Loading...
04/10/1978 - 00014212+l THE MINUTES OF THE PU6LIC HEARING MEETI�JG OF THE FRIDLEY CITY COUNCIL OF APRIL 10, 1978 The Public Heartng Meeting of the Fridley City Council was cabled to order by P9ayor Nee at 7:30 p.m PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Mayor Nee led the Council and audience in the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag. ROLL CALL• MEPIBERS PRESENT MEMBERS ABSENT Councilman Barnette, Councilman Schneider, Mayor Nee Councilman Hamernik and Councilman Fitzpatrick None ADOPTION OF AGENDA: Mayor Nee requested two items be added to the agenda as follows: (1) Receipt of a letter from P1r Virgil Nordgren, Re Testing of Firearms and (2) Request by Islantls of Peace Re Sate7lite Service. 1 MOTION by Councilman Fitzpatrick to add the above two items to the agenda. Seconded by Councilman Barnette. Upon a vo�ce vote, a]1 voting aye, Playor Nee declared the motion carried una m mously MOTION by Councilman Hamernik to adopt the agenda as amended. Seconded by Council- man Schneider. Upon a voice vote, all voting aye, Mayor Nee declared the motion carried unanimously. PUBLIC HEARINGS PU6LIC HEARING ON WILLIAM A. NICKLO -SALE LIQUOR LICEMSE AND Fl SUNDAY LIOUOR LI MOTION by Councilman Fitzpatrick to watve the readrnq of the Public HearTng notice and open the Public Hear�ng. Seconded by Councilman Schneider. Upon a voice vote, all voting aye, Mayor Nee declared the motion carried unanimously and the Publ�c Hearing opened at 7:32 p m. Mr. Nicklow stated they have contracted to have their parking lot reconditioned and the holes filled. He stated this would be done as soon as the weather permits. Mr. Nicklow also stated they have extended their parking lot on the East side of their property behind Sears. Mayor Nee stated he was pleased to see that food constitutes over 50% of their sales. There was no response from the audience regardtng thts renewal of the liquor license for Shorewood Inn. MOTION by Councilman Schneider to close the Public Hearing. Seconded by Councilman Barnette. Upon a voice vote, all voting aye, Playor Nee declared the mot�on carried unantmously and the Public Hearinq closed at 7 35 n.m. PUBLIC NEARING ON AN ON-SALE LIOUOR LICENSE AND A SUN�AY LIQUOR LICENSE TO 1 MOTION by Councilman Schneider to waive the reading of the Publ�c Hearing not�ce and open the Public Hearing. Seconded by Councilman Hamernik. Upon a vo�ce vote, all voting aye, Mayor Nee declared the motion carried unanimously � and the Public Hearing opened at 7�3 p m. Mayor Nee asked Mr. Weiss about the status of the sprinkler system for hts building Mr. Weiss stated he has signed a contract to have the sprinkling system installed. I� � PUBLIC HEARING MEETINU OF APRIL 10, 1978 PAGE 2 P�ayor ��ee asked if he �.�as ab1e to obtain the lower cost system. Mr Uleiss indicated this system wasn't approved by the State and he was told tt was a bad deal if the City wanted fire protection. Mr. Quresht, City Manager, stated if the s�st:zin meets �he requirerrents, there wouldn't be any problem having it installed. There was no response from the audience regarding this renewal of the liquor license for Sandee's. MOTION by Councilman Schnetder to close the Public Heariny. Seconded by Councilman Barnette. Upon a voice vote, all voting aye, Mayor Nee declared the motion carr�ed unam mously and the Publtc Hearin9 closed at 7 4� p.m. PUBLIC HEARING ON AN ON-SALE LIOUOR LICENSE AND A SUNDAY LIOUOR LICENSE TO MOTION by Councilman Schneider to waive the reading of the Public Hear7nq nottce and �pen thP Ptahlic Hearing. SeconriPd hy C�uncilman Hamei°n�k, l�non a voice vn�2; aVl voTina aye, P1ayor Nee de�l�re�1 the mnt�on car�ied una m mously and the Public Hearing opPned at 7•a0 �,m htayor Nee stated i�r. Aldr�ch of the fire D2partment hus ind�cat�d that Plaple Lanes has one more year to go befo�°e they hade to provi�e spr�nk�2rs Mr. Brunsell, City Clerk, pointed out that this establ�shment, as v�el1 as all the others applying for renewal of the liquor licenses, meets the food requ�rements, tidith the except�on of the Rice 6o�v1 vanich hasn't started to serve liquor. Mr. Sobtech, Public Works Director, stated hlaple Lanes has cooper-ated with the City in the past and felt they have come u long way w-ith theii° -improve- ments There was tio response from the audience rega�•d-�n9 this renevaal of thz liquor license for Maple Lanes. MC�TIO�� b,� Courc�lman Barrette to close the Pub�-�c Nearinq. Secorded bi� Councilman Schretder. Upon a ve�ce vote, all veting aye, Mayor Piee declared the motion carried unanimously and the Public Hearing closed at 7:�3 p m. PUBLIC HEARIPJG ON AN ON-SALE LIQUOR LICENSE AIVG A SUNDA`( LI4UOR LICCNSE TC E MOTION by Councilman Hamernik to waive the read�ng of the Public Hear�ng notice and open the Public Hearin�. Seconded by Councilman Sc�ne-ider Uuon a voice vote, all voting aye, P�ayor� Nee declarad the �notion carr-�ed unani�nously and the Public Heariny opened at 7:43 p.m. Mr. Sobtech stated there are exterior tmprovements to be made at this location, ho�vever, a lot of the �mprovements would be contingen� on whether the serv�ce drive is constructed. Mr. Sobiech stated the matter of the service drive improvement is before the Council this evening for scheduling a public hearing for this pro�ect. Mr. So6iech stated, in any event, the staff would work with Mr. Purmort on the external landscaping and rndicated the City does have a performance bond to insure compl7ance. Mr. Brunsell stat2d the raito of food sales to liquor sales shows 131 of the sales are For food. �� �, , m PUBLIC HEARING MEETING DF APRIL 10, 1978 PAGE 3 Mayor Nee asked when the landscaping would be done, if the street improvement does not occur. Mr. Sobiech stated the City would require completion of the landscaping along the fJorth and West property lines. On the East side, if the service drive is not constructed, they would encourage grading to an approprtate elevation and landscaping tn the area, Mr Purmort stated they are in the process of doing the landscap7ng, but have not done anything on the East side of the property, until the status of the s2rvtce dr�ve is determined. There was no response from the audience regarding this request for renewal of the liquor license for House of Londs. MOTION by Counc�lman Hamerntk to close the Public Hearing. Seconded by Councilman Barnette. llpon a voice vote, all voting aye, Mayor Nee declared the mot�on carried unantmously and the Pqblic Hearing closed at 7:47 p.m. LIC HEARING ON AN ON-SALE LIQUOR LICENSE AND A SUNDAY LIQUOR LICENSE TO ARD JOHNSON COMPANY WALTER W. CURCIO FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 5277 TRAL AVENUE N.E. DBA GROUND ROUND MOTION by Counctlman Schne�der to waive the reading of the Public Hearing notice and open the Fubl�c Hearing. Seconded by Councilman Hamernik. Upon a voice voie, all voting aye, Mayor Nee declared the motion carried unanimously and the Public Hearing opened at 7:47 p.m. Mayor Nee noted the ratio of food and liquor sales for this establishment shows 54% of sales are for food. There was no response from the audience regarding this request for renewal of the liquor license at the Ground Round. MOTION by Councilman Schneider to close the Public Hearing. Seconded by Councilman Fitzpatrick. Upon a voice vote, all voting aye, Mayor Nee declared the motion carr�ed una m mously and the Pu61ic Hearing closed at 7:49 p.m. PUBLIC HEARING ON AN ON-SALE LIQUOR LICEPdSE APJD A SUNiIAY LIQUOR LICENSE TO MOTION by Counc�lman Fitzpatrick to waive the reading of the Public Hearing notice and open the PUhlic Hearing. Seconded by Councilman Hamernik. Upon a voice vote, all vot�ng aye, Mayor Nee declared the motion carried unanimously and the Public Hearing opened at 7•50 p.m Mayor Plee asked if sprinklers had been �nstalled �4r. P�icklow stated they are plamm �g to expand which would take about 32 months so he felt it would be about 6 months before the sprtnkler system is installed, 7n eon,7unction with the expansion. Mayor Nee stated he noted they have met the requirements of food sales in relation to liquor sales. Mr Ntcklow stated the dim ng room business has picked up considerably with completion of the Camden bridge. There was no response from the audience regarding this request for renewal of the liquor license for George's in Fridley. MOTION by Councilman Barnette to close the Public Hearing. Seconded by Councilman Fitzpatrick Upon a voice voie, all voting aye, Mayor Nee declared the motion carried unanimously and the Public Hearing closed at 7 52 p.m. I� ' ' PIIRITf HFARIN� MFETING OF APRIL 10, 1978 PAGE 4 ' MOTION by Councilman Schneider to waive the reading of the Public Hearinq notice and open the Public Hearing. Seconded by Councilman Hamer m k. Upon a vo7ce vote, all voting aye, Mayor Nee declared the motion carried unanimously and the Pu61�c Hearing opened at 7.52 p m. Mr. Sobeich, Public Works �irector, stated one of the rzqu�rements of the existing liquor license was that the Cit,y staff ineet with the owners to discuss � exterior development. Mr. Sobiech stated siafF has met with the owners and they have plans to work wtth an architect regarding the motiff of the outside of the building. Mr. Sobiech stated staff would recommend approval and they would continue to work with the owners regarding the exterior development of the building. Councilman Schneider asked what arrangements have been made regarding signing. Mr. Sobiech stated the owners do have ideas regarding the signing which possibly wiil call �or removal of some siyns and install�nq others. He felt he would like to see them obtain the archttect they desire, to see vehat they come up wi th There was no response from the audience regarding this request for renewal of the liquor license for the Fireside Rice Bowl. MOTION by Councilman 5chneider to close the Public Hearing. Seconded by Councilman Fitzpatrick. Upon a voice vote, all voting aye, Mayor Nee declared the mot�on carried unanimously and the Publ�c Hearing closed at 7:55 �.m. PROJECT ST 1978-2, A�DENDUM l (17G . � MOTION by Councilman Schneider to open the Public Hearing. Seconded by Councilman Fitzpatrick. Upon a voice vote, all voting aye, Mayor Nee declared the motion carreid unanimously and the Pu61ic Hearinq opened at 7:55 p.m. Mayor Nee stated this item had been tabled on March 13, 1978, in order that �he affected property owner, P1r. Saunders, could be notified of this proposed improvement for installation of sidewalks on the East side of 7zh Street from 61st to 63rd Avenue. Mr. Sobiech, Public Works Director, stated the City and School District '„'14 would share in the cost of this improvement, with no cost to the property owner Mr. Sobiech stated, hopefully, the City could work with the property cwner, Mr. Saunders, on some easements in order to have the proper alignment for the sidewalk. Mr. Sotriech stated Mr. Saunders has shrubbery alon9 his property and the City would have to work with him on replacement and landscaping Mayor Nee explained that the request for the sidewalks was made by the School Board to facilitate the school children who would be going to Hayes School, as a result of the closing of �arkview Scheol. , Mr. ,]im Hedren, representing School District #14, stated they don't anticipate a large volume of traffic in that area He stated there always will be children walking to school whether or not there ts bus service provided. Councilman Schneider stated he noted the Parks and Recreation Commission recommended a d�fferent route for the sidewalks and asked what this would tnvolve. PUBLIC HEARING MEETING OF APRIL 1D, 1978 PAGE 5 Mr. Sobiech stated the Commission's recommendation was to move the sidewalk East of 7th Street, along the Junion High School property, for a tie into Monroe Street. He stated this would involve acquiring some easements from private property owners Councilman Schneider stated there were several other concerns raised at the last meeting regarding the sprinkler system, fencing, trees, etc. Mr. Qureshi, City Manager, stated it would cost about $4,000 to relocate all these items. Mr. Hedren stated they did not want to cause any problems with the park and stated if these are the�requirements, the School District is certainly willing to go 50/50 on the cost. Mr. Qureshi stated'Councilman Barnette had discussed these additional costs with the School Board, after Mr. P�erce had attended the previous meet�ng Mr. Hedren stated another aspect, which hasn't been finalized, is the use of Parkview School as a Community School and the serving of lunches to senior citizens. He stated,w�th construction of the sidewalk, it would also provide access for the senior citizens to the school. Mr. Sob�ech stated that, with development of the senior citizen and housing complex, sidewalks will be installed by the developer along the West side of 7th Street, Mr Qureshi pointed out that, at the present time, the City would not relocate the ballfields, however, some signing wou7d be put up. It would be necessary, however, to relocate trees and some of the sprinkling system. Councilman Schneider questioned if the City would be opening itself to some additional liability by not moving that ballfield and someone was hit by a ball. Mr. Qureshi stated he felt, when sidewalks are along a park, you always have thts potential. He felt it would be safer if the ball f�elds were relocated and backstops installed, however, this would result in additional cost. Mr. Qureshi stated the School Board has indicated that whatever cost is involved, they will contribute 50%. Mr. Saunders, the affected property owner, indicated he had no ob�ection to the sidewalk construction and would give easement to the City as long as there is no sidewalk assessment to their property. Mr. Qureshi stated an easement wiii be necessary from Mr. Saunders and the City would work with him on any replant�ngs and landscaping. MOTION by Councilman Schneider to close the Public Hearing. Seconded by Councilman Fitzpatrick. Upon a voice vote, all voting aye, Mayor Nee declared the motion carried unam mously and the Pu61ic Hearinq closed at 8:08 p.m. OLD BUSINESS: I�ERATION OF REOUESTS BY HARVEY ROLSTAD; SPECIAL llSE PERMIT S. P. Mr. Sobiech, Public Works D�rector, stated Mr. Rolstad was invited to attend the meeting, but would be here later since �t wasn't anticipated the Council would be considering this request until a later hour. 1 1 ' ' � L__1 PUBLIC HEARING MEETING OF APRIL 10, 1978 PAGE 6 Mr. Sobiech, Pu61ic Works Director, stated staff has met with Mr. Rolstad regarding his requests for a special use permit and lot spl�t. He stated it was learned that potential buyers of the property have indicated they plan to construct a garage. Mr. Sobiech felt, therefore, the stipulation of the garage requirement, in con,7unction with the lot split, would be no problem. He felt there should be an additional stipulation on the garage that it be compieted by September 1, 1979. Mr. Sobiech stated staff would recommend the driveway access be from Street to the rear yard. He stated this was done on property to the North and has worked out satisfactorily. Mr. Sobiech stated there is possi6tlity of the garage being attached to the house which would necessitate the need for a variance. 2nd the Mr. Sobtech stated one alternative, which the staff would not recommend, is access from 46th Avenue through vacated properties. He felt this would involve certain liabtlity questions between three different property owners for vehicles and equipment going through the close quarters. Mr. Sobiech stated Mr. Rolstad felt there would be no problem in having the garage requ�rement put in the abstract so any potential buyer would be aware they would have to construct a garage. MOTIoN 6y Councilman F�tzpatrick to concur with the recommendation of the Planning Commission and grant Lot Split #78-01, as requested by Harvey Rolstad, with the stipulation that a garage be constructed on the property by September 1, 1979, and recommend that this garage have access from 2nd Street; further, the City take steps to make sure this is apparent in the abstract. Seconded by Councilman Schneider. Upon a voice vote, all voting a��e, Mayor Nee declared the mot�on carried una m mously. MOTION 6y Councilman F�tzpatrick to concur with the recommendat�on oF the Plamm �g Commission and approve Special Use Permit #78-03, as requested by Harvey Rolstad, Seconded by Councilman Hamernik. Upon a voice vote, all vottng aye, Mayor Nee declared the motion carried unanimously Later in the meeting, Mr. Rolstad advised he had s�gned a purchase agreement for hts property and has indicated certatn garage requirements to the buyer. He stated one thing put in the purchase agreement was the option for access from 46th Avenue through the vacated alley. Councilman Fitzpatrick indicated there may be certain problems involved with access from 46th Avenue and asked Mr. Sobiech to review the comments he made earl�er. Councilman Fitzpatr�ck stated, if the buyer feels strongly about access from 46th Avenue, he has the right to petition for this, but felt he did not want to change the motion to automatically give that access. Mayor Nee felt the buyer could work out an access, without City approval, because it involves private land. Mr. Rolstad pointed out that he felt the buyer would build an attached garage. Mayor Nee stated there proba6ly would be more of a problem to build an attached garage, because of the extreme variance required, and the buyer would have to apply for a variance. Mr. Quresht, City Manager, pointed out that whether the access is from 2nd or 46th, it has to 6e a paved access. Mr. Sobiech stated staff would review, with �r. Rolstad, the stipulations of the lot split regarding construction of the garage no later than September 1, 1979, and the requ�rements for a paved access. �j �f, J� PUBLIC HEARING MEETING OF APRIL 10, 1978 NEW BUSINESS IDERATION OF PAGE 7 BETWEEN DONAL� AND LOIS l�1HITE � . Mr. Sobiech, Public Works D�rector, stated this item had been discussed by the Council at their meeting of January 23, 1978. At that time, it was suggested that perhaps Mr and Mrs. White could share in the cost of the culvert extension. Since the property owner did noi wish to share in the cost of the extension, the request for the extension was denied by Counc�l. Mr. Sobiech stated, since this time, staff has worked with Mr. and Mrs. White and there has been an agreement regarding the extension of the culverts which is now before the Council for consideration. Mr. Sobiech stated what the agreement covers is that Mr. and Mrs. White would purchase the materials for one culvert extension and the City would provide the materials for the remaining culvert extension and all instaliation costs. Mr. Sobiech stated it would be a �oint effort in trying to solve the problem. The cost to Mr. and P1rs. White would be $�26 and the cost to the City would be $1,309 Mayor Nee stated he was concerned about Item 4 in the agreement where it states that each party reserves their right to make claim for any future damages. Councilman Schneider also tndicated his concern and suggestetl it be deleted. Mr. Sobiech stated the City Attorney had some rationalization regarding that pa rt�cular clause Councilman Fitzpatrick felt poss�bly actton shouldn't be taken on the agreement without the City Attorney present. Mr. Qureshi, City Manager, felt the Council could approve the agreement with deletion of Item 4, and if this is not agreeable to the property owner, it would be brought back to the Council MOTION by Councilman Fitzpatrick to amend the agreement by deletion of Item 4. Seconded by Councilman Schneider. Regarding Item 5, Councilman Hamer m k questioned if the City is assuming any responstbility for mainta�ning it. Mr. Sobiech stated this is done with alT the City`s storm sewers. UPON A VOICE VOTE TAKEN ON THE MOTION, all voted aye, and Mayor Nee declared the motion carried unanimously Mayor Nee stated he also shared Councilman Hamernik's concern regarding Item 5 and questioned if this item should be deleted. Councilman Fitzpatrick stated it seems the City's action would be the same whether or not this ttem is included. MOTION by Councilman Fitzpatrick to amend the agreement by deletion of Item 5. Seconded by Councilman Hamernik. Upon a voice vote, all votinq aye, Mayor Nee declared the mot�on carr�ed unanimously. MOTIdN by Councilman F�tzpatrick to authorize the City entering into the agreement with Donald and Lois White, as amended. Seconded 6y Councilman Hamerm k Upon a voice vote, all voting aye, Mayor Nee declared the motion carried unan�mously. n �I , ' � � � PU6LIC HEARING MEETING �F APRIL 10, 1978 ING THE PRELIMINARY � PAGE � Mr. Sobiech stated this improvement would cover the service drive which, basically, abuts the House of Lords He stated the serv7ce drtve in front of the golf driving range is not included. MOTION by Councilman Hamernik to adopt Resolution No. 31-1978. Seconded My Councilman Fitzpatrick Upon a voice vote, all vot�ng aye, Mayor Nee declared the motion carried unanimously. CLAIMS: MOTION by Councilman Hamernik to authorize payment of Claims No. 093A30 through D96993. Seconded by Councilman Fitzpatrick. Upon a voice vote, all voting aye, Mayor Nee declared the motion carried unanimously. REQUEST BY ISLANDS OF PEACE RE SATELLITE SERVICE: Mr. Qureshi, City Manager, stated a request has been recetved by the Islands of Peace Foundat�on for the C�ty to pay for sanitary satellite services at the Islands of Peace. Mr Qureshi stated the cost of the two satellites is about $90 per month. He stated, previous to this time, community education paid the cost. MOTION by Councilman Fitzpatrick that the Ci�y assume the cost of these satellites, as it provides public sanitation serv�ces where needed, un±il such t�me as the sani�ation facilit�es are available in the buildin9. Seconded by Councilman Barnette. Mr. Ed Wilmes, representing the Islands of Peace Foundation, stated the School District paid for these satellites up until September, 1977. He stated the charge for these services was $674 from September, 1977, through April, 1978, however, two were stolen, which insurance did not cover, so the total billing was $933. Mr Wilmes stated the Islands of Peace made a payment of �535, leaving a balance of 3398 and requested the City also pay this amount. Councilman Fitzpatrick stated he had no ob�ection to adding to the motion that this b�ll of $398 be included. WITH PERMISSION OF HIS SECON�ER, Counci1man Barnette, Councilman Fitzpatrick requested that the payment of $398 for the outstanding bill be included in the motion. Councilman Hamernik stated he would suggest that, if the City supplies the sanitation facilities, the sign "No Bicycles Allowed" be taken down. Mr. Wilmes stated he has had complaints from persons on the trails being harrassed by the Bicycles. He stated there is a btc.ycle rack available by the gate where bicyclists can park and lock their 6ikes. Gouncilman Hamernik stated he has no objections to the sign, if there is a group at the Islands of Peace, but couldn't see why the sign couldn't be taken down in the evening Mr. Wilmes stated they have requests for use of the Islands of Peace in the evening and felt there are oth�r areas for the bicyclists. Mr. Alex Barna, 560 Hugo Street, stated bikes aren't allowed on the sidewalks and felt they shouldn't be allowed in an area where there �s pedestrian traffic that isn't agile. � PUBI_IC HEARING MEE7ING OF APRIL 10, 1978 PAGE 9 Mr. W�lmes stated one of the agreements the Islands of Peace made with people who provided the funds is that this area will be available to persons who are denied use in other areas. He felt, if this �s opened up in the evening for b�cycles, it would be denying the concept of what the Islands of Peace is all about Mayor Nee asked if there was a way to compromise this by saying the bicyclists have to walk their bikes instead of ridtng them. Mr W�lmes stated, �f the bicyclists come in groups, there is no room for anyone else. He stated �nstitut�ons will not hr7ng their people out to an area where there are motorized vehicles or bicycles. He felt there are other areas in the City for bicycle use. UPON A VOICE VOTE TAKEN ON THE MOTION, the following voted in favor: Councilman Fitzpatrick, Councilman Barnette, Mayor Nee and Councilman Schneider. The following voted against the motion: Councilman Hamernik. Mayor Nee declared the motion carried by a 4 to 1 vote. RECEIPT OF A LETTER FROM MR. VIRGIL NORDGREN RE: TESTING DF FIREARMS: MOTION by Councilman Schneider to receive the letter from Mr. Virgil Nardgren. Seconded by Councilman Barnette. Upon a voice vote, all voting aye, Mayor Nee declared the motion carried unanimously. Mr, qureshi, City Manager, stated the present ordinances do not allow the discharging of firearms. He stated, if the Council desires to allow this request, it would necessitate an amendment to the City code. Councilman Barnette questtoned if this was part of being a gunsmith, to try out weapons in your home. Mr. Alex &arna,560 Hugo Street, stated that Mr. Nordgren is partially handicapped and this was the reason hestarted the gunsmith bustness. He felt, under normal conditions, a gunsmith would probably to out to a shooting ran9e to check the weapons, but it would be a difficulty in Mr Nordgren's case. Councilman Fitzpatrick stated the comments from Mr. Nill, Publrc Safety Director, indicated this could be accommodated. He felt, if the Pu61ic Safety Department had no ob�ections, the Council should consider it. Councilman Hamernik questioned if anyone would be permitted to put in such a facility in their home. Mayor Nee felt possibly it could be handled on the basis of a permit so if it was a nuisance, the permit could be revoked. The City staff was asked to check into this further and draw up something along the l�ne of possibly requiring a permit. ADJOURNMENT: MOTION by Councilman Barnette to ad�ourn the meeting. Seconded by Councilman Hamer m k. Upon a voice vote, all voting aye, Mayor Nee declared the motion carried unanimously and the Public Hearing Meeting of the Fridley City Council of April 10, 1978, ad�ourned at 8:55 p.m. Respectfully subm�tted, �V������,� �.� � iCcr.�,,c� �d/-,-,c-�c,�Z �� Carole Haddad Wtlliam J. ee Secy. to the City Council Mayor Approved � I � � � � �� ' � J