Plemel, seconded by Mr. Barna, to close the Public Hearing. Upon a voice vote,all voting aye,the motion carried unanimously. Ms. Gabel said that she felt Mr. Marchant had looked into several alternatives and she also felt that the plan he had would probably be the best for the lot. Mr. Plemel thought it was a nice structure and the situation on the lot would be the most logical. Mr. Barna liked the way Mr. Marchant planned to situate the garage in relationship with the front of the house. MOTION by Ms. Gabel, seconded by Mr. Barna, that the Appeals Commission approve the request for a variance of Section 205.053, 4, C, to reduce the rear yard setback requirement of 25% of the Lot from 34 feet to 27 feet, to allow the construction of a dwelling and garage, on Lot 15,' Block 3, Innsbruck North Addition, the same being 1401 North Innsbruck Drive N.E. Upon a voice vote, all voting aye, the motion carried unanimously• Chairwoman Schnabel indicated that Mr. Marchant was now free to apply for a Building Permit. Chairwoman Schnabel requested that the Staff include an extra copy.of the Administrative Report in the folder so that the Commission can give one to the petitioner. 4. REQUEST FOR A VARIANCE OF SECTION 205.0531 51'A, FRIDLEY CITY CODE, TO REDUCE THE SIDE YARD WIDTH ON A STREET SIDE OF A CORNER LOT FROM THE REQUIRED 17 112 FEET TO 10-13 FEET, TO ALLOW AN ADDITION TO THE GARAGE FOR PARTIAL GARAGE AND LIVING AREA, ON LOT 10, BLOCK 51 EDGEWATER GARDENS, THE SAME BEING 90 N.E- 66th WAY. {Request by Roger A. Nawrocki, 90 NE 66th Way, Fridley, Minnesota 554321. MOTION by Mr. Plemel, seconded by Mr. Barna, to open the Public Hearing. Upon a voice vote, all voting aye, the motion carried unanimously.