VAR 07.79��J��T
CrTY riNEGOTA EY' SUBJECT
(612) 571-3450
portmc��f rv�sron
PUBLIC WORKS/CODE ENFORCEMENT
APPLICATION TO APPEALS COMMISSION
Number ev ane Approved by Date
910-F23 2 1 of 2. 800 7-17-79
I r
Namell Address S-C,hone 57`
L gal
Description
L o.
Block No.
Tract or Addn. 6'r
Variance Requests attach plat or
etc., where applicable)
survey of property showi i ding, variances,
List s ec' is hardship(s) which requires the variance(s)
rl
P-az� A& 144-e- a6z4eL
F A
Y e2t.&&!2�
.v2
ae
Meetin Date
Fee
Receipt
9
o.
S gnature
'fte _
Comments & Recommendations by
the Appeals Commission /';�-
_
f�
6..
/ 4� �.
I
City Council Action and Date
For Internal Use,
S710JECi
c INr4rSBOTA
portment msion
PUBLIC WORKS/CODE ENFORCEMENT
APPLICATION TO APPEALS COMMISSION
(Staff Report)
NumberApproved y Dote
910-F23 2 2 of 2 800 7-17-79
Staff Comments:
Board members notified of meeting by % — VC) List members,
date notified, and "Yes" or "No" for plans to attend hearing.
Plan
Name Date To Attend
Person ma° ing appeal and the following property owners
notified:
M/M Phillip Dierling-5972 5th Street N.E.
M/M Archie Lahti-5964 5th Street N.E.
— Margaret Seefeld-5956 5th St. N.£'.'
M/M Ronald Ocel-5948 5th Street N.E.
_ M/M John Carraher-5941 4th St. N.E.
M/M Thomas Annett-5949 4th St. N.E.
— M/M Harold Weinreich-5947 4th St. N.E.
_ M/M James Lambert-5965 4th St. N.E.
M/M Gary Webb-5973 4th St. N.E.
_ Allan W. Weber-5980 4th 5t. N.E.
M/M Mark Zeck-5978 4th St. N.E.
_.M/M Douglas Mehr-5974 4th St. N.E.
M/M Joseph Healy-5968 4th St. N.E.
_,George Hultman-5960 4th St. N.E.
Clinton Coppicus-5950 4th St. N.E.
_ M/M Julius Jenson-5946 4th St. N.E.
M/M Michael Perreten-5980 5th St. N.E.
M/M Lyle•Linnell-5976 5th St. N.E.
M/M Gerald Gorecki-5977 4th St. N.E.
— M/M Leslie Berge-5987°4th Street CE,
having
yDate
property within
T".5 Mail
200 feet
By Whom
'fied
Fol Internal Use
CITY OF FRIDLEY
6431 UNIVERSITY AVENUE N.E., FRIDLEY, MINNESOTA 55432
AMENDED
N'0TI(:E OF PUBLIC HEARING
TELEPHONE ( 612)571.3450
August 1, 1980
's hereby given that the Appeals Commission of the
(duct a public hearing in the City Council Chambers
!rye Northeast a'C 7:30 P.M. on Tuesday, August 12,
V luiving matter:
City of Fridley
at 6431 Univer-
1980, in regard
Consideration of a variance request pursuant to
Chapter 205 of the Fridley Code, to reduce the
side yard setback for an attached garage from
the required 5 feet to 3.5 feet, to allow the
construction of a j3 ft. by 29 ft. addition to
an existing.attached garage, located on Lot 19,
Block 2, Bennett Palmer.-Additiom- the same
being 5965 4th Street N.E., Fridley, Minnesota,
EC'Ii;e i -I hv— t.iJ all }erscns having inLcres+ aC-3
e}�,n will be
given an , pp"'z.r .uni Gy to .:_ heard at the above t i;mo a?!e, place.
VIRGli;TA SC)%ABLE
CHAT nl• 0MAN
APPEALS f:OMMISSION
Note: The. Appeals will have the final action on this request, unless
there are objections froiii surrounding neighbors, the City Staff, or the'pe::itioner
doeZ- not ag-,2e with Che i:o rir.ssian's de(Asion. Iif any of ;.hese events occur, the
request wii! to tk City Council th'!o(igh IL -he Planning Commission with
only a reCk,7;if`C?I?.J:iLi0ii 'iP'l.tii ti�:? Appeals (;;)ll!?`•, ?Ute.
August 12, 1980 Item #,1
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF REPORT
5965 4th Street N.E.
A. PUBLIC PURPOSE SERVED BY REQUIREMENT:
Section 205.053, 48W #4, requires a side yard setback of 5 feet on an
attached garage.
Public purpose served by this requirement is to provide open space between
individual structures to reduce conflagration of fire, to provide access
to the rear yard for emergencies, and to limit the condition of crowding
in a residential neighborhood.
B. STATED HARDSHIP:
My car is too long for present garage, plus we have 2 cars. We have 8
children and many bikes and a canoe, in general, not enough space."
C. ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF REPORT:
The existing attached single car garage is 16.5 feet from north property
line, and they wish to add on a 13 foot garage addition that would be
only 3.5 feet from the line. The neighbor's house to the north is 7 feet
from the common lot line, which would leave 10.5 feet between a living area
and a garage. Therefore, if the Board approves this request we recommend
that there be no unprotected openings in the north wall of the garage
addition and that the exterior of the north wall be 5/8 Type -X -gypsum
sheet..rock:
SJUNJERNLAICIM
ano Sys
r- 1 -o -rd mNltmN%i-icj ojL Nun.Law
JLSI-1>103H0 MaIAMI 23.LB3'ldVlJO3
sm
010(3 -- �Aiq pa Ac i d d vNn8nd A.IP 2od3n'
r
OUVO
Vo ld�dV r,,JOISSILAJUUC:3
I
lonronsi
City of Fridley
APPEALS COMMISSION MEETING - AUGUST'12, 1980 Paqe 1
CALL TO ORDER:
Chairwoman Schnabel called the Appeals Commission meeting of August 12, 1980
to.order at 7:30 p.m.
ROLL CALL:
Members Present: Virginia Schnabel, Alex Barna, Patricia'Gabel, Jim Plemel
Members Absent: Dick Kemper
Others Present: Darrel Clark, Chief Building Official
APPROVE APPEALS COMMISSION MINUTES: JULY 15, 1980
MOTION by Mr. Barna, seconded by Mrs. Gabel, that the Appeals Commission
minutes of July 15, 1980 be approved as written. UPON A VOICE VOTE, ALL
VOTING AYE, CHAIRWOMAN SCHNABEL DECLARED THE MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
1. VARIANCE REQUEST'PURSUANT TO -CHAPTER 205 OF THE FRIDLEY CITY CODE, TO
REDUCE THE SIDE YARD SETBACK FOR AN ATTACHED GARAGE FROM THE REQUIRED
5 FEET TO 3.5 FEET, TO ALLOW THE CONSTRUCTION OF A 13 FT. BY 29 FT.
ADDITION TO AN EXISTING ATTACHED GARAGE, LOCATED ON LOT 19, BLOCK 2,
BENNETT PALMER ADDITION, THE SAME BEIN35965 4TH STREET N.E., FRIDLEY,
MINNESOTA.-' (Request by James M. Lambert, 5965 4th Street N.E.,
Fridley, Minnesota 55432).
James M. Lambert, 5965 4th Street N.E., was present and Gary Webb,
5973 4th Street N.E., was also present.
MOTION by Mr. Plemel, seconded by•Mrs Gabel, to open the public he
UPON A VOICE VOTE, ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRWOMAN SCHNABEL DECLARED THE PUBLIC
HEARING OPEN AT 7:35 P.M.
Chairwoman Schnabel read the staff report:
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF,REPORT
5965 4th Street N.E.
A. PUBLIC PURPOSE SERVED BY REQUIREMENT:
Section 205.05.3,•4B, #4, requires a side -yard -setback of 5 feet on an .
attached garage.
Public purpose served by this requirement is to provide open space
between individual structures to reduce conflagration of fire, to provide
access to the rear yard for emergencies, and to limit the condition"of
crowding in a residential neighborhood.
9
APPEALS COMMISSION MEETING - AUGUST 12, 1980 Page 2
B. STATED HARDSHIP --
"My car is too long for present garage, plus we have 2 cars. We have -
8 children and many bikes and a canoe, in general, not enough space."
C. ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF REPORT:
The existing attached single car garage is 16.5 feet from north property
line, and they wish to add on a 13 foot garage addition that would be
only 3.5 feet from the line. The neighbor's house to the north is
7 feet from the common lot line, which would leave 10.5 feet between a
living area and a garage. Therefore, if the Board approves this request,
we recommend that there be no unprotected openings in the north wall
-of the garage addition and that the exterior of the north wall be 5/8"
Type X gypsum sheet rock.
Mr. Clark stated that on the elevations of the proposed addition there are
windows and a door and that these would be all right if the windows are wire -
glass windows and the door is a self-closing fire door.
Mr. Lambert stated that he had a lot.of stuff stacked on the north side of
his house and this addition would -improve the appearance of the existing area
and also allow him to fit his car into the garage. He also stated that the
roof and siding of the addition will match the roof and siding of his house.
Mr. Webb stated that he had no -objections -to Mr. Lambert's proposed addition.
MOTION BY Mr. Barna, seconded by Mr. Plemel, to close the public hearing.
UPON A VOICE VOTE, ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRWOMAN SCHNABEL DECLARED THE PUBLIC
HEARING CLOSED AT 8 P.M.
MOTION by Mr. Barna, seconded by Mr. Plemel, to allow request for variance to
reduce the side yard setback for an attached garage from the required 5•feet
to 3.5 feet, to allow the construction of a 13 ft. by 29 ft. addition to an
existing attached garage, located on Lot 19, Block 2, Bennett Palmer Addition,
the same being 5965 4th Street N.E., Fridley, Minnesota, with the stipulations
that any openings on the north wall be a•protective type of wire=glass windows
and self-closing.fire door -and the exterior wall be 5/8" Type X gypsum
sheet rock. -UPON A VOICE VOTE, ALL•VOTING AYE, CHAIRWOMAN SCHNABEL DECLARED
THE MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY. °
ADJOURNMENT:
MOTION made by Mr. Barna, seconded by Mrs. Gabel, to adjourn the meeting.
UPON A VOICE VOTE, ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRWOMAN SCHNABEL DECLARED THE APPEALS
COMMISSION MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 1980 ADJOURNED AT 8:05 P.M.
Respectfully submitted,
Deb Niznik, Rhca&ding Secretary
^f
• City of Fridley
APPEALS COMMISSION MEETING - AUGUST 12, 1980 Page 1
CALL TO ORDER:
Chairwoman Schnabel called the Appeals Commission meeting of August 12, 1980
to order at 7:30 p.m.
ROLL CALL:
Members Present: Virginia Schnabel, Alex Barna, Patricia'Gabel, Jim Plemel
Members Absent: Dick Kemper
Others Present: Darrel Clark, Chief Building Official
APPROVE APPEALS COMMISSION MINUTES: JULY 15, 1980
MOTION by Mr. Barna, seconded by Mrs.'Gabel, that the Appeals Commission
minutes of July 15, 1980 be approved as written. UPON A VOICE VOTE, ALL
VOTING AYE, CHAIRWOMAN SCHNABEL DECLARED THE MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
1. VARIANCE REQUEST PURSUANT TO -CR APTER 205 OF THE FRIDLEY CITY CODE, TO
REDUCE THE SIDE YARD SETBACK FOR AN ATTACHED GARAGE FROM THE REQUIRED
5 FEET TO 3.5 FEET, TO ALLOW THE CONSTRUCTION OF A 13 FT. BY 29 FT.
ADDITION TO AN EXISTING ATTACHED GARAGE, LOCATED ON LOT 19, BLOCK 2,
BENNETT PALMER ADDITION, THE SAME BEING 5965 4TH STREET N.E., 'RIDLEr,
MINNESOTA. (request by James M. Lambert, 5965 4th Street N.E.,
Fridley, Minnesota 55432).
James M. Lambert, 5965 4th Street N.E., was present and Gary Webb,
5973 4th Street N.E., was also present.
MOTION by Mr. Plemel, seconded by Mrs.'Gabel, to open' -the publ c'hearing.
UPON A VOICE VOTE, ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRWOMAN SCHNABEL DECLARED THE PUBLIC
HEARING OPEN AT 7:35 P.M.
Chairwoman Schnabel read the staff report: .
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF REPORT
5965 4th Street N.E.•
A.' PUBLIC PURPOSE SERVED BY REQUIREMENT:'
s ,
Section .205.053,.4B, #4, requires a side yard setback -of 5 feet 'on an
attached garage.
Public purpose served by this requirement- is- to•provide open space
between individual structures to reduce conflagration of fire, to provide
access to. the rear yard for emergencies, and to limit the condition of
crowding in a residential neighborhood.
APPEALS COMMISSION MEETING - AUGUST 12, 1980 Page 2
B. STATED HARDSHIP:
"My car is too long for present garage, plus we have 2 cars. We have
8 children and many bikes and a canoe, in general, not enough space."
C. ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF REPORT:
The existing attached single car garage is 16..5 feet from north property
line, and they wish to add on a 13 foot garage addition that would be
only 3.5 feet from the line. The neighbor's house to the north is
7 feet from the common lot line, which would leave 10.5 feet between a
living area and a garage.. Therefore, if the Board approves this request,
we recommend that there be -no unprotected openings in the north wall
of the garage addition and that the exterior of.the north wall be 5/8"
Type X gypsum sheet rock.
Mr. Clark stated that on the elevations of the proposed addition there are
windows and a door and that these would be all right if the windows are wire -
glass windows and the door is a self-closing fire door..
Mr. Lambert stated that he had a lot.of stuff stacked on the north side of
his house and this addition would improve the appearance of the existing area
and also allow him to fit his car into the garage. He also stated that the
roof and siding of the addition.will match the roof and siding of his house.
Mr: Webb stated_that -he had no objections to Mr. Lambert's proposed addition.
MOTION BY Mr. Barna, seconded by Mr. Plemel, to close the public hearing.
UPON A VOICE VOTE, ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRWOMAN SCHNABEL DECLARED THE PUBLIC
HEARING CLOSED AT 8 P.M.
MOTION by Mr. Barna, seconded by Mr. Plemel•, to allow request for variance to
reduce the side yard setback for an attached garage from.the required 5 feet
to 3.5 feet, to allow the construction of a 13 ft. by 29 ft. addition to an
existing attached garage, located on Lot 19, Block 2, Bennett Palmer Addition,
the same being 5965 4th Street N.E., Fridley, Minnesota, with the stipulations
that any openings on the north wall be a protective type of wire -glass windows
and self-closing fire door and the exterior wall be 5/8" Type X gypsum
sheet rock. UPON A VOICE VOTE,. ALL'VOTING AYE, CHAIRWOMAN SCHNABEL DECLARED
THE MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.
ADJOURNMENT:
MOTION made by Mr. Barna, seconded by Mrs. Gabel, to adjourn the meeting.
UPON A VOICE VOTE, ALL VOTING AYE, CHAIRWOMAN SCHNABEL DECLARED THE APPEALS
COMMISSION MEETING OF AUGUST 12, 1980 ADJOURNED AT 8:05 P.M.
Respectfully submitted,
�R
Deb Niznik, Rec ding Secretary